minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.89 (Highly recommend) from 7 votes (88 Visits)

To school or to home school?

YUB by YUB In Nappies(June 3rd) (rank 500+)

For the past two years my husband and I have been pondering very deeply what to do with our childrens education. There has been reason for this thought because my husband went to a public school, and I was home schooled. Interestingly my husband only finished year 10 while I

finished year 12, so this raised the question "How shall we educate our children?"

Now, I know that parents in general are either VERY for Public (or private) schooling, or VERY for home schooling, and there seems to be very little middle ground, so please do not take my words as an attack of any kind, it is just my experience I am sharing, nothing more.

The pros of home schooling: Home schooling allows us to take a leading role in their education, and gives us control over what they learn, when they learn it, and how they learn it. Eliminates a lot of the negative influences, the biggest one of which is bullying. Gives us a more intimate knowledge of our child and their personal growth. Gives us better knowledge of their comings and goings (socialising).

The pros of Public and Private schooling: A break from the child, "free time" during the day. Teaches the child independence and self reliance. Teaches how to interact with other children and form friendships.Gives them structure from day to day.Provides a wealth of information through various avenues.

Some of the cons for home schooling is:  the time the parent has to give the child every day, both for the school work, AND the activities the child would participate in. The possibility of isolation for both parent and child, depending on where you are and how you go about the teaching. Very little respite.

Some of the cons for public/private schooling is: The negative influences (peer pressures, bullying, certain 'attitides' brought home etc) The possibility of your child 'growing apart' from you due to two seperate lives being lived and little knowledge of how to 'build bridges'. Travel to and from (either public transport, or your own vehicle, and the worry of safety and cost because of this.

One thing is for sure: You can obtain the info for either easily, and never dismiss the other simply because you don't think you can, or because the thought is too unnerving. (I am talking about both home schooling and public here) This is your childs future you are dealing with. Be careful with what you do with it!

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.89 (Highly recommend) from 7 votes
Report
ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

sandra106
September 15th | sandra106
Re: To school or to home school?

interesting article



Reply Reply Report
OliviaHill
June 9th | OliviaHill
Re: To school or to home school?

My son is only 10 months old and I am planning to homeschool him at least for primary school.  This is mainly because of the hours I work.  I run my own business and work 3 afternoon/evenings a week and all weekend. If he went to traditional school I would never see him and I would hate that.  I was also incredibly bored at primary school and spent most of the time reading under the desk.  I hope I can make schooling more interesting for him and still keep a really close bond!



Reply Reply Report
      YUB
June 9th | YUB
Re: To school or to home school?

Be prepared for him to not necessarily agree with you on what's fun and what's not! My four year old and I have 'discussions'  quite often about whether or not he should do what I want him to or not, and I find myself making a lot of subtle compromises so that I can 'win' the debate, and not have to do it all over again, and I also find myself giving a nearly outrageous amount of praise over the smallest thing, just to encourage him to go on!

It brings back so many memories of my Mum doing the same thing with me, and I tell you what - I seem to have a lot more enthusiasm and patience than I gave myself credit for!!!!



Reply Reply Report
tyheamma
June 9th | tyheamma
Re: To school or to home school?

I like that you don't specifically say that one method is the only way to go. Far too often, I see the public schoolers or the homeschoolers becoming close minded and trying to convince people that their counterparts are harming the children involved, when really, everyone is just trying to do what they think is best for those they love.



Reply Reply Report
      YUB
June 9th | YUB
Re: To school or to home school?

Thanks mate!



Reply Reply Report
Philosopher13
June 5th | Philosopher13
Re: To school or to home school?

 I was actually home schooled for the last 3 years of my schooling before college. I was given the choice by my parents to either be home schooled or return to the school where something traumatic had happened. (I had wanted to go to an arts school for creative writing.) 

 The first year was horrible. My parents and I were always at odds with each other, I often finished my work well ahead of schedule and became bored. The second year however, I was eligible to attend a Co-op of home schoolers, that also happened to have a few friends of mine in it. We met once a week, and each parent taught  or assisted in a different subject. We were given work assignments for the rest of the week. That's when I really started to enjoy myself, although I wished we had met more than once a week. 

Having a lot of friends that have been home schooled, I have seen many of them go one of two ways. They rebel either at home or when they get out, or they are so sheltered they are scared of everything. There are a few who ended up in the middle ground, but honestly, most of those had some regular schooling at some point in there lives.  I do believe it can be done successfully though. 

I would have this advice for those considering it. Be sure you don't get into it out of fear. Trying to keep our kids from harm is every parents desire, but sheltering them hurts them too. If you are going to do it, make sure it's your child's education you have in mind, not just their safety. And be sure you have the patience, self-control and finances for it. Home schooling is a lot of work and can be very expensive. It's also a good idea to look for a local co-op or start one. Oh, and I know at least here in America, home schoolers are often allowed to participate in after school programs and sports at local public schools.

 



Reply Reply Report
kathryn-solaris
June 4th | kathryn-solaris
Re: To school or to home school?

fantastic advice, there is also the middle ground of vollenteering in the classroom. it is free, easy to do and verry little stress. although i would dearly love to go back to homeschooling i started with so little support and found it a bit much for me to cope with at the time which kind of has me fearful of it.

i have since put my hand up for the classroom helper atm once a week but would love to make it twice and have found that i get more interaction with the teachers and know more about how logan is going there than i would know just through a once a term meeting and a newsletter. it is wonderful to get to know all his friends there too and help them all learn, they have such a lovely class of kids.

::)'s from becca.



Reply Reply Report
llmunchkin
June 4th | llmunchkin
Re: To school or to home school?

There are so many considerations... I guess with Home Schooling, you would need to be confident in your own ability to impart knowledge and stick to a learning routine on a regular basis.  Do you really want to spend that much time every day with a school aged child or do you need a break to get on with your own education, work etc?  The local schools would also affect your choice, are they good are they bad?  Do you know anyone who attends them?  What are their experiences?  Will you be able to provide alternative occasions for your child to associate with his/her peers to learn things in a group environment, or partcipate in sports, music etc?  How do you create a balance in the home between schooling and ever day learning?  What boundaries do you set between being a teacher and parent, or do they merge?  Where can we find out more about home schooling and statistics in regard to the acadmeic results of equivalent aged home-schooled, public-schooled and private-schooled children?  Great article as it provokes thought, however it prompts me to ask these and many more questions ; )



Reply Reply Report
      YUB
June 4th | YUB
Re: To school or to home school?

I am actually happy that it provokes the questions, as  I recon the more area that is consiously covered as far as childrens education  is concerned the better.

I also understand that a lot of parents get overwhelmed by a flood of questions and information, but I have never met or heard of any one who has ablsolutly no avenue to find out what they need to know, (bar the motivation and self confidence), as every one has access to friends, family, neighbours, a church, a school, the telephone or mobile phone, the internet, or the library. The list goes on.

The most common thing a person will say to me if schooling comes up is, 'I did not think there was anything else I could do." and some times they are right, but they never looked into the matter to make sure!



Reply Reply Report
           llmunchkin
June 5th | llmunchkin
Re: To school or to home school?

I read a few different articles about home schooling, most have been very informative and about personal experience... Somehow the way you wrote this actually got me thinking about it more. 

I certainly think that it is an important and valid option, though no matter what method we end up choosing, we will be the primary educators in his life ; )



Reply Reply Report
YUB
June 4th | YUB
Re: To school or to home school?

Okay! Off the top of my head. . . .

The cons for home schooling is:  the time the parent has to give the child every day, both for the school work, AND the activities the child would participate in. The possibility of isolation for both parent and child, depending on where you are and how you go about the teaching. Very little respite.

The cons for public/private schooling is: The negative influences (peer pressures, bullying, certain 'attitides' brought home etc) The possibility of your child 'growing apart' from you due to two seperate lives being lived and little knowledge of how to 'build bridges'. Travel to and from (either public transport, or your own vehicle, and the worry of saftey and cost because of this.



Reply Reply Report
      llmunchkin
June 4th | llmunchkin
Re: To school or to home school?

Great comment, it really would add a lot of value to your article, you can edit it in by cut & paste... There is an edit option for your advice, you can change it as many times as you like : )



Reply Reply Report
Juzzy
June 3rd | Juzzy
Re: To school or to home school?

This would be great if you did put the cons as well as the pros as then people can see both sides of the story. Even if it does cause some discussion, heated or otherwise.

Juzzy xoxo



Reply Reply Report

Related Content

Add

No related content has been added

Related Tags

Add

None

Bookmarks

No bookmarks found

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend