minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

Cesarean vs natural birth

Cesarean vs natural birth
Global Global
Blog Calendar
« October 2008 »
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31

Groups » Cesarean vs natural birth » Blog

29
Sep
2006
Tink1976

Do c-sections effect the bond between mother and child?

by Tink1976Comment Published at 05:4505:4516 comments16 comments897 Visits897 VisitsReport
I have one child and she was a vaginal birth and I wouldn't choose to have a c-section unless it was necessary for medical reasons because I feel that having a c-section might effect how I bond with my child, Is this the case? please tell me your experiences if you have had both vaginal and c-section births.

External Links

No external links found

Related Content   [Login]

No related content found

 
Add a comment on this blog.


Comments

mummy2girls
October 2007 | mummy2girls
Re: Do c-sections effect the bond between mother and child?

i had a section with my 1st and had no probs with bonding.

i miscarried my 2nd at 12 weeks.

and then had a natural with emily, my little angel, whom i love and adore, but i looked at her the day after and thought 'god you hurt!!!!!'

if i had the choice i'd have a section every time i recovered much quicker than after my natural delivery!!

that may be hard to believe but it's the god's honest truth.  my tummy healed much quicker than my.......   well you know!!!  and i had pain/discomfort for a much shorter amount of time.

saying that i had no probs bonding with either of my girls, although i had that minute the day after emily (natural delivery) appeared, but it passed in a second.



Reply to this person
kseers
March 2007 | kseers
Mixed feelings
I have had one of each birth and my answer would be NO.  I love both my children and I'm veyr close to each of them.

I bonded strongly during pregnancy with both - talking to them, singing, touching.  Breathing good, relaxing thoughts down to them etc....  But I think the birth does affect you as it is your actual meeting.  A bit like meeting a pen pal that you already know intimately.

The bonding is much harder work after a caesar.  Mind you my experience of a caesar is not the same for every body.  Mine was an emergency, I was unprepared and I went into shock.  I had been very unwell with pre-eclampsia and that was an issue too.  I was awake but was not really there.  They showed me my son then whisked him away and I did not see him again for hours, when we finally met and fed.  It all seemed so unreal.

I had issues with bonding - it was not automatic but it happened.  With love and patience it will.  i wish I had known about teh theory of skin contact and I know now that some mothers in this situation will have a bath with their baby with lots of skin contact and that can compensate for some of the issues around the caesar.

With my little girl, I was healthier, more with it.  I had a VERY long labour and was very tired at the end but the bond was instant.  I felt she was mine straight away as I had felt her come out - she was never out of my sight and was feeding within half an hour. Very different.

Hope that helps someone - it may be different at first but it will happen!


Reply to this person
ann-of-loxley
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | ann-of-loxley
My section...
I had to have an emergency section because my son was breech and rather large (10lbs 4.5oz!) - And though it was the last thing I wanted, and I felt really detached at the time through the whole process - we are both healthy and alive as thats all that matters....I do not feel it has effected our bonding at all! - I feel we are really close! I cried when I heard his first cry before I could even see him, and I feel instantly in love with him! - My feeling still havnt changed and never will!! hehe (mind you, second baby aroudn, I really really really want a vbac!)


Reply to this person
Tadexpress
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | Tadexpress
Do c-sections effect the bond between mother and child?
Definately not, I had four c sections because there was no other way to have my babies. After feeding baby number one until I was in such a distressed state that I could understand why women went crazy I realised that it wasnt for me, sadly with my M-I-L it became an issue so there you have it I was 21 couldnt deliver naturally and couldnt breast feed I questioned my abiltiy to be a mum for many years because of comments she made but it didnt stop me from having and loving three more babies, we are all close I was awake for each c-section my hubby was there and I never questioned my bond with my child, it exists because I am his/her mother same as it exists because their father is their father and he sure as eggs didnt deliver them vaginally or c-section. The truth is you do whats safest for the baby and regardless of which way they come into the world you bond, love and nurture your little treasures.


Reply to this person
      kseers
March 2007 | kseers
Do c-sections effect the bond between mother and child?
Too true!  For me I struggled to realise that the way he came out didn't matter - that he had still been a part of me.  Now it doesn't make any difference - he is still part of me!


Reply to this person
cookclan
December 2006 | cookclan
my experience

Aidan was a vaginal birth and because of the complications I can no longer have vaginal births I had a c section with Michaela Jess my still born child and then Nikita. I believe personally that I have just as good a bond with all of them. I was handed them all as soon as they were born. I agree the bonding starts from conception!!! Have a great day



Reply to this person
rkcrtbrown
October 2006 | rkcrtbrown
Bonding
i had one vaginal birth and one c-section. i was very disappointed in the c-section i had. i think that it delays the bonding process. i had to wait a couple of hours to hold my twin boys until i was transferred to my room. Once i held them, i was able to bond with them. it was just a longer time until i was able to.


Reply to this person
Tink1976
October 2006 | Tink1976
Thanks to you all.
I would like to thank everyone that took the time to answer my question. As I said before it was mostly asked out of curiousity, I really feared having to have a c-section with Amy but even though her delivery was difficult I had a vaginal birth, I now know that there is nothing to fear if I was to need a c-section when it comes to bonding with the baby.


Reply to this person
Gypsie
5.00 (Excellent) | October 2006 | Gypsie
Do c-sections effect the bond between mother and child?

Hi,

Definately not...I needed to have a C-Section with my daughter for medical reasons,

we bonded straight away and to this day have a wonderful relationship. ( She is now almost 16yrs )

I also have a 3yr old boy with whom I had a natural vaginal birth with no complications,

and our bond is so strong people say he is joined to my hip....lol

Overall...it's really what's best for the baby during labour how they are entered into the world.....just keep an open mind I guess.



Reply to this person
candie81
September 2006 | candie81
bonding after a c-section

I have had 3 c-sections, unfortunately never experienced a normal delivery! All my babies were given to me  virtually straight away after birth and then while i was getting stitched up, they take the baby away, do what they have to and then when i was ready, the baby was put in my arms and i got to hold them while i was wheeled to my room. They latched onto the breast straight away and i got to keep them in my room whenever i wanted to! I was  fortunate enough to have everything go well, some people don't get to see their babies straight away and then they have to wait in recovery for half an hour to an hour! It still doesn't affect the bonding though, just makes the mum more anxious to see her baby!

All my children are affectionate and have bonded with me quite well.



Reply to this person
busyasabee
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2006 | busyasabee
Do c-sections effect the bond between mother and child? NO
I've had both. My daughter vaginally and my son C-section. My son is by far the more loving and affectionate of the two. As a child even, he always wanted to be near me. Now at 9,  he is very independant, but still says I love you at night and wants the occasional hug. My daughter (10) couldn't care less if she gets hugged or not, She still says I love you. It's all in the child's personalitly and yours. The method of birth makes no difference. They are sill your children. 


Reply to this person
shoolacy
September 2006 | shoolacy
Bonding

What a good question I had no one to ask before bub was born as my mother and mother inlaw had never had a c-section I had wondered the same thing too, and I did not breastfeed long either but my bub has loved and responded to me since even before birth and the c-section. He picks up on my emotions and mood, he sences when I am happy and sad ... babies are very attentive and they can't focus till 6weeks of age so they don't even know your body lanuage there is just a connection between mother and baby nothing can sever.



Reply to this person
bubba76
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2006 | bubba76
3 vaginal births and 1 c section
Hello, the bond is not different no matter how the baby is born. l agree with lzzy and wildrose the bond starts while you are pregnant. l love my children all the same and they all have show me the same love back.


Reply to this person
wildrose
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2006 | wildrose
Do c-sections effect the bond between mother and child?
Absolutely NOT! I had twice c-section. I'm sure I love my both children as much as other mother who gave birth vaginal and I believe my both children love me too. Like Izzy said, the bond between mother and child is start from when she carried the baby in the tummy...all the care and talk and touch she gave...and the first touch when the baby born, the kisses, the smell of the mother and baby...the breastfeeding...etc..etc. So the way how the baby birth won't take affect of bonding.


Reply to this person
Izzy
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2006 | Izzy
Do c-sections effect the bond between mother and child?

Absolutely not. Bonding with the baby starts when mom puts her hand on her belly in response to baby's kicking. When she talks to her baby, they're bonding. When she imagines herself holding her child in her arms, they're bonding.

I had a c-section because my son just wouldn't come out after I pushed for several hours, and I don't consider myself to have bonded any less with him. While in the hospital, my son roomed with me for 2 days after his birth, but on the 3rd day, I was so tired that the nurse thought it better that I let Matthew in the nursery to get much needed sleep. During that night when my son wasn't in the room with me, I bolted up awake every time I heard a cry that I was sure to be him. I woke my husband up and made him get our son. When he came back without him, he said he saw that our son was fast asleep and he didn't want to wake him up by moving him.  That first few days, I've already bonded with my son. Wouldn't you agree?

I was fully awake during my c-section and after. I wasn't groggy, I wasn't in a haze. I was just anxious to hold my son. I had to wait 1 hour before he was brought in the room for me to hold. But I'm sure that even moms who were knocked out would say that they were able to form a bond with their baby within the baby's first few hours of life.

 



Reply to this person
      Tink1976
4.86 (Excellent) | September 2006 | Tink1976
Do c-sections effect the bond between mother and child?

Thank you for taking the time to answer my question, I asked this as I was curious being that I have not experienced a c-section. It was something that I had wondered about.



Reply to this person