minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.51 (Highly recommend) from 49 votes (2465 Visits)

Debunking Myths about Homeschooling

kristinabrooke by kristinabrooke Talking Back(June 2006) (rank 53rd)
Many people argue against homeschooling because they are unclear about the purpose of school and the benefits of homeschooling. When I tell people that I was homeschooled for four years,  and that my husband and I may homeschool my daughter, I am often criticized as being a religious and overbearing
fanatic.  The purpose of this article is to clarify some of the most common misconceptions about homeschooling.

Homeschooling hinders the social development of children.
School should NOT be the primary method of socialization.  I hate when people say that children should socialize at school.  School is not about socializing.  It is a structured environment meant for learning.  Because so many parents think that students should socialize in school, emphasis has been taken off academics and placed on social skills.  Social skills are taught at home, in the community, and through activities outside the classroom.  Think about it, when was the last time you had to raise your hand to speak to your friends? The key to homeschooling your child is to find as many extracurricular activities as possible for your child.

Children cannot learn everything that they need to know in a homechool.
Home schooling can be better for a child because it is individualized learning. Children learn better when they receive one-on-one instruction.  The number one problem with schools is overcrowding.  If you take that factor away, students will naturally do better.  They get more attention and the learning is tailored for their needs.  In traditional schools, children spend 45-50 minutes a day in a subject class.  This is by no means enough time to learn everything.  Parents should be supplementing this learning with in-home learning to help children become skilled in the academics subjects.  The responsibility of the teacher is to present knowledge in a basic level so that the child understands it, but parents have to ensure that the children practice it.  The time between the end of school and the start of school the next day is enough time to forget.  If this time is used wisely, it can enable kids to become masters of a skill.  In the homeschool setting, you do not have these problems (time constraints) because if you notice that “Suzieā€ needs more time on writing, you can give it to her without interrupting the day or ignoring the others.

Only college-educated parents are qualified to homeschool.
Parents do not have to be college educated, but do have to be resourceful.  This is true in both the home school environment and the non-home school environment.  If you are home schooling, it helps to have graduated high school as you do need a basic working knowledge of the subjects, but when you do decide to home school, there are SO many resources available for you.  You just have to be willing to look for them and use them.  Many times, you can connect with your neighborhood school and use their curriculum.  Alternatively, you can go online to find ready-set-go bundles.  If you are not home schooling, you still need to be active in your child’s education so being resourceful helps.  You may need to provide your child with extra materials in order to ensure academic success.

Traditional school teach competition and street smarts.
Homeschooling gets rid of the competition factor in schools.  Yes, competition is good later on, but young children need to learn to have faith in themselves.  They need a solid level of self-esteem before they can deal with the pressures of peer-competition.  In fact, homeschooling can prevent kids from falling into the dangers of peer pressure because they have learned to form their own identities.As for street smarts, you do not learn these things in school.  Again, school is a structured community; the streets are not.  You learn these things from life experience.

A personal look at homeschooling.
I was home schooled and had to take all NYC Standardized exams.  I always scored in the 90th percentile. Yes, I test well, butI was also able to learn at my own pace.  My learning was very independent.  I had assignments where she would take me the library and give me a list of things to do and no help.  I learned to do things for myself and that gave me a hand up.

I already mentioned the socializing, but let me reiterate, I had many friends; I had family.  I took dance classes, piano lessons, voice lessons, and art classes.  I went to summer campI, played sports at my community center and traveled a lot.  I am a very social person but I also like to be alone. I am never lonely because I learned to keep myself occupied.

The downside was that in 6th grade I went to public school and was very bored.  I had done everything that they were doing and I was annoyed.  Therefore, I would correct my teacher and make them all mad at me.  My mom decided that the next year I would be going to private chool.

Private School was a tough school academically.  However, I was ready for it because I had such a solid background.  I did well.  College was the same way and I flourished there because I was very independent.  I admit that the traditional classroom has always (and still does) bored me.  I would rather be given a list of assignments and their due dates and be left alone. However, as a high school English teacher is a large public school, I see what happens when kids get lost in the crowds. Often times they do not learn because they do not receive the attention that they need.

Resources for Secular Homeschooling

http://www.oakmeadow.com/Information/FAQ.htm

http://www.independent-learning.com/

http://www.nhen.org/forum/default.asp

Yahoo Group

Find other Homeschoolers in your area

New York Homeschooling Links (links to other states too)

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.51 (Highly recommend) from 49 votes
Report
ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

peace613
January 27th | peace613
Re: Debunking Myths about Homeschooling

Great advice.  I teach my son at home and I believe that he does much better here that at any public school.  His is hyperactive and dyslexic.  He would be put into a "special" class and not learn like he needs to.



Reply Reply Report
sowens1789
January 12th | sowens1789
Re: Debunking Myths about Homeschooling

Key point I think made is you can challenge homeschoolers - see Challenging Homeschool Students - which I just wrote, but I also think the point mentioned about a slower pace is just as valid.



Reply Reply Report
AudreyBlissful
August 2008 | AudreyBlissful
Re: Debunking Myths about Homeschooling

Thank you so much for clearing that up!



Reply Reply Report
Rebecca2
October 2007 | Rebecca2
Re: Debunking Myths about Homeschooling
Wonderful! I'm glad someone is finally standing up for homeschoolers. I do not homeschool my children right now, but I am completly for it. I homeschooled my son in Middle school, he is now a freshman at a public high school.

Thanks for standing up for what you believe in.
rebecca


Reply Reply Report
AZMom
July 2007 | AZMom
Re: Debunking Myths about Homeschooling
Great advice, and wonderful to hear about other people's experience. My husband has mentioned he would like me to homeschool our son, we have a long time to consider it, but your article really helps. Thanks for sharing!


Reply Reply Report
anaturallearner
July 2007 | anaturallearner
Re: Debunking Myths about Homeschooling
I totally agree with your comments about socialisation and school and homeschooling. It is impossible for children to be properly socialised at school because they are restricted to socialising with mainly children and a very select group of adults. Without a healthy social life outside of school, school children are just as likely to lack the social skills critics of homeschooling complain about.

Our 20 years of experience with both school and homeschool - meeting hundreds of families from all over Australia - gives us great confidence that home education will not damage a child's ability to socialise with other. Social skills are actually enhanced, though to be honest, most homeschooled children I know, apart from being reasonably mature and well-natured for their ages, are generally typical children. I've written a few articles on the social development of homeschooling children on my website http://homeschoolaustralia.com

Regarding competition, homeschool children don't shun competition and generally thrive on it! It's not competition that is a problem with schooling, it is the attitude toward competition and the motivation behind it. I've found that most homeschooled children are very competitive, but usually not against each other. They strive to do their personal best and often help others to achieve theirs. Most people can't get over the helpfulness and cooperative behaviours of homeschooled youngsters. It still surprises me as it is so different from what people generally expect, especially from teenagers.

cheers
Beverley
http://alwayslearningbooks.com.au
http://www.minti.com/members/anaturallearner/blog/


Reply Reply Report
llmunchkin
5.00 (Excellent) | July 2007 | llmunchkin
Re: Debunking Myths about Homeschooling
I really enjoyed reading this, as I think there are some children with special needs where it is best for them, and some amazing parents are great teachers.  I like that it is from your personal perspective, and that you have also experienced different forms or more traditional education, so your point of view is validated from more than one perspective.

It is well written, and most informative - I hope a lot of people read it and gain more insight from it.  Cheers - Lui.


Reply Reply Report
      kristinabrooke
4.33 (Good) | July 2007 | kristinabrooke
Re: Debunking Myths about Homeschooling
Thanks Lui. I hopw it helps people see Home schooling in a whole new light.


Reply Reply Report
cazza
5.00 (Excellent) | July 2007 | cazza
Re: Debunking Myths about Homeschooling
I really enjoyed reading this and it has helped me understand what home schooling is all about, and just like to say that you parents that do it, do a wonderful job, and its good to be able to read diffrent advises on here on schooling our children. as the way i look at it we are all diffrent and so are our kids and we as parents try and do whats best for our childrens education....

Thank you so much for sharing your home schooling lifestyles ..


Reply Reply Report
Rose24
5.00 (Excellent) | July 2007 | Rose24
Re: Debunking Myths about Homeschooling
I have wanted to homeschool my children for a while now but I don't have the courage to stand against my mum who is very anti-homescooling. Now I at least have this article to help me. I am hoping to start homeschooling by the end of the year. Thanks for some great info.


Reply Reply Report
Kellzacar
5.00 (Excellent) | July 2007 | Kellzacar
Re: Debunking Myths about Homeschooling
Hi there,

I home schooled my eldest daughter for a few months when she was in grade 7 as no school would have her due to her mental health status at the time . . .  I found home schooling to be very difficult and i have the utmost respect for those who do it.

cheers Kellz


Reply Reply Report
angieh
5.00 (Excellent) | May 2007 | angieh
A non-traditional look at schooling
I was reading on the internet about a family who is taking a non-traditional look to schooling. This family has decided to sell their house and buy a camper van and go on a road trip. The kids are going to be home schooled so they don't miss out on their school work. Pretty interesting concept and and a different take to home schooling I imagine!

You can find out more

http://bluesuitnomads.typepad.com/blue_suit_nomads/2007/05/about_a_year_ag.html
and
http://www.welcometotheworld.org.uk/ (the family's actual website)


Reply Reply Report
RebeccaDorant
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | RebeccaDorant
home school kindy

i have just started homeschooling my son through kindy and i'm relieved to find other parents who homeschool spend only a few hours a day formally tutouring their children... i was worried that the 2 hours a day sometimes less if he's in a good mood was not enough. all the kindy's near us do 2 full days a week and i often wonder how a teacher can keep 25 plus children occupied for six hours at a time??? there are fantastic reasources on the net for art  but having trouble finding science stuff. also i was wondering if anyone out there knows how to answer all the questions and dissaproving looks from rellies who mention that dreaded word SOCIALISATION!!! :(



Reply Reply Report
      gingermuggins
July 2007 | gingermuggins
Re: home school kindy

pets make an excellent subject for a science lesson as does anything to do with nature. Why do the leaves fall off the trees in Autumn? Being of kindy age make it simple and entertaining for your son. A walk in the park looking for insects is always a good start and when the lesson ends a swing and a slide do wonders

Good luck with homeschooling

Keep Smiling

gingermuggins xx



Reply Reply Report
Naya
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2006 | Naya
I think everyone should homeschool!

I've wanted to homeschool even before I was old enough to have kids. My mom wanted to homeschool my siblings and I, but because she hadn't graduated from high school herself, she didn't think she was smart enough to do it... and hiring a tutor would have been too expensive. I had a really bad experience in the school system, though, and found that the classes just went to slow for me. I lost interest very quickly and usually made the teachers angry because I was three chapters ahead of what they were trying to teach.

Most of the things I learned in school I learned on my own through self study so I always felt that ,other than being with my friends, school was pretty pointless. Now that I'm a mom, I just don't want to subject my daughter to the things I went through. And with the violence and peer pressure kids have to deal with these days, I really believe they're better off at home. At least they're in a safe environment and can concentrate on learning rather than all the other things that have no place in a learning environment.



Reply Reply Report
ollie71
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2006 | ollie71
You who homeschool are super mums.

Power to you if you have the stamina to do housework entertain another child and home school.

I had a friend who did this due to missing so much school with bad asthama.  It worked in her family as her dad worked early morning cleaning offices.  So both parents where home during the day.

It truely is scary sending our children off to schools now.  You worry about bulling but now more and more we have to be wary about teachers.

O



Reply Reply Report
michellei
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2006 | michellei
Thinking of home schooling
Thank you for a great article.
It has certainly helped me to reach some important desisions regarding Miss Cheeky Chops.


Reply Reply Report
BellaMoone
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2006 | BellaMoone
Wonderful points!
I am in the 8th year of homeschooling my children. We love it and wouldn't change a thing! I get questions all the time about their socialization. A word i have come to loathe when used in a form of a question. Your points made in this post are right on the money. I couldn't have said it better myself! Thank you!!


Reply Reply Report
JadieLady
5.00 (Excellent) | August 2006 | JadieLady
awesome
I know a girl who did a bit of home schooling, she left school being in a 'special' group that went out of the class once a week for support work. when she came back to school she was head of the class. you cant tell me that it wasnt because someone actually took the time to explain things to her in a way she can understand and took their time instead of just rushing on through.


Reply Reply Report
Sistersarah55
5.00 (Excellent) | July 2006 | Sistersarah55
Thinking of home schooling..

I've been thinking of home schooling for a while now as i found the new zealand schooling to lack in the basic academic's like maths and english. I am, however, worried that my children will lack in social abilities because i live in the city and i dont have any friends with children. There should definatly be a more interactive way mothers can get involved with there childrens study while still getting the interaction with other children in a learning inviroment. xxx



Reply Reply Report
      kristinabrooke
5.00 (Excellent) | July 2006 | kristinabrooke
Thinking of home schooling..
Again, I reiterate that school is not the primary means of learning socialization...if parents stopped thinking about school as a social institution kids would be more apt to succeed academically because they would understand that school should be about learning academic. 

With that said, there are many ways to get your kids the social interaction they need outside of school. If you are religiou- church is a great place to meet other kids. Mommy and me groups, local homeschooling association...do the research and you will find so many options.


Reply Reply Report
Tink1976
4.33 (Good) | July 2006 | Tink1976
Homework.

Every parent should be doing some kind of home schooling even if your child goes to school, shouldn't you as a parent be taking interest in the homework they bring home? Isn't this  home schooling in a small way?

I don't know what other countries do but here in the UK secondary school students are expected to do at least 2 hours of homework an evening. We should be taking an interest in that and not let things go on blindly, hoping that they will do ok in exams then when they don't blame the school or child for failing, when it is our responsibility as parents to make sure they are doing well and getting the support they need.



Reply Reply Report
      kristinabrooke
4.33 (Good) | July 2006 | kristinabrooke
Homework.
I totally agree. Here in the US many parents complain if kids are given too much homework. LOL.


Reply Reply Report
           Naya
4.42 (Good) | December 2006 | Naya
Homework.
The only problem I have with having too much homework is that it really takes away from quality time with the parents and wind down time kids really need from school. After spending 7 hours in school the last thing a kid needs is another 3 hours of schoolwork to do. That's another reason I want to homeschool... at least I'll get more quality time with my daughter because she won't be gone 7 hours a day 5 days a week, and she can complete a full day of school work (including what a school would assign as homework) at home in just a few hours a day. That leaves a lot more time for "us" time.... and even better learning can be "us" time too.


Reply Reply Report
      llmunchkin
5.00 (Excellent) | July 2007 | llmunchkin
Re: Homework.
Absolutely - we are the primary educators,and main influence in our children's lives.  It would be foolhardy and remiss not to be involved in your own child's education as much as possible.  It is also an opportunity to spend quality time learning and growing together.


Reply Reply Report
sanspotash
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2006 | sanspotash
Many things to consider...
That was a really, really excellent post (and nicely written, too ). This is a topic that my wife and I discuss quite often. We are both the product of high quality public school education, but worry that the public school system (in the USA) is so terribly degraded at this point, at least in our area, that it will not offer the experiences and challenges to our daughter that we ourselves had. Private schools are better, but tuition is an entirely different financial consideration. We would LOVE to school Esmee ourselves (and probably will) but our big concern is having the time and making the time. There is no doing homeschooling half way and this is what troubles us at the moment. We are going to check out the resources you listed tonight. Thanks again, really enjoyed that pos t.


Reply Reply Report
      kristinabrooke
4.00 (Good) | June 2006 | kristinabrooke
Many things to consider...
You are right- homeschooling can not be done half-way. If you are willing to give it 150% of your attention, then it will work for you. I'm glad that my article helped.


Reply Reply Report
      Lissa
4.00 (Good) | July 2006 | Lissa
You'd be surprised about the time issue
Because you're working one on one, and because you know your children's interests and learning styles, and because you have the freedom to custom-tailor learning experiences to best suit your individual kids, homeschooling is far less time intensive than you might think. In school, much of the day goes to organizing large groups of kids--standing in line, collecting papers, etc. At home you aren't dealing with all of that, so right away you've got a lot more free time. Most of the homeschooling families I know (and we're talking BIG families) are able to get their formal studies done before lunchtime, and the rest of the day is free for activities, playing, housework, etc. I'm able to work at home writing children's books while homeschooling my five kids. With home education, learning permeates all you do. It's a fabulous lifestyle!

Here's an article I've written on the subject: Why I'm Too Busy to Put My Kids in School.


Reply Reply Report
kryztyna
4.00 (Good) | June 2006 | kryztyna
homeschooling

thanx

I still have two years to think about it. But i am leaning towards yes so far.We will see Im still looking into it.

again thank you for your advice



Reply Reply Report
      kristinabrooke
3.00 (Average) | June 2006 | kristinabrooke
homeschooling
I have a while to think about this too, but it's never too early. start compiling reswources now in order to save yourself time later. Glad this helped.


Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend