minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) 4.37 (Worth a try) from 15 votes (2514 Visits)

Pack Your Bags, We're Going on a Guilt Trip!

goldilox by goldilox Talking(September 2006) (rank 500+)

When children do what their parents want because they feel guilty, they are the victims of emotional bullying.

Subjecting anyone - but especially children - to guilt trips is a form of bullying.

I do believe that most parents who use this tool to control their children or

to get what they want, don't know just how damaging it is.  And it is more common than one thinks. I also believe many parents who use it don't realise that they are doing so.

Parents who make comments to their children that are designed to make the children feel sorry for them are being manipulative and using guilt. They may give themselves various reasons for this - "Children must learn to consider the feelings of others."; "I'm only being honest"; "My children should know what I'm going through or they won't appreciate me" etc. etc. But the effect it has on the child is to make them feel guilty.

It is so much more rewarding when children willingly offer to help, or do things for the parent because they want to, and because they have been taught to be caring and helpful, and have learned to enjoy being able to help - not because of guilt or pity.

Some of the effects consistent guilt trips have on children:

* it teaches them to use manipulation - children copy the significant adults in their lives, that's how they learn to be in the world. If the parent uses guilt trips on the child to get results, the child will learn that the way to get what you want is to manipulate others

* they can develop a guilt complex. Children have a tendency to think that things revolve around them anyway, it's the way they're made, and it is perfectly normal. They don't need help in feeling guilty and that things are "their fault". Divorce is a classic example where many children automatically assume it's their fault. A parent should put the child's mind at rest and keep things in perspective. If the parent is disappointed because the child didn't live up to their expectations, then it is for the parent to deal with their own feelings of expectation and disappointment, not to make the child feel guilty.

* it can give the child the message that other people's feelings are more important than their own - which gives the message that they are not as important as other people - which leads to feelings of low self-esteem, lack of confidence, and low self-worth - which can lead to further issues as an adult, for example, feelings of unworthiness which can affect financial prospects, relationships, career prospects, and of course, the way they treat their own children.

* a huge side-effect to guilt trips is resentment - it abounds in the victims of emotional manipulation. Who wants someone to do something for them when they resent it and are doing it purely because they feel guilty? Guilt is often used by parents on children to get them to spend time with them, or to call them. I couldn't bear the idea that someone was spending time with me or calling me, not because they want to and enjoy it, but because they feel they "should".

Using guilt to manipulate and control children is passive-aggressive emotional bullying. It does damage. There are many alternatives to teach children to be caring, compassionate and helpful.  This site is full of them. Using methods that are positive, encouraging and uplifting will have a great effect, not only on the child, but also on the parent. It will lower stress, tension and arguments, and both parent and child will feel more valued.

 

 

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.
ADVICE RATING
 (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) 4.37 (Worth a try) from 15 votes
Report
ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

JadieLady
5.00 (Excellent) | October 2006 | JadieLady
guilt

i also grew up with guilt trips, and as such i will NEVER use them on anyone!

 



Reply Reply Report
goldilox
September 2006 | goldilox
I hate guilt trips
That's brilliant, well done MumtobeKim - it's great to have put your mind at rest, and get on with enjoying the rest of your pregnancy and your child


Reply Reply Report
MumKim
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2006 | MumKim
I hate guilt trips
Great advice. I have a relative who is really good at guilt trips. I am now 37 and still find myself justifying why I have said 'no'. When you have grown up with guilt trips it can be very hard to know where to set boundaries. I hope I will not do the guilt trip thing on my child.


Reply Reply Report
      goldilox
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2006 | goldilox
I hate guilt trips

Hi MumtobeKim,

It's great that you are aware of the effect guilt can have and the damage it can do.

Better than "hoping" you won't do the guilt trip thing on your child - DECIDE not to do it. Since you are aware of it, you should get a warning feeling when you start, and your responsibility will be to pay attention to that warning feeling, and make a swift U-turn in the middle of the trip

You can also start noticing if you use it on other people in the meantime. People who were dragged on a lot of guilt trips as children, tend to use it on others when they become adults - it's perfectly natural - as I said, children learn how to handle situations and other people by watching and copying their parents. So seasoned guilt travellers will have unconciously learned to use guilt in the same way the adult/s in their lives did. But being aware of it gives you the control and the opportunity to correct it.

You know you're taking your child on a guilt trip when:

* you are trying to make them feel sorry for you (regardless of the reason)

* you make them, or lead them to, feel they are responsible for something (anything) negative in your life

* you don't put their mind at rest and reassure them when they think that something that's happened to you or someone else is their fault - and you know it was not directly caused by something they did deliberately 

* You manage to get your child to do or say something because they feel guilty or sorry for you

Hope this helps



Reply Reply Report
           MumKim
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2006 | MumKim
I hate guilt trips

Hi Goldilox
Your article got me thinking and I asked my husband if I use guilt trips on him. He said that no I don't. I also asked him to make me aware if he ever notices me trying to do the guilt trip thing on anyone, especially our child. He has promised he will. I was worried because as I said before when it is something you have grown up with as normal it is sometimes hard to recognise from the inside. I feel much better knowing that I am not using them now and that he will let me know if I slip up.



Reply Reply Report
hrs2004
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2006 | hrs2004
Guilt trips

I have seen this from a few angles. My mother-in-law is clearly burdened deeply with guilt about everything. She feels inadequate and apologises almost constantly to the extent that she is tough to talk to without you just wanting to tell her to stop saying sorry. If she could apologise for breathing I think she would. This seems (from what I can gather) from huge expectations placed on her by her family as a child, and by her one surviving sister. She feels guilty for getting married, having a family, not allowing her three siblings and parents to move in to her new family home, etc etc etc. How she has managed to get through life and raise four happy and independent children whilst clearly feeling so inferior amazes me.

From another angle, I remember just one occasion when I found my mum crying. I was heartbroken. She was always careful to hide a number of her emotions from us, and I am thankful for that. I have to say that at the time (I was probably about 7), I was still struggling to make sense of the world and my own emotions, and the thought that my parents got hurt and upset was just too much to bear. I cannot imagine a parent deliberately trying to make a child feel emotions that they are just too young to fully understand. My mum has always made a point of not pressuring us to visit as adults. She was duty bound to visit her in laws every weekend (and even decorate their house, despite being 8 months pregnant) and almost still seems angry now, when we talk about it. Perhaps as a result of this lack of pressure, we now live four doors away from my parents. If she had piled on the pressure before now, I think that the chances are we would have steered well clear and bought a house somewhere else! So, I agree, who would want someone to do something through a huge sense of duty rather than the realisation that they actually want to do something for you.



Reply Reply Report
goldilox
September 2006 | goldilox
More baggage ....

Another effect of the guilt trip:

Children subjected to guilt trips can grow up to be "people-pleasers". They could become adults who find themselves unable to say "no", and end up doing all sorts of things they don't want to do because of a guilt complex. Add to this, feelings of resentment and frustration, not only at those who take advantage of them, but also at themselves. Enter a spiral of plunging self-esteem and sinking self-worth. This of course can lead to a multitude of other side effects and issues.



Reply Reply Report
      mewannaboy
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2006 | mewannaboy
More baggage ....
well thats me as a whole a "people pleaser" now it has a name. I always thought saying "no" would lose me friends hence why im friendless almost but i finally spoke up and lost a damaging friendship that was ready to be lost.With my sister im always trying to justify my no answer and she lays on the guilt trips....."IVE GOT MORE KIDS THAN YOU","YOU HAVE A PARTNER" Blah blah blah.i give up i need to do whats right for me.


Reply Reply Report
           goldilox
September 2006 | goldilox
More baggage ....

Absolutely! I used to be a "people pleaser", but through a fair amount of self-development over the years, I discovered that through putting myself out in order that people would like me, or not be angry or dissapointed in me, I was spending a lot of time feeling resentment and a sense of injustice.

Like the oxygen masks on airplanes, you're of no use to anyone else if you don't look after yourself. One of the most important responsibilities I have to my son, is to look after his mother.

Dumping the guilt baggage, and becoming more self-sufficient emotionally has meant I am able to say "no" when I feel I need to, and am able to be happy about saying "yes" when I do say yes. This has meant I feel happier and more generous and more tollerant generally - which is much more useful to those I love.

Do keep in mind when your sister, or anyone else, uses guilt as a weapon, it is just that - a weapon. It is a lazy form of a person getting their own way, and it is, as I said before a sneaky form of emotional bullying. Each person is responsible for their own lives - and for their own reactions. 

A wonderful experiment to try - because the reaction can be very amusing  is to, when you say "no" - give the reason "I'm really sorry honey, but I just don't want to." or "Ah, I'd love to help, but I just don't feel like it." The important thing about being this frank is to say it with genuine sympathy, but not with guilt. Think of it as if someone has come into your library looking for a particular book, but you don't have it. You wouldn't feel guilty about it, but you'd feel sorry that you haven't got it for them. It's a combination of that attitude, and the honesty of a child who makes no excuse for not playing a particular game - not "I'm busy" or "I don't have time" or "I have to take the dog to the vet" but simply "I don't want to."

Everyone has a right to say they don't want to do something, but we often forget this.

Try it, it's fun. Sometimes, when we don't get what we want from others, we have to give it to ourselves. Give yourself the protection and consideration and the "break" and acceptance that you wish your sister would give you. It's incredibly empowering.

And you may be pleasantly surprised at the other person's reaction. As long as you say it with genuine care. You do care, you just don't want to do it yourself this time. Maybe next time. Once the person has had a chance to absorb and digest what you've said, you may well find they learn to respect your boundries.

Remember, we teach people how to treat us by the treatment we accept from them.

No-one who loves someone will not love them, or love them less, for saying "no" when they don't want to do something. They may not like it, they may get annoyed, but if they love you, they love you. And if it's a relationship that has no real foundation (for example the "damaging friendship" you mention) then as you say, you are much better off without them.

 



Reply Reply Report

Related Content

Add

No related content has been added

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend