minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Tina and Z.jpg
Author Tina Shaw with her little bundle of JOY
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.60 (Highly recommend) from 29 votes (1596 Visits)

Judgemental Parenting

The-Single-Parent-Bible by The-Single-Parent-Bible Speaking(April 2006) (rank 149th)

The following article was well received on my online magazine www.singleparentbible.com.au, so I wanted to share it with all of you.

I'm a Lover not a Fighter

Today I read an article; about how some mothers can be incredibly judgemental of others who choose parenting styles dissimilar to their own.  This made me contemplate my own baby rearing. 

I flew in the face of all advice (however well meaning).  I was single with a supposedly severely colicky baby.  I did whatever I could to make his little life easier.  This included breast feeding on demand, feeding him to sleep and allowing him to sleep in my bed.  I spent two years with my child attached to my hip (and my breast).

I didn’t care what others thought or said, I just did what was right for my child and I.  It turns out, that my sweet boy had undiagnosed Giardia and was in unbelievable night pain for over two and a half years.  The same health professionals that urged me to get him out of my bed were telling me that his Giardia was colic and that he would grow out of it.  Hmmm.  I eventually found the champion of GPs (after I went through many doctors and specialists who told me that I was a panicky parent) and my little one is now well and happy.

The moral of this story, is that a mother does for her child what is instinctively natural and right for them.  Had someone told me before I became a parent, that I would be taking part in a breast feeding marathon, I would have laughed at them and vehemently denied that could be possible (having previously been somewhat lukewarm to the idea).  As it turns out, I was like the ‘Big Cow’ of breast feeding and I let my son give me up – when he was good and ready.   

Placing my child in day care two mornings a week at the age of one, had many a coupled parent friend up in arms also.  Why when I wasn’t working (at the time), did I feel the need to place my son in care?  What sort of a mother does that?  How selfish.  Well, you know what?  This is MY life and unless you are me, you have no idea what is best for my child and our ‘family’.  When you are a single parent, with no relatives living within a reasonable distance and no local support network, two hours on your own to grocery shop and do the vacuuming, is like a day at a health spa.

Sometimes you just need to recharge and all of those who are judgemental of our choices, will have issues within their own parenting structure (to face at some stage).  Whatever happened to live and let live and why do some people find it necessary to force their views upon us?  My thought, is that what you don’t understand scares you.  So, it’s easier to put it down than to accept that your way isn’t everyone’s way.

I hope those that read this and are struggling with tiny babies and opinionated friends, breathe a sigh of relief, because ladies, it’s okay.  It will fall into place and you can do it.  Lock the door, take the phone off the hook and do it your way.  Your baby will thank you for it.

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.60 (Highly recommend) from 29 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

DarkenedAngel
5.00 (Excellent) | August 2007 | DarkenedAngel
Re: Judgemental Parenting

Excellent! I'm glad to see others willing to stick it to the deliberate ignorance, presumptuousness, and judgementalness of many people out there.

Well done!

DA



Reply Reply Report
The-Single-Parent-Bible
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | The-Single-Parent-Bible
The Secret Business of Manic Mothers

If you like and appreciated this article on Judgemental Parenting, then you may find the humour in my recent offering - The Secret Business of Manic Mothers...  http://www.singleparentbible.com.au/contents.php?id=9&p=9

Cheers
Tina Shaw



Reply Reply Report
cjmcbain
4.72 (Excellent) | August 2006 | cjmcbain
opinions every where
I was a single mum of two and also had judgemental people up in arms about being a single mother. Now I am married and a mother of five. Now i get some (and the ones i dont know about) judgemental opinions about being a mother of five. So I have come to the conculsion - my children are happy and healthy. As a mother you do what you think is right. AND it does not matter what you do-  there is always going to be people who judge. So do your best, dont think about peoples comments who really dont know anything about anything, look after yourself and continue with life. Some peoples opinions change with understand but others wont. Thats there problem.


Reply Reply Report
JadieLady
5.00 (Excellent) | August 2006 | JadieLady
good

you are absolutely right. and  as a single mum, how can they judge you for putting your child in day care? they have partners to share the load so to speak. they get a break. you don't have the extra set of hands to help pick up around the hosue when your beat, you don't have someone to get up i nteh middle of the night with a bottle so you can have some more sleep.

My heart goes out to you. along with a darn lot of admiration- I know I couldnt do it alone!!

Single mums are a great inspiration and I hope your baby makes life easy on you :)



Reply Reply Report
elizabeth
4.77 (Excellent) | July 2006 | elizabeth
Totally agree
 I was in a similar situation with my daughter, but I found that not only was I sick and tired of being judged as a parent, but I grew extremely tired of being judgemental of other parents. Once I realised what I was doing, it made it much easier to see the great things all parents do ever single day!


Reply Reply Report
mrslunar
4.72 (Excellent) | June 2006 | mrslunar
Agree...to a point.
I would agree that we need to stop listening to ignorant advice and start listening to ourselves more...........
BUT, here's the catch. We need to be educated parents to do this. Our society has completely reprogrammed parents today. No longer to women trust their bodies or their insticts and no longer do we truly have a society of child-centered parents. They are few and far between.

There a far too many parents today who use the statements like "You don't know ME and MY SITUATION" in order to make what ammount to selfish parenting choices. And I just don't believe we do anyone any favors by supporting selfish parenting.

If a mom can honestly look as breastfeeding, as an example, and say "yes, I know that I'm not making the best choice for my child, and I know all the studies and research, but I chose not to breastfeed" well then that's fine. But when women scream about how they just don't want to because it's "gross" or "boobies are for daddies" and willfully chose NOT to educate themselves and ignorantly chose selfish parenting, I think that is the time when we AREN'T obligated to just blindly accept that. You know what I mean?

It's SUCH a fine line.........Clay and Rachels example is a good one.........putting your child in day care when you are a stay at home mama. I'm sure there ARE plenty of parents who judge them for that and plenty more who completely understand how hard it is to be a stay at home mama. Yes, there are fine lines, there are grey areas.

If we are going to tell parents we aren't going to judge anything they do, I think we as parents have an obligation to go into parenting with as much knowledge and eduation as possible and continuously seek after those things. Selfish parenting shouldn't be something we all just accept. Just my 2 cents.


Reply Reply Report
lindterbean
4.85 (Excellent) | June 2006 | lindterbean
split personalities
And of course when the kids are around someone new they act like completely different people. I have heard a million times from between my own lips and others' . . . 'no really, they're not usually like that. . ."


Reply Reply Report
ClayCook
4.76 (Excellent) | May 2006 | ClayCook
Here here!
Totally agree! All those with their "unsolicitored" opinions should take them all back... but they wont. For example... I went to the doctors yesterday with Codi for some "medical" advice and got some "bonus" unsolicitored parenting advice that we needed to be stronger with our child and bring him up with more discipline, and that children are a pain in the ass. A note to that doctor, zip your bloody lip! Our boy is sick and he is obviously upset, we are sorry he wasn't a perfect angel in your office. If we wanted your parenting advice we would have asked for it! We also put Codi in day care once a week and I know for a fact that some of our "freinds" and "family" voice and/or think that this is being selfish... "why does Rachel need a day to herself?" Umm... try these: Maybe to recharge? Maybe to get other things done that are a little difficult with a toddler? Maybe to get some work done that she loves doing also? I could go on for pages... but wont. I especially find that the older generation has very different views, and I sometimes think that they have forgotten what it was like when they were bringing up a child. This is a great article - well done for writing it. It is a topic that I and am sure others are very passionate about. -- Clay


Reply Reply Report
      The-Single-Parent-Bible
4.62 (Excellent) | June 2006 | The-Single-Parent-Bible
Re: Here here!

Thanks Clay.

In my rough trodden road of parenting, I have found that some doctors are incredibly judgemental of our parenting skills (some however are fabulous - thank God).  I have in the past, almost felt bullied by some care professionals.  Luckily for my son, I am a strong person who takes the information I need and discards the rest.

The shame of it all, is that many of those who judge us, are friends or family.  I have a girlfriend who has just had her first baby and is also a single parent and unfortunately she is copping a lot of unsolicited 'advice'.  The funny thing is, she is 34, a qualified midwife and is quite high up in the Queensland Health department.  I think we all get it from time to time, no matter who we are, or what our situation.  I guess we just have to trust our health professionals and take all advice on 'a use it as needed basis'.  It sounds as though you and Rachel are a wonderful support for each other and Codi. 

One thing I have done in the past, is told the doctors how I feel about their comments, tone, or advice.  More often than not, you get an apology.  I guess they have bad days too.

I hope your little one is on the mend.  It's cold season, so my boy is down for the count also.



Reply Reply Report
thordora
4.48 (Good) | May 2006 | thordora
Judgement

Amen to that.



Reply Reply Report
Anonymous Member
4.00 (Good) | April 2006 | anonymous  
Judgment vs. Advice
I couldn't agree more that mothers--and especially single mothers--need to back themselves. Believe in themselves and that they doing the right thing for their child. You story is really empowering for women that feel under the thumb of opionated family, family-in-law, friends.

On the other hand, I have seen some parents maintain behaviours and attitudes towards their children that were detrimental. Unfortunately, there are situations when our intuition may decieve us. Intuition can equate with a defence mechanism, making us believe that it's okay, when it isn't.
Backing yourself is fine, as long as you are aware that sometimes we need to listen to others, let them help us see things from a different point of view. Back yourself, but take time to reflect about things.
Being a single mum can also mean that you feel that people are judging you, when they aren't. They maybe trying to help. They might be talking to you about it because they care. And when you are alone with a child or children, you need all the help and love you can get.
Some of this advice is not specifically written for single-mothers. Some women with partners have just as much trouble with "judgmental" others. They also have the problem of having to share their parenting with men. And men are often more trouble than help.


Reply Reply Report
rachelcook
4.27 (Good) | April 2006 | rachelcook
Judgemental parenting
I agree, sometimes people who are judgemental don't know the other person's circumstances, they only see 'face value'. I suppose it's also fair that people wonder whats different from their situation (why aren't they the same, and sometimes judge)..

I try and think that if they spent a day in my life they would see why I made those choices and why I run things in different ways. I guess it's counter-productive to worry about people that judge. I think for me I try and have understanding for people that don't understand and take their judgements as a grain of salt..I live by the mantra "believe in the power of believing in yourself"... I have found that getting all the information to best help you make that decision will confirm your choices regardless of what people may say... a great article...


Reply Reply Report
      exquisite-flower
5.00 (Excellent) | May 2007 | exquisite-flower
Judgemental parenting
Hear hear!! 

I know I wouldn't last a week if I worried about what other people think and say about me.  As far as I am concerned it is the end product that speaks for itself, and if my method works for me and E - with our situation, personalities and so on taken into the mix, then surely that is a good thing.  People who judge I find often have too little to do in their own lives and so commit their time to causing havoc for others.
Peace
EF.x 


Reply Reply Report
Anonymous Member
4.33 (Good) | April 2006 | anonymous  
wow
I wonder what Giarda is? Amazing article...mother's instinct is very powerful...


Reply Reply Report
      Anonymous Member
3.11 (Average) | April 2006 | anonymous  
Re: wow


Reply Reply Report
           ClayCook
4.63 (Excellent) | May 2006 | ClayCook
Re: wow
I think you were trying to link to... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giardia_lamblia http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dpd/parasites/giardiasis/factsht_giardia.htm


Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend