minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) 4.07 (Worth a try) from 13 votes (773 Visits)

Disposable vs. Cloth Diapers

collie by collie Walking(April 2007) (rank 500+)

Cloth or Disposable

There are three primary considerations when deciding
whether to use cloth or disposables: (1) cost, (2)
health and comfort, (3) convenience, and (4)
environment.

(1) DiaperingDecisions.com compares the cost of single
use and cloth diapers for children from birth through
three years and

shows a savings of $2,500 - $5,000
when using cloth diapers.  Their calculations show
that "Cloth diapers pay for themselves within a
six-month period. After six months, you’ll be
diapering for almost free."http://snipurl.com/1gk72 .
If cost is a primary factor in your decision making,
it’s a no brainer -- go for the cloth.

(2) Health and Comfort -- Disposables with plastic can
cause diaper rash. Sure it’s curable, but it sure is
painful once it gets started. If you’re using
disposables and diaper rash is a problem, you might
want to switch until everything is back to normal, and
then watch for first signs of rash to treat it. Corn
starch and powders can help cure and prevent the rash
in both kinds of diapers. Creams that include zinc
oxide can also rapidly cure that red rash. Basically,
prolonged wetness or dampness contributes to the rash,
so the best practice is to be sure to keep baby
bottoms dry and that wet diapers come off as soon as
practical. 

(3) Convenience -- If you have time to soak, wash, and
dry cloth diapers, the convenience of disposables
might be limited to travel or various outings during
the day.  A lot of moms report cloth being the better
choice for night time diapers -- unless you like
getting up to put on a new disposable.  Some people
use cloth as their primary diapers and resort to
disposables when handling the dirty diapers is the
major consideration. However, you can’t beat
well-fitted disposables for long-distance travel.  In
this case, the disposables are worth the cost and
prevents a lot of stress.

(4) Environment -- Take into consideration whether
your disposables are bio-degradable.  Some say it
takes 200 years for the usual disposables to
biodegrade in the land fill.  Disposables like Eco
Baby are reportedly made of recycled materials and
will decay rapidly.  There is the argument that water
and detergents are as much a hazard to the environment
as are the disposable diapers, but today’s sewage
treatment plants can eliminate much of this hazard,
and the amount of water used is negligible compared
with other water consumption. You’ll have to decide
whether you want to conserve water or avoid items that
fill the dump forever.

You can make a simple decision about which you prefer
-- cloth or disposables -- but there are times when
you might want to switch from one to the other.
Regardless of which is your primary diaper, be sure to
stock some of the other for those special needs.

Potty Training Research Team (PTRT) -- More about baby
topics and potty training at http://www.PottyTrainingArticles.net
Permission is given to publish this article on line or in print if
the PTRT web site is included in the byline.

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.
ADVICE RATING
 (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) 4.07 (Worth a try) from 13 votes
Report
ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

mcm
April 2007 | mcm
Cloth
I use cloth the modern lazy way. I don't have time to fold soak iron whatever you were 'meant' to do!
We use mostly fitteds and dry pail. They work very well and I only wash a small load every second day.
Cloth has changed and it isn't as difficult as ppl may think.


Reply Reply Report
      collie
December 2007 | collie
Re: Cloth
A lot of good observations and experience here.  You might also want to check out the articles at http://www.pottytrainingarticles.net


Reply Reply Report
           mcm
December 2007 | mcm
Re: Cloth
 I noticed you posted 3 times on this page the same link on the one page. Once is enough I am sure. Thanks anyway.
My children are all toilet trained.
I will EC with the next - much easier than training. So much stress with my 2 big kids.


Reply Reply Report
pfallerj
4.31 (Good) | April 2007 | pfallerj
All good points
Nice article. My wife and I had high hopes of doing cloth, but they were just too messy. Not to clean up, but when he was wearing them! They leaked so much more than disposable, we chickened out and went the easy route. :(


Reply Reply Report
Vinny
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | Vinny
Cloth Vs Disposables
Great Article.   I used both and now use only cloth with my youngest.  Cloth Nappies are absolutely worth the effort, and my little one find them so comfortable.  I used to be quite sceptical about "Cloth Evangelists" who would shout the benefits of Cloth Nappies from the rooftops.  Turns out that they had a point though, they certainly work well for us. 

I can totally understand why peope would choose to alternate their use with Disposables for things like long car journeys as disposables come into their own in this environment.  

Whilst both are still available I think this will always be a matter of personal choice.  Judgements will always be passed on either side as to whom has the corect method, much like traditional Chinese mothers consider "us westerners" strange for using nappies at all.  (many/most children are taught using E.C methods from birth so that they are aware of their own bodily functions and their control of them by six months!). 

nice to see unbiased advice though!

Vinny



Reply Reply Report
      MummaBear
April 2007 | MummaBear
Cloth Vs Disposables
Well put, but I don't know what the "E.C. method" is.  It sounds interesting, I'd like to know more about it if you could extend on that.


Reply Reply Report
           Vinny
2.00 (Poor) | April 2007 | Vinny
Cloth Vs Disposables

E.C is where the child is held at appropriate intervals over a potty or toilet and an encouraging noise is made to allow the baby to associate the bodily function with the noise, so that after a certain age (a few months) the noise can be made and the baby then knows what is expected (i.e to go to the toilet).

Chinese women (and those using EC) clothe their children in trousers with a convenient split down the back (baggy enough trousers that the child's modesty is protected, but then easy enough to squat the child and have the pants come away either side!).  Nappies would confuse this way of "training", obviously. 

As time consuming as this technique is, if you are an advocate of "attatched parenting" then it is a very natural choice.  As you know, my son is in Cloth Nappies, but he wears nothing on his bottom half at home so that I can use a similar technique.  I have potties in each room and hold him above them his usual times ( I had never thought that he had a pattern until I wrote down his every move over a few days!!).  He is now at a stage where he knows the feeling associated with "just about to go". 

We don't make a fuss about the pees and poos on the floor, we just take them immediately to the toilet in tissue and wave goodbye as we flush.  I guess it depends what "you" are comfortable with!!  

Also he is ready for this kind of interaction I suppose because he has three older brothers and has known for sometime the feeling and association.



Reply Reply Report
                collie
December 2007 | collie
Re: Cloth Vs Disposables
A lot of good observations and experience here.  You might also want to check out the articles at http://www.pottytrainingarticles.net ... you might even want to post your blog note on the articles site.


Reply Reply Report
           MadMel
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | MadMel
Cloth Vs Disposables
Elimination Communication. Type it in advice. Should be something there :)


Reply Reply Report
MummaBear
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | MummaBear
I was a cloth-bum Mum
I had my daughter in cloth nappies the majority of the time.  She wore disposables for most of her first few days as the hospital didn't have enough room for soaking/washing nappies so it was just easier. She wore a disposable nappy on the day of her Christening, as well as a cloth nappy and plastic nappy cover because I was worried she would poo and it would go all over the nice white Christening gown!  I also put her in disposables during the time that we were living out of the car for obvious reasons.  But using cloth nappies and breastfeeding were the things I did that saved enough money to allow me to stay home with her for longer before having to return to work. If I was paying for nappies/formula I would have had to work to pay for those.


Reply Reply Report
      collie
December 2007 | collie
Re: I was a cloth-bum Mum

A lot of good observations and experience here.  You might also want to check out the articles at http://www.pottytrainingarticles.net



Reply Reply Report
Ngairi
4.07 (Good) | April 2007 | Ngairi
Nappies

Great info. I used both for all of my kids, probably more so disposable on the last one, as I was at the school with the older boys a lot of the time.

Leisa



Reply Reply Report

Related Content

Add

No related content has been added

Related Tags

Add

None

Bookmarks

No bookmarks found

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend