minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

Mental Health Support

Mental Health Support
Global Global
Blog Calendar
« December 2009 »
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31
20
Jul
2006
Sistersarah55

Medication for depression?

by Sistersarah55Comment Published at 09:5909:5917 comments17 comments925 Visits925 VisitsReport

On the plus side medication can be a great way to get some sort of normality back into your life

but on the down side, medication only plasters over the cracks but doesnt actually mend or heal

So I'd like to hear other peoples thoughts on medication for depression

Yah or Nah?

Add a comment on this blog.


Anonymous Member


Comments

Wendigo
December 2006 | Wendigo
Depression, psychological or psychiatric?

This all depends on what is causing the depression.  For most cases of depression it is a psychological thing, but for some it is due to a more serious psychiatric condition.

The biggest problem I have with society's attitude with any medication for any mental illness is that it is taboo.  It's a rather silly attitude to have.  If we had to be on medication for the rest of our life because of diabeties, epilepsy, heart disease, or asthma, no one has anything to say about it other than "Have you remembered to take your medication?, You really shouldn't forget it, you do need it after all."  Yet if we have to take medication to keep us from going off the rails, it's a totally different story.  "Why do you need that?  It's really not the best thing for you.  You should try other methods."  The simple fact is, for many people with mental illness, medication is just part of life.  Many that suffer from conditions that a good amount of psychological therapy can help can get off the medication eventually, but to do so too soon can be disasterous.  They feel fine while on the medication, and so they think they don't need it anymore.  They stop taking it because their peers are on their case about it and they are tired of having to remember it every day, and then the next thing they know they have lost the plot and are reacting very badly.  Violence, murder and suicide are the extremes, but even just having trouble dealing with day to day issues can be debilitating for the sufferer and frustrating for their loved ones.

My attitude is, if you are getting professional help and are given the professional opinion that you are ready to wean off the medication, then by all means give it a go - as per prescribed.  If not, and you need it, then take it.  If you suffer from a condition that is more psychological than psychiatric, such as common depression or PTSD, then get all the psychological help you can get and then ask about getting off the meds.  But if it's more psychiatric, such as schitzophrenia or certain forms of bi-polar, then for the sake of those that love you if not your own, take that medication as your specialist has prescribed it.



Reply to this person
nell18-3
December 2006 | nell18-3
Medication and Depression
I would like to say that I think the best way for ME, is that I am on medication to sort out the physical side and regain my strength till I am fully fit again, however at the same time I am having counselling sessions to enable me to still cope when I stop the medication. I believe that only by talking things through with a professional can you be fully cured and whilst medication is just a band aid, it is a good band aid that binds you together whilst the counselling makes you heal


Reply to this person
      Izzy
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | Izzy
Medication and Depression

Thanks for sharing. You are absolutely right, in that both medication and counseling is the best way to combat depression. There are numerous research that show counseling (along with medication) reduces the instance of recurrence.

Medication takes care of the biological part of depression, while counseling takes care of the mind.



Reply to this person
seabreeze
4.71 (Excellent) | December 2006 | seabreeze
Depression -chemical imbalance

I have been suffering from depression for many years, but it was just about 3 years ago that it got really really bad, where I just did not want live, i just wanted to leave this world, i contemplated suicide many times, some days that was all i could think about, i had no reason to feel this way because i am married and have 2 teenage kids, and an average family life. I took my self to the doctor and she put me on Lexapro, actually i tried zoloft, luvox etc. and they didn't agree with me, but i found Lexapro changed my life, i was suddenly happy and able to enjoy life again, i am still on it, and i am scared to go of it, in case the depression comes back. has anyone been on lexapro?



Reply to this person
redbeard
November 2006 | redbeard
Medication for depression?

Hiya guys

Have been in a relationship with a depressive for about 2 years...was goign to say happily married now but that would be a slight exageration!  Did a whole lot fo research on depression - THE best site I could find is depression(n?)et.com.au - community based too so awesome for both depressives and partners. 

Medication for depression is critically once you have reached a certain stage of depression.  It becomes biological, where your brain is no longer producing enough of the "happiness" chemical for it to function correctly.  Counselling or meditation or changing diet at this stage is not productive - fewer than 10% of cases respond.  People honestly do need medication to treat, as they would for any other illness.  Cause that is what it is, an illness. 

Best case scenario once depression has reached a certain stage is medication AND counselling...AND exercise AND diet AND meditation - awesome book is "Optimal Nutrition for your Brain" which goes through all of the different foods you could be eating to improve your depression.  In terms of counselling, if anyone has the cash for it, quadrinity.com.au is website for an awesome 10 day course that many participants and counsellors believe advances participants 2 years in counselling time during the course...and its downright enjoyable / lovely / wonder full. 

Hugs to you all - my mantra at times is " you will get through this, just not yet" - certainly applies to depression! 

 



Reply to this person
mewannaboy
September 2006 | mewannaboy
hello to you all
I have just joined this group,but wondered why id done so,until i started shaking again because i have to go out.See my life 2 and a half years ago was ruined by a girl in my life who wanted to tell me what do do with my kids now im anxiety ridden ..more lter


Reply to this person
jamie
July 2006 | jamie
Medication for Depression
I have to say that the best thing I ever done for my self was go to the doctor and get antidepressants. I got PND with my second child and I would not wish it on my worst enemy. Taking these tablets made mesee that there was a light at the end of the tunnel and that with time and a bit of patience I ended up coming out of it with a smile on my face and the weight of the world of my shoulders. Tablets are not always the answer but I wouldn't dismiss it and never be embarrest to go see a doctor and ask for help. 


Reply to this person
      Sistersarah55
July 2006 | Sistersarah55
Medication for Depression

Thanks for your comment jamie. I'd be interested to know about your expiriences. How long where you on medication? did you find medication that suited you imediatly or did you have to try a couple? How do you feel about it all now? How long since you stopped taking them?

xxx



Reply to this person
           jamie
July 2006 | jamie
Medication for Depression
Hi Sarah .My experience with PND felt horrific but  not as bad as some stories I have heard. But I'll tell you my experience with it. When my second baby was born something with myself just didn't fill right but I just keeped putting one foot in front of the other. From the time he was born up until he was about 6 months old I just felt myself getting angry and crying over nothing or stuff you would normally be able to handle. It all came to head one day when I just had not stoped crying all day and my baby was giving me a hell of a day. I was changing his nappy and no matter what I did he would not stop crying, I lifted my fist up into the air and stoped just as I was about to hit him. I realised that this was just not right and had to go to the doctor. From that day I have not looked back, The doctor made me fell like Iwasn't a freak all a fool for what I thinking or feeling. We talked through it together and it was desided that I would try a tablet called zoloft and see how it would go for me. It was the right medication for me (luckly). Iwas on the medication for one year  before starting to come of  them and that took about 2 months. To answer ,How do I feel about it all now?  I am so glad I went to the doctor that day, It was the best thing I have ever done for myself. I am now proud of the mother I am and I enjoy myself with him. (He can still drive me nuts but in a normal typical way). I have now been of them for over a year now and have never looked back. Taking antidepressence was the right thing for me but it won't be right for everyone  but if you think that taking them might help, don't be afraid to try.  


Reply to this person
nomes
July 2006 | nomes
Medication for depression?
too right....medication fills in the cracks, and you come tumbling down when the filler doesn't stick.  I was on a herb called Dong Quai.  great for lots of things. Doesn't make you forget what's wrong, just relaxes you when knitting just isn't your thing.    I still take it, but not as much and more for my monthly.


Reply to this person
bobbys-mum
4.00 (Good) | July 2006 | bobbys-mum
knitting
Totally agree about the knitting, and even though it's hard a positive outlook can do wonders


Reply to this person
      mcm
July 2006 | mcm
knitting
I love to knit. Its strange actually,  just thinking about it. I haven't knitted for a while. But since things have been getting stressful for me I have found myself starting to knit again. I love it so much. It does help. And just when I thought I was going to post saying no it isn't helpful!!!! It is- even if it is just a little pressure off - can make all the difference. Also thinking positively as hard as it can be. I have been very positive for the past 3 years. Everything was just hunky dory. Then wham everything seems to get on top of me. I just feel like I need to take one day at a time.


Reply to this person
      Sistersarah55
July 2006 | Sistersarah55
Knitting never sat well with me..

I think its the knit one, pearl one thing. Or maybe i already have enough scarves, lol. but i diffenatly understand what you are getting at. After I read your post I sat and painted my war hammer figures for 2 hours and by the end i felt quite at peace.

Thanks xxx



Reply to this person
Izzy
July 2006 | Izzy
Medication for depression?
You are absolutely right. Medication can help with chemical part of depression, but it is a "plaster" over the cracks. It is more effective to be both on psychotherapy and medication. The psychotherapy part will help the person change the pattern of thinking, and help rid the person of the negative self talk. One or the other alone is not as effective as doing both. People who use both medicine and therapy help tremendously in lowering the risk of recurrence of major depression.


Reply to this person
      Sistersarah55
July 2006 | Sistersarah55
Medication for depression?

I can see what your saying but i think that part of depression is about the way that you act in certain situations. So say for instance you go to the supermarket and you walk past the tomatoe section. On medication you select the right amount of tomatoes for your recipe put them in your basket and carry on shopping. With out medication upon seeing the tomatoes you remember the time you cooked them with your ex-husband and then brake down because daddy never loved you. So on the one hand your emotions were hard to control and maybe at times even uncontrollable but you got something useful out of the episode.

I fear that the person on medication just goes to the doctor week after week saying "Yeah, i was fine again this week doctor" and never really progresses with their life.



Reply to this person
           sillyboho
July 2006 | sillyboho
Medication for depression?
it's a band aid. meditation and changing my diet has helped me immensely. knitting as well. it relaxes me. most of my problems are energy issues, panic and anxiety come from excess energy.


Reply to this person
                Sistersarah55
July 2006 | Sistersarah55
Medication for depression?

I really like your way of thinking. I seriously think that there is something to the posititive effects that a purer diet can have one mental health. So much so i'm tempted to do it.

As we know that postnatal depression is usually temp. what are peoples thoughts on medication for postnatal?



Reply to this person

Related Content

Add

No related content has been added

Related Tags

Add

None

Bookmarks

No bookmarks found