minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

Raising High Need Kids

Raising High Need Kids
Global Global
Blog Calendar
« March 2010 »
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31
28
Mar
2007
Izzy

"No" just doesn't work anymore.

by IzzyComment Published at 19:2319:237 comments7 comments136 Visits136 VisitsReport

Lately, telling my son "no, you can't do that", "No, that's bad", etc etc just doesn't work anymore like it used to. I noticed that  more often than not, I have to get down on his level and go into a long explanation. 

For example, my husband assembled the twin stroller we bought this weekend to make sure all the parts are there and that everything works. My son found the stroller to be exciting and wanted to be in all the time. At night, I've been putting it away in the dining room, and so in the morning he wants it back. When the livingroom is so messy that there isn't room for it, I tell my son no. But of course he cries and throws a tantrum. So I get down and tell him we can't play with the twin stroller becuase it's folded right now and he can't get in it and I pretend that I don't know how to unfold it. At the end of the explanation, he seems to think about it and get into another toy.

AT night, when his dad comes home, my son asks him for the stroller. My hubby would tell him "no, we can't play with it right now" and a tantrum ensues and it doesn't stop. I've been telling my husband to use more than just "no".

This is a lot of work!

Add a comment on this blog.


Anonymous Member


Comments

mumof2b
5.00 (Excellent) | May 2007 | mumof2b
Don't say "No"

My son also throws a tantrum if I just say "No" without a huge explanation, if I explain things to him then he takes it a lot better.. he's only 2!!!! 

Even though I know explaining things has a better outcome I just get so frustrated when I have to, it would be so nice if I could just say "no."

 



Reply to this person
      Izzy
May 2007 | Izzy
Don't say
I know exactly what you mean. Going into an elaborate reason as to why your child can't do something requires a heck of a lot more energy than just saying no!


Reply to this person
kseers
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | kseers
mmmmmmmmm
I bought my son a t-shirt that says "But Why?" because some days that is all I hear.  What's worse is when you have gone through a lengthy explanation and it obviously just doesn't answer his mindset because he still says "but why".  Sometimes it is so illogical and what they want just is not possible but they still won't accept "no" - that is my struggle!  My husband seems to be able to redirect his attention and avoid the issue and I am learning too but it does take a lot of energy and thought. 

For example, yesterday all he wanted for breakie was cheerios, but we don't have any.  He would not accept anything else I offered and cried for half an hour.  Dad walked in and I explained what was going on.  he said "oh well, I'm going to have some noodles (R's favourite) - shame you don't want any!" and sure enough when he made them and started eating, R wanted them too and the tantrum was over!  Why wouldn't that work for me?

This may seem the last thing you need at the moment, but maybe think about why he is doing it and is he trying to get your attention or feeling insecure?  I still struggle with this, but hang in there and mayeb things will improve!


Reply to this person
      Izzy
April 2007 | Izzy
feeling insecure

Well, I don't know that he's feeling insecure, as he's always been this way since about 18 months old. My husband and I used to be able to leave him in the church nursery while we attend mass, without any problem.  But the church nursery closed for 3-4 months, and then when we brought him back, he never stopped crying while there.

Some people (not necessarily those with HN kids) tell me that this is normal at this age. And that things should get better at about 2 1/2  to 3 years old.



Reply to this person
      KathrynR1402
March 2007 | KathrynR1402
mmmmmmmmm

Oh, I so know what you two mean!

I have my "long" answers off pat now so shorter ones come out. Plus I've learned lots of devious tactics now, like knowing if we've run out of cherios to says "daddy had frosties this morning coz we're out of cherios - would you like frosties too, or would you like weetabix like me?" - she always wants what daddy has!

She still doesnt like "no" and she still loves "why". But the one that gets me seeing red now is "what are you/is she doing now mummy?" to which the tempting answer is "isnt it OBVIOUS, I'm eating a banana" etc, but to which I try really hard to say either "you guess" or more politely "what do you think I'm doing right now?"

The irony is, I was so looking forward to "why?" but it isnt really why at the start, it has a lot of defiance in it. Now there is a genuine need to know and the intellectual ability I think to grasp the concepts, if I can just get the words together in the right order!



Reply to this person
           KathrynR1402
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | KathrynR1402
mmmmmmmmm

sorry, I have a two second memory right now.

Stroller: I know it's awkward, but if Matthew helped you tidy up, would there be room for it to be static in the room? I just wondered if he got it out of his system now, then he wouldnt be fighting the twins for the use of it later? And maybe he could be encouraged to be extra helpful and tidy right now if you gave him a way of achieving his dream?

Just a thought.



Reply to this person
                Izzy
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | Izzy
stroller
Great idea. We may do this when the babies are nearing due date. But last week, it worked to my advantage. When I took him to my doctor's appointment with me, he was excited to get in his stroller while I was getting an ultrsasound. I usually have the stroller with me, since he's so inquisitive and would want to be all over the examination room if he wasn't tied to the stroller.


Reply to this person

Related Content

Add

No related content has been added

Related Tags

Add

None

Bookmarks

No bookmarks found