minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.55 (Highly recommend) from 11 votes (412 Visits)

Earning Things Instead of Automatic Rewarding

rogerslili by rogerslili Talking(September 2006) (rank 500+)
My son has driven me to the insanity point. *sigh* He refuses to do his classwork at school, runs around the classroom like a banshee, and then some. His teacher and Roger and I have tried everything we can think of, to no avail. So last evening, I had to put
my foot down, and hard. (Mind you, he is 7 years old. This might not work well with children under the age of 5.)

My son helped me pack every single toy in his bedroom into a Rubbermaid tote, leaving only his books and one stuffed puppy dog (Spike) in the room. I sat him down and explained to him that the new way of going about this is quite easy:

1. Every day that he does his classwork at school and follows rules and et cetera, he earns one type of toy back, aka his tote of Legos.

2. For every day after that which he is well-behaved at school, we add another type of toy back to the mix.

3. Every day that he acts out at school and is not behaving, he loses all of his toys again, and has to sit and read quietly afterschool instead of playing.

4. It's okay to have bad days, so long as we continue to follow the rules, even while we are grumpy-pants.

He was unhappy, but hopefully, it sunk in. When time-outs don't help, taking away tv time doesn't work, and you've gotten to the breaking point, this might seem heartless, but it's better than yelling and so on. If a child has to earn the right to do something, not only does it make them feel better about themselves, but it teaches them that working for something is healthy and good and right. It also eases the exasperation levels of Mom and Dad quite a bit!
Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.55 (Highly recommend) from 11 votes
Report
ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

exquisite-flower
January 2007 | exquisite-flower
Worked for me
I felt awful, but one morning she scared me three times before 7am!!!  So it was no toys, she sat on the sofa reading a book, and we didnt go to gymnastics either.  One thing for each bad thing she had done, and they were seriously bad.  Since then we havent had anything seriously bad happen.  She hated it, but she knew that if she was good I would reinstate treats one at a time.  Something I have always done is to be honest and keep promises, so it gives me credibility when I take things away, because she knows that I will maintain the conditions to get them back - or remove them again
Peace
EF.x 


Reply Reply Report
Prinea
October 2006 | Prinea
I couldn't Agree More...

That doesn't sound heartless to me, heartless would be screaming at him nonstop and not looking for constructive avenues to deal with this, you've done the exact oppostie you're thinking outside the box and doing whatever you can to help him help himself in a positive way! Kudos to you mom!

My only suggestion would be that if he does lose all his toys often or for long periods would be to add some sort of structured physical activity to his night in the place of the play he would be doing otherwise. Maybe go for a walk or bike ride with him, this would give you a chance to talk with him about how he's feeling about everything as well, that way he doesn't get a lot of pent up energy from having too many quiet nights in a row and the punishment still sticks. Sounds like energy is something he has plenty of as it is. ;)



Reply Reply Report
Jessgore
September 2006 | Jessgore
A parent has to do what a parent has to do....

I don't think it sounds heartless at all....  There is a time and a place for everything. And every one has to learn that one way or another... When it is my sons turn I will be doing the same thing..



Reply Reply Report
mcm
September 2006 | mcm
Confiscation
I confiscate my daughter's things too if I feel it will help. I think it is important that children don't just expect things without doing their bit.


Reply Reply Report
upinchina
September 2006 | upinchina
we do it too

I started something like that when my oldest was 2 1/2 with chores that were age appropriate and she earns things that she sees in the store, etc.  Her chores are putting the dogs food down, opening the door when the dogs have to go outside, not having a tantrum on the floor, etc.  My 2 year old is now doing it too and they are so proud when they have "earned their stars and get their prize".  I guess later, we can adapt it to homework as well.  



Reply Reply Report
michellei
3.00 (Average) | September 2006 | michellei
Earning Things Instead of Automatic Rewarding
I agree with Izzy that it's a good idea - not cold hearted at all.


Reply Reply Report
      rogerslili
4.00 (Good) | September 2006 | rogerslili
Earning Things Instead of Automatic Rewarding
Thank you, sweetheart!! *grin*


Reply Reply Report
Izzy
September 2006 | Izzy
Great idea!
I think that's a great idea. It teaches that the toys are a privelege and not a right. Also, it'll teach him to appreciate what he already has so you don't need to keep buying new toys. And if he ever does poorly in school (in terms of grades), taking toys away will provide less of a distraction.


Reply Reply Report
      rogerslili
September 2006 | rogerslili
Great idea!
*nodding in full agreement*

Nowadays, too many of our children think that everything they have and do is a right, instead of a gifting or a privilege, as you say. How are we to teach our children the art of self-discipline and that hard work has so much merit, if we just hand them things? Thank you, too. Part of me felt so guilty, for having to play the Mean Mommie last evening. *sigh* It helps to have moral support.


Reply Reply Report
           lindterbean
September 2006 | lindterbean
Great idea!
ditto. I have had this discussion with our eldest who can be quite trying at times. I have told her that because I love her it is more important to me to have her grow up to be a healthy, intelligent, self-sufficient young woman than for her to like me, so if I have to make a choice, I will make sure she stays healthy instead of trying to buy her affection. That actually seemed to do some good, and she cut down on some of the psychological warfare after that. It all pays off in the long run.


Reply Reply Report
           Izzy
September 2006 | Izzy
Great idea!

Don't feel too guilty. I think it's actually a great thing for parents to do, rather then let children continue on with whatever bad behavior they are doing.  This is something I see myself doing in the future if I need to.

My 18 month old has been sick this past few days with croup and then ear infection and he all of a sudden hated taking medicine. He cried and tossed and turned and I had to hold him down. It made me feel terrible to do this but what can I do? He needs the medicine in order to get better. Anyway, just making comparison that moms sometimes have to do what seems terrible at the moment but that really results in a whole lot of good later.



Reply Reply Report

Bookmarks

No bookmarks found

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend