minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.51 (Highly recommend) from 9 votes (56 Visits)

Don't believe everything you hear - choosing what's right for our families!

taranicole by taranicole Standing(November 1st) (rank 500+)

  • When my first child was born I ONLY wanted to give him the best. He ONLY wore designer labeled clothing and had multiple pairs of shoes before he could even walk! I only used huggies nappies and Johnson and Johnson bath products and wandered the streets in my way
    too expensive pram. When he was 3 months old I attended a course on “teaching your baby to read” and looked into “baby sign language”. I bought into EVERYTHING I saw, heard and read whether it was a product or advice (even if it didn’t work for me!) as I really wanted to give my child the best of everything.
      By the time my second child was born, I was slowly learning that my boys were a little “different” to the norm – there was nothing “wrong” with them but they just didn’t respond to famous sleeping/settling books or discipline techniques the way other kids did. The advice wasn’t working and neither were the products. I couldn’t be bothered dressing him in outfits in my sleep-deprived state and his eczema seemed to flair up everytime we used the bath products. I was slowly realizing there wasn’t a one-size-fits all approach or product when it came to babies or kids and I had just blindly followed our consumerist society without even so much as a question. I just went with the flow and then wondered how I got there!   Three children later and I still consider myself a normal, mainstream mum but have a lot of questions and aren’t as quick to go with the flow and buy into advertising – I even wonder whether there are times when we need to go “against” the flow to find what’s right for us.   So I guess we can ask ourselves – How can we make better or make sure we make the right choices for our families and not get sucked in by clever marketing and advertising?

  • 1. Consider where they are coming from - motives?
  •  
  • I think a great example is nappies. Disposable nappy companies have done a great job in making sure that cloth nappies are considered alternative or hippy and generally unappealing to mainstream mums. The marketing of disposables is hard to resist as we are constantly bombarded with advertising. These big companies use very clever marketing strategies to tug at our heart strings (to the extent where they employ psychologists) in order to convince us their product is best. The sad reality is that these companies don’t really care about selling us a product that is best for our babies – their main goal is to make a profit.   Another example is the well-known example of Nestle’s unethical marketing of baby formula in third world countries which as resulted in millions of unnecessary deaths for the sake of profit. Ref: http://www.breastfeeding.com/advocacy/advocacy_boycott.html
    Therefore, I think it’s important when considering parenting information or products to question – what are the persons or company’s motives in giving me this information?  
      2. Is what they are selling (products, advice, info) in line with your value system or parenting style?
      Having two (and more than likely three) very strong-willed children and boys for that matter, I’ve had to filter through advice given to me about sleep, feeding, discipline etc. I’ve learnt that my parenting style is to acknowledge my kids individuality so I won’t prescribe to a particular book or theory as I don’t believe in a one-size-fits all approach.  I also have Christian values that I won’t compromise so anything that goes against my value system can be easily dismissed. Another value that is important to me  is caring for the environment as best I can so I try and consider that in the choices I make (e.g by choosing cloth nappies) and also try to buy fair trade products where possible.   What marketing and advertising tells us is the “best” isn’t necessarily so and we need to trust our intuition even if it is going against the flow.  So...I've learnt that we shouldn't be afraid to go against the flow!
  • Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.
    ADVICE RATING
     (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.51 (Highly recommend) from 9 votes
    Report
    ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
    GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
    AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
    PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
    Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

    Voting help


     
    Add a comment on this article.

     

    blue-raven
    November 7th | blue-raven
    Re: Don't believe everything you hear - choosing what's right for our families!

    This is so true, we should adhere to our beliefs or standards  and do what works for our kids. I use many different techniques of displine for my kids. Each is designed to be effective for each child. As I have medical issues for each of my kids, well 3 of my 4, their treatments are all different, finding products has become a trial and error formula. Thanks for writting this....it's important to do what is right for your kids.

    Cheers Raven



    Reply Reply Report
    mcm
    November 7th | mcm
    Re: Don't believe everything you hear - choosing what's right for our families!

    Very good points.

    Everyone has their own agenda and for me its the well being and happiness of my family so I will do what is best for my family through my own research and more importantly my instincts. Hopefully it will help society too in the long term.



    Reply Reply Report
    KathrynR1402
    November 2nd | KathrynR1402
    Re: Don't believe everything you hear - choosing what's right for our families!

    I agree completely with you!

    One of my friends told me that Johnsons REALLY "do not make their products for anyone else" - her DH & DD1 are allergic to Johnsons and she could use any of the other products but not theirs in the bath etc! As my DDs come from two allergic families, I started off suspicious, and just as well - I have one with eczema and the other that seemed prone to bleeding nappy rash. DD1 got rushed into hospital in an ambulance a year ago with a rash and my chief suspect is the biological powder that MIL used when I was ill. Not brave enough to test my theory scientifically though! Her skin has never knowingly been exposed to biological powder.

    I do love fleece pocket nappies! And I usually use laudry wash balls, or non-bio if I must.

    I studied a bit of marketting at college - I always said I wasnt influenced by advertising til I studied it, and then I realised how well it was working. I'm even more sceptical now. Just watch the cleaning product commercials on TV and see how they brain wash you into believing that unless your home is sterile enough for open heart surgery you are not a good mum. When the truth is that a speck of dirt will not harm your child and may actually give it's immune system something useful to do. And as your grandmother would tell you, vinegar and lemon juice works just as well as all these expensive cleaning products anyway.

    I have one and probably two strong-willed/high needs daughters, and I agree about finding out your child has not read the instruction manual everyone elses child has - most bewildering! There is a good group on Minti for parents of High-needs kids, which has given me a lot more confidence in parenting my DD1.



    Reply Reply Report
    MrsSanders
    November 2nd | MrsSanders
    Re: Don't believe everything you hear - choosing what's right for our families!

    With you on this, one size does not fit all,LOL.

    I was not so much into the "Designer Brand" culture, but did wish to be as chemical free as possible, good ! Yes! No. I had a baby who had severe reactions to plant based enzymes, the type you find in almost all natural, organic and biological products, from nappy soakers, washing powders, shampoos and some creams, arrrrgh.

    They tested the poor girl and came up with a list of "Do Not Use" enzymes that were practically everywhere, sheesh. So we had to resort to using some standard Non Biological and Chemically processed products, yuck.

    Then along comes second girl and she is the exact opposite,LOL Try stopping two laughing kids tumbling into bed on Sunday morn with you, because no matter which washing powder you have used, one of them is going to react,ugh. Still we found a way, we just boiled and rinsed a lot,:(

    Great thing about kids though is they are so individually unique and teach us so much on the path of parenthood and life : )

    Thankfully both girls are building tollerances as they mature, but I feel for parents who's children never do.

    Luv.Winnie.xxxx



    Reply Reply Report
    mango-mummy
    November 2nd | mango-mummy
    Re: Don't believe everything you hear - choosing what's right for our families!

    Couldnt agree more!!!

    My girl is.. very strong willed!

    The pretty packaged products do NOT Stop her gettin excma (for sensitive skin my butt)

    AND baby sorbelene cream has too much alcohol for it to work on her  i now buy the cheap ugly adult hydroderm its the best for babies

    Aldi nappies and no name nappies work just as well as huggies :D although i still buy snugglers cuz they look so pretty hahaha ( i look through to find the nicest design) Huggies arent that good at all!

    We got EVERY natuaral thing to settle her n non of it worked one bit!!!

    EXCEPT for the cough relief thats pretty good (for us)



    Reply Reply Report

    Related Content

    Add

    No related content has been added

    Bookmarks

    No bookmarks found

    Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend