minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
100_0304.JPG
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.61 (Highly recommend) from 25 votes (2586 Visits)

"Boys are blue & Girls are pink" (says my 3 y/o)

kseers by kseers Young Parent(November 2006) (rank 23rd)
I've been thinking a lot lately on gender issues and what makes people the way they are.  After reading some articles on Minti I thought I'd add my thoughts (for what it's worth)

I think that children should be developed to their own potential - whoever they are. 
The more well rounded and confident your child the better a chance they stand. 

To my mind this means letting them try everything and work out what is right for them.  All children have different things that interest them, different ways of learning, different personalities.  How will they ever learn what their inclinations and skills are if you don't let them experiment (with close care & supervision of course)?

Girls and boys are made differently (as are men & women - ask any wife!).  Visit any three year old's birthday party and you will see the differences showing already.  However that doesn't mean that we can't add to their program so to speak.  We help them enhance and develop their personality through our parenting.

My boy is definitely a boy - very much so - yet he loves "making me tea", so I am looking for a non-pink tea set for him.  He helps Daddy in the kitchen so he doesn't see it as girly (most of the best chefs are men!).  He does play with dolls (though he generally drags them around by their hair).  He also has lots of cars.  His favourite toys are his musical instruments, his dress up box, his trampoline and his tool set.  He also loves books and loves to read (especially about dinosaurs).  To my mind this shows a well rounded personality.

I have been criticised for letting him play with dolls and letting him have pink things as it will make him gay!  I replied that I think it a lot more likely that boys that have that side of them suppressed will look into it later in life - if they are even slightly that way inclined...  (not to say that a gay son would be the most dreadful thing that could happen)  I find the more homophobic and suppressed boys are the more I wonder what is going on under their skin!

How can we expect our sons to make great Dads if we don't let them practice? 

Kids learn through play.  They also work out their worries and fears through play.  Depriving them of that outlet stunts their emotional growth.  Yes, your son might want to dress up like mummy or play with dolls, but isn't it true that the person they see the most of (generally) is Mum?  Isn't imitation the sincerest form of flattery?

That said, despite all my fairness and never telling him things are 'girly' my son has now decided that pink is girly and will not have anything pink, but instead gives it to his sister.  He also told me he can't be friends with the girl next door as she is a girl (though he will play with his girl cousins 'cause cousins don't count! - 3 year old logic)

Where do they learn these things from?

I have also made a stance of not giving him violent toys - like guns & swords.  My husband laughed and said he would make his own.  Of course he has - sticks are swords and guns are made from Duplo.  I feel really uncomfortable about that but I can't stop him.  i just talk to him about hurting other people and why we don't!

The important thing is that my husband has never judged - he plays along and sings, dances and reads with him - as well as all the rough stuff!  Apparently growing up with older sisters he was brought up much the same.

So when it comes to my daughter, how do we play it? 

I am surprised that my daughter is bringing out my softer, more feminine side naturally.  I hated pink before but it is growing on me and she has a fine collection of dresses (as well as her brother's hmds).  However I quite frequently dress her in colours other than pink.  I am happy for her to play with cars and dolls - I hope the two children will share toys.  However as my husband said "surely we should be teaching boys to care and nurture, not teaching our girls not to!" - profound!

Anyway that's what I think - give them a chance and don't push them into your mould - encourage them to be who they are and they will be the best person they can be.
Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.61 (Highly recommend) from 25 votes
Report
ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

kathryn-solaris
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2008 | kathryn-solaris
Re: "Boys are blue & Girls are pink" (says my 3 y/o)

the nail has a sore head! ::) well done



Reply Reply Report
kseers
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2008 | kseers
Re: "Boys are blue & Girls are pink" (says my 3 y/o)

I write this some time ago and wanted to update:

My son has gone back to loving pink - but is still definitely a boy!  He loves super heroes, running, jumping (the trampoline is used daily), books, building, dress-ups and makes up brilliant stories.  His sister loves his cars - he shows no interest.  She plays with them, rides on his ride-on car every day, runs around after him and is generally a very active, little person.  I hesitate to call her a tom-boy but that is definitely the way she is looking.  However just before Christmas she discovered dolls.  At no prompting from me she carries them around, dresses them, pushes them in her pram etc....  Interesting how different they are.  One small thing shows a difference - whether it is boy/girl or just different make-ups I don't know, but he has always loved puzzles.  At 18 months he could do a 4 y/o puzzle.  At 20 months she picks up the pieces, looks at them and puts them back down again - no idea what to do with them... - interesting isn't it??



Reply Reply Report
emmie
5.00 (Excellent) | October 2007 | emmie
Re: "Boys are blue & Girls are pink" (says my 3 y/o)

brilliant advice i totally agree

cheers

emz



Reply Reply Report
siobhan11
5.00 (Excellent) | October 2007 | siobhan11
Re: "Boys are blue & Girls are pink" (says my 3 y/o)
Hi how r u and wuu2 lol


Reply Reply Report
shlindz
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | shlindz
Thankyou
Wow, I really think you have some great thoughts there. I love to qoutes and will probably keep them on my mind for several days. Thank you very much for this great article


Reply Reply Report
HOTMAMA
4.20 (Good) | December 2006 | HOTMAMA
tucks and dolls
When my daughters are playing with their dolls my son takes one and puts it in the bed of his dump truck and runs all over with it, occasionaly he will stop and give it a bottle then bring it to me and tell me " I daddy I go work Vernaliss"  Which is Vernaliss where his dad works!  He will be three and he knows the difference. My girls play with trucks too, I think they are all growing up well adjusted, you made a great point, Kudos!


Reply Reply Report
Primal-Fire
4.50 (Excellent) | November 2006 | Primal-Fire
great
Fantastic. I wish more parents would have your insight!


Reply Reply Report
mewannaboy
4.73 (Excellent) | November 2006 | mewannaboy
lets kids be kids
I agree i was critisised for dressing all of my 4 children in red,white or blue,i always have up until 1 year ago now ive found pink and purple and my daughters thank me for it.But i have no objectings to my son wanting a barbie or my daughter stealing his tonka trucks. You as a parent choose to do what ever you wish with your children,Parents have dealt with many a dilemma and still manage to cope.Every one male or female should be raised to know how ever they choose to be is good enough.


Reply Reply Report
ckelly
4.57 (Excellent) | November 2006 | ckelly
Let your Child be who they are

I agree with you. Given the chanse a son or daughter will develope into who they really are. As kids grow they will go through phases, I would much rather see a son be a little "pink" or a daughter a little "blue" than see them struggle with who he might be later in life.



Reply Reply Report
Jessgore
4.00 (Good) | November 2006 | Jessgore
Boys and girls...

Kids will be kids.. One day they like one thing the next they will play with another...  My sons favorite toys are at the moment a pink pram handed to him by his older sister, and a barbie car, also given to him by his sister.. Now his sister loves to skateboard...   She used to be into barbies and such...  I guess they go through stages, at one point my stepdaughter loved boys then she hated them, she is back into liking them now (but this time we have to watch her. :) )

And if boys want to be girls or girls want to be boys.. Well who am I to stop them. I don't think what they play with as kids is going to determain that...  But that is just my opinion....



Reply Reply Report
ssedgar
4.00 (Good) | November 2006 | ssedgar
boys and girls
it is amazing just how different boys and girls are. OUr friends have two little girls and when my boys go over to play i always get tols mum they squeal too much, why don't they want to play guns? (not that i like the fact that zac is obsessed with guns at the moment, Where do boys learn this is it pre progreammed?)


Reply Reply Report
Frontier
4.50 (Excellent) | November 2006 | Frontier
Great thoughts
You have found a very good approach to growing those little human beings.
i agree that they should be allowed to develop in what areas they want as they feel their way through life. Denial creates a market for them to see what is withheld from them. This include behaviors and play weapons as they will want to explore these even more because they have been told they cannot and this just makes them more curious and more likely to experiment in these areas outside our position of control.
We have 2 boys and they have played with dolls, footballs, toy soldiers, dress-ups, swords and shields and musical instruments. Our 6yo shows some "pink" tendencies sometimes but our 4yo is very "blue".
They were denied toy guns and they made their own, swords, they made their own. I even helped them make some shields out of cardboard boxes so we used our imagination and had a craft session as well.
We can guide them where we would like them to go but denial will only make them seek those things more.
Home made shields


Reply Reply Report
jenlemen
4.14 (Good) | November 2006 | jenlemen
i think personality is everything!
my firstborn daughter craved violence and my secondborn son is the biggest mushy mush ever.  i think her outgoing temperament made her seem more boyish at times while he has all the trappings of mamma's boy.  thanks for making space in this article for there being more than one way to be a boy or girl.  it's excellent!


Reply Reply Report
elizabeth
4.43 (Good) | November 2006 | elizabeth
Completely agree
I couldn't agree with you more.My son thinks that perfume smells like pink. My son loves all the typical boy stuff and the gun thing I will blame on his cousin. I will never buy him toy guns or swords and most people I know, will not them for him either. He will play with my daughter's toys too. Trying to stuff dolls into his cars or trains mainly. He loves helping me cook and clean. Actually he is a clean freak and thinks I clean the toilet just for him and always says thanks mummy when I've finished. My husband worries too that by playing with dolls he will grow up 'soft'. Funny because he still has a dolly from when he was a boy.
I tried to encourage my daughter to play with boys toys but she is just too much of a girl. Loves pink, yuck. But I couldn't do anything to disuade her. Now at 8 years old, she mixes it up just as good as any boy, just dressed in the perfect outfit.
Let kids be kids. If they are happy and healthy and play well together, what more can we ask for?


Reply Reply Report

Bookmarks

No bookmarks found

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend