minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.70 (Highly recommend) from 30 votes (1600 Visits)

Learn 5 Logical Consequences You Can Use Right Now!

JeanTracy by JeanTracy Talking Back(June 2006) (rank 45th)

Have you ever given your child an illogical consequence? I have. I learned how my kids tricked me too. Don't make this mistake.


Jean Tracy, MSS, "Granny Jean"

 

Learn 5 Logical Consequences You Can Use Right Now!

Being a working mom, like many of you,

I was so busy. Although I loved gardening, I never had enough time to weed the rain ditch in front of our home. When my boys misbehaved I thought I had the perfect solution. "Go out to the ditch and pull a bucket of weeds," I'd order.

I never noticed how quickly they pulled the weeds. I did wonder why the ditches never looked weeded. Since I was usually working in the kitchen, the boys would open the front door and yell up the stairs, "Here are the weeds, Mom." I'd look down the stairs and nod, "OK." Then I'd go about fixing dinner and they'd go off to play.

Now they're adults. They recently told me their "dirty" little secret. They loaded their buckets with dirt from our compost pile. They also pulled out a few fresh weeds to top off their buckets. They knew I'd never come downstairs to check their buckets. They knew I'd never guess their "dirty" little secret.

What two things did I do wrong?:

  1. I didn't check their work closely.
  2. My consequence wasn't logical.
My consequence for their misbehavior suited me but it didn't suit their conduct. My consequence wasn't logical. What can you do to avoid my mistake?

 

Make sure your consequences are logical. How? Make sure they fit the misbehavior. Here are 5 examples:

 

  1. If your children fight over the TV controller - no TV.
  2. If your child punches a hole in the wall - make him/her fix it.
  3. If your child leaves toys around - take those toys away for a week.
  4. If your child calls another child mean names - require your child to apologize.
  5. If your child won't eat the dinner you fix - let your child go to bed hungry.

 

If you think before you speak, you'll be creating consequences that fit the misbehavior. You won't be making my mistake. You'll be helping your children grow. You'll be building character too.

Subscribe to my free Parenting Newsletter, Tips and Tools for Character Builders at www.KidsDiscuss.com  

 

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.70 (Highly recommend) from 30 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

dolphins30
October 2006 | dolphins30
sounds great
have taken your advice and taken alot of notes down etc. will come in very handy. thanks


Reply Reply Report
michellei
September 2006 | michellei
Learn 5 Logical Consequences You Can Use Right Now!
I don't need this advice just yet, but I'll be thinking about it though. Thanks .


Reply Reply Report
allyp
4.86 (Excellent) | June 2006 | allyp
Learn 5 Logical Consequences You Can Use Right Now!
I agree 100%, I remember when I was younger, my parents would do the exact same thing. So I know what to do when my baby gets older lol.


Reply Reply Report
      JeanTracy
4.71 (Excellent) | June 2006 | JeanTracy
Learn 5 Logical Consequences You Can Use Right Now!

Great! You're ahead of the game.

 



Reply Reply Report
lindterbean
4.80 (Excellent) | June 2006 | lindterbean
they ARE tricky!
When our girls used to fight over who got to sit in the front seat of the car.

Attempt 1 - Take turns
The older one managed to convince the younger one she had just gotten to sit in the front. . . every time.
The little one figured out something was up but wasn't sure what. Tears or sulking ensued.

Attempt 2 - Whoever sits in the back gets to choose the musc we listen to
The older one managed to convice the younger one she actually wanted to listen to the older one's music. . . every time.
The little one figured out something was up but wasn't sure what. Tears or sulking ensued.

Attempt 3 -
Both kids sit in the back, and I pick the music.
Pleading and attempts at negotiation followed by a series of 'no's and 'too bad's.
I printed lyrics to their favorite songs I had on CD and made only one book of them and they would sit in the back seat together and sing.

Added bonus - that also sunk in the idea that when I made a decision I was not open to bargaining.

I feel for ya!


Reply Reply Report
      JeanTracy
4.00 (Good) | June 2006 | JeanTracy
they ARE tricky!

Sounds like you solved the problem well. Your kids are fortunate. It must be fun to hear them sing.

Recently my granddaughters were acting up in the back of the car. My consequence for them was just to pull over and tell them that the car wouldn't move until they settled down. They did.

Granny Jean



Reply Reply Report
      JadieLady
4.00 (Good) | August 2006 | JadieLady
they ARE tricky!
The decision  always used on us as kids fihgting over the front seat was something like, whoever sits in the front has to close the gate (which weighed about 6 times our own weight!) or if you sit in the front you have to babysit/cook dinner etc. the chore associated with teh front seat of the car varied everymonth. it solved the problem qiucksmart! only problem was someone HAD to sit in the front- the car was jsut too small! but it got the chores done :) it was regualted so that the slower kids weren't in the front all the time. some of us were given a heads up that we were going out a few minutes before the other kids on occasion :)


Reply Reply Report
mrslunar
4.00 (Good) | June 2006 | mrslunar
thanks
I always need a little reminder to make my punishments meaningful for both me AND my kids. Great ideas!


Reply Reply Report
      JeanTracy
4.00 (Good) | June 2006 | JeanTracy
thanks
I'm glad you're thinking about matching the consequences to their behavioris. Let me know how you are doing. I'm always looking for what parents use for consequences and how they relate to misbehaviors.


Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend