minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
j0382674.jpg
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.94 (Highly recommend) from 71 votes (2295 Visits)

Ask Your Child This Question

AMAMom by AMAMom Talking(January 2007) (rank 135th)

As parents, we ask our children lots of questions. I'm sure it's part of the official parental job description, which is hidden somewhere in one of the many piles of paper throughout my house. We ask things like:

Why did you put your teddy bear in the toilet?

You want peanut butter and what for breakfast?

How was school?

Why does your teacher want to talk to me?

How old is this boy and why is he calling you?

You want to major in what  in college?

(The questions change as our kids grow up!)

During my first go-round the parenting block, I heard a speaker suggest parents ask their children one specific question. (I can't remember the speaker's name, but I promise to look for that while I'm looking for the official parental job description document and post it later.) Here's the question:

What do you have to do to make me love you?

Go ahead. Ask your child the question. I dare you.

And be prepared to be surprised.

I talk lots about wanting to love my children unconditionally--but asking that question revealed to me that they heard all the unspoken conditions I had for them.

I don't remember how all three of my children answered, but I do remember that they each had a very clear idea that they had to do certain things to make sure I loved them. I do know my one daughter said, "I have to be good."

Wrong answer.

The good thing about being brave enough to ask the question was that my husband and I got to correct their misconceptions. We changed the question just a little bit to: Do you want to know what you have to do to make me love you?

They sure did!

And then we told them.

Nothing.

You don't have to do a thing to make me love you. I just love you because you are my child. You're mine and I love you.

You should have seen their smiles!

Go ahead, ask the question. Make sure your children know the right answer.

 

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.94 (Highly recommend) from 71 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

kjayaraj
August 9th | kjayaraj
Re: Ask Your Child This Question

it just worked superbly. my daughter said many things to be loved. When i said nothing. it was a moment of silence & happiness for all my family members. Thank you for the advice. keep posting.



Reply Reply Report
nabutters
July 31st | nabutters
Re: Ask Your Child This Question

love this article......

naomi x



Reply Reply Report
emmie
June 10th | emmie
Re: Ask Your Child This Question

Fantastic article

Love this

Cheers

Emz



Reply Reply Report
nfrethem
June 10th | nfrethem
Re: Ask Your Child This Question

This is wonderful and an important check for parents to teach them about the messages they may be unintentionally sending their children.



Reply Reply Report
The-Single-Parent-Bible
May 26th | The-Single-Parent-Bible
Re: Ask Your Child This Question

Absolutely gorgeous.  I love this, thank you!



Reply Reply Report
sars
April 22nd | sars
Re: Ask Your Child This Question

My 4yr old said he had to give me kisses aswell, I told him that was very welcome because we all love kisses but right now he is still hungary so we need to get more food!



Reply Reply Report
DCMerkle
April 19th | DCMerkle
Re: Ask Your Child This Question

Something so simple, but often forgotten.

DCMerkle



Reply Reply Report
Juzzy
April 18th | Juzzy
Re: Ask Your Child This Question

What a beautiful artical. Very well put!!!!



Reply Reply Report
2BeautifulGirls
March 28th | 2BeautifulGirls
Re: Ask Your Child This Question

I just thought I'd let you know that I asked my 5 yo this question and she said "I have to give you kisses" I then went on to explain that I love her no matter what and just because she's my child and she said okay.

Michelle



Reply Reply Report
2BeautifulGirls
March 26th | 2BeautifulGirls
Re: Ask Your Child This Question

What a great article!  I'm going to ask my daughter when she gets home from school because I want her to know that I love her because she's my daughter and not because of the way she behaves.

Thanks

Michelle



Reply Reply Report
alishas-mummy
March 5th | alishas-mummy
Re: Ask Your Child This Question

awwwwwww what a sweet article ! :)



Reply Reply Report
SuziQu
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | SuziQu
How true
I'm sure I would get a similar response if I asked my child that same question. I reminder to me that I should let her know more often that she does not have to earn my love. She already has it.


Reply Reply Report
lucky321
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | lucky321
done it
I done that  and your right   but i also said to my kids no matter what wrong you  do i always love them and no matter what they end up doing work wise  i be proud of them


Reply Reply Report
hippiechick
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | hippiechick
what you have to do
I asked my 4 year old and at first she looked at me all funny i repeated the question and she said " I have to give you lots of kisses" lol so i told her of course that i love her always and she said "even when i'm bad" and i say yep so its cute i'll have to try it on my 10 yr old later


Reply Reply Report
mcm
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | mcm
What to you have to do?

I asked my boy (3 3/4)first - "Hugs and cuddles!" (he thinks he knows all the answers) It was so sweet - I said that is nice but you don't have to do anything Buddy, I love you anyway.
Then I asked my girl (almost 7) - "Love?" She was more cautious with her answer. I said "I will love you no matter what Sweetie."
I asked my bub (14months) - he just whinged. I said yep, even though you are cranky, I still love you.


Reply Reply Report
Kuristima
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | Kuristima
How do I love thee?

Ok- So I asked my 11 yar old daughter this question and she laughed at me... She said, "I don't have to do anything! You already love me." Great answer right? Well, years ago the answer would have been different. I think if you were to ask my husbands two children from his first marriage the answer would be just as you said... "be good". I believe that some children have the misconception that they have to "earn" our love. That is wrong is so many ways so I agree that parents should ask their children this question, and ask it often.

Thanks for the great article. It is great advice for parents.

Oh, I did ask my 11 month old too but he just walked away! :) Ha, ha!

Kuri~



Reply Reply Report
domesticgodess
January 2007 | domesticgodess
great question
i plan on asking all my kids this question....... congrates on posting this


Reply Reply Report
Goddessie7
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | Goddessie7
funny!

I just asked my 7 year old daughter and she said 'make a card?' When i said no and proceded to tell her the real answer, she asks me why my face is red and it looked like i was going to cry?! LOL!

I simply told her it was because i love her SO much!



Reply Reply Report
mcm
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | mcm
THE Question
As Mrs Brown I want to wake my kids too. What a wonderful thought. Thankyou so much. I am going to ask tomorrow even of my bub.


Reply Reply Report
mrsbrown4701
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | mrsbrown4701
Can I wake them?
I just read this at almost midnight! I want to go wake my kids NOW and ask them NOW!

I am looking forward to our breakfast conversation tomorrow.

Thanks for a great post!

I think I love YOU too, now!


Reply Reply Report
cookclan
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | cookclan
3 out of 5 hehehe
Well I asked mine this and my 16 year old and my 12 year old said with a funny look on their faces as if to say WHAT????? the then turned to me and said nothing my 2  13 year olds thought they had to be good ........Shy my 7 year old said I don know and shrugged her shoulders then said prolly nothin hehehe so three out of five aint bad......... maybe  but it was a great conversation starter any way...... thank you for writing it
Cheers
Angie


Reply Reply Report
Omegastar
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | Omegastar
Love
I just asked my nine year old and she looked at me like I was crazy and asking the stupidest question ever, she said nothing mom, I then proceeded to hug her like crazy.


Reply Reply Report
nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | nell18-3
Love
Just tried this on mine my 9 year old said Nothing
My 13 year old said Nothing
Now then
My 19 year old daughter said........
I don't get the question.
Honestly she is the limit sometimes


Reply Reply Report
lillkatheryn
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | lillkatheryn
Wow!

That is so true!  It really  makes you think about how our children preceive love.  And it's a very imortant lesson to learn on how show true love.  Katheryn says: 2 thumbs up!



Reply Reply Report
blackwidowkate
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | blackwidowkate
loving you
Hi
I just asked my teenagers this and my daughter answered first saying I don't know then my son said be good and I said nope think about it and my daughter said "nothing we don't have to do anything...
I said yep thats right....
They both said Love you mummy
After all the turmoil of the last few weeks this was good to read
Thank you
Luv Deb


Reply Reply Report
MelodyS
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | MelodyS
I asked
Yesterday as the boys sat around the table eating lunch, I asked "boys, what do you have to do for me to love you?"  They look at me as thoughI had asked the dumbest question they had ever heard, then they replied in a "duh" tone...."Nothing".   I'm a happy mom.


Reply Reply Report
OzBinky
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | OzBinky
I asked...

I asked my 18 year old this last night and he answered with...."I didn't know you had to, I just thought you did"

I just LOVE my kidling....



Reply Reply Report
angelmum
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | angelmum
Thats nice
I love that, I went and asked my 4 yr old and he said um draw you a beautiful picture lol, I said no mate you don't have to do anything for me to love you I love you anyway with that he smiled and said oh I love you to mummy.  Cant wait to ask my daughter now


Reply Reply Report
MelodyS
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | MelodyS
This Question

WOW, I would never have thought of asking this question point blank.  I do know that I have told them many times "I love you always" and explain that there is nothing they could every do or not do that would cause my love for them to stop.  But I wonder what their answer will be when asked?  Thanks for giving me a new vantage point.



Reply Reply Report
moondust
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | moondust
Excellent advice
I'll be asking DD - 8 , this question tomorrow! DS will get it also, but he's 2 so might not know how to answer!! LOL


Reply Reply Report
kelfa
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | kelfa
WoW

wow, As I started to read this, I got to the bit  that says ask your child what you have to do to make mummy love you , I thought oh my god how could I ask somthing like that to my child , but then I read on it made me smile. I think thats a fantastic question for your children.



Reply Reply Report
Jessgore
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | Jessgore
Great Question...
When my son is old enough to answer I think I will ask that question... I would like to think he knows this answer...

As for my step daughter well I will wait until after we have decided how we are going to go about custody.. I don't want her to think I am fishing or trying to manipulate her in anyway, most of all if she goes back to mummy with the question I have asked if you know what I mean....


Reply Reply Report