This post is from from my other blog here I’m one of those parents that loves to do classes w/ her kid. I worry about it ever becoming overwhelming, he is only 19 months old, but so far I’m pretty sure we’re both having a blast. There seems to be a lot of classes geared to lil’ns. Music classes has been an interesting search for me. I feel lucky that my mother had a background in music. She studied it in college and encorporated music into our lives. i’ve been hoping to impart even a small part of that to Sal.
We started classes when Sal was about 6 months old. He was starting to really engage in the world, could sit and starting to crawl and explore - it seemed like a good time to be able to get into classes. One of the first classes I searched for was a music class. People typically look a little confused on why I’d bring such a young baby to a music class, but once I explain it is really more for the exposure, movement, and time together - people seem to understand I’m not looking for Sal to come out of the class to be a music virtuoso.
Still, you’d think all classes are about the same to someone this age. They’ve got a teacher, their songs, some simple instruments, and a bunch of children. Children’s programs seem to love to throw around a couple buzz words about cognitive development, bonding, motor skills. I’ve gotten so used to it I pretty much skim it quickly to see if there is anything outside the ordinary.
Today, instead of reading first about the class - I experienced it instead. We had previously taken Sal to Kindermusik. He enjoyed it well enough, got familiar w/ the songs, loved playing on the instruments, but I always had a slight discomfort with the class that I couldn’t quite put my finger on. Today we tried Music Together, and I felt like this class, taking similar elements, had a couple key fundamental difference that I really appreciated.
The class was a mix of ages. There were babies and kids all the way up to 4 year olds. Kindermusik had us sectioned by age - which - although I can see how it may feel like you can “specialize” for the age, I think it left a lot to be desired as Sal grew a little older for the baby group. I like the Montesorri approach of mixed ages - Sal seems to find fascination in both kids younger and older. I think he gets a chance to pick stuff up from the older kids as well. This was a nice change of pace.
Since we were in a mixed age class, I think it was easier to keep to a philosophy of not forcing the children to participate by moving them for them. For once, we were in a music class where we weren’t trying to force the kids to do certain movements. The teacher was clear on just modelling, and allowing the kids to choose on their own what they wanted to do. Some kids chose to watch, some kids chose to mirror the actions, and some chose to run around. In all cases it was fine. The movements weren’t overly complicated either - no complicated dance steps that a lil’n, if they so chose to follow, would have a hard time encorporating.
And the music - all catchy, repetitive songs. Not all of them had words, not all of them had rhythms. By breaking down some of the elements it made it easier to focus on those elements. The songs w/out words but just sounds like “la la la, ba ba ba” were a lot easier for Sal to participate in.
Afterwards - I read some more of the classes literature. Instead of just using the standard jargon - it actually had some words about children picking up music. I liked that. It also talked about how parents are the most important role model - and watching and listening to the parents participating was the strongest reinforcer - more then doing the movements for the child. Made sense.
I don’t know if my experience of Kindermusik is representative of it or not, but just going by the materials and the thought that went into it - I can say I prefer the philosophy of Music Together and it looked like Sal did too.