minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.77 (Highly recommend) from 22 votes (426 Visits)

The Gimme Monster and Other Advice For Kids Who Want More, More, More: UPDATED

jenlemen by jenlemen Young Parent(November 2006) (rank 22nd)
When my daughter Madeleine was a pre-schooler, I'd find myself going slowly insane whenever I needed to bring her along to the store.  Every bright and sparkly item had her name on it--as far as she was concerned--and she didn't understand why Mama didn't just give her this or give
her that.  Over time we came up with a good handful of strategies to address not only the incessant asking, but the underlying forces at play. 

  • The Gimme Monster.  I wanted Madeleine to become aware that her requests were becoming demands, but I didn't want her to feel ashamed or embarrassed for being so drawn to all the glittery, fun things at the store--after all, they make things pretty for a reason.  So, the next time her asking was sounding like a broken record, I'd tell her playfully--"Watch out!  I think the Gimme Monster is trying to get you!"  I explained that the Gimme Monster always says "Give me this!" and "Give me that!" without really thinking about what she truly needed or wanted.  This set up the conversation as a playful exchange, and gave Madeleine a chance to do a double-take and decide if she really, really meant what she was saying or not.  
  • Show me the money!  As Madeleine got older and better practiced at dodging the Gimme Monster, our outings became an opportunity for her to honestly consider different items and decide if she needed or wanted them.  Instead of saying no on repeat, I decided to bring up the topic of money instead.  "Okay," I'd say, eyeing the latest, greatest whatever.  "How are you planning to pay for it?"  As soon as Madeleine realized that Mom was not able/willing to pick up the tab, she began to understand both the value of the dollar as well as the limitations of personal finances.  By debunking me as the family money machine, I was able to help her start to see the strategy and planning involved in making purchases.  This decidedly quelled the feeding frenzy around having the hottest new toy/doll on the market. 
  • Madison Avenue Madness.   Like most kids, Madeleine was completely unaware of the marketing campaigns designed to keep her (and every other kid in America) wanting more.  We decided to do a little Advertising 101 and start talking about the different ways companies try to get kids hooked on products.  Madeleine was surprised to learn that some of the desperate longing for stuff she was experiencing was directly connected to certain approaches to marketing.   Now I playfully ask her the million dollar question, "Are you getting tricked by advertising?" Little by little my savvy shopper is learning how to see through a slick campaign to a true blue interest in something new.
  • Let's make a deal.  In the ice age of life before TiVo, my husband and I agreed to see if we can raise our kids without TV.  While this isn't an option for everyone, limiting exposure to television, commercials and the constant barage of advertising has helped us stave off a wave of consumerism that can leave kids feeling like there's never enough.  By sheer lack of exposure to all the cool toys available, our kids are figuring out that they can have fun--no batteries included.  I'm sure there'll be a day when our kids insist we join the land of the living and get a TV, but so far, so good.
  • Don't ask, don't tell.   We have more clutter and junk in our house than I know what to do with--noble goals regarding consumerism and materialism aside.  That's why I make it a point to shop alone and limit the opportunities for the kids to get the shopping bug.  When we do shop together, I let my kids know what they can expect regarding our purchases.  If I know that I won't be buying toys or kid stuff, I say so, and ask the kids to refrain from asking since my answer will definitely be "no" no matter what.  Knowing that getting something new is not an option helps everyone relax and we can get through the errand that much faster.
  • Go off the grid.   Almost every fun thing you can think of can involve hard cold cash--especially when you live in a big city.  It's important to me that my kids learn that you can have a good time even if nothing is purchased.  Getting out in nature, having family dinners, staying home to read books or watch a movie--all these things teach our kids that there's no substitute for meaningful connection.  And that's something money can't buy. 
  • Give your little money monster something to work with.  We've noticed that our kids are much less grabby on trips when we start off by giving them a small amount of money for spending and souveniers.  Instead of asking every five seconds if we can get this or that, they spend their time comparison shopping and scheming about what is a wise buy.  A great strategy when you know you'll want to bring home a little something and don't want to be under constant pressure to continue to feed the gimme monster.  We've found this keeps everyone engaged with money in a very positive way.  (Added:  April 18th, 2007)
In so many ways our family is still in the learning curve when it comes to consumerism and money.  How do you curb the Gimme Monster at your house? 
Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.77 (Highly recommend) from 22 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

KyAquarius
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | KyAquarius
Great advice
As soon as my daughter gets older and understands what she demands of me when we're out shopping, I will be sure to implement some of these strategies. Sounds very effective!


Reply Reply Report
kseers
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | kseers
Another brilliant article!
This is a huge issue with us at the moment and I am getting sick of saying NO - but if I say yes, I get the "Why did you buy that?" when I get home!  I am so frustrated at all the toys and mess and most of them aren't necessary or appreciated.  We did wonder if pocket money would solve the issue or make it worse?  Then that raises more questions - when do you start and how much?  Thanks for some very practical advice!


Reply Reply Report
      robalman
April 2008 | robalman
Re: Another brilliant article!

You ask good questions.

I personally think that pocket money is a great idea but you can go one step further by getting them to do chores to earn it then the things they purchase might not end up left on the floor.

When?....Talking stage is not too early for many.

How much?....This depends on your income and what you foresee them wanting to purchase.

A good idea is to get them to save 50% of all pocket, birthday and christmas money.

I even made my kids save 50% of their wages from part-time work when they were older.



Reply Reply Report
nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | nell18-3
Learning Money
I have lost track of the times one of my children has asked me to buy them something and I answered I haven't got the money, their predictable response being
'Well go to the bank and get some more!!!"
If only life was that simple
LOL
xxx


Reply Reply Report
      robalman
April 2008 | robalman
Re: Learning Money

That part does take them a while to grasp so it is best to educate them.

They see us go the the bank/ATM to get money but because we fail all to often to let them in on what happens in our adult lives all they see is a place to get money.

To us, going to get money out is a boring task that we do all the time but the child must stand back with eyes wide open in amazement at such a machine. Include them in the process and before to long they may even be running your finances...LOL.



Reply Reply Report
pfallerj
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | pfallerj
Money
Love the tip about giving them some money and letting them scheme about what the BEST thing they can get is.


Reply Reply Report
      robalman
April 2008 | robalman
Re: Money

Well said.

They learn the value of money quite fast and you can almost see the little cogs turning as they decide when, where and what they will buy.



Reply Reply Report
Izzy
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2006 | Izzy
Great stuff

Great tips. I will have to file this away for later use, as my son is too young yet. Right now I can get away with redirection when he sees something he wants at the store.

Your tips are also great for making children appreciate what they already have and what they do get. I wish my husband's 3 nephews learned that. They are a family that is being supported by my mother-in-law, yet, their mother gives them everything - 3 xbox, ipods, 3 TVs. It's a sad situation, because on top of everything they don't know how to share.

During one of our visits there, I asked the 8 year old how much money he had, as he was asking their gramma for something. He looked at me and told me how much money he had. He almost had enough to get what he wanted, so I told him to just wait a little longer. He looked at me like he didn't understand what I was telling him. Why would he use his own money to get something that someone else could get for him? Unbelievable.



Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2006 | jenlemen
Great stuff
money is really scary this way! kids learn so quickly if they can get away with something or not--and too much is always a bad idea! good for you for bringing it up.


Reply Reply Report
      robalman
April 2008 | robalman
Re: Great stuff

It is really sad that some parents would allow their kids to think that receiving is more important than giving. Having said that, it is understandable that kids can get like that when we want our kids to have everything that we may have missed out on.



Reply Reply Report
wildrose
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2006 | wildrose
Buy toys
When we go out with our children if we are not intend to buy them toys but just window shopping, I would tell them that we're only looking not buying. Usually it worked. When it's not, we would ask them back like 'Do you have money to buy, cause we don't have it at this time', usually the nagging would stop since obviously they don't have money to buy it. We always try to make them understand that money don't grow on the trees. We work for it. And not everytime we go out shopping means we have to buy things. Most of the time, they will understand...but ofcourse you would expect the un-expected day too.
I like the way you show the marketing stuff, haven't done that yet. Maybe for next tricks. Thanks.


Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2006 | jenlemen
Buy toys
it's true--my kids are funny, too, when i ask them how we will purchase something, but i think the money-doesn't-grow-on-trees thing is really important.  i know some adults that need that refresher--self-included!


Reply Reply Report
      robalman
April 2008 | robalman
Re: Buy toys

When the kids were little ones I used to give them all my 5 and 10 cent pieces, they thought they were rich and just loved Fridays because of it. They would wait for me to come home from work and it was a great way to end what had been an otherwise exhausting week.

The little money the actual had was minimal but gave them a sense of independence from a young age and also forced them to learn both the value of money and how to use it.



Reply Reply Report
MumKim
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2006 | MumKim
Great strategies
I like all the strategies you have mentioned. Especially the one about educating your kids about how advertising works, and the tricks the companies use. I really like your style!


Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2006 | jenlemen
Great strategies
you'll be way ahead of the game by the time your little one can go out shopping!  :) excited for you...


Reply Reply Report
      robalman
April 2008 | robalman
Re: Great strategies

I tried to teach my kids about such strategies and was working great and they never even asked for lollies nor did they know what they tasted like until they stayed over at nanas.

Other than that, they were generally good and knew that in order to get something they had to be part of our "caring sharing" family.

As teenage years began the advertising became too much of a temptation as they started earning their own money but are learning the hard way.



Reply Reply Report
cazza
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2006 | cazza
monsters
I think that every child would benifit by this strategy.


Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2006 | jenlemen
monsters
thanks, cazza!!


Reply Reply Report
      robalman
April 2008 | robalman
Re: monsters

We just need the strength as parents to enforce the, "have to be cruel to be kind attitude" sometimes. We need to learn that saying no to our little loved ones is allowable.

The first few years of a childs life is character building and it is our responsibility to lay sound foundations for them to develope from.



Reply Reply Report
sweezie
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2006 | sweezie
Constant challenge

Jen, thanks for these strategies. We also decided not to have a TV in the house and I think this helps enormously. My son's 3 and definitely has a hunger for STUFF. The only ideas I can add to those you wrote about are these:

If I do intend to buy him a toy or new item I try to buy it when he's not in the store and present it to him at home. At the stores where we've never purchased something (at least to his knowledge), his behavior is less whiny and demanding.

When he really throws a fit at a particular store (like Target!) over wanting something and not getting it, I try to avoid taking him to that store for at least a month or more. I also try to increase other ways of play after a bad episode - going to the park, playing chase, etc.



Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2006 | jenlemen
Constant challenge
i really like this--i agree that it's wise to switch gears and do a different kind of outing if the last store visit was a disaster.  my kids ar 8 and 5 and it definitely gets easier.


Reply Reply Report
robalman
November 2006 | robalman
More, MOre, More & T.V.

I particalerly like the part about no televission in your home.

I too believe that T.V. can be likened to a sewer pipe running directly into your living room.

It is also my belief that T.V can be the blame for many disfunctional families out there. Think of all the things we could do as a family if just this one thing was omitted from it.

Just at a guess, I would say that 20 to 30 hours per week are lost from such an anti-social device as the T.V.

Sure entertainment (if you can call it that) from the T.V is cheap but so are the many things you can do to strengthen family bonds. Many of these things would contribute to us having healthier bodies and minds.



Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2006 | jenlemen
More, MOre, More & T.V.
true confession!  we would probably have a tv in a second, but me and dear husband would be the worst TV junkies known to man.  so maybe you can say that our decision is rooted in weakness more than strength!!  ;)    thanks for your comments though--it is an unconventional decision.


Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend