minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.58 (Highly recommend) from 34 votes (2459 Visits)

If Breastfeeding Fails...

Wendily by Wendily Walking(May 2006) (rank 500+)
Sometimes, despite our best intentions, things just don't work out the way we had hoped. As a mom-to-be, I went to the breastfeeding classes, read some breastfeeding books, and researched the topic extensively on the internet. Long before my due date I had my bags of frozen peas in the freezer (ready to relieve the inevitable engorgement), my breast pump was on order, and I had practiced the various holds for proper breastfeeding positioning.

A few hours after Jack was born the lactation consultant brought him in to teach me how to breastfeed. Her first reaction was that I had flat nipples. Flat nipples, I wondered? I always thought I was normal. No problem she said, we'll just use a nipple shield. So she showed me how to use it, and Jack latched on, and it was wonderful. I felt like the best mommy in the whole world because I was holding my baby close and he was snuggly and happy, and he fell asleep. I was sore, but I was prepared for some soreness at first. A few hours later, Jack was hungry again, so the lactation consultant came back, and he latched on, but this time it was very painful. The consultant saw my toes curling in pain, and she said, "That shouldn't be happening!" I insisted that it was probably fine, but she went and got another consultant to help. They checked the latch, and they said it was fine and correct, but something just wasn't right, because it wasn't supposed to hurt that much. So they took Jack off and as soon as they removed him from my breast they looked down, and one exclaimed, "Honey, he's deforming you!" They each stuck a finger in his mouth and determined that Jack was a "tongue-sucker." I told them about how even at the 20-week ultrasound, Jack sucked his thumb, and on all his ultrasounds he did this thing that looked like he was blowing bubbles, but apparently was him sucking on his tongue. So Jack was a pro at sucking on his tongue, which in turn gave him the unusual sucking motion of smashing his tongue up against his hard palate, which is what he was doing to my poor nipple, not taking it back onto his soft palate like he was supposed to. And since he had been doing this for at least 19 weeks, his tongue smashing motion was very strong!

Anyway, after two more consultations for breastfeeding, it was determined that I would risk permanent damage if Jack continued to breastfeed. I was heartbroken, but at least I had my breast pump (tip: buy it before you deliver!), so he'd still get the nutritional benefits of breastmilk. So I pumped and I pumped, and I just didn't get very much milk out, even though in the first month I was religious about pumping every two hours and even when I did 24 hours of pumping every hour to simulate a growth spurt (this is supposed to stimulate your body into making more milk). My milk just kind of went away after two months, and I was very disappointed that it hadn't worked out like I had hoped. Hopefully with our next baby things will work out better.

In the meantime, however, I've looked, and there isn't a lot of support out there for moms who have tried breastfeeding but ran into problems like this. We all know that "breast is best," but sometimes it doesn't work out despite a lot of effort. I felt guilty and depressed for weeks, and still do a little bit, that I was unable to give my little guy the best start possible. But I'm realizing that this guilt isn't helpful to anyone. If this happens to you, it's important to not feel guilty. You tried, and you love your baby and just want what is best for him. So reassure yourself that you're a good mom, and trust your baby the next time he smiles at you and tells you that he loves you.
Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.58 (Highly recommend) from 34 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

lovingmum
5.00 (Excellent) | February 23rd | lovingmum
Re: If Breastfeeding Fails...

hi, thank you so much for sharing your experiance! 

thinking back to when Jaimyn was born and I was attempting to breast feed, Everyone said that everything was fine and I was discharged from hospital.  I remember sitting on the couch tring to breastfeed with my toes curled, hunched over my newborn in excruciating pain and my mother in law saing "relax"?!!? anyway one month later I was admitted to hospital with a really high fever, it turned out that I had mastitis really bad.  after that was under control (morphine and antibiotics) consultants tried to figure out what was wrong. A lovely consultant told me I had flat nipples But regardless Jai still had a good latch but his technique was wrong, then they started saying that the connection under his tounge needed to be cut so he could suck properly. (luckily that got sorted out quickly sounded barbaric to me) anyway they watched Jai feed and after he was finished they  noticed my nipple was all munched up so concluded that he was biting rather than sucking.But  to persevere, I spent a week in hospital with all this tring to get it right. In the end I was so sleep deprived, exausted and in pain, half the time I was hooked up to this industrial looking milking machine. I was so past it that I was phisicly pushing Jaimyn away because I was dreading the agony. So I reluctantly decided to bottle feed jai. I would rather cuddle my baby than resent him. So Jai had about a month and a bit breast milk.

For so long I felt guilty and not worthy and depressed because you do get BREAST IS BEST imbeded in your mind and it does bring up negative feelings if you wanted to do it but circumstances beyond your control stopped you. so thank you for your story and those who had commented because it has made me feel completely normal       



Reply Reply Report
tunky
5.00 (Excellent) | February 9th | tunky
Re: If Breastfeeding Fails...

I'm so glad you shared this. I've never heard of such a situation, and I think it's important that ppl are made aware of as many scenarios as possible, so we can learn more and understand more... You are a legend!



Reply Reply Report
Sylv
October 2007 | Sylv
Re: If Breastfeeding Fails...
When my 3rd child, I had so much trouble getting her to latch on, but I was anemic, my milk didn't come in fast enough for her and she just fought me the whole time.  After 3 weeks of fighting with her to latch on, and her not putting weight on the midwife told me to put her onto the bottle.  I was absolutely gutted as I had breastfed my older daughter for 8.5 months and a year with my middle boy.  When my little baby was admitted into hospital with an infection and I stayed with her the hospital even sent me a breast feeding expert to come along to see what we were doing wrong (despite my 3rd!) she could find nothing that I was doing wrong.  I was absolutely gutted and I blamed myself for a week afterwards.  It was only when I went to the Dr's re my anemia that she turned to me and said, you gave her 3 weeks of your goodness, she has had the best from you.  You are a great mum, just enjoy her.  I did just that..... Jayne is now 7 months old and so content, sleeping through the night after 5 weeks of being born.  So mums out there don't beat yourself up, if you have tried and cannot breastfeed, you have done your best.


Reply Reply Report
MumKim
July 2007 | MumKim
Re: If Breastfeeding Fails...
It sounds like you did lots of preparation and tried extremely hard. I am sorry that it didn't work out for you, but I think that you are an amazing person and should be very proud of yourself or trying so hard.
I didn't do the prep you did. I had some difficulties and asked for a nipple shield at 3 am when my milk came in and things just weren't going well. I know that a lot of midwives don't like nipple shields but it got me through the rough patch and we were later able to wean her off the nipple shield.
Your little boy is very lucky to have such an amazing mother.


Reply Reply Report
Anonymous Member
 
This Comment has been deleted
blackwidowkate
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | blackwidowkate
brest is best
Hi Yes I spelt it wrong purposely
Guess what you gave him your breast and your best....He got the first milk...he got the best part of the milk the collustrum
Don't ever let anyone including yourself make you feel guilty
You perservered a long time after a lot would have given up.
Jalan would not latch on no matter what we did...and this is one I actually wanted to breast feed....
I got sick of feeling like a cow and being milked all the time.....but I was determined she would get the first milk and as much as I could give her.
Her paediatrician came and checked her and said she was whats called a lazy suck.....they blamed it on a lot of factors.
They had to feed her with a syringe as she would not feed herself no matter what they did.
In the end I said try a bottle and even it took a long time to get her to feed right.....
I feel I gave my baby the best start in life and that is all that matters,
She is happy and well adjusted jsut as your son will be
And dad got to bond with his baby too being able to feed her
Luv Deb



Reply Reply Report
ssedgar
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | ssedgar
brestfeeding

i tried brestfeeding with both my boys but as in ally's case my milk didn't come in, i did feel really guilty when i put Zac on the bottle with everyone saying breast is best but when he settled easier and was happier i knew i had done the right thing.

When my milk didn't come in with jacob i didn't hesitate to put him on the bottle



Reply Reply Report
kseers
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2006 | kseers
A Happy Mum is a Happy Baby
You can never underestimate the effect your own psyche has on your baby, so if you are in pain and suffering it cannot be good for your baby. Don't be hard on yourself - we are often our own harshest judges - you do what you can and what seems best at the time. You are to be commended for wanting the best for your baby - and I'm sure that your baby will appreciate the love you have regardless of how it is fed!


Reply Reply Report
Jessgore
5.00 (Excellent) | October 2006 | Jessgore
Very true...

No one should feel guilty about how they feed their baby.. I did in the first few weeks because with out fully knowing what was wrong I was starving him. I was told by my mother and others that I should give him the bottle formula, but I did not believe them because they were not doctors... Then I just was not making the milk so the doctors suggested formula but then feed him with a tube so he won't forget how to suck the breast if I went back.. Once again every one else was saying give him the bottle.... But again I did not listen they were not doctors...    My baby was still not happy, in the end I gave in to all those other mothers that said just give him the bottle, I actually handed my son over to these woman and said you do it, (I was getting depressed and needed to be away from all these other mothers that knew what was best for my child).   Turns out they were right. For the first time since he was born he was well fed because the other mothers gave him the formula and he was full....    I felt guilty as hell that I did not listen to them and not the doctor that for three weeks had I of listened to them in the first place I would not have starved my son.   I was able to start breast feeding again.

But regardless, no one should feel guilty how they feed their newborn, if your baby is happy and well fed that is what matters.



Reply Reply Report
JadieLady
4.00 (Good) | August 2006 | JadieLady
too right
your on the spot regarding support. i had the same thing happeb, but i managed to last three months. i was actually told the pump was stimulating me as it should have. my fault too. and then i had a rude doctor tell me i was a bad parent because of it. but i just think of the convenience the formula has given my family. always makes me feel i have done the best io could


Reply Reply Report
allyp
June 2006 | allyp
same here

I tried to breast feed my daughter but my milk didn't come in. So I had to start giving her formula. I didnt feel like a bad mother though. Because I had to do what was best for my daughter since my milk hadn't come in yet.



Reply Reply Report
portugreek
3.50 (Good) | June 2006 | portugreek
Me too
It's so good to know there are other Mom's out there struggling my struggles as well.  I breast fed my daughter when she was born but my milk had not come in, it wasn't until four days after that it finally arrived.  She was getting the colostrum but she was never content after her feedings (she would be at the breast for HOURS at a time to no avail)!  I had to supplement her with formula and I felt like such a failure.  The nurses were no help at all; they were constantly hammering down my throat how "breast is best."  I agree that it is, but sometimes breast doesn't work and so the next best thing is the formula...I wasn't about to starve my daughter because I couldn't keep up with my milk supply.  I still do breast feed my daughter but it is only in the morning and at night and even then I have to supplement her with a WHOLE bottle of formula.  It's also sad how people look down at you because you are bottle-feeding...it's like, hey i tried and it didn't work.  I'm not looking for sympathy but I do feel like I'm in a sense a bad mother because I'm not giving my daughter what's "best." 


Reply Reply Report
TrishySwishy
3.67 (Good) | June 2006 | TrishySwishy
Same here...

  My little one was exactly the same.  I remember being so frustrated and sore that I would cry every time I had to feed her.  I wanted so desperately to do the right thing by her that I kept at it.  The pain did finally go away after 8 weeks when she finally figured it out, but I can't help feeling like I would have enjoyed my time with my new baby more if I wasn't  "dreading" her feedings.....



Reply Reply Report
Sistersarah55
2.14 (Poor) | June 2006 | Sistersarah55
I Had the same thing!

I got tired of people asking me if he's latched on properly and everything i read said "pain is due to baby not latching on properly". I had so many midwives and breast feeding councellors watch me breast feed i felt like the bearded woman at a carnival. All of which came to the same conclusion, i was doing everything fine and that the pain would go away. It didnt. I only had it on one side though but he was a hungry baby and had to have my whole supply every 3-4 hours. I'd started to dread feeding my own son so after 3 weeks to relieve some of the tension i started expressing from the one breast. It seemed like all i was doing was feeding, expressing, sterilising, soothing. After 4 weeks i was expressing from both breasts because he stopped feeding from the breast well and the process was taking longer. I had no idea that my breast milk was stimulated from the nipple so my breast milk started to dry up and he was having more and more formula. I almost broke down before i had to let it all go.

Your totally right when you say that there is no support for this, i'm so sick and resentful of the phrase 'breast is best'. I cryed for the longest time and reading that i wasnt alone has really helped. You build such a bond when you start breast feeding that you cant think of a worse thing that could happen than to stop.

Anyway i'm at 6 weeks now and its easier, he's even started sleepin through the night.

Thank you!

Sarah xxx



Reply Reply Report
rachelcook
3.33 (Average) | May 2006 | rachelcook
heartfelt
I had now idea how thumb sucking in the womb changed the way he suckled on the breast, this is really important to know. thanks so much for sharing your experience, this hopefully will help educate mother's more about breastfeeding and when cases aren't sometimes as clear cut. I am glad I know this...I had latching on problems on the second time I breast fed a few hours after birth, I was sore/red after four days and I pumped into a bottle for a month as soon as I got home...I admire your guts and determination to pump as much as you did, especially for 24 hrs, you are an amazing mom!!!!!!


Reply Reply Report
hrs2004
4.17 (Good) | May 2006 | hrs2004
You tried

You know, I can't imagine anyone would criticise you - and you shouldn't feel bad either. You tried. You were ready to go, it just didn't work out. What annoys me a tad is those who don't want to breast feed because thier boobs might sag more afterwards. You did your best. What child could ever be unhappy with a mum who did her best? In the same way, you will no doubt be over the moon when Jack does his best, right? You won't be annoyed or disappointed with him for not succeeding when he did everything he could? Then give yourself a break and move on to your next challenge!



Reply Reply Report
Izzy
3.75 (Good) | May 2006 | Izzy
So sorry!

I've never heard of this before. I am so sorry breastfeeding didn't work out for you. Is pumping still working out ? In my experience some breastpump are better than others. There are also some out there that doesn't even stimulate a let down so you can barely express enough milk.



Reply Reply Report
      Wendily
4.13 (Good) | May 2006 | Wendily
Re: So sorry!
I have the Medela In Style Advanced pump, which simulates a let-down and is supposed to be one of the best pumps on the market. It was very comfortable and easy to use. The lactation consultants said that problems like mine happened rarely, but I had never read about anything like this, so that's why I decided to write the advice.


Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend