minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Wouldn't recommend) (Wouldn't recommend) (Wouldn't recommend) (Wouldn't recommend) (Wouldn't recommend) 1.73 (Wouldn't recommend) from 20 votes (465 Visits)

HELP

Dawn by Dawn Talking Back(August 2006) (rank 56th)

Hello my name is Lauren. I'm a mother of a 14m child who likes to hit, throw toys, and pull his girl cuz hair.. What can i do?? I feel like a bad mom all i do is cry over it... It doen't help that i just moved about 3m

ago right after i had Jeremiah. So i'm staying with my brother and his wife with there three kids and they are BRATS!!! My son is learning to behave like a brat.. What can i do?? I put him on time out, i give him a light tap on the diaper and say no we don't do that.. What am i going to do??/ I have a sick grandma that i take care of so i feel bad about that (she has Alzheimers in the begining of it. So she is never happy) So i have all this to deal with. Am i taking it hard that my son is being a brat?? If anyone can help. Please do i need it...

CHILDREN ARE PRODUCTS OF THEIR  SURROUNDINGS, DON'T BE INSULTED, BUT THEY ARE LITTLE APES TO APE SOMEONE IS TO DO WHAT THEY DO. MY FIRST SUGGESTION IS TO MOVE OUT OF YOUR BROTHERS HOUSE AS HIS COUSINS SEEM TO BE A BAD INFLUENCE ON HIM. HOW LONG DOES HE GOE IN TIMEOUT FOR I MIN. PER YEAR IS THE RULE OF THUMB, AND IF YOU ARE HITTING HIM ON HIS BOTTOM THEN WHY DO YOU EXPECT THAT HE WON'T HIT YOU? DO YOU THINK THAT BECAUSE YOUR HIS MOM HE SHOULD NOT HIT YOU? THAN WAY AS HIS MOM DO YOU HIT HIM? NEXT ARE YOU A QUALIFIED NURSE?YOUR GRANDMA SHOULD GO INTO A HOME WHERE SHE CAN GET PROPER CARE. WHY DO YOU SAY SHE IS NEVER HAPPY? YOU ARE TAKING ON ALOT AND BECAUSE OF GRANDMA'S CONDITON I THINK THAT IT IS UPSETTING YOU AND SO IS YOUR SONS NEW BEHAVIOUR AND IT SOUNDS LIKE YOU HAVE TAKEN ON MORE THAN YOU MIGHT BE ABLE TO HANDLE.

DO NOT THINK ME HORRIBLE TO SUGGEST THA TYOUR GRANDMOTHER GO INTO A HOME, THERE ARE ALOT OF GOOD ONES THAT KNOW HOW TO CARE FOR ELDERLY PEOPLE WHO SUFFER FROM ALL KINDS OF HEALTH PROBLEMS. PERHAPS IF YOU STUDY UP A BIT ON ALZHEIMERS, YOU WILL KNOW WHAT TO EXPECT, AND I WOULD NOT ADVISE HAVING A SMALL CHILD AROUND AN AGING ILL ADULT. TAKE A BREATH TAKE A TRIP TO YOUR LOCAL LIBRARY TALK TO YOUR FAMILY WHO I HOPE IS HELPING WITH GRANDMA AND THEN DECIDE WHAT TO DO. IN THE MEANTIME UNLESS YOU GET JEREMIAH AWAY FROM HIS COUSINS, A BRAT HE WILL BE BECAUSE APES ARE APES

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Wouldn't recommend) (Wouldn't recommend) (Wouldn't recommend) (Wouldn't recommend) (Wouldn't recommend) 1.73 (Wouldn't recommend) from 20 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

lexiw
September 16th | lexiw
Re: HELP

hmm I am not sure about this. I agree that if she has the means she should move out of her brothers house. I don't agree though that you should not have young children around an ageing ill adult. I would never give up the time I spent with my great aunt as she died from cancer. I was only very young and it was a very sad time but I learnt so much and I have special memories from my time with her.

 Lexi xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
llmunchkin
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2007 | llmunchkin
Re: HELP
I don't really see this advice, I see it more as a personal opinion...  You have addressed the situation by really saying what you would do in the same situation.  As a personal opinion, it would be better suited as a comment attached to the question, or in a blog.  It seems you have no empathy for this poor girl at all.  I hope that she managed to find some appropriate advice in the other comments submitted both here, and in Q&A.

If anyone else finds themself in a similar situation - don't despair, and remember to contact the patient's Doctor to get in touch with professional assistance - whether it be a home carer on a regular basis, or someone who can ease the burden by taking her on an outing.  Discuss your concerns with your family if you feel like this, and your own Doctor, it seems like you may have PND on top of all the other stress you are experiencing.


Reply Reply Report
yularaangel
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2006 | yularaangel
hope this helps ligthen the burden

I understand it is very hard to stay with members of family. Do you get the chance to spend any quality time with your child. Children learn what they see. If you are tired, upset because of Grandmas condition perhaps you can talk to the local respite unit , they can give you time out from grandma and during that time use it to find a small place for you and you child. You sound as though you have to much on your shoulders to carry and need to lighten the load. The song "He ain't heavy he's my brother" comes to mind. There are times when you need to share the load and grandma is a burden that you need to share. and your child isn't heavy he's your son.

God bless you during this current trial



Reply Reply Report
hennen
5.00 (Excellent) | August 2006 | hennen
Thanks for your help!
Thanks to everyone who has tryed to help.. I spent the last week woth my oldest son and he is doing alot better.. I think !! LOL He's happy and when his dad comes home from work he is all smiles..  I've talked with my dad, it;s his mom.. He thinks that  she took care of him, that he should take care of his mom, but then i told him that i'm the one taking care of his mom. That i have a family two boys, and one more on the way.. SO he is going to help out more, and i'm taking my mom on long walks every night with no children or husbands... When my grandmother gets worse then we will put her into a home, but for now we are going to take care of her.. It's very weird taking care of her, she ask for the weidest things every... She wanted us to put a spice on her cereal.. But we are all getting use to her ways.. Thank you all for your help.


Reply Reply Report
cheleinkal
4.00 (Good) | August 2006 | cheleinkal
Lauren Asked for our help
Dawn, I am aghast at your "Advice".  Firstly because you are answering a woman who by her own admission is at the end of her rope & you have used nothing by way of consideration for obvious fragile emotions. "Yeeeaaarrrsss" of experience or not, you might want to try toning down your opinions and honing up on your people skills.  

Not nice when you are slapped in the face with the cold fish of reality is it?? Even when it's written in lower case. 

If someone asks for help you help them. You don't bash them over the head with your opinions.  Oh and by the way, this would have been better off being written under "know a little", which is in direct answer to the question and not written as "Advice".  Just remember you don't know any of these people.  You don't know if she is living on fresh air and a prayer.  She I bet isn't living with her brother because she can afford a room at the local Hilton.  And perhaps her Grandmother doesn't own her own home & does not have the thousands of dollars that it takes to place a person into a decent aged care facility.  My grand father is in one with the same thing, and it costs a fortune, even with his vetrans affairs subsidy.  Not only that but there is a waiting list here in Australia years long.  people litterally have to die, before you can get in.  So maybe you should think first and type later next time.  try reading between the lines.  try placing yourself in someone elses shoes before bestowing the benefit of all your "yeeaarrs" of wisdom upon us. 


Reply Reply Report
      Dawn
August 2006 | Dawn
Lauren Asked for our help
Yes she did and in My opinion that is exactyly what I gave her! If a person is not trained to look after an aging relation than of course she is going to get a bit frazzled especially when she has a small child  to tend to as well. It is all well and find to say I would never put my parents in a home! But are you ready to deal with your mom soiling herself and you having to change her,or wandering off and her not knowing where she is. i will not make apoligies for the advice I gave as i experienced this first hand! so I know of what I speak, and sometimes the TRUTH as hard as it may be to take is what a person needs.Who by the way said anything about the HILTON? where do YOU come up with this? there are agencies out there to help people in need. I am personally as you put it aghast at your own advice are you actually suggesting that rather thanseek help she just sweep it all under the carpet and not talk about the family problem. Talk about honing people skills you yourself should try it. Come off your high horse and stop being so condesending! P.s. if you think what you said was a slap in the face to me, you are I must say sadly mistaken for as I said before I stand by what I said as I have lived it! 


Reply Reply Report
           JadieLady
4.00 (Good) | August 2006 | JadieLady
Lauren Asked for our help

OK guys this is getting out of hand!

We dont know the situation, so instead of makign genrealisations or commenting on that situation, leave it out of the equation? the real question is about the children here, NOT the grandmother!



Reply Reply Report
JadieLady
August 2006 | JadieLady
the situations

okay im not sure i agree with you saying children are apes- im not sure if i missed some kind of joke or not, but it seemed to be used out of context if it was a joke.

sometimes our situation puts us in a place we dont feel we deserve or that isnt quite  perfect. having an gradnmother with alzeihmers is hard enough, but living with her and your brother with their kids must be like a really bad dream! I say this as i have had to live with family before and it is just really straining.

I think that you need to address what is happening in a more firm way, maybe confront your brother and see if they can help discipline their kids.

with that in mind, your son will go to school one day. their will be brats there. he may pick up that behaviour. how would you combat that situation? you cannot literally confront every child's parent and tell them to make their children behave. you should get your son disciplined, so if he is exposed to bad behaviour again he will still behave properly. its hard to do, but can be done :)



Reply Reply Report
Izzy
5.00 (Excellent) | August 2006 | Izzy
life is hard

We don't know the specifics of the questioner's life. She may have moved in with her brother because of financial hardship. If this is the case, it may not be an option to have the grandma at a nursing home either.

Also, children are a product of a great many things - not just the surrounding. It is entirely possible to raise a well mannered child even if he/she is surrounded by terrible children, it may be hard - but not impossible.



Reply Reply Report
apwed
5.00 (Excellent) | August 2006 | apwed
need to teach you don't accept

it is a little bit like the different home different rules for kids that have seperated parents... you need to try the tacted that it is okay for them as their parents allow it but you are his mum and you do not find this as acceptable behaviour and that as you are his mum he needs to behave for you... maybe hearing you say to your child that this behaviour is acceptable to the other children's parents and not you may makeyour brother and his wife  take bit offence and start telling their kids not to behave that way too... if son is feeling you all stressed out about his behaviour and your dealing with granma too that could be another reason playing up so much as kids tend to play up when they feel you are stressed because they don't know what is going on and it stresses them too and causes them to play up.... you sound like need to try and get some alone time just you and your son and maybe show him a happy stress free you for a few hours and start rewarding him more for good behaviour and showing him very happy with him when not doing the stuff his cousins are doing and showing him he getting a reward for not doing what they are doing and they aren' t as they still behaving that way

good luck hope can get own place soon!!



Reply Reply Report
hrs2004
4.29 (Good) | August 2006 | hrs2004
Children and behaviour

It sounds like Lauren is in a really tough situation and needing help. When I was younger, my gran moved in with us and declined rapidly with alzheimers. In her, it also made her generally miserable - I think it can bring out the worst in people somehow, although they have no control over themselves. Moving her in to a home was not only not an option financially, but also morally. My parents are from a generation where you take care of those who took care of you. Sure, a home is a great solution for many but doesn't work for many others. I also think that suggesting she moves out from her brother's fails to address the problem. In life, we have to build on what we are given and cannot always change the situations we are unhappy with.

I agree with the fact that children learn by imitation and so Lauren will have her work cut out if she is trying to impose a different kind of discipline to her brothers idea. I believe she needs to sit down calmly and try to work out with her brother and any other adult involved in caring for the children how discipline and respect can be improved in the house. Not an easy one to tackle and bound to need lots of tact and diplomacy.



Reply Reply Report
ClayCook
4.00 (Good) | August 2006 | ClayCook
Do you mean to yell?
Hi Dawn,
Your advice above "IS IN CAPITAL LETTERS LIKE THIS".
This appears as though you are yelling?
Much nicer to read if "it were in lower case like this"
My ears are sore
-- Clay


Reply Reply Report
      Dawn
3.00 (Average) | August 2006 | Dawn
Do you mean to yell?
just to let everyone know that when I WRITE SOMETHING IN THIS MANNER, I am not yelling just my way of getting my point across.If I offended anyone I am sorry as that was not my intent. I was only trying to share my yearssssss of experience. please accept mu humble apology. sincerely Dawn


Reply Reply Report
           JadieLady
5.00 (Excellent) | August 2006 | JadieLady
Do you mean to yell?
Dawn, it is just that the block text full of capital letters is hard to read. if you needto make a point you could perhaps use the bold or italic feature, or only use capitals to put the emphasis on a particular word or phrase instead of the whole text. a lot easier on the eyes :)


Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend