The following is not intended to conclude what is best but it is an account of our experiences and the influence that others can have on our decisions.
Every child is different and like anything toilet training should be sympathetic to the individual.
Apparently - I have been told- I toilet trained very early.
This great achievement has been related to me many times as a kind of triumph to aspire to. I was an only child so my record remained unbroken.
(Funnily enough though I can remember having many accidents - yes even over three decades later those 'accidents' are obviously notable enough to still filter through...or is it old age and that much talked about phenomenon where childhood memories are clearer than what happened yesterday *grin*)
From Potty Trained to Trainer.
So as you may imagine when I became a mother toilet training rapidly became an issue of great importance, I am assured that I was reliably out of nappies at 12 months (!?) so my daughter was destined for early introduction to the potty.
Progress was followed closely by grandparents and we were soon following a tight regime of nappy removal and potty popping- and sitting to wait for the great event.
So far so good.
I must say it all seemed to be very successful and DD took to carrying a potty around with her. There was a potty in every room and outings became a "check where there is a toilet' stress event. Sure enough at around the 12 month age she was pretty much toilet trained.
The thing is - she continued to wet the bed and need night nappies until she was 5 ( at which stage, consumed with worry I took her to an incontinence clinic and after two weeks with an alarm she was dry all the time). She also went through a long stage at 2 until 3 of wetting her pants- surprisingly often.
Did we toilet train too soon? Would waiting longer have saved wet pants and stress - or just have meant more dirty nappies? Obviously this is impossible to answer and everyone will have a different story and opinion. But its an interesting point to ponder.
Interestingly when she was wetting her pants she didn't even seem to notice and couldn't have cared less......
The boys
Then the boys came along.
They were close together and there was a miscarriage in-beween them as well.
Toilet training was a little lower on the list of priorities but i was reminded constantly of its importance so it was always a 'worry'.
Not ready
So when Baby number three was born I dutifully pressured the middle child into potty training. Looking back now ; he wasn't ready. It upset him- he protested and spent many long periods sitting on the potty- quite possible trying NOT to go!. If I could go back and do it again I would not have done things this way -but I thought it was 'necessary' - I was also constantly told it was "much later than i was, and DD".
DS 'middle child' was 20 months when the baby was born and we introduced the potty around about that time- prob a month or two before to avoid to much problems. I was so worried that he would be in nappies at 2 (horror!)
Potty training together
Well by the time number three was a year old the middle child was still potty training and only JUST starting to accept it and make some attempt - now aged three. The youngest thought it was fun to get another potty and sit beside his big brother and the pair of them would sit side by side on their potties. It would be about a year though until the youngest was reliable without nappies and his brother by that time aged 4 was STILL having problems.
Some Mums stress, and some Mums wont. Some worry about the potty and some Mums don't.
Since then I have watched other mothers shrug off the issue of toilet training and I've observed many many children aged three in nappies without a stressed parent in sight. ( A sight I had been brought up to believe was a 'ridiculous disgrace')
If I had my time over with my babies I would stress less and let nature take its course - allowing the toilet training to be a slower gentler process guided by the individual child. I haven't met anyone yet who sent a child to school in nappies and leaving the process until later has reliably and consistently appeared to result in fast low stress toilet training - not a lazy child who would rather use a nappy.
There may well be exceptions of course (*smile*)
Would love to hear others views and experiences on this one!!!!!!!
Good luck and Relax - it will happen 