minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) 4.07 (Worth a try) from 26 votes (1244 Visits)

Boys and Guns

Anonymous Author (March 2006)

What is this thing with boys and guns?

I had my baby later than some of my friends and in my childless years, I made the mistake (once) of giving a cowboy set (complete with faux cow hide vest, plastic rifle and sheriff's badge) to a 4 year old

birthday boy. The little boy was thrilled of course, but my girlfriend had a quiet word with me regarding the protocol that surrounds gift-giving. We should never ever condone violence, and toy guns are strictly a no-no. 

With tragedies such as the Port Arthur and the Columbine High School massacre, we can't blame parents for being wary of guns and what they represent. We are afraid of how our boys may turn out if they are allowed to play with toy guns from a young age.

When my son turned 4, all he wanted was a gun. He wanted one that shot 'laser beams' and can 'kill all the bad guys' in one blow. As he didn't own a toy gun, he constructed one out of his megablocks. I was very perturbed and disturbed since we don't encourage that sort of role-play at home and I thought that he may have picked up this influence from elsewhere. 

I was right of course, my son and other little boys did role-play at the playground and at kindy. They picked up objects that vaguely resembled guns and they shot at each other, making "phoosh phoosh" sounds for sound effects.

I brought the matter up with my brother one day and he set me straight. He reminded me of how we (our friends and us) used to make belief as well. We had loads of water pistols, play rifles, swords as well as light sabres. We were forever playing games that involved one team being the "bad guys" and the other team being the "good guys". We ran around the house and the garden, ducking behind furniture and pot plants shooting at one another. We all turned out ok. None of us have violent tendencies nor are we psycho killers.  We eventually stopped those games and moved onto board games and movies.

My son is now 6 and he has grown out of his gun-phase and is now into martial arts and ball games. He still plays his gameboy and sometimes playstation and he still shoots at the "bad guys", but aiming with his joystick rather than his building blocks. He understands that the games are all make-belief and are not real. He also understands that only criminals use weapons to hurt people.

The thing with children is that they do have an active imagination.  I feel that it is only right to allow them to let their imagination run wild. As long as they understand that there are boundaries such as no-hitting and no-hurting (other children or animals),  and that it's 'all pretend', I cannot see the real harm in letting them make belief.

From experience, the more that you try to curb the shooting games, the more likely it is that they want to play these games when you're not around. It sometimes becomes more exciting because it is so forbidden. Don't feel bad when the boys want to play such games, just ensure that you draw the line at what is acceptable play (for me, I did not like my son telling his sister things like "I will kill you!") and just relax. You don't have to encourage it, but you don't have to make a big deal out of it either. They should eventually grow out of the "gun phase".

 

 

 

 

 

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) 4.07 (Worth a try) from 26 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

MissKelly
January 2008 | MissKelly
Re: Boys and Guns

I too was also against guns when the boys were very young. Do you know how hard it is to find water squirt guns in the shape of something else for the pool. I did find dolphin shaped ones. When the boys were about 5 and 6 I thought they could understand the whole thing. But here is a funny one. When they were about 4 I caught them biting their grahm crackers into the shapes of guns. I had to laugh. At my preschool where I teach there are no guns aloud and the boys AND girls chew their toast onto the shapes of guns and pretend to use them. UGH!



Reply Reply Report
mumof2b
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | mumof2b
Boys and Guns
I too was one of those mums that said NO WAY was my son ever going to play with guns, but he too was one of those kids that used just about anything he could find to resemble a gun. Eventually i gave in and as he got older we taught him about guns and what they can do and that it's okay to pretend as long as he keeps those things in mind.


Reply Reply Report
HOTMAMA
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | HOTMAMA
Teach your children gun safety
This is a touchy subject, but people need to realize guns dont kill people, people kill people!  My brother in law accidentaly shot and KILLED his BEST FRIEND!  He was arrested, put in jail for almost a year through the trial, and released.  No one ever showed him propper gun safety.  ALL of my kids know NEVER to point a gun at a person, be it a real gun or a fake one.  My daughter is 9 and she received a 22 rifle as a Christmas present.  She is only allowed to shoot with her father or I right next to her, she has known the rules of handling a gun, and if she breaks even one of those rules then she will no longer have it.  We keep it in a safe, she doesnt have the combination, she is not allowed to carry it around.  She knows what guns do.  Parents need to set rules.  We started with toy guns, never point them at another person.  It is hard, I remember playing cowboys and indians when I was little.  My dad always had a loaded gun in his truck, in his room and usually on him at all times, I never ever touched them, I knew better!  It is a tragedy that more parents dont teach their children gun safety, even if they do not own a gun, because your child could come across one at a friends house, or find one just about anywhere.  They should know that it is a dangerous thing.  Teach them to never point them at themselves or others, and always assume that it is loaded.  I know this pertains more to the older kids, but start somewhere.  My brother in law has to live with killing his best friend for the rest of his life, and it was an accident that could have been avoided, they thought that taking the clip out of the gun meant that it was unloaded, not knowing that there was one in the chamber.  Better safe than sorry. 


Reply Reply Report
      bubba76
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | bubba76
Teach your children gun safety
l understand what you are saying there, my boys my older 2 have been taught everything about safety etc. they go shooting with there uncle and father sometimes.


Reply Reply Report
      lunaeclips5
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | lunaeclips5
Teach your children gun safety
Great one!


Reply Reply Report
bubba76
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | bubba76
Guns
l do belive children need to grow and pretend play as a mother of 4 boys l can say they do grow out of it and every now and then they play there little army games. my oldest two are nearly 14 and 12 and he will play army games with my nearly 9 and 4 year old when they want to play. l rather they play there games around me instead of telling them no to there growing needs. l know when l was younger l use to play the same outdoor games with my younger brother and it did has no harm. it applys to telling boys they should not play with dolls/ action figures as they are for girls and telling girls they cannot play with cars. my boys do own a few guns (whats left that have not been broken) but they rather use pieces of cardborad cut out. they older boys play pc/psp/ps2 games that are shooting games and l play with them. they also understand that any weapons are dangerous and they no what is right and wrong. Pleas dont stop your children from there growing and the games they play as kids need to grow and do things like we all did!


Reply Reply Report
cazza
3.80 (Good) | January 2007 | cazza
Boys and Guns....
well im the same as the rest here, I havnt let my son play with toy guns, but he does have a army set...But saying that he is always being more interested in playing with toy cars then anything else... I have seen how my nepgews have turned out by having toy guns, and it not preety, now im not saying all boys are like them, I think its how you teach your boys on how to play this imaganitive game...


Reply Reply Report
Jessgore
3.80 (Good) | January 2007 | Jessgore
I am in two minds.
I really have not come upon this as yet, my son is a bit young to even know what a gun is. But I do have a friend who's children take things a little to far, in their case they are not allowed to play these sort of role  playing games as they can get a bit out of hand, and when here their mothers asks us not to let them play the shooting or fighting games. As I myself noticed that they can take it a bit to seriously.

I guess really what you need to do is watch how your kids react to these type of roll playing games and decide for yourself if you wish to let your children play these games or with these type of toys.  As the above advice stated they turned out ok. I myself played cops and robbers all the time. My father was a police officer and we had a jail in the back yard. So we actually (when no one was in it) had a place to put the criminals. And I turned out ok.  I think it really depends on how the kids react and really only we can be the judge of that.

I don't think my hubby would mind giving a toy gun to our son, and I will give him one chance with it. If I see it getting out of hand and taking it to seriously then I will put a stop to those games. As above they will pick up sticks or playmobil and make their own. I guess we just need to be parents and watch the way the game goes and make our minds up. Not all kids are the same, and some kids will take it way to seriously others will just make believe and forget about it in a few years. I pray that if my child gets a toy gun for Christmas this is what he would do, make believe and grow out of it.  And that if he does take it to seriously I can stop it before it gets out of hand.....


Reply Reply Report
NINJAFAIRY
3.80 (Good) | January 2007 | NINJAFAIRY
boys toys

No guns are allowed in my house - and any guns given to my boys as presents were confiscated, including those that came with GI Joe etc.

however - the rule is, if the boys make the gun themselves, they are allowed to play with it for the day, because by being creative/constructive I figure they've earned the right to play with it. It also shortens the actual time they have left to play with it - and with most boys attention span being not very long, by the time they've made it, they loose interest not long after.

And thanks for the memories - I hadn't thought of playing cops'n'robbers myself for a long time (even though I've seen my own kids do it)



Reply Reply Report
exquisite-flower
3.50 (Good) | November 2006 | exquisite-flower
"Beware the mystery"
We never had guns in our home, or snakes or things that could scare or hurt or harm.  We had pretend play, but no gameboys etc that emulated that lifestyle.  My auntie used to say to my mother "Beware the mysterious" But there ws no mystery.  Mum and dad tended to face the issue, offer their opinion and we fell in line, but it was rational and not mysterious.  they didnt leave out details that were important, they didnt shroud these harmful things from us.  They explained the dangers and how they didnt feel comfortable having these things in their home.  We all turned out ok.  It depens how you tackle things as to how our children, and other children we interact with respond to the different things we expose them to. 
Peace
EF.x 


Reply Reply Report
gr8est
4.14 (Good) | August 2006 | gr8est
Bang your dead
A gun to a child is something that is not harmful they know the dead on tv are just acting and you will see them grabbing their oscar at the awards night what we do about toy gun control in our home is our buisness but for my family I am happy to pretend to be dead


Reply Reply Report
hrs2004
3.50 (Good) | June 2006 | hrs2004
Guns

I agree that there is little you can do to stop boys being boys, or girls being girls for that matter. I have no intention of giving my lad guns or any games that promote shooting, but have no problem if he decides to use his imagination to make weapons. I'm all for as much imagination as possible and who am I to stifle that? Still, I have also seen my brother and nephew go through gun phases. OK, my 40 year old brother still hasn't sadly grown out of it (he likes paintballing, but not real guns), but like Clay, he would be upset if his cat caught a mouse, let alone set out to harm anyone. I think a far more worrying thing to look out for is children just generally harming animals and others. When thers's real injuries, then you can worry!



Reply Reply Report
      Kate
5.00 (Excellent) | July 2006 | Kate
Guns

I can see validity in promoting imagination, and also agree with others in that making too big a deal of it can be detrimental to promoting "peace"...  To be completley honest, I don't know where the line should be drawn.

However, I think that there is a great deal that you can and should do to discourage violent play among young children.  I have a two year old daughter who is often bombarded with toy  weapons by her four year old cousin.  The reason why I think that intervention is necessary is because I don't want to wait until there are injuries to "worry".  I don't think that she has the understanding let alone the muscle control to play with weapons.  I strongly believe that consistancy is an integral part of healthy child development.   To that end I have a no guns rule. Guns are not toys.  If blocks, snacks or fingers become guns, I'll say, "guns are not allowed".  No double standards for the adults either - at least in front of the (ie: paint ball, pellet guns, video games).  Isn't it a huge responsibility for our kids to determine which guns/weapons are good and which are bad?   What is safe and what is not? 

I try to explain that guns hurt people, and will answer any questions that are bound to arise (especially if I have a son one day).  Unless I am convinced otherwise, I'll just keep promoting alternatives.



Reply Reply Report
ClayCook
4.48 (Good) | March 2006 | ClayCook
I remember my gun phase
Great article!

I remember my army man phase. It lasted many many years and I absolutely loved it... I still love watching war movies... however I would be the last person to ever hurt anyone in real life, or even think of hurting someone.

I say let them play with the toy guns and use their imagination. Just make sure they understand what is reality and what is good and what is really bad.


Reply Reply Report
Matt2
4.52 (Excellent) | March 2006 | Matt2
Glad it worked for you
Personally, I just don't want my 4 year old talking about killing anything or anyone. He is just too young to really comprehend what death is all about and I feel that giving him a play weapon at such a young age will just encourage this type of behavior. If he needs aggressive play my wife and I encourage him to use his animal and dinosaur toys to express himself.


Reply Reply Report
      Anonymous Member
3.55 (Good) | March 2006 | anonymous  
Re: Glad it worked for you
That's a great idea re: using animal and dinosaur toys to express his aggression!


Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend