minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
DV Ribbon by binky.jpg
Domestiv Violence Ribbon
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.77 (Highly recommend) from 37 votes (814 Visits)

Don't be too quick to judge other parents decisions (edited)

OzBinky by OzBinky Young Parent(December 2006) (rank 14th)
Sometimes the only thing a parent can do is walk away. We focus on protecting our children as they grow up. We vow to love and protect them always, they are our life...  But fact is when they grow up you loose that ability more and more. When they reach
different ages and stages, when they begin along the road of 'independence' and when they leave the nest you have created for them, you can not protect them from the 'horrors' of life. You just hope that they remember and leave with all you have taught them. But what happens when they act or make choices that you know are wrong, what happens when their choices have placed them in trouble? What happens when no matter what you do, it makes things worst? What happens when one child's choice puts you or others at risk?    

Last year I found myself collecting my daughter (20) off the side of the road in the early hours of the morning, taking photos of her tiny body covered in bruises and lying to the boyfriend about her where abouts. I gave her all the support I could, all the information I could find and took her to counselling. What I couldn't do, is change the way she felt about him, or thought she felt and she kept going back. I was terrified that he was going to kill her one day, something that nearly happened when he tried to stab her with cementers peg. Still this was not enough for her to leave and she went back to him.

The boyfriend resented my family and I for the help we gave her and began threatening my eldest son and I. He would drive past, phone and each time she made contact with me, the threats got worst.   I was torn between helping my daughter and protecting my other 3 children. I had gone to the police, I begged her to leave him, I had some pretty evil thoughts of what I could do or have done to him....things became so bad I had to make a choice. Something NO parent should have to do.....I had to walk away from my daughter, I had to stop rescuing her, I had to stop contact with her. If I didn't I would have ended up rescuing my son (17) from god knows what.  

DV (Domestic violence) is a horrible situation for anyone to be in and when its your child, you feel helpless, frustrated and completely useless. My relationship with my daughter suffered terribly. She understood why I didn't like the boyfriend, but didn't accept the fact I would not have him in my home, hold conversations with him or tolerate him. She didn't like the fact I wouldn't allow any of the other children to stay over her house and if I stood up to him, for myself and my children she would become angry with me and refuse to talk to me...I felt I was in a no win situation.   The decision to step away from my daughter did not come lightly. I was terrified at what would happen to her, I was also terrified as to what may happen if my eldest son retaliated as well. The two youngest were too scared to do anything outside because of threats made, I would check my car everyday to make sure he hadn't done anything to it...we were becoming that paranoid I may as well had been in a relationship with him. I stepped away for 4 months, the LONGEST 4 months of my life. I was glad to be able to keep track of what was going on through friends, but yet kept an extremely hard and quite watch, hoping that she would leave him before it was too late.   Something she did finally do....  

When we caught up after she left this relationship we spoke at great length over my decision to step away. I needed her to know how hard it was for me to do that, I needed her to know that I never stopped watching out for her and I was relieved to find out that it was a great part of why she left him. Not being accessible to her made her realise what she had and what he had taken from her. The lack of a safety net showed her exactly what dangers she was facing. It was like holding a mirror and seeing the truth.   I was judged so many times by others for what I did. I was called heartless, ruthless, a bad mother....you name it I was called it. We all have our own perspective of what being a good parent is, how we might react in different circumstances. Truth be known I never would have thought I would have stepped away from something like this, not my own child. I also never thought I'd be a widow at 35 either. The point I am making is that we may have goals and expectations of what we are, who we are and what we want and want to achieve for ourselves and our children, these change though and sometimes they change despite how hard you may fight to keep them.

My actions, despite the many critics, were the only ones I felt I had. I made them with the intentions of keeping 3 of my 4 children safe. Sometimes the best thing to do is walk away and hope like hell that the ones you love follow you. I was lucky, she did....but it could have very easily backfired on me.   Each person who shot me down did not help the situation, they contributed to it and contributed to the friction felt between my daughter and I. If you know someone who is in a similar situation as I was, support them as these decisions do not come lightly. You may think you would act differently to another, but you just don't know. We are not perfect parents, we are not without faults and no one has the patent on 'Perfect Parenting'. We are all learners striving to be in control of the direction we move and sometimes the roads are foggy....
Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.77 (Highly recommend) from 37 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

emmie
December 2007 | emmie
Re: Don't be too quick to judge other parents decisions (edited)

great articel thanks for sharing your story

Emz xx



Reply Reply Report
llmunchkin
August 2007 | llmunchkin
Re: Don't be too quick to judge other parents decisions (edited)
Lavinia, I hadn't read this one before... You certainly have been through so much, and I am sure that your actions to preserve the safety of your own family must have had an effect on her decision to finally leave him.

Thanks so much for sharing your story, it must have been a terrifying time for all of you.


Reply Reply Report
NINJAFAIRY
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | NINJAFAIRY
what if

Binky,

thankyou so much for sharing that. I can only say again: you are incredibly strong. I'm so sorry that your daughter went through this, but so glad she survived. Many don't.

I too never thought of supplying the "what if" scenario. This is one of the best pieces of advice I have ever been given, and I will be using it.

 



Reply Reply Report
blackwidowkate
January 2007 | blackwidowkate
DV
Hi
You are one amazing woman Lavinia......you go through so much yet still help us with your wisdom.....
I was the other way around....I was the child living in a Domestic Violent house with my mum and her boyfriend fighting and arguing all the time
In the end I had to give my mum a ultimatum that she either left him or I was leaving......I could not live with it any more  and if he ever came back I was leaving
Luckily enough she loved me enough to walk away....
He came over once more about 4 years later and I walked straight to my room and started packing....Mum came in and saw what I was doing...said I love you and walked out and kicked him out of the house once more...She knew I was serious
I was one of the lucky ones not only making my mum escape but also breaking the cycle
Only one man has ever tried to hit me in a arguement.....that was my teenagers father
When I asked him later why he didn't he said the look in my eyes was not me I was no longer there and all he saw was if he hit me then it would be the last thing he would ever do......
But I cannot say the same for emotionally....because yes the scars don't heal and are easier to hide.....
One day soon I hope that you and all the other Minti survivors will have given me the courage to finally tell the whole story  Maybe then I will finally heal forever.....
Luv Deb


Reply Reply Report
Omegastar
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | Omegastar
tears in my eyes now

Once upon a time I was your daughter. I didn't walk away until my daughter was threatened. It's so sad what people will put up with, and for what?

You deffinatly did the right thing, I can't bare the thought of that happening to my child but if it did I think I would do teh same thing as you, I would hope anyhow. You are a very brave woman.



Reply Reply Report
jmrmumstheword
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | jmrmumstheword
you are a great mother

you are really a great mother and my heart goes out to you for making one decision that was possibly your hardest to ever have had to make, good on you and i think you did the right thing

i bet she is proud of her mum now though, now that she understands what you had to do



Reply Reply Report
breannababy
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | breannababy
Mothers love
You are right it was not a decision a parent should have to make.......However you are the eptimom of great parenting.Once they reach a certain age we can only make sure they know we will be there for them always if they choose to need us.I am so pleased your daughter had the strength to leave that destructive relationship.Sometimes we have to be cruel to be kind.I love the saying walk a mile in my shoes......I think if we all did this we would be less inclined to judge.


Reply Reply Report
lightbee
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | lightbee
I'm so proud of you

I can only imagine how hard that was for you to do. But I am so proud that you did and that you never gave up on your daughter - continuing to watch from a distance and contacting her when she was out of the relationship.  I think this is an example of the true meaning of tough love.  Good on you.



Reply Reply Report
Wendigo
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | Wendigo
You win First prize for Most Sensible Mother

Your words to me when I told you I was sending my boy to the USA to get good therapy for several years still ring in my mind, as you were the first person to really show any support on my decision: "My God, you are such as strong woman! You really love that boy more than anything."  I am proud to say that you are a friend of mine. The way you dealt with the situation with your daughter is nothing short of admirable. You are what I aspire to be as a parent and a woman.  You may think I'm a tough little cookie, but girl, you are a rock.

I think what is important is that we give our children not only the ability to avoid the horrors of life, but also to give our children the ability to survive those horrors when they can't be avoided.  There are victims, and then there are survivors.  I hope my children never have to be either, but if that can't be helped, I would want them to be survivors.



Reply Reply Report
ssedgar
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | ssedgar
don't judge

My parents have just gone through a similar thing with me and my partner, they knew he was into drugs and wanted me to leave but knew it was up to me to make the decision. i fanally saw what i needed to see and took my children and now live with my parents. You want  to do the best for your children but you can't make their decisions for them.

I think you are a very brave woman well done



Reply Reply Report
      OzBinky
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | OzBinky
don't judge
Congratulations matey!! Its an amazingly hard and strong journey that you have taken and one that must have taken a great deal of strength for you to do. I think it takes a stronger person to leave than to stay.....congrats again.


Reply Reply Report
Nontoxic
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | Nontoxic
Don't be quick to judge
ozbinky, Thanx for sharing that story with us, I here you loud and clear bieng the mum of 2 girls and a boy and coming from a home with an abusive father (to my mum) I no longer have My mum to call on for advice or help as she died 14 years ago, before I had kids. What you did was the only thing you could do and I APPLAUD YOU.


Reply Reply Report
      OzBinky
4.33 (Good) | December 2006 | OzBinky
Don't be quick to judge

Thank you and I'm so sorry to hear about your mother..((hugs))



Reply Reply Report
HOTMAMA
4.55 (Excellent) | December 2006 | HOTMAMA
Parents
I hope I never face something like this!  You are a strong woman!


Reply Reply Report
michellei
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | michellei
Don't be too quick to judge other parents decisions
I'm hoping that I can empower Miss Cheeky Chops with the tools she needs to not become a victim. I do not want her going down this road like I did.

Why do so many of us end up in this situation?

I am not saying that you didn't empower your daughter enough. I don't want my comment to refelct on you or be taken out of context. It is in no way an insult to you.

Thank you for sharing this very important decision in your life.


Reply Reply Report
      OzBinky
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | OzBinky
Don't be too quick to judge other parents decisions
I understand exactly what you're saying and nah, I didn't take it out of context. You are completely right. The only thing is, the older they get, the less you know. They fall in and out of love, each one being their 'one and only true love' (until the next one that is). Despite what you teach a child they will more often than not experience the total opposite to what you say. We learn by our own mistakes. I left home, although very young, with good values, common sense and self respect and was taught that no man has the right to hit you, no matter what. I still went my direction, made all the mistakes my mother taught me not to make and ended up with a dominating man that spoke with his hands. I wasn't my mother, I needed to learn my own way and as my mother and more than likely her mother, we send our kids into the world hoping that they take these values and goals with them. We all make mistakes but its only when we do that we fully understand the impact of the choices we make. I hear my daughter now talking to those who are in the same relationship as she was. I see the frustration in her face, the question even...Why haven't these people learnt through me? Because it's always different, or they think this is the case. Falling in love is an incredible feeling and when we do it's like no body else understands how you are feeling. Giving your children the tools for life is one thing, but so many of us, parents, do not think of offering the 'what if' scenario. I taught my daughters 'no man has the right to hit/hurt or whatever. I told my sons the same and that 'no woman has the right to hit/hurt or whatever. What I failed to do was tell my children what to do if they happened to be in this situation. I didn't think about that possibility. I only taught them not to. I thought that was enough and sadly it wasn't. There are so many tools of life that no one person is ever going to be able to give their child every one. Each generation brings something new and we are bound to miss some vital piece of information. Teach your children what to do if they are in trouble, give them the tools to understand the signs and do it real early.....


Reply Reply Report
pdubble2
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | pdubble2
good luck

I wouldn't listen to anyone either when I was going thru it and I hope I dont have to eva go thru this with my kids. best wishes



Reply Reply Report
MumKim
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | MumKim
A courageous story from a courageous lady.
A courageous story from a courageous lady. It is so easy to judge other people without knowing all the facts. Thank you for sharing your story with great advice.


Reply Reply Report
OzBinky
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | OzBinky
Thank you guys
This would be one of the first times I haven't been criticised in a negative way. Thanks muchly guys, you've made my day!


Reply Reply Report
nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | nell18-3
Domestic Violence
I have recently come out of a long marriage where I was emotionally abused and controlled. My parents knew this was going on some 10 years ago, but kept in the background and quietly supported me without once criticising him to me. Until the day I knew there was also a physical threat and he was trying to convince me I had gone bad and needed psychiatric treatment, I then got out and ran right into the comfort of my parents, who have been consistent and supportive all my life. I am 42 but I need them now more than ever and there they are ! Fantastic parenting I hope my children will one day say the same of me


Reply Reply Report
lexiw
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | lexiw
Domestic Violence
I was in a violent relationship and would not listen to anyone who told me I should leave I had to learn for myself. Good on you for what you did I think you possibly helped to save your daughters life.


Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend