minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.86 (Highly recommend) from 8 votes (128 Visits)

There are other ways to discipline a child other than smacking.

Juzzy by Juzzy Speaking(July 15th) (rank 176th)

 

I know this is a controversial subject and I am not writing it to start any arguments but to give parents other alternatives to smacking.

Let me start by saying, I am not perfect, I don’t have perfect children and parenting is one of the hardest

jobs in the world.  

One thing I feel strongly about is the fact that I don’t smack my children. I feel my kids could never do anything so bad that would make me want to smack them. To me smacking them for misbehaving or hurting someone else would not be teaching them anything. There are other ways to discipline a child, from time out to removing their favourite toy for a period of time. I will cover these more in depth further on. I have found with Josh it is as simple as saying ‘That upsets mummy’  

I strongly disagree with anyone using a weapon on a child, to some people it may just be a wooden spoon but to a child on the receiving end it is a weapon. Most of the time a parent smacks a child to relieve their own frustrations, which in itself is completely wrong because if you are frustrated you tend to smack harder. 

  There are so many things you could do if you become frustrated on a particularly bad day.

Walk away and count to 10, in those 10 seconds of removing yourself things may not look so bad. If that doesn’t work remove yourself for a few minutes, go into another room and keep yourself busy. Most of the time you will find that the frustration passes and you will be calmer. Afternoons are particularly trying in our house due to the fact that we are up by 7am and I have an almost 4 year old that hasn’t had a day sleep in about 2 years. So everyone is a little tired.   I have found if the kids are bored then they tend to play up and get into all sorts of trouble, so if the weather permits, take them outside for a run around. Trust me, you will have happier kids.  

Positive attention goes a long way as well.

If you spend the whole day yelling at the kids then they will just expect that they are going to get yelled out regardless or whether they are behaving. I have found that just spending time playing with the kids with their toys there is less fighting which in turns means less yelling from mummy. 

 Other ways you can discipline a child would be Time Outs.

Ever since Super Nanny became popular all those years ago time out is something everyone uses. Depending on how old your child is you sit them away from everyone else for a set amount of time. E.g. A 3 year old would sit in time out for 3 minutes and a 4 year old for 4 minutes. After the set amount of time you would then make them apologise for their behaviour. We have found removing toys has also worked well in our house. If they are misbehaving warn them that if they continue then they will loose a certain toy for the remainder of the day. I find if I have to remove a toy, I keep it in view but out of reach. In doing this Josh realises the consequences of his actions.  

Always give positive praise when you child is behaving.

If your child has been playing nicely for a while and you haven’t had to use your mummy voice then praise them for it. Tell them how proud you are. If Josh is having a particularly good day I will tell him at least 3 times that day how proud I am of him. At the end of the day when Josh and I are having a cuddle before bed we will talk about how good or bad he has been that day. We always end the day with an I Love You.  

Another idea is a rewards chart.


Have the days of the week and at the end of the day you and your child will decide if they have been good enough for a sticker. This is also a good time to have a talk if it has been a bad day and work out ways of how tomorrow will be a better day. After 7 stickers or a full weeks worth of stickers they get their reward which could be as simple as getting to watch their favourite DVD to a toy that they really want. 

  And finally, choose your battles.

Ignore the small things. If you have said not to something and your child is still asking or throwing a tantrum, just walk away.   Hopefully with all this information you may think twice next time you get frustrated with your children. In saying all of this, when I say smacking I don’t mean a light tap on the hand when you little angel/devil decides to stick a  flat instrument into an electrical socket. But in my opinion smacking a child never teaches them anything other than to be scared of the ones that are there to protect them.   

Thanks for reading.   Juzzy xoxo  

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.86 (Highly recommend) from 8 votes
Report
ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

mystikal
July 18th | mystikal
Re: There are other ways to discipline a child other than smacking.

I think you and I have similar ideas to punishments. Personally I've found parents who say they have "naughty children" are those who don't spend much time with their children. Their kids misbehave on purpose because it recieves the most kind of attention from them. They don't care if it's negative attention, just that they get some. I also practise on the do's rather than the don'ts for example "Inside voice please!", "walking in the house!" rather than "be quiet!" or "stop running!". I especially despise parents who resort to smacking their children under the age of 1 year, even if it's just a "fairy tap" on the hand. Children under the age of 12 months can't even cognitively comprehend a smack and that's why it cheeses me off, the child is hurt for no reason at all. I don't believe in bad children... just bad parents or parenting. But that's just me, thanks for sharing.



Reply Reply Report
      mystikal
July 18th | mystikal
Re: There are other ways to discipline a child other than smacking.

P.S I was always hit when I was a child and for 99% of them, I don't even understand what they were for. The only thing it succeded was making me fear my parents. I got the belt, wooden spoon and smacks hard enough to leave a hard print/bruises on my body. So smacking is definitely not for me. The only time I would ever consider a smack is if my son were in immediate danger.

 



Reply Reply Report
boredmum
July 18th | boredmum
Re: There are other ways to discipline a child other than smacking.

 Great advice juzzy.. I always got the strap(belt) when I was younger..I cannot hit my kids..been known to smack from reaction though if theyhurt me first but time oust generally work for us. The postive praise when good works wonders for Brad 

Thanks for sharing hon xx



Reply Reply Report
      Juzzy
July 20th | Juzzy
Re: There are other ways to discipline a child other than smacking.

Thanks hon,

I think everyone got the strap in our younger days. I am a big one for finding other ways to discipline my children before ever having to resort to smacking. Time out worked great in this house until Josh decided that he enjoyed time out so much that he would intentionally hurt Amy just so he could dit in the corner. Needless to say we found another timeout spot that wasn't so entertaining.

Thanks for reading xoxoxoxo 



Reply Reply Report
llmunchkin
July 16th | llmunchkin
Re: There are other ways to discipline a child other than smacking.

Less yelling from Mummy also makes Mummy feel better!  I'm glad your article is out of gaol Juzzy, I must say that I agree with everything you have written in general, though MicroMe received a firm smack on the bottom when he leapt out of the car and ran across the road at a friends.  I got such a shock & fright, then again, so did he!  I am hoping not to have a repeat performance of that episode, it was very much reactionary on my part.  If all else fails, the easiest thing is to takea breather from the current situation, even if it is just something simple like going into another room to get a change of scenery, or dropping everything and taking everyone for a walk around the block to get some fresh air... Great tips, well explained and well worth the read ; )



Reply Reply Report
      Juzzy
July 18th | Juzzy
Re: There are other ways to discipline a child other than smacking.

Thanks for reading Lui,

I really hope MicroMe learnt his lesson from that. I think i would probably have the same reaction if i was in your shoes. When things are getting crazy here we quite often put our shoes on and go for a walk up to the park in our street.

Juzzy xoxoxo



Reply Reply Report
neets
July 16th | neets
Re: There are other ways to discipline a child other than smacking.

fantastic advice Juzzy, I'm going to try it tomorrow and Ill let ya know might even stop Katelyn being a little la, la all day xxx



Reply Reply Report
      Juzzy
July 17th | Juzzy
Re: There are other ways to discipline a child other than smacking.

Thanks for reading Neets. Hopw Katelyn wasn't too much of a la la for you today.

xoxoxoxox



Reply Reply Report
janicepovey
July 16th | janicepovey
Re: There are other ways to discipline a child other than smacking.

 Excellent Juzzy and reads well.

You have explained the ways of disciplining and how they work, a great read for Mum's having problems disciplining their children

I agree parenting is the hardest job around. I totally agree giving praise and positive reinforcement are a must.

Thanks for sharing.

Cheers Janice



Reply Reply Report
      Juzzy
July 16th | Juzzy
Re: There are other ways to discipline a child other than smacking.

Thanks for reading Janice.

I hope it will help some frustrated mum's out there. I found that when i fell pregnant with Josh is when i started thinking about what sort of parent i wanted to be and i decided then and there that giving praise and positive reinforcements was going to be something that we practised every day.

Glad you enjoyed reading it as much as i enjoyed writing it.

Love Juzzy xoxoxoxoox



Reply Reply Report

Related Content

Add

No related content has been added

Bookmarks

No bookmarks found

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend