minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) 4.07 (Worth a try) from 24 votes (1747 Visits)

ADD/ADHD Is It Real Or Poor Parenting

Anonymous Author (December 2006)
Until my nephew was diagnosed with ADD I was a real skeptic on the condition,I was like a lot of non believers and just touted the poor parenting speale.

Since the diagnosis I have seen my sister try and move mountains to help her boy.She along with many
other Mums and Dads has had to cop the flack off inconsiderate and ignorant people flying the poor parenting banner.......I am not saying that this disorder is not taken advantage of by some negligent parents,however who are we to judge any way????

As some of you have stated,Diet does play an important role in managing this disorder but on the contry in no way does it suggest that it must now mean it is only a food allergy or such so in fact supports a non ADD belief.We are all entitled to our opinion on this issue and I respect this.

However I think a little understanding and perhaps research before slamming this into a mythical disorder basket would be a very compassionate and humane thing to do.I will now include a number and web sites to contact to either help parents or give doubters and interested persons some facts to peruse.contact number:132289 web sites: www.adders.org/ausmap.htm. alternative therapy: www.dore.com.au Hope this will assist those who need it or need to broaden their horizons.regards Merle
Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.
ADVICE RATING
 (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) 4.07 (Worth a try) from 24 votes
Report
ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

Krazykat22
March 2009 | Krazykat22
Re: ADD/ADHD Is It Real Or Poor Parenting

i didn't even know what ADHD was until my daughter was diagnosed. I thought I was a bad parent even though I have two perfectly adjusted children too. Now I understand she just has a different way of viewing the world and I can help her see the world as I do with a few small adjustments to the way we do and learn things.



Reply Reply Report
bgregory
May 2008 | bgregory
Re: ADD/ADHD Is It Real Or Poor Parenting

Hi,

ADD does exist as you said, and I agree diet can help an awful lot. I used the Davis methods to help my own kids and have since become trained in the methods I was so happy. Check out www.focusonlearning.com.au if you are interested in hearing more. The book the Gift of Learning by Ron Davis is also interesting.

 



Reply Reply Report
MelodyS
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | MelodyS
ADHD

I just commented on ADHD in Kevin's advice post.  Boy do I live with the "reality".  Combine ADHD with bipolar disorder for real interest.

My son living with bipolar/ADHD has done very well for several years on the non-stimulant drug Strattera for ADHD.  Just wanted to mention it for those who may not have heard of it.  He has had no side effects.  He was recently dx bipolar and added a medication due to BD which included suicidal tendancies and the medications are working well together...doesn't solve everything, but allows him to manage his life in a more balanced manner along with psych therapy and behavior modification techniques.



Reply Reply Report
ladyprincess
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | ladyprincess
AD/HD

Like a lot of others I worked on my son's diet - but he was very much like MadMel's sister - couldn't concentrate, didn't think before he acted, hyer etc and we saw such a huge improvement initally with his meds. When he was at school he spoke to his psychologist about increasing the dose, at first he was put on slow release dex, but that increased his blood pressure and heart rate, so he was put back on the tablets.  His psyc has said he won't increase the dose as he doesn't need it - some days his normal dose is fine, but there are times when he does need extras, eg when he was learning to drive and getting his license.

He works it out for himself now, but we still control them as we know that if I just gave him the bottle they would not last the two weeks.  The last 4 years have been trial and error.

AD/HD affects the whole family



Reply Reply Report
cookclan
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | cookclan
again a wonderful bit of advcie
Hey there Merle
Once again a wondeful bit of advice from a very smart lady hehe. 
have a great chrissie
Cheers
Angie


Reply Reply Report
      breannababy
4.44 (Good) | December 2006 | breannababy
again a wonderful bit of advcie
AAWWHHH SHUCKS ANDIE(HEH HEH HEH)YOUR MAKING ME BLUSH......YOU  HAVE A GREAT XMAS TOO.MMMMMWWWWWWWWAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHH


Reply Reply Report
nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | nell18-3
My son is ADHD
I always remember thinking my son was a handful, and I was used to it and when 18 months ago his school teacher called me in to say she thought he had ADHD I was quite annoyed initially. When I went home I researched like crazy and it was like all the lights coming on everything made sense.
My son is now on a low dose of ritalin but this has only just started, for all the months previously I tried loads of things to help him, medication was always going to be my last option. I still don't regret trying everything first but I am convinced this low dose of medication is amazing for him.
His brain has been controlled so his true creative self is emerging and I would never have known my sons capabilitlies without trying the medication. I agree with Merle that there are always cased where ADHD is used as a copout but in the real cases it is so sad to see the whole family coming under a microscope about how bad behaved the child can be.
ADHD is very real. I know it!


Reply Reply Report
      breannababy
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | breannababy
My son is ADHD
Hey there Nelly,You know you can only do what works for you and yours..........what works for some does not for others.Good on you for trying all avenues.thankyou for the comment regards Merle


Reply Reply Report
Naya
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | Naya
I'm ADHD

It is a real disorder... don't let anyone fool you. But it is something that can be controlled through diet, exercise and a good healthy dose of nature. Tell your sister that certain foods and food additives can aggrivate ADD and ADHD. She should avoid giving her son anything with food dyes... some of them are actually derived from petrolium and have been known to cause behavior problems in children. Don't give him anything that is processed.... and stay away from any snack foods especially flavored chips and the like. Most of them contain MSG (which can be disguised as spice, spices, natural flavor or anything like that on the label in the US and goes buy food enhancer 621 in AU... also tell her to avoid anything with the food enhancer 635... that one is suspected to cause serious rashes in young children). Her best bet would be to feed him whole foods like fruits and veggies and just stay away from boxed and canned stuff all together.

Some kind of structured exercise is good too... like taking martial arts. It gives them an outlet for their extra energy and teaches them how to focus. And kids like this need lots and lots of time outdoors. Tell her to spend as much time at a local park with him as she can.

These things won't cure him, but they'll certainly calm him a bit and make her life (and his) a lot easier to handle.



Reply Reply Report
      Naya
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | Naya
I'm ADHD
I'd also like to add that I've never been on the drugs for this disorder. I actually learned how to focus through meditation and yoga when I was about 10 years old. If your sister doesn't want to go the drug route, there are other alternatives. Personally, I wouldn't suggest the drugs (unless nothing else works) because some of them have really negative side affects that can make them worse in the long run.


Reply Reply Report
           breannababy
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | breannababy
I'm ADHD
Fortunately my sister has not had to medicate my nephew,she has opted for a lot of which you have written.thank-you very much for your contribution I really appreciate it and will pass on the info to my sister.regards Merle


Reply Reply Report
                Naya
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | Naya
I'm ADHD

I had another thought that occurred to me... another natural way to help a kid physically and mentally relax is with herbs and aromatherapy. I use that a lot now when I have a hard time sleeping because my brain won't shut off. There are herbs like chamomile and lavendar that are great for calming.

If she's interested in trying herbs and stuff she should talk to a naturopath or herbologist in her area... they can tell her what would be good for her son based on his age and the proper amounts that he should have.



Reply Reply Report
bottleslingguy
4.69 (Excellent) | December 2006 | bottleslingguy
Mercury or other toxins?
Have you seen the discussion about mercury preservatives in vaccinations causing autism? Google Thimerisol Autism. These disorders like ADD/ADHD could be variations of autism or even just related/caused by, either toxins in the environment or drugs/meds in mom and dad's bloodstreams.


Reply Reply Report
meggles
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | meggles
adhd

It gives me the willys when people stand in judgement over others.  ADHD is a medical condition. That is a fact. Poor parenting can cause some of the symptoms of adhd but not all. Once you have been exposed to adhd either personally or via friendships you stop being cynical. I certainly am in awe of parents who cope with adhd. (mine has mild adhd and anxiety disorder). I can assure you I am not a poor parent. In fact probably spend more time working with my child than most parents.  Nice to chat to you



Reply Reply Report
      breannababy
4.44 (Good) | December 2006 | breannababy
adhd
It is sometimes easiest to criticize that which we don't understand.Thankyou regards Merle


Reply Reply Report
      bottleslingguy
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | bottleslingguy
adhd

My son was diagnosed at about eight or nine. He and his sister (two years apart) couldn't be more different so I don't think it's the parenting. I don't think it's genes either.

I have a friend in his forties who acts just like someone with ADHD and he told me he wished he had the meds when he was in school because it caused him to be kicked out of several.



Reply Reply Report
MadMel
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | MadMel
ADHD
Your right. My sister was diagnosed at 10. She couldnt concentrate, wouldnt think about what she was doing before she did it, she was in tears all the time, clumsy, hyper, touchy and more. First my mum changed her diet. Helped a little but not a lot. Then they tried physo specialising in balance, memmory and oher stuff. It wasn't until she was medicated that we saw the biggest change. She could sit in one spot for more then 3 minutes, grades went up a lot, she stoped walking into walls/parked cars and all that, she calmed right down. It was quite remarkable. She was a whole different person. I have seen some shocking ADHD cases. I have also seen some parents that just cant be bothered controlling their children so call it ADHD. So yes, dont judge. Its over diagnosed BUT the parent that your bitching about might have been through what my mum went through... pure hell.


Reply Reply Report
      breannababy
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | breannababy
ADHD
Look, I felt so rotten after my nephew was diagnosed,my sister is a stickler for guidelines and disciplin I know she is a good parent and as such I found out more about the disorder and realized my previous ignorance.This has helped me to try to be a bit more non-judgmental to situations I don't really know too much about.Thanks for your comment regards Merle



Reply Reply Report
      bottleslingguy
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | bottleslingguy
ADHD

I was talking with my son today about his meds and he asked if he could up his dosage. It's the same since he first started on it five or six years ago. Back then I hated the idea but since it is water soluable and like caffeine, urinated out of his body within hours, I thought we'd give it a try.

And just like that his school improved dramatically. He gets regular meds checks for growing/sleeping/appetite problems and has grown normally, sleeps fine (sometimes too fine) and has a normal appetite. His social skills are also "normal" aside from bouts of immaturity every now and then. And not to mention his grades.

The medication worked wonders for him but he can tell he, now at sixteen, needs a higher dose. I think it's a testament to the credibility of these meds that he is able to notice the difference.

I talk to him about imagining himself controlling his behavior without the meds because there may come a time when he is without them or has to stop taking them. I warn him about the psychological crutch some types of meds can become and also that the chemicals may have long term effects on his body so it is good to get check ups in his later years.

Having a friend, who definitely has some form of hyperactive disorder ( in his forties), who  wishes he had the meds when he was in school. He says it probably would've kept him from all the trouble he got into; it makes it easier for me to see what my son could be and realize I made the right choice.

It's a tough choice consenting to medicate your child with anything (for me that is, even cough syrup), but it would be worse to know I failed him for the fear of guilt or because I didn't want the stigma of having a medicated child.



Reply Reply Report
           breannababy
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | breannababy
ADHD
I agree with you, it is a tough choice any time we have to decide whether to medicate or not......All situations and people are different,some kids only need mild meds and other forms of treatment or no meds at all,others need high dose meds and extreme methods of treatment.We as parents do our best and I think a bit of understanding from people in general would be great. Thanks for your comment regards Merle


Reply Reply Report

Bookmarks

No bookmarks found

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend