minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.99 (Highly recommend) from 24 votes (178 Visits)

Actions not People

kseers by kseers Young Parent(November 2008) (rank 25th)

I am constantly learning about my use of language.  The way we refer to people and things can often be an integral part of how we see those things.  I have written another article about labelling our kids and how our use of terms to classify them can actually

affect our attitude to them.  I have learnt this particularly where my son is concerned.  But today I want to share some thoughts on a similar subject.

I have noticed some disturbing use of words from some Minti members to attack one another - I don't mean using swearwords as that has recently been addressed, but I am talking about language that attacks people and puts them on the defensive.  Not only is this a way to cause conflict with other adults, but it is a way that we can antagonise our children and give them messages quite different from what we think we are saying.

I give you one example I saw in a friend of mine last week.  She is a lovely mum of two kids who does her very best to do the right thing by her kids.  As we were cleaning up after playing I heard her say "I love you kids when you help me clean up".  She was trying to offer them encouragement - but the message I heard was that her kids have to do the right things for mummy to love them.  I am sure that is not what she meant, but this is a classic example of mixing up the action and the person.

I am very aware of saying to my kids "I love you  no matter what".  When they do something hurtful or wrong, I address the action - not the child.  I then say "I love you no matter what you do, but I do not like that behaviour".  Or on the opposite end of the spectrum, when they do something great - I say "thanks for doing <that action>, I really appreciate it when you are helpful.  I am so proud of your behaviour."  Perhaps the mum above could have said "I love it when you help pack up" or "seeing you being so helpful really makes me happy".  Do you see the difference?  One addresses the action and one the child - the key word above was "you".

Another example I have seen among adults is when a discussion arises and one person disagrees with the other.  They may say "you are stupid", when what they really mean is "your idea is stupid" (though stupid is not a word I would use anyway).  The 2 statements, though very similar, mean very different things - one is a response to the person, the other a response to the action.  Saying "you are stupid" attacks the person - it attacks their intellect and their world view - which is very threatening.  You can say "i don't agree with your idea", or "that statement is ridiculous", which address the person's theory - not their person. 

In a similar way, if you don't agree with a decision, you can say "I don't agree with that decision" or even question the decision, without attacking the person who made it.  I know you feel frustrated and you may feel at that point in time that they are stupid, but you are merely escalating the argument worse than it needs to be and putting them offside from hearing anything else you have to say.  It also makes you look bad to others as you are not showing another person respect and respecting another person is so important and is a value we want our children to share.

I see this response used with children too - and this leaves children feeling worthless, unloved and stupid.  If a child does something stupid, don't say "You're stupid", say "that was a very silly thing you did".  That gives them a very clear guideline as to their behaviour, but doesn't attack them or make them think you don't love them or value them.  Children mimic what we do and the child who is told by your poor choice of words that you don't respect them or appreciate them is going to show the same response to the people in their lives - to you and other family members, to their friends and in their future relationships.  We need to encourage them to treat people in a way that will give them lasting and meaningful relationships. 

I hope I am making the difference a bit clearer.

One last tip on this subject is addressing the feelings someone causes you to feel.  The first point is to recognise that your response to any event/action is up to you.  The way we respond to anything that happens to us and what we say to ourselves about it can often influence heavily the way the action pans out.  You have that control and need to recognise that - and don't give that control to someone else or blame them for it. 

For example, when your 2 year old pulls all the books off the bookshelf just after you've tidied up their bedroom.  I know it is frustrating and it makes me angry - especially when I am tired and frustrated at not getting anywhere with the housework.  That doesn't mean she makes me angry - she has done the action that caused my anger, but my anger is up to me.  I could respond differently if I chose to and if there weren't other things going on, I probably would.

This recognition affects how you respond.  If I am talking to my husband about something he has done to upset me, I can say "you made me angry", but that is not quite true and is liable to put him off listening to anything else I have to say.  Instead I can say "when you did <action>, then I felt angry".  The message to him is very different - I am not attacking him, but rather something he did.  The response to the situation is mine, I am sharing it so we can move on, but I am also taking responsibility for my response.  The action may not have been intended to cause that response and perhaps in a different situation or with a different person would not have caused that response.  I recognise it as mine and move on.

I hope this helps, but feel free to email me or leave a message below if you want me to clarify something or if you have a question - also if you have a suggestion or an example to add.  Thanks!

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.99 (Highly recommend) from 24 votes
Report
ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

peace613
January 2009 | peace613
Re: Actions not People

Some actions are not acceptable but love is unconditional.



Reply Reply Report
sarah237
January 2009 | sarah237
Re: Actions not People

I agree I always tell my 16 year  old son I love him no matter what and he tells me he loves me even in front of his friends!



Reply Reply Report
sairys
January 2009 | sairys
Re: Actions not People

Thank you for posting this article. I can't choose my words wisely and most of the time what I mean to say is not what I said. So many times I don't think before I open my mouth and my children and people around me suffer for it, it's not that i'm intentionaly trying to hurt them it's just I don't know how to word what I'm trying to say. I'm going to print your article out and the next time someone does somethign that upsets me or does something that makes me happy I'm going to stop and read this again and then choose my words. Again thanks for writing this, this is just what I needed :)



Reply Reply Report
      kseers
January 2009 | kseers
Re: Actions not People

Thanks! I hope it helps - we can only learn from our mistakes and once you are aware it gets easier and easier to improve - there will be times when we get it wrong again - but we just take it time by time and one day.....  well, one day it works and it feels great!




Reply Reply Report
aiman
January 2009 | aiman
Re: Actions not People

This is something that I personally have been working on when communicating with my own children. I love my family to death, but we tend to be a bit rough on the edges when it comes to teasing and commenting on actions.

Great article! Thanks.



Reply Reply Report
sacha77
January 2009 | sacha77
Re: Actions not People

I couldn't agree more!!! I have reinforced many times to my son that its his behviour not him that is upsetting me.



Reply Reply Report
rhysmum
January 2009 | rhysmum
Re: Actions not People

i am in total agreement with you  and also would like to add what I personally use to help myself in theses types of situations. it is quite simple but accurate and that is, no-one can make you feel inferior without your consent! thanks



Reply Reply Report
bruciegee
December 2008 | bruciegee
Re: Actions not People

Well said!... and you're so right about it being appropriate behaviour for us to model as adults in all adult conversations (including on line ones!), as well as to our kids!



Reply Reply Report
allenrm
December 2008 | allenrm
Re: Actions not People

Thankyou.  I have just given birth and while I know I have a while before my child can completely comprhend everything I say, I know that the time can fly past.  I am so happy I stumbled upon this article as this subject of how do I want to talk to my kids has been on my mind these past few days.  You provide some very helpful guidelines to follow when my child is older and for how to approach my fiancee with a potentially argument causing topic tonight.  I honestly can't thank you enough.



Reply Reply Report
sandra106
November 2008 | sandra106
Re: Actions not People

This is a fantastic articile I hope alot of people read it as I have seen some disputing with people on this site aswell and they forget waht they are actually giving advice on and then it becomes more of who thinks they are right and who thinks they are wrong. Keep your articles coming I like reading other peoples ideas and what they have to say we can all learn alot from other people.



Reply Reply Report
      kseers
November 2008 | kseers
Re: Actions not People

Thanks!  That's exactly what prompted me to write it....




Reply Reply Report
KathrynR1402
November 2008 | KathrynR1402
Re: Actions not People

Great article! It such a tricky skill to learn, isnt it? We dont as a rule say "stupid" about people in our house (tho I pull up DH when he says it about himself sometimes) but we do call things stupid ("stupid door" when we crash into it). I hope I wont regret that! And I try to separate compliments from other encouragement (eg "you're so beautiful" from "I love you soo much") just in case the two separate statements are linked together in my childrens minds (eg "I love you [BECAUSE] you're so beautiful" is not what I want them to think). And children overhear so much - DD1 has told me several times recently "I was an UNUSUAL baby, wasnt I?", because I've been careful over the years when discussing her with other people not to use words like "difficult" or "naughty". "Unusual" has been used with a large dose of irony, but fortunately she doesnt realise that; she just understands that I think being unique is a good thing! Too often I see adults forgetting that my child (or theirs) is listening into adult conversations, where somebody's behaviour or looks are being criticised. I know we are all desperate for adult conversation, but unguarded adult conversation can cause no end of problems. I know of one child who became afraid of my DD1 not because of anything she had experienced or seen but I am convinced it's because she listened in to adult conversations and decided my DD1 would hurt her. These two had been great playmates for 4 years so it was a great sadness to me when my DD1s friend refused to see her any more.



Reply Reply Report
      kseers
November 2008 | kseers
Re: Actions not People

That's so sad - and you're right it is something most of us do.  I have one friend who will not talk about her son when he is in the room - unless he can join in the conversation - I respect that - but most of us forget about little ears taking everything in. Good point!



Reply Reply Report
mcm
November 2008 | mcm
Re: Actions not People

Wonderful advice.

You can dislike what ppl do but not hate them. Big difference. It annoys me when ppl say their child is naughty cos they did something they consider naughty. That labels the child and can have a lasting effect.



Reply Reply Report
      kseers
November 2008 | kseers
Re: Actions not People

Thanks mcm.  That's true - and I think with kids we have to be so clear that we may not approve or even agree with what they do (especially when they are becoming adults) but we can still love them - and in fact that is why we care about what they do. 

My son as asked me before "am I naughty?" - he must hear it somewhere else - and I confirm that he does naughty things, but he is also quite capable of doing good things and I know he does both.  Hopefully that encourages him to do the good things! :)



Reply Reply Report
exquisite-flower
November 2008 | exquisite-flower
Re: Actions not People

So well written kseer.  The practical examples help clarify and present the differences.  This is so important, especially when we are talking to our children. 

Peace
EF.x



Reply Reply Report
Rhadika
November 2008 | Rhadika
Re: Actions not People

Wow this is an absolutely fantastic article, and can applied to every part of our lives. You have done a fantaastic job writing this, and some other articles of your's I have read have been just as helpful and intriguing. Please keep up the good work as it is much appreciated. Thanks you.

Dika. xx.



Reply Reply Report
GilliLP
November 2008 | GilliLP
Re: Actions not People

This is a brilliant article! I already followed the advice in another article, asking my son what he has to do to make me love him, and reassuring him that he doesn't have to do anything because I always love him. But your article takes it further, giving those of us with fiery tempers better ways to handle anger-inducing situations to minimise (or hopefully avoid altogether) the hurt we can inflict on those we love when we get angry. Thank you!



Reply Reply Report
      kseers
November 2008 | kseers
Re: Actions not People

thanks!



Reply Reply Report
janicepovey
November 2008 | janicepovey
Re: Actions not People

 This is an excellent article kseer...well written and explained clearly.

I agree we should address the action not the person..... and in doing so you will always recieve a more positive result.    My pet hate is someone calling a child or adult STUPID....sais often enough it can cause emotional damage, especially in children.

Cheers Janice 



Reply Reply Report
      kseers
November 2008 | kseers
Re: Actions not People

Thank you Janice, it's so true!




Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend