minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
praising2.jpg
Parenting through problem solving
driven.jpg
Empowering our kids to reach the stars the hardworking way
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.68 (Highly recommend) from 32 votes (1319 Visits)

Hard work vs you're smart, praising your child

rachelcook by rachelcook Minti Founder(December 2006) (rank 31st)
I just read a very interesting article from "Psychology Today" today, that funny enough had an impact on me so suddenly. It caused me to think about exactly 'what' I 'say' to my two and half year old son. Usually, I say to my son, "Well done clever boy", although I know of course I am not damaging his spirit, but I have realized lately he won't do something (like drink from a cup) unless he can do it perfectly. He won't draw because he can't draw like mommy (mummy). I know this is a development stage, however, I know he can do a lot of things, yet he decides not too, because it's not perfect and the response isn't always "Clever boy".

However, when I say to him, "wow, you tried hard" or "you an do it, keeping trying, you are working hard to concentrate well done", he tries and tries and tries over and over again with such determination.

The results from this study showed that students that were praised based on their "efforts" rather than their "innate" abilities, were more likely empowered to succeed, than those children that were told that they were naturally smart or clever. These students who had been told they were smart or clever, found coping with failure difficult and began to "measure" themselves against the results concluding to themselves that, that is all they were worth - the score in their test results. (hmm that's sounds familiar to me in my life as a student)

Ways to praise that brought out the best and caused the child to try hard was highlighted in the article...
  • Put in a lot of effort into that
  • You were hardworking, well done
  • You have the will power to do it
  • You have the determination
Also, a friend of mine highly skilled in this area, also mentioned to say the specifics, as to why you think they worked hard to achieve the desired result.

For example: "Well done Codi, you tried really hard to hold the cup to your mouth and not let any water out", "You really concentrated hard to thread that string through the hole, well done"

What really hit home was,

Psychology Today..."Children praised for their natural abilities were not so resilient. Their motivation and performance suffered after their "failure," and they tended to inflate their scores when reporting them to others. Ultimately, they began to measure their worth by their test results, believes Dweck.

"The kind of praise that all of society thinks is wonderful is the kind of praise that makes kids very vulnerable," she says. "Parents need to focus on what children put into a task, rather than making implications about the worth of the child."
(source)

I am going to sharpen my praising skills and see how my little man responds. I believe it pays to pay attention to your praising and in my experience I have learned to "make it really meaningful" so that I am not just "praising lazily"...with no attention to the outcome or result and if I did in fact make a positive impact on the life of my child....and you know I have inspired myself to do this to my husband too.

How are you going with how you praise your child?
Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.68 (Highly recommend) from 32 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

RebeccaDorant
June 2007 | RebeccaDorant
Re: Hard work vs you're smart, praising your child
omg! so that is what i did to make logan be a perfectionist with his schoolwork!!! i always tell him how clever he is with it!! and dont tend to praise until he is finished. and consequently he wont try somthing if he thinks it is to hard... thanx muchly for this.... you have no idea how much convincing him time this will save me if it works...


Reply Reply Report
      Rachall
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | Rachall
Re: Hard work vs you're smart, praising your child
I did the same thing with Josh, that may be why he took so long to walk because he wanted to get it right the first time and the same with crawling.


Reply Reply Report
Rachall
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | Rachall
Re: Hard work vs you're smart, praising your child
I will have to give it a try on Josh


Reply Reply Report
taniagirly
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | taniagirly
Re: Hard work vs you're smart, praising your child
This makes sense-i will try it with my three year old. I also have heard that you can overpraise your child,so they think they are better than they really are. This kind of false confidence can lead them to be lazy and not try to perfect their skills-which ties in with your advice.


Reply Reply Report
Raine
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | Raine
Hard work vs you're smart, praising your child
You have written an excellent article once again full of valuable insight... One of my favourite sayings is... 'your not a failure if you don't succeed, your a success because you tried' - source 'feel the fear & do it anyhow.

Don't you just hate teachers that scrawl over the little ones work & write some negative comment about it being messy... My little ones often go outside the lines if colouring in...I tell them 'It doesn't matter if you went outside the lines what matters is that you tried so very hard & you did it just for me... ' Then up on the wall it goes.


Reply Reply Report
Kaelkitty
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | Kaelkitty
Oh Yes!
I was always told things like "you are so intelligent - why can't you do better" by teachers at school.  (I have serious disability issues that just went unrecognised in the 1960s) .  I know exactly how frustrating it is as a child to be held up to an ideal rather than to be rewarded for effort.  Something I've heard from several sources, but I can't document is that it takes 30 days to create a habit. If you are trying to teach something to a child, howabout a 30 day reward program with a prize at the end?   I wish I had a few more good habits now!


Reply Reply Report
jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | jenlemen
carol dweck
i *just* read an article with carol dweck about mindsets--her research is profound.  i have to confess this is very difficult for me, but i've been working on it since becoming aware of this advice.  thanks for bringing it to minti!


Reply Reply Report
Kristen
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | Kristen
You tried really hard
This one works really well for us because you can say it when he succeeds OR when he fails.  I just asked Derek the other day when we were going to reach a point that we didn't truly think that every single accomplishment Ethan does ISN'T the greatest thing in the world.  He laughed.  It's so difficult because you are just so proud that they are so focused on doing it right.  Thanks for the advice, Rachel.


Reply Reply Report
gabm
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | gabm
Praising your child
That's great stuff. I often use "clever boy" - and I find that sometimes he will commence an activity and then stop and say "I'm not very good at this. Let's do something else". It makes sense that his little brain says "too hard - won't please mummy - better do something I know how to do". Interesting, isn't it? I shall commence the above experiment in the morning and see what happens.....


Reply Reply Report
ethrin
4.00 (Good) | December 2006 | ethrin
You worked realy hard on that advice
You set it down realy well


Reply Reply Report
wildrose
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | wildrose
Well done for trying
Great article, Rach. Yes I found if we only say 'Great or Well done', the children might not understand or get the message behind it. But if we mention the meaning (the effort of doing it) of it (ie. Well done for trying, Good Job for doing it yourself, etc, etc), I will give the children more motivations and pride of trying.
I was a bit slack with my son, but I've changed now. I encouraged him more of doing some stuff by himself and let him learned from mistakes and be proud of what had he's done. I found now he becomes more relax.
Practices make things better than before.


Reply Reply Report
      rachelcook
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | rachelcook
Well done for trying
Yes I agree, thanks for your comment this is extremely helpful...I love reading about others experiences..."doing it yourself" is a big one and I realize hey I do say that sometimes and he is so proud of himself....thanks wildrose it was very helpful reading...the great thing it that once we find out ways of improving with kids you can just start straight away, they are very forgiving of any laziness - lol


Reply Reply Report
           wildrose
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | wildrose
Well done for trying
Agree, we all start from nothing/zero. I always shared my thought/experiences with my son, telling him that I didn't know that before either until I tried and kept trying till I knew what to be done. I told him the key is being patient (put away the frustration and anger feeling) and keep trying, when he does something new. If can't do it now, try later next time.

Now, when he found his way, he would keep going and going. When he stucked he'd come to me and ask for help. And i'll be  happy to help him by then (after he showed that he did make effort to do something).


Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend