I'm lovin' Minti ... the honest and open sharing, the stories: whether of funny family incidents, challenges overcome, through to earth-shatteringly devastating real-life dramas -- all the stuff that makes up life! (I'd love to see more dads represented, but that's another issue for another day!!)
In the short
time I've been part of the Minti community, I've seen a number of questions in regards to concerns for a child welfare in our own family, with friends or neighbours children... people asking "should I or shouldn't I?" alert authorities, speak to the parents, do something... or just let it go?
Life has it's ups and downs and stuff happens, to all of us!
I know that I've had a couple of embarassing moments as a parent... like the time when my 3 year-old N went to kindy (they start 'em young in HK) with a black eye, and explained calmly to the teacher that "Daddy kicked me"!!
Thinking about it now, I probably should have volunteered the story myself earlier -- at the time it didn't even cross my mind! When I collected her from the school that afternoon, the teacher approached me and asked me directly, "What happened here?". I explained how the accident had occured, that I had been carrying her little sister in a baby pouch in front of me (which made seeing the ground directly in front of me a bit of challenge), while she stood at my side as I was talking to a neighbour. As we said goodbye and I turned to walk away, she had left my side and darted across directly in front of me, and I hadn't noticed... my knee came up and collided with her little face! I had to calm her down and apologise for my clumsiness of course... and the eye came up in beautiful dark shades of blue/purple/indigo/violet later that afternoon!
I have to admit I was acutely embarassed for a moment, and a little shocked, that the teacher had to approach me (it was a church-run kindy, and I was a pastor at another local church... and they should just KNOW I would never deliberately kick my child in the head!)... and after explaining I went away wondering how many other parents and friends had seen the damage and wondered all kinds of stuff
-- but once I got over myself, and thought about it a little, I was SO thankful that she had taken the initiative to ask, and not just assume that everything was OK; so I went back and told her that the next day... and encouraged her to ALWAYS do or say something if there was any doubt!
A while back we were asked to visit a grandmother who lives near us, who was struggling to cope with 4 of her grandchildren moving in with her suddenly. She was in this situation because the children had been removed from their parents after their two younger siblings had died, in the family home, from neglect. My wife stayed to have a chat with grandma, while I and my own kids brought the kids home to play for a while, just to give grandma a little breathing space. Meeting these 4 kids personally brought home the awful reality of the story that I'd already seen on the news... but also made me ask myself... what about the neigbours? what about the teachers of the older siblings at their schools? What about this grandma? friends of the family? Didn't any of these people see that something was seriously remiss in the family? If someone had spoken up, maybe two young lives would not have been snuffed out, ... and a family may have gotten help in time to stop a lifetime of emotional and social consequences for every family member!?
Yes, these kids were probably used to a level of dysfunction that most of us might not be able to get our heads around... BUT, at the same time, what stood out to me was that they were not THAT much different from a number of kids that I know at school... which makes you think!
I now think that I would much rather that neighbours and friends and teachers confronted me or reported me (or any other 'good' parent I know) to government authorities or the police or to the school if they had any concerns for my children's welfare... rather than risk the long-term damage to any child's physical, emotional, sexual health... or worse! -- that can take place where we second guess. And, at least in Australia, I know that the police and government agencies are there to INVESTIGATE these claims, and then to provide a whole range of different types of support/intervention strategies where needed -- with the goal of keeping families together wherever possible, helping parents learn coping skills, getting counselling for children and adults... If you do report, you are not 'breaking up a family', you are possibly giving them access to tools and support that can keep them safely together!
So, in short... if in doubt, share those doubts or concerns with somebody! Say something!! Talk to a parent/grand-parent/school principal/police info line/Dept of Child Safety...
I know I'd find it hard to live with myself if a child was killed, seriously injured, or seriously emotionally maimed, in a situation that I had doubts about but had not reported!