minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 
Practical-Princess



Blog Calendar
« October 2008 »
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31

Talking Back Member » Practical-Princess » Blog » Peeved off!

22
Apr

Peeved off!

Comment Published at 17:2717:275 comments5 comments38 Visits38 VisitsReport

I'm not happy! I recently wrote advice on babies and solids and, though I had positive feedback, my advice has been reported. Here's the report.....

"I find it very rude that this member has said that i dont know anything cos im not a parent yet. I really dont appreciate being told my advice isnt useful just beacsue im not a parent yet.Ive had alot of experience with kids so i think i do have some knowlege on parenting. I was only telling Cass that boiled meat is good for babies at 8mnths, thats what i did for my neices and they were fine and took it well."

This person has said that I said she knows nothing because she's not a parent yet. I'd like her to point out where it says that! I said she's not a parent yet, but never said she knows nothing! I just meant she does have things to learn, as ALL parents, esp new parents, do. It's a part of being a parent - learning! It's also called 'constructive' criticism - somthing everyone should be able to take in all aspects of life. It's how we learn.

Next she has said that I said her advice is not useful. Again, I'd like her to show me where it says that! I never said such a thing, nor implied it.

All I did was to say that boiling meat was not necessary. It was nothing against her (which I DID say). We are all here to receive and accept advice. I give advice based on my experiences as a mother and a child care worker. If you don't agree with what advice I give, that's your perogatvie. It doesn't mean you have to report me!

I had actually sent a compliment to this girl for being a 'wise owl' as I thought her to be a very mature-minded young lady who will be a great mother. But if she can't read what I write properly, if she wants to say things I did NOT say about her, then I'm sorry but this changes my mind about her.

I did NOT say anything offensive to or about her. I said in the article that I mean no offence to her. I did not even mention her bloody name! All I did was point out a fact that would hopefully help her and others in here. The only reason I said in the article, "someone wrote that...boiling meat..." was so that she will know, when her little dalrilng gets to the age of eating meat, that it is not necessary to boil it. It was to HELP her! And HELP others!

External Links

No external links found

Related Content   [Add link]

No related content found

 
Add a comment on this blog.

 

Comments

matthew
5.00 (Excellent) | April 22nd | matthew
Re: Peeved off!

HI PP - I realise you did not mention her name and were trying to be helpful.  Unfortunately the member knew who you were writing about and responded, thus her name is known and although it may not seem "offensive" many people can be sensitive about being labelled as "not a parent yet" in a community like Minti.

You advice article was excellent in content and simply did not require the additional sentence referring to the member's opinion, I thought it would be a nice compromise to keep all the article except this small part offering a tip to a specific member(which you can also message the member directly about in a private way).

If you are unhappy with the small deletion of a sentence then feel free to delete or report your own advice and it can be removed although I would be sad to see you take this step.  Minti is an emotive place and compromise is often the smoothest solution to issues which are viewed differently by the parties involved.  all the best, Matt



Reply Reply Report
Arna
5.00 (Excellent) | April 22nd | Arna
Re: Peeved off!

No, it wasn't offensive, but we do have to be more sensitive when wording things.  If you edit that little bit out and repost the advice, it should be ok.  It was good otherwise.  please let it go now, admin are following through with promises of a minti time out, and noone wants to have that happen to them.  Although, I'm sure my other half would love if it happened to me!

Hope you have a smiley dayNerd



Reply Reply Report
      Practical-Princess
5.00 (Excellent) | April 22nd | Practical-Princess
Re: Peeved off!

That's the thing - I was being sensitive. I said 'no offence' to her and did not mention her name. I was just being helpful.



Reply Reply Report
Izzy
5.00 (Excellent) | April 22nd | Izzy
Re: Peeved off!

According to Matthew's comment on the report, he was going to edit by removing some words on your advice and then keep it up.

 



Reply Reply Report
      Practical-Princess
3.25 (Average) | April 22nd | Practical-Princess
Re: Peeved off!

I don't see why it needs to be edited. I've said nothing wrong! I never mentioned the girls name, I never said what she says I did, I merely gave her and others advice.



Reply Reply Report