minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 
MumKim



Blog Calendar
« October 2008 »
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31

Young Parent Member » MumKim » Blog » Why don't we have milk banks?

04
Jan

Why don't we have milk banks?

Comment Published at 21:3921:3913 comments13 comments76 Visits76 VisitsReport
Some mothers are unable to breastfeed. Why is it that in our society these women are forced to give their babies the fourth best option instead of the third best?
Some people think and I have seen it written on many sites that formula is second best. Actually it is not that highly placed. According to the World Health Organization hierarchy:
1) breastfeeding;
2) the mother's own milk expressed and given to her child some other way;
3) the milk of another human mother; and
4) artificial milk feeds (4).

Some countries operate human milk banks, here in Australia some hospitals offer donated human milk for premature babies. We have blood banks why can't we have more milk banks? I would be happy to donate as I am sure would many others.

External Links

No external links found

Related Content   [Add link]

No related content found

 
Add a comment on this blog.

 

Comments

Ametrine
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | Ametrine
Re: Why don't we have milk banks?
Hi,  My mom used to give milk for prem. babies , I can remember the midwife taking it away with her. This was in 1964 My brother was prem. and only 7lb. incubated for 4 months before mom could bring him home.  she had to come home with out him as there was not the understanding mother/baby depts. then so parents were shipped off a.s.a.p. out of the way so to speek. She obvously had milk ot spair which she was only too happy for any needy baby to have.  It must have been strang to express milk but not to have the reward of feeding?  When my brother finaly came home he had to be bottle fed as her milk had dried up by then.


Reply Reply Report
Izzy
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | Izzy
Re: Why don't we have milk banks?

I heard of one here in the U.S. I only heard about it when I attended a breastfeeding class. There is a strict guideline for milk donation, understandably, to protect against diseases and to screen for whatever medications and condition women have. They give donated milk to the same age babies as the mom hae at the time of the donation.

While I used to find wet nurses a little disturbing (pre-marriage and pre-children), I don't anymore, now that I know how good breastmilk is for babies.



Reply Reply Report
winja
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | winja
Re: Why don't we have milk banks?
while i agree that milk banks would be a good option especially for premmie babies i just dont think that they would work.
alot of time and effort would have to be put into screening the milk for viruses and diseases, then we have the problem of the donating mothers lifestyle choices...
would you be ok with giving your baby milk from a mum who is a smoker? a drinker? who takes drugs or prescription medicine? what about their eating habits?  can you screen all milk for theses things in the small amount of time that it is able to be used? do you screen the donor for these things everytime they donate? how do you trust that they haven't been in contact with maybe HIV or hepatitis in the last few days?

blood is frozen while tests are run for these things while milk couldn't be frozen long enough and still be viable. hep and HIV are tested for and then retested in 6 months because it doesn't show up till then.

sorry but i think even now with all the technology we are still a long way off having milk banks as a safe option.
and by the way... mothers who cant breastfeed can only exclusively pump for around 6 weeks b4 their breastmilk dries up.


Reply Reply Report
      MumKim
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | MumKim
Re: Why don't we have milk banks?
Milk banks are already a viable option. They operate in the US, Canada, Europe and Brazil. We have one operating in Perth but it is only for premmies. Here is a link to an article about them.
Australia is trailing behind.


Reply Reply Report
Kellzacar
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | Kellzacar
Re: Why don't we have milk banks?
Hi honey,

I think we need to be careful here as this is and can be a volatile subject . . . some formula's are better than others. Sumara is on a prescription Formula due to multiple food allergies which prevented me from being able to breastfeed . .
As to Milk Banks -  I think this is a GREAT idea as long as the milk is tested in much the same way as blood is these days as there are many drugs and diseases that can be passed through breast milk . . .

I have always donated my breast milk to the ICU newborns and have often been thanked by Mum's for doing this. I am on of those lucky women who could feed an army with the amount of milk i had. When Sam was a baby I was feeding her plus 4 other bubs in ICU and still had it Milk left over . .  That being said NOT all mums like the idea of giving their babies another persons breast milk

Cheers Kellz


Reply Reply Report
      MumKim
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | MumKim
Re: Why don't we have milk banks?
I just think that mothers should have the choice of giving their babies donated human milk or formula. At the moment very few mothers have access to donated human milk when they can't feed the baby themselves.
It is about choice and at the moment the choice is not there!!!!
I would love to donate breastmilk but there is no where near me that I can donate it. The KEMH bloodbank is 200km away and already has more willing donors than they can use.


Reply Reply Report
Libby24
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | Libby24
Re: Why don't we have milk banks?
i think the babie hospital in perth here has a milk bank for the premies, but i am sure thats as far as it goes. I would love to join in on the fun, i loved breastfeeding my kids (when i could)

Personally i think there needs to be more help to get people to breastfeed and more info and schooling. i wasnt given any help with my son and after 6 weeks i gave up, 4 months with my daughter.


Reply Reply Report
      MumKim
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | MumKim
Re: Why don't we have milk banks?
I heard about it from some ladies that went to the Hotmilk conference. Apparently it costs a lot to process the milk but it pays for itself because the babies get out of hospital faster (than if they were fed on formula)and thus saves more money than it costs.


Reply Reply Report
dannii17
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | dannii17
Re: Why don't we have milk banks?
i wudnt like my baby drinking somebody elses milk,i think its abit wrong. These days formula has all the vitamins and nutrients babies need anyway,and some ppl cant express milk and need to use formula.


Reply Reply Report
      MumKim
3.00 (Average) | January 2008 | MumKim
Re: Why don't we have milk banks?
Actually formula doesn't have all the vitamins and nutrients in it that babies need. It is an inferior substitute for breastmilk. Some women can't produce enough milk or feed their babies for other reasons - formula shouldn't be their only alternative.
 Why we have blood banks - so why not breastmilk banks?
Given all I have read about the risks of formula if I couldn't have fed my baby myself I would much rather have used milk from a milk bank or a friend. Why are women not given the choice?


Reply Reply Report
           Libby24
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | Libby24
Re: Why don't we have milk banks?
i have to agree with you so much. i hated giving my kids formula and wished there was an alternative.


Reply Reply Report
August88
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | August88
Re: Why don't we have milk banks?
Sorry the thought of it isn't nice to me. Milk donors? I would not like to give my baby someone elses milk. Reminds me of the olden days when they had wet nurses. The poor black people usually would have to feed the rich peoples babies. It isn't right.


Reply Reply Report
      MumKim
2.00 (Poor) | January 2008 | MumKim
Re: Why don't we have milk banks?
When you give a baby formula you are giving them another animals  milk - a cow!. I often drink cows milk - it comes treated in a bottle but it still came out of a cows udder.
Back in the olden days many women made good money as wet nurses.
What would be wrong with donated, milk - we use blood banks!!!!!!!!!!!!


Reply Reply Report