minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
emotional-abuse.gif
images-3.jpg
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.71 (Highly recommend) from 55 votes (1519 Visits)

Who Wants to be Shouted At?

nell18-3 by nell18-3 Young Parent(March 2007) (rank 2nd)
Okay I confess there have been times when the deep breath hasn't worked and I have shouted at my children

I guess we have all been there

What does it get us

Apologetic, Sincere, Regretful and Obedient Children ............

Not in my Home!!!!!

I get from my children:

Angry, Moody, Sulky or even worse......

Demoralised Children

I have been shouted at enough to know that no good comes from it.
The feelings that rise up are usually:

ANGER

Adult  reaction - Who do you think you are shouting at me
Child reaction - I'm not listening to you

MOODY


Adult  reaction - Slamming doors, Throwing things...
Child reaction - Throwing toys, slamming doors, Loud Music from bedrooms.......

SULKY

Adult reaction - Ignoring people, not communicating, build up of resentment......
Child reaction - Pouting, Turning their back to you, putting on their headphones, muttering under their breath......

FEAR

Adult reaction - Loss of respect, being afraid, losing confidence....
Child reaction - Terror, Nervousness around you, no self confidence.......

DEMORALISATION


Adult reaction - We lose our identity and try to become the person we think the other wants us to become, we make ourselves ill, we believe ourselves to be mentally ill, we lose our ability to think for ourselves, we no longer know our own minds, we allow others to make our decisions,  we become dependant on the other adult who has demoralised us, a feeling of worthlessness,  we become confused, we lose our morale and develop a weak spirit and eventually we snap...... we can go one of two ways
1) Into a severe breakdown or depression
2) We break free of our 'captor'

Shouting at an adult to the point of bringing them down to this level is emotional abuse.


Child reaction - The child will never grow to their full potential, they will become introverted children and find it difficult to make friends, they are likely to become either bullied or the child who becomes the bully themselves, they will be unsure of themselves, they will feel themselves to be both unloved and not worthy of receiving love, they will look and search for happiness in other things as they get older, they will push you away as they feel its better to push you away then be hurt and rejected again.

Shouting at your children to the point of bringing them to this level is emotional abuse.


Emotional abuse is ONE of the worst kinds of abuse to ever recover from
It leaves no visible marks or bruises
The injuries are all internal to the Heart, Soul and Spirit

Next time you think you are going to lose it with your child and yell and shout, take a time out, take a deep breath, calm down
THEN AND ONLY THEN WHEN YOU ARE BACK UNDER CONTROL
discuss the problem with your child, in a firm, authoritive BUT LOVING manner
Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.71 (Highly recommend) from 55 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

exquisite-flower
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2007 | exquisite-flower
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?
Earlier this afternoon I was reading your series of articles about relaxation techniques.  I think that when we indulge ourselves and look after number one in this way we are more patient and forebearing with situations we encounter - especially those including our children and their perceptions of the world as they know it.
Peace
EF.x 


Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
December 2007 | nell18-3
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?
Great point made EF
Thankyou
xxx


Reply Reply Report
Arna
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | Arna
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?
well, I must confess, I've just snapped at my oldest as the softly approach didn't work.  4 times I tried getting her attention and she just kept ignoring me!  LOL.  I'm not the most patient person, especially when it comes to noise, but I have found over the last year or so that my tolerance of my girls has gotten to be more and I am able to enjoy being with them more.  It is the occasional bark these days, just to get the attention I've been trying to get for 5 minutes!

On a very personal note, what you describe is how I was through my child hood.  I'm adopted but the 2 years I was in the foster care system had already done the damage.  I was both a bully and the bullied, just depednded on how i was feeling at the time.  Thankfully, I have better balance in my life now and my mum won the battle she desperately wanted to win.  It took over 20 years, but I am grateful she did!


Reply Reply Report
      Arna
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | Arna
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?
by the way, you wrote this really well!


Reply Reply Report
mumof3-1982
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | mumof3-1982
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?
My 2 year old is at the stage now where he wants to help me tidy up everything, so we make it a game, I only have to say pick up time and he waddles around picking everything up, its very cute. My 5 yo is not so co-operative most of the time. I don't smack my kids unless i absolutely have to, which is barely ever, but yelling, I do, do. But I never degrade my kids, yeling for me is more of a pay attention to me thing.


Reply Reply Report
boredmum
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | boredmum
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?

Thanks for writing such great advice. I'm a yeller, I try not to be ,buts it's very hard when you have asked for something to be done 100 times & still get ignored!  I loved everyones  trick for getting the bedroom tidy, I am going to try that tonight!

Great article, well done.



Reply Reply Report
Anonymous Member
 
This Comment has been deleted
      mumof3-1982
1.00 (Very Poor) | November 2007 | mumof3-1982
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?
Here here!


Reply Reply Report
HarrisonsMommy
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | HarrisonsMommy
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?

Well Said.

Angela



Reply Reply Report
sebcanatalay
5.00 (Excellent) | October 2007 | sebcanatalay
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?

This is great I always try to remember but as you say some times it doesn't work and I feel so guelty. It is good refreshing. Thanks

Love Seb



Reply Reply Report
sluxton
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | sluxton
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?

This is beautifully written and I so need a lesson in it.  I come from a long line of yellers to the point that I am now a yeller. 

But I always make sure we have "good time" together each day as well.  I only yell when I have asked calmly lots of times before (e.g. for teeth to be cleaned or for them to get dressed or pick up toys.  Yes they are young but they can do all these things and have done all these things so many times themselves before, so I am not being unreasonable to ask them).

I remember as a child I got sick of being yelled at and always tried to the right thing.  What I hated was that I wasn't given many chances and was misunderstood many a time.  We weren't hugged a lot, we weren't played with a lot (meaning our parents didn't get down on the floor and play games with us).  All this is important.  But I also think that at some stage in life, someone will yell at them and it will upset them more if they haven't experienced it at some stage at home.  I still dont condone the practice but it is a normal reaction (however much we must learn to control our anger) and if pushed people yell.  It is unnatural to never yell.



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | nell18-3
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?
Thankyou for your comment
I think we are capable of a good yell now and then LOL
Especially under extreme provocation
xxx


Reply Reply Report
emmie
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | emmie
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?

i totally agree great advice

luv emz xx



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | nell18-3
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?
Thankyou Emz
You been busy reading again LOL!!!!
xxx


Reply Reply Report
Mystique
4.81 (Excellent) | July 2007 | Mystique
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?
Well written and very very true! Think before you act, thats what alot of parents need to learn.

One of my so-called friends in particular sits on her PC from the moment she wakes to moment she sleeps. Her 2 year old can't speak properly cos she doesn't give him any attention.

When she does give them attention its in the form of screaming at them to shut up cos she can't think while shes "chatting". She has even thrown a bottle at her 5 year old and cut his mouth open, then told him to go wash out his mouth cos he was bleeding everywhere and ruining the furniture. That he discusted her.

I hate it. DOCS had been called on her but they never did anything about it. When I'm there, I spend all the time I can with them cos she doesn't realise what she's doing to them!!


Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | July 2007 | nell18-3
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?
That is so sad, what a shame for those poor children
Sounds like you are doing what you can to support themxx


Reply Reply Report
      Anonymous Member
 
This Comment has been deleted
      Anonymous Member
 
This Comment has been deleted
      Arna
November 2007 | Arna
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?
That is sad Mystique.  I am on my computer most of the day too (oops, at!) but I am watching my girls all the time still and interacting with them.  I do have set times when I'm not here and mostly I'm having tv time with them.  Or trying to get the baby to sleep.  If I didn't have Minti, I would go nuts!

There are parents out there who really don't seem to get what parenting is about and they don't deserve to have these sweet, adorable little people in theirs lives.


Reply Reply Report
llmunchkin
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | llmunchkin
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?
What lovely advice, and so true - I can't believe that I hadn't read it sooner, and I certainly do my best to adhere to this too.  Being yelled at is nasty for everyone of all ages - especially children.


Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | July 2007 | nell18-3
Re: Who Wants to be Shouted At?
Thankyou
I believe words can be totally soul destroying
xx


Reply Reply Report
merlin0903
5.00 (Excellent) | May 2007 | merlin0903
shouting

i grow up with a father that only knew how to talk to his children by shouting and even tho we are both grown up now and have our own lives he still sometimes shouts at us

great advice sweetie i wish that i had that when i was growing up



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | May 2007 | nell18-3
shouting
That must have been really hard growing up like that
thankyou for your comment
xxx


Reply Reply Report
lunaeclips5
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | lunaeclips5
When We Dont Know What to Do!!!
Sometimes we shout because our emotions build up so much we cant hold them in any longer, i know i used to be the worst when i was a teen, frustrations of never being heard, my emotions would build up, i'd start crying then abuse the person my mum dad or brothers for being arrogant. Anger & Frustration are emotions normal emotions, people get upset wehen we get angry most of the time because they either dont care or are to worried about there own lives, they only take it to heart when you say something insensitive about them while yelling, then they rebel and Hate you. You cant control what comes natural & after years of not being heard sometime this is all some people can do, because they fear they will only recieve the same end result! My opinion of myself anyway!


Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | nell18-3
When We Dont Know What to Do!!!
I still flinch now if I hear shouting and I can't stand being near any kind of tension even if I am not involved.
I try real hard not to shout at the boys but sometimes its the only way they would hear me!!!!!
I just regret it after cos I know how demoralising it is
xxx


Reply Reply Report
jenbann
3.15 (Average) | March 2007 | jenbann
yelling

do you listen when your partner ylls, or did you listen when your parents yelled at you. I try were possbile to calm the boys down enough to get down to their level and talk to them like an adult even if the eldest is only 4. If he does something wrong he is sent to a corner of the lounge (not his bedroom as I don't want it to be seen as a bad place to be) he sits there until he calms down (which is now becoming faster as he is learning the routine) and when he has calmed down I ask him to come sit with me and talk. I ask why he did why he did and why he thinks I made him sit in time out. 9/10 he has worked it out and either appoligises or we discuss it more with explination as to why these things happened.

It would be nice if it worked this easy all the time but what we must remember is when someone is yelling the are overwhelmed with emotion it is like they are in their own bubble and nothing matters unless its what they want. Let them vent and get it out before trying to tackle the issue.

I have used the bin trick o few times but have never actually thrown the items away instead I put them away for a month or so then bring them out when the kids have been extra well behaved. It works a treat they are so excited to have their favourite toys back nothing else matters and they are rewarded for behaving at the same time and it hasn't cost me anything but time.



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | nell18-3
yelling
Exactly
Who listens when your being yelled at??????
Much better and more calmer and effective ways to get them to listen to you
Thanks for your comment
xxx


Reply Reply Report
      lunaeclips5
5.00 (Excellent) | May 2007 | lunaeclips5
From the eye's of an abused child

When you are a child and i mean right threw to teens and adults as in my case, and you make the tinyest mistake and your constantly being yelled at for it and the words that are being said are. Will you just stop it, your not any good at it, i hate it, i hate it when you. when you do that to a child they have no option other than to listen esspecially when you are yelling inches from there face. They are your parents who are supposed to love you and care about you Especially when they also hit you, wheather this be with a hand or strap so on. As a child the only words i ever heard where taken straight to my heart because it was if  they said them because they hated me. There words where telling me they hated me, all i ever tried to do was please my parents and in return i got no thanks no oh your good at that. Just quiet it stop it. No, No, No, No selfishness. Every word they said to me while yelling only told me one thing that they didn't like me. I cant cope when i get near people that i think may have the tinyest problem with me. I avoid the whole situation just incase they scream like my mum & dad did. I always think i'm no good at thing and i never put in any effort because i feel as though if i make a mistake i'm going to get hurt and if you make a mistake with a complete stranger you really get hurt. There not going to just scream at you they are going to really hurt you. I succlude myself from people just so i dont get yelled at and hurt, i dont trust anyone, unless i have known them for years & years and i feel like there personality is friendly and i can genuinly talk to them, its easier for me to talk in a chat room than in a room full of people, because i am a stranger you pass on by and forget what i have said because you don't need to know me. Anyway this subject is probably still falling on deaf ears thanks nell nobody ever believes whats right in front of there faces always blind only concerned with there own comings and goings..  Cant be told from the horses mouth it always only comes from the horses arse.



Reply Reply Report
           nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | May 2007 | nell18-3
From the eye's of an abused child
I'm so sorry you had to go through all that whilst growing up.
I wouldn't wish it on my greatest enemy to be brought up thinking all your life that what you do is never going to be good enough.
I know exactly what you mean about chat rooms, I am the same with Minti, I don't talk to anyone very often face to face but here I can be me, I too avoid confrontation on all levels, I'm even uneasy watching an argument brewing on a film or tv show, makes me very nervous.
Lets hope this won't always fall on deaf ears
Thankyou for saying what you think and being brave enough to talk about your past
xxx


Reply Reply Report