minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.78 (Highly recommend) from 69 votes (2404 Visits)

Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

lightbee by lightbee Talking Back(December 2006) (rank 26th)

After a rather heated discussion with my boyfriend on this topic, I just wanted to put my 2 cents in.

I believe you should never ask a woman if she's pregnant - even if she looks like she's about to pop - because:

  1. You could be wrong, and you're basically just calling her fat.
  2. You could be right and she doesn't want to tell anyone yet.
  3. She may have been pregnant and already had the baby.  Again, you're just calling her fat.
  4. She may have been pregnant and lost the baby.   Now you're calling her fat and bringing up a traumatic issue.
  5. She may just want one day in her life where she doesn't have to discuss pregnancy and birth.
  6. If you're a family member or friend who wants her to have children, you're putting undue pressure on if you're wrong.
  7. If you're the 5th person to ask that question that day, I'll bet she's sick of answering it.  Whether she is or not.

If someone's pregnant, they will share it with you if they want to.  Then you can talk about it to your heart's desire.  But if they don't tell you, then don't bring it up.  You might just manage to avoid that really awkward pause where she looks at her feet and says "No..."

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.78 (Highly recommend) from 69 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

ksweatman
June 29th | ksweatman
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

Definitely true!  A lady I work with had gastric bypass surgery and didn't tell anyone.  When she came back to work after summer vacation (we are teachers) she had a very swollen belly (she looked about 6 months pregnant)  The rumors began to fly.  I just assumed she was pregnant. She stayed the same size all year and finally I figured she couldn't be pregnant because surely she would be about 15 months pregnant if she was.  Finally I had to know.  I asked a coworker and she told me about the surgery.  I came so close to asking this woman if she was pregnant.  How embarrassing would that have been....."No I'm not pregnant, I just had gastric bypass and didn't want anyone to know........"



Reply Reply Report
MJB
June 27th | MJB
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

This is so true! i work at a doctor's surgery so even if a patient is about to POP i know nothing! unless they tell me i dont know whats going on...also we've had a few pts lose their babies very sad so that doesn't put either of us in an awkward position...and also as a medical receptionist its my job to support not to stick my nose in! as in my job i do outside of work a woman might knock me over with her belly but i dont know anything lol when i was 14 i asked my mums friend when her baby was due...and she wasn't pregnant it was so awful i felt so bad! never again have i commented on anyone i think or know is pregnant till they spill the beans and also its their place to let everyone know their happy news =)



Reply Reply Report
Shadowbrooke
June 27th | Shadowbrooke
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

First I would like to say - thanks to all who have posted replies and for the intial thread - it made me remember what over the years I had forgotten. Having been in many of the positions listed above, I understand (and remember) the stuned looks I am sure I gave over comments made.

Now all of my children are grown and gone,I did "forget",what was like for me over 20 years ago but now it is with a child who you wonder on - but instead of asking, I am going to allow her to tell us in her time and save myself the ackward situation I would be putting myself into. Could be they are enjoying the blessing on their own for now.



Reply Reply Report
jerzgirl818
June 27th | jerzgirl818
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

I also agree!  I spent my entire third trimester trying to ignore rude questions.  Are you pregnant?  Oh, are you crazy?  Don't you already have your hands full? Can I feel your belly? (Do I know you?)  Do you know what you're getting yourself into?   It was only my third for goodness sake!!  And after I had given birth to him, he had severe jaundice, so I had to bring him to the hospital every day for 10 days.  When he was three days old, my mom was walking him so I could sit down, and these people said, "oh, when are you due".  I told them that  baby was three days old and they exclaimed, "wow, your stomach is still so big!".  I was mortified.  I mean, what did they expect?  9 months of baby belly to just dissolve?  I managed to bite my tongue, get up, and waddle away!!



Reply Reply Report
missnickley
June 20th | missnickley
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

I agree! There are just so many things that it could be. But at the same time being asked if you are going to have any more children when i am 32 weeks pregnant was a little upsetting as well! How big does she think i am normally???
And especially if you dont really know the person, unless they speak about it there is really no reason to bring it up!



Reply Reply Report
kseers
June 7th | kseers
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

I agree!  Been on the receiving end a few times.  Had to laugh recently though when a friend announced she was pregnant - six montths!  "I can't believe none of you had noticed - it's a bit obvious!"  We all thought the same thing - we may notice but you never ask!



Reply Reply Report
AZMom
May 2nd | AZMom
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

Lol I'm with you!

I had recently had a c-section and was in a store buying newborn diapers with my 6 week son in his pram when the cashier asked me when I was due....HELLO!!! I was gutted as I didn't realise I was still that big  

Lorna



Reply Reply Report
Juzzy
April 18th | Juzzy
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

With my first pregnancy i would have loved anyone to ask. The day i was leaving work to have the baby i actually told a regular customer that today was my last day and they asked me why i was leaving. I think that can also be embarrassing too.

Great artical. Very lighthearted



Reply Reply Report
amazon
5.00 (Excellent) | April 11th | amazon
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

Yeah Im 29 weeks pregnant and people can be so rude sometimes, its amazing how your weight gain is suddenly their business, Ive had some comments that I have just shaken my head at like hmm your getting large are you having a baby? (Thinking) Well I think its a baby or it could be and elephant......I'm quite surprised that most of the comments have been from other mothers I think we should all be educated in how to speak to a pregnant women. So great advice lightbee.......



Reply Reply Report
      alishas-mummy
April 17th | alishas-mummy
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

i definitely agree with your last sentence...
you'd think that mothers would know what to say to other mothers :)

but good on ya for shaking your head !!! :)

xox



Reply Reply Report
Guerin
5.00 (Excellent) | April 11th | Guerin
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

I agree, especially soon after you have given birth and still look 5 months pregnant because it all hasn't gone done.  I wonder if mine ever will.

 



Reply Reply Report
bels25
5.00 (Excellent) | March 20th | bels25
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

i agree, i have been asked numerous times by strangers if i am-this has occured before and after i was pregnant,as i've alway has a bit of a belly. in the end i stopped getting embarrased and hoped more i embarrased the person asking me!!



Reply Reply Report
avanliamsmum
5.00 (Excellent) | March 14th | avanliamsmum
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

I can't believe the amount of people who are confident in asking a woman if she's pregnant. With my 1st, I was still working and some customers would actually ask me if I was and how far along I was! What if I wasn't pregnant? How would they fix that up?!



Reply Reply Report
Jessgore
5.00 (Excellent) | March 8th | Jessgore
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

You forgot also..

"NEVER PAT A PREGNANT WOMAN ON THE BELLY WITH OUT ASKING FIRST"  realated or not... :)



Reply Reply Report
      lightbee
March 20th | lightbee
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

Thanks Jess!  I totally agree.  It is such an invasion of privacy.  I had a few people do that to me - including one total stranger - when I was pregnant with my first and I just felt totally violated.  It feels like such an intimate part of your body, and you want to be able to decide whether or not someone can be part of that.



Reply Reply Report
weejohnny1972
5.00 (Excellent) | March 8th | weejohnny1972
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

If you have ever seen a certain episode of "Frasier" then you definately should never broach this subject (or offer your seat on the bus) ... as it could actually turn out to be a bloke!!



Reply Reply Report
mummy2girls
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2nd | mummy2girls
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

Absolutely!!

lol xxxx.



Reply Reply Report
alishas-mummy
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2nd | alishas-mummy
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

haha great advice..
and with a piece of comedy too ! hehe

xox



Reply Reply Report
exquisite-flower
5.00 (Excellent) | January 12th | exquisite-flower
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

Great advice.  Sadly it is awareness of being pregnant that makes us tactful to others who are going through what we have (recently) been through.  As time goes on, somehow many women forget how annoying those questions were - or figure that since they have been there then they have rights above anyone else to ask.  Just wait though, I know this right now, but I bet there will come a time when I too put my foot in it - just hope it is not with anyone who reads what I have written here!!!
Peace
EF.x 



Reply Reply Report
angieh
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | angieh
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant
I have to agree about that one.

It reminds me of Hugh Grant in the movie 2 Weeks Notice when he asks the African American woman that he's interviewing whether she's pregnant or not, then blames it on Sandra Bullock as a scapegoat.


Reply Reply Report
natelz1
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | natelz1
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant
lol, yup, good one leith xox


Reply Reply Report
      natelz1
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | natelz1
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant
whoops i mean great article, so true, needs to be asked hehe, 5 stars


Reply Reply Report
FremantleDocker
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | FremantleDocker
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant
Excellent advice and all so true. Well done on the article, and it's a great reminder also. Thankyou.


Reply Reply Report
Ngairi
5.00 (Excellent) | October 2007 | Ngairi
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant
And also it could be very embarrassing for the person asking if you are not pregnant. I never lost the weight after the first 2 kids, and was putting on more on my belly with a few other issues I was having. The janitor at the primary school asked me if I was pregnant and got really embarrassed when I said I wasn't, that I was just fat. He was close to retiring age too so I think that made it worse for him. Then when I did fall pregnant with the last one I went and told him specifically that I was pregnant. He really appreciated it.
Leisa


Reply Reply Report
LibbyS
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | LibbyS
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant

This season and last season those flow-y dresses which hang from the bust are in fashion - it looks like everyone is wearing maternity dresses! My man almost asked a friend of mine about her (non existant) 'pregnancy', then remember the golden rule and didn't ask - thank goodness. She was wearing one of these dresses; it was just the way it fell.

Must make it easier to find nice clothes if are actually pregnant at the moment I guess!



Reply Reply Report
      lindterbean
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | lindterbean
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant
SO true!


Reply Reply Report
mcm
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | mcm
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant
Very good point.

I do want to be asked if I am BUT if I am not its the worse question.

I was once asked when I was due. I answered, "For a holiday? About now"


Reply Reply Report
      mcm
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | mcm
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant
Just to add when I was pregnant with the last baby, it wasn't until I was 8 - 9 months that I was asked if I was pregnant. It made me feel like I must have just looked fat before then.


Reply Reply Report
           lindterbean
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | lindterbean
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant
too funny!
I agree with this article entirely, but I was pretty excited the first time I was asked when I really was pregnant, it made it feel more 'real'. I guess the best thing to do is ask the woman's best friend first! -ha!


Reply Reply Report
angelicarose
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | angelicarose
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant
love it!!!  SO SO SO SO TRUE


Reply Reply Report
lucysmum
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | lucysmum
Re: Never ask a woman if she's pregnant
I agree. It's just a matter of privacy and respect, isn't it?!


Reply Reply Report