minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Av in sunburst BBB.jpg
My bub in a bamboo fitted
Av in shorties netherwood.jpg
My bub in knitted shorties - wool is amazing and makes a fantastic nappy cover
Av in Thomas.jpg
My bub in a pocket nappy - does up with velcro
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.66 (Highly recommend) from 40 votes (943 Visits)

Why use disposables?

mcm by mcm Young Parent(February 2007) (rank 3rd)

Why use disposables (nappies or diapers)? Since discovering modern cloth I can think of only one reason. For convenience.  All you do is place under baby, wrap tabs around then chuck in bin after it is dirty or wet, after putting solids in toilet where they belong. It is
like using plastic plates and cutlery instead of the real thing. I haven't used disposables in a while now - probably 6 months. It is just so much easier for us to use cloth.

I have heard people have some reasons for not using cloth. This article is not about making people feel guilty for choosing not to use cloth. It is a choice and we are lucky that we do have such choices. But must say I have many choices each day with our cute and funky naps! Our bub loves to choose his nappy and then literally jumps into his soft nappies and woollies (covers).

This article is for those who have reasons for not using cloth. I would like to dispel some myths about using cloth while I am here.
  • Napisan is expensive
It sure is! And I found it doesn't work that well either. The sun does such a better job, its natural and best of all its free. I avoid chemicals as much as possible especially when it comes to putting it on my bub's skin.
  • Soaking in buckets is dangerous
It sure is! When my girl was in cloth as a newborn I thought soaking in buckets wouldn't be a great idea when she would be toddling. Babies can drown in only centrimetres of water. So its great to hear about dry pailing. I just throw the nappies in the bucket after emptying solids in the toilet where they belong.

  • We are in a drought in Australia and I don't want to waste water
That is a great reason not to use disposables. Most disposables are made right here in Australia using 10 times the amount of water for one disposable than it takes to wash one cloth nappy.  The materails used to make cloth are from countires which have abundance of water to grow crops (organic cotton, bamboo and hemp) We dry pail so we are only using a load of water to wash several nappies every two days.
  • Disposables keep babies skin dry
It has something to do with all those chemicals that soak it up which probably dries out bub's skin too. I use natural  materials against bub's skin as that is our preference. But there are other choices such as fleece liners which the moisture goes through away from baby's skin. Also microsuede and microfleece do a great job of this too.
  • Disposables don't have to be pinned on
I use fitteds which have snaps. So quite easy. You can also get cloth with velcro which is just as easy as  the tabs on disposables. When I use cloth without closures I use a snappi which is easy to put on and doesn't pri*k my fingers or baby's skin.
  • It takes too long to wash, dry and fold reusable nappies. I'd rather spend that time with my child(ren)
I spend about 10-15 minutes a week washing nappies and hanging them on the line (though you could chuck them in a dryer). I have other washing too as we don't wear disposable clothing. Not much folding here as we only use flats occassionally and fitteds most of the time.
  • I tried cloth, but my baby has sensitive skin and/or eczema and developed a terrible nappy rash
This may be because of the detergent you are using. I only use a small amount of washing detergent on the nappies - about 1/3 or 1/2 normal detergent will wash them sufficiently, leave less build up and this is less irritating for baby. My eldest son has sufferd from severe eczema so this is an issue. We use sensitive detergent and only a small amount on all clothes and it does make a difference.

  • I don't want to use plastic pants that don't breathe
I wouldn't want to wear plastic either. We use wool as it works so well and it breathes. Wool is amazing. Other choices include fleece, and PUL (laminated fabric) These breathe and offer waterproofness.
  • You can get leaks in cloth nappies
You can get leaks in disposables too.  We haven't had much problem with cloth. I think its a matter of putting the cloth on properly and having a well fitted cover. When using fitteds and covers you also have a second defence.
  • I don't want to have to deal with poo on my nappies
Unfortunately the reality with having children is that they make mess and whether you use disposables, cloth or none at all you are going to have mess at times. We use flushable liners so makes it easy to put the poo where it belongs.
  • Whenever I try cloth nappies my baby gets red marks on their legs
The nappy may be on too tight. With fitteds which have elastic in the legs they don't need to be put on tightly. Check the sizing - they may be too small.

  • Modern cloth is so expensive
They do seem expensive initially. At about $20(Aus) each you could get half a box of disposables. But in the long run, you are saving thousands  of dollars over the time your baby is in nappies. When you buy disposables you are throwing that money in the bin after every use. Cloth can be washed over and over and I have heard of cloth lasting several children and generations! Hemp especially is very long lasting.
  • I am too lazy
Yeah me too! That is why I love cloth so much. It is that easy to use cloth. I wont be going back to a smelly bin - that is the worst part to me about using disposables though there are many other reasons. Please read my other articles on using cloth if you are interested.

(I might add to this!)
Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.66 (Highly recommend) from 40 votes
Report
ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

Katherine-oshannessy
June 1st | Katherine-oshannessy
Re: Why use disposables?

I am so sick of hearing all the people taking every oportunity to use forums to compare nappies to pitch their belief system of cloth nappies! As a parent I am getting more and more frustrated with the biast iformation showing up everywhere concearning the use of cloth nappies, independent research has shown that cloth and nappies can be equally as bad for the environment and in some cases worse for the environment depending on the way you use them. find out for yourself here http://www.kca.com.au/environment/disposableorcloth.htm. Furthermore I am tired of how much better for your baby they are, my daughter is in disposables, I use quility disposable nappies and my daughter is yet to get nappie rash, her nappies do not leak and believe me they are impressive, she is breastfed so she has the impressive runny type poo and there is lots of it particularly in the mornings and her nappies hold up. I know that with her disposable nappy she can fill it to compacity over night and when she gets up in the morning her skin is still dry as is the nappy regardless of how filled it is. It does not dry out her skin infact she has beautifully soft skin she is 7 months and is yet to have dry irritated skin anywhere near her nappy sight and has not had any nappy rash what so ever, she has cut teeth and done other things thought to cause it and she is yet to suffer.

It may sound as though I am pitching disposables, but seriously read the above question "why use disposables?" I am simply answering and evening up the playing field. There has to be a pretty good reason why more peole favour disposables, if cloth were as good as every one is saying then more people would be using them, particularly considering now you can get flushable liners and nappy wash services they are almost as convenient but people are sticking to disposables. Alternitivly if you dont mind washing nappies for yourself, you need to by all the detergents and hot wash, as much as people say you dont, it is important to kill any remaining bacterior and how exactly do you propose to do that with little or no detergent and cold water? doesnt sound very higenic to me, I certaintly wouldnt be comfortable putting my baby back into nappies that I didnt feel were properly sanitised.

Although I have not used personally used cloth nappies I know a few people who have and each one of them has ended up swapping over to disposables after a short time for various reasons including nappy rash and leakage.So in conclusion I intend to leave my daughter in disposables.



Reply Reply Report
      mcm
June 1st | mcm
Re: Why use disposables?

Very interesting rant. I think its fine you use disposables, that is your choice. But just to respond to a few of your points as I like to share information.

  • Cloth is better for the environment depending on how use them - there are variables. New study.
  • Sun is a great sanitiser - I have an article on this.

 

 Use disposables if you wish. Otherwise check out cloth. Its worth a try. I wasn't sure at first but we are still using cloth and my youngest who is 8mths has never used a disposable. I personally prefer no nappies but its not always practical.



Reply Reply Report
KathrynR1402
March 2009 | KathrynR1402
Re: Why use disposables?

Brilliant article! I agree with everything you have written 100% (including being too lazy NOT to use washables).



Reply Reply Report
missnickley
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | missnickley
Re: Why use disposables?

This is a very well written article! I am going to also email it to some friends who just tell me cloth are a waste of time!
Incredibly well written and diplomatic! Lots of facts and ideas for people already using cloth as well!



Reply Reply Report
nettieH
5.00 (Excellent) | August 2007 | nettieH
Re: Why use disposables?
This is one of the best articles I have read on why its easy to use MCN's.  YAH!, I have sent this page link to several friends because I think they need to see from somebody else not just me, how & why its so easy to use cloth, and its not as bad as they think.


Reply Reply Report
hoprah
4.20 (Good) | July 2007 | hoprah
Re: Why use disposables?
WOW!  You are a better woman than me!  I could never try doing washable nappies.  I don't have time to get everything else done as well as washing nappies!  Bravo to you!


Reply Reply Report
mandymum3
4.50 (Excellent) | March 2007 | mandymum3
found
this sew your own pocket nappies for all you creative mums


Reply Reply Report
mandymum3
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | mandymum3
Im
going Googleing these bamboo nappies! What other brands are good?


Reply Reply Report
      mcm
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | mcm
Bamboo
I like bamboo fitteds like Very Baby,and Bits For Bots in Australia though they are hard to get as they are made by WAHMs.
Baby Beehinds are easier to get. And are very popular (good if they don't work for you they have great resale value) They don't suit my bub so well as he is so skinny.


Reply Reply Report
           mcm
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | mcm
My fave fitted cloth
I would have to say my favourite cloth fitted is Pookey Pockets quick dry fitteds. They are fantastic - they dry quick, they are absorbent and the sewing is amazing plus the materials Bek uses is lovely and not cutesy.


Reply Reply Report
MummaBear
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | MummaBear
cloth cloth cloth, all the way to the end with mine (except that one week)
I only ever used the cloth nappies on my bub, except that week or so when we were living out of my car, but that's a different story.  Is that a Thomas the Tank Engine fitted nappy your bub is wearing in the photo? I wish I knew about these when my daughter was in nappies, all I had was the towelling squares.  I bought some pastel coloured ones, but they faded quickly. I also had some bright coloured bought for me which I started putting on her when she was around 6 months old that looked cute. And my mum dyed some of them orange and purple to make her look like a hippy baby.  I thought the bright and colourful nappies were awesome, but I would have definately bought some fitted ones had they been available.  Have you ever noticed how some baby clothes simply won't go over a cloth nappy? There were so many nice clothes my daughter couldn't wear just because I would have had to use a disposable to have it fit.  Where can I buy these fitted ones from? My cousin is due to have a baby in august and although she has already been up to get all the cloth squares that are still usable I think it would be a nice idea to buy her even just a few of the fitted ones when bub comes along.


Reply Reply Report
      mcm
February 2007 | mcm
cloth cloth cloth, all the way
That Thomas print is made by Green Kids (Sasha is a minti member actually) These are very popular in Australia. These are called pockets - you put an insert in them and they do up with aplix (like velcro)
We have some funky bright flats too. I like them - they do look cool. we also have a hand painted flat - amazing! They do look cool.
Where abouts are you? In Australia the best place to get most nappies is online. (not ebay!) I will try to get a list together of my recommendations. For now you can try googling Baby Beehinds, Tot Bots, Very Baby (the wee wuns) nurturenappies (they sell many diff brands) Pookey Pockets, Bits for Bots. There are many! I will list the website addresses tomorrow if I can.

My bub is quite skinny so we haven't had problems getting clothes to fit him over cloth (they probably fit better!). Also fitteds are trimmer than flats imo. I remember I had trouble with my girl in flats - she was chubby. She looked funny in her big butt!


Reply Reply Report
lilysmom
4.88 (Excellent) | February 2007 | lilysmom
wonderful article
What a great article! I was using cloth with lily until i moved into an apartment, and i loved them, once i figured out how to get the yeast infection she got from sleeping them under control. Right now I'm using disposables, as it's just easier until i get myself set up properly in the apartment, but i definately plan on going back to cloth soon.


Reply Reply Report
MumKim
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | MumKim
works for me
You converted me with some of your earlier articles. Natalya is now six and a half weeks old and we use cloth (mostly cotton flats and about half a dozen fitted nappies. We have a woollen cover but mostly use the motherease air flow cover (I highly recommend it).
When we go out for a whole day or away for a few days we use disposables, but at home we use cloth.


Reply Reply Report
Gypsie
3.46 (Average) | February 2007 | Gypsie
Disposable Nappies

I also remembered after I left my comment yesterday....that recycled disposable nappies are turned into useful items such us.......High heel  ( stilletto ) shoes for us ladies amongst several other items I can't remember...lol

But  after  watching a documentary within the last two years......I even forget where......I  was surprised to see the disposable

nappy recycling factory was here in Australia.......Melbourne to be precise but I have forgotten the suburb.

Maybe another minti member  may have more information......or " Google " it.....hehehehe



Reply Reply Report
nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | nell18-3
Nappies
My oldest was in cloth nappies and that went fine but the other three were all in disposables due to they were allergic to the plastic pants!
there was no alternative when mine were young that i knew of to the rubber pants
Great piece though
xxx


Reply Reply Report
breannababy
4.00 (Good) | February 2007 | breannababy
tried twice
with both my bubs first one was fine in cloth.....second I used cloth and she got rashes(lived out in bush and used rain water)only natural product with wash........I gave them a fair go just did not work for us.Great article though


Reply Reply Report
Gypsie
4.27 (Good) | February 2007 | Gypsie
Disposables V's Cloth

I read your article which was interesting reading

However..... I tried  cloth nappies with both my babies...and both seemed discomforted as soon as they had done one pee in it   ( my kids are 12 yrs apart mind you... ) bummer because I was trying to save money and the enviroment...sadly..... I also converted to disposables because both my kids also got a terrible rash and reaction to cloth nappies and I know it wasn't the washing powder because I also washed their clothes in the same solution. That and they also seemed to have a much more calmer sleep with disposables on. I'm not a lazy person and I did give cloth a go...twice....with a considerable time inbetween and I vote and reccommend disposables, or nothing at all....

In fact I also still have my nappy pail/bucket after 15yrs  and use it for my recycled water from the shower, after all it does hold  afair amount.



Reply Reply Report
      mcm
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | mcm
Disposables V's Cloth
I agree - about nothing at all is best! I have tried but I am hopeless! Maybe next baby.
We use bamboo a lot - it is so soft and I wish I had bamboo undies (though I would be happy with bamboo cloth pads)
Nappy free time is wonderful - I recommend it as much as possible.


Reply Reply Report
zacsmum
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | zacsmum
cloth nappies
Well I have been using disposables for all the points made above even though we did buy cloth nappies. I use them instead of bibs as I couldnt find any functional bibs. I figured it would cost around the same as napisan without the 12hr soak ect. I might try switching though bubby may think mum's gone la la putting his dribble wipers on his bum!


Reply Reply Report
cookclan
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | cookclan
Ya know......
I wish someone like you was around when I needed this advice......Alas Corrie is only in night nappies now.....I had never heard of dry pailing till i read your advice......very clever....great advice
Cheers
Angie


Reply Reply Report
angelmum
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | angelmum
Totally guilty
Brilliant article once again, I know if I have another I won't be using disposables, I wish I had of had your knowledge on them when my first son was born, I was told over and over, use disposables, cloth nappies are to much work!!!


Reply Reply Report
kseers
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | kseers
Guilty as charged
I'm putting my hand up!  I use disposables and my reason has always been that we live in rural australia on tank water and just cannot afford the extra water - I do a load of washing a day as it is.  I do use recycled disposable nappies though and biodegradable bags (though I believe that cloth nappies when bleached are as bad for the environment  as disposables). However you have me thinking!!   I will read the rest of your articles - I am not guaranteeing I will change but thanks for opening my mind!


Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend