minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.70 (Highly recommend) from 26 votes (447 Visits)

To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide

jenlemen by jenlemen Young Parent(September 2007) (rank 20th)
There's been some controversy in celebrity news lately as reports surface that (former) U.S. pop star Britney Spears is sometimes un-clothed in the presence of her two small children, ages one and two.   The internet is buzzing with analysis and advice worthy of a national emergency, with experts being called in right and left to give the "official" perspective on what's healthy and what's not in terms of nud*ity in the home. 

While I'm sure in some cases this kind of behavior is worthy of a national uproar, I wonder what mother of infants and toddlers has the luxury of remaining unseen when going to the bathroom, showering, getting dressed, etc.  The fact that Britney Spears has the cash and resources to ensure total privacy on all these points doesn't automatically put her (very normal) mother behavior in question for me--especially when there are so many other areas of her life as a mother that might merit more strenuous scrutiny (if we must scrutinize at all).

Here's my take on healthy exposure to the human body (no pun intended).  I'd love to hear your point of view in the comments below.

  • Having children present during your bathing rituals is a normal part of motherhood--especially during that stage of parenting where nursing is a regular part of your child's understanding of who you are and what you provide as a chief caretaker, nurturer, etc.
  • Bathing with your small children is harmless, too, and can be a source of healthy bonding.
  • Having a honest conversation about human anatomy, privacy, safe and unsafe touching is essential for your children's healthy development.  Not talking about it will create more harm than good.
  • It's essential to follow your children's cues on what feels comfortable to them in terms of modesty.  Children naturally go through stages where they feel more modest and private about their bodies;  we should respond in part by showing more modesty ourselves during these times and affirming in our children that these stages are a normal part of growing up.
  • If our children are very, very curious about our adult body, wanting to touch, etc. especially as they are coming out of toddler years--I think that's a sign that a little bit more modesty is in order by way of promoting good boundaries and teaching about healthy vs. inappropriate touch.  This doesn't have to be the end of the conversation--it's just a sign that the topic needs to be moved to a more intellectual form of learning vs. the experiential.
  • The best thing you can do for your children is to develop a healthy body image.  Your kids know exactly how you feel about the body without you needing to say a word, so it's in your best interest to do the work to cultivate you own sense of positive regard, so that that attitude comes across to your kids--whether you are clothed or not.
  • While your children need healthy exposure to the human body, they do NOT need exposure to any aspect of your intimate relationship with your partner.  Adult relationships should be conducted on adult terms in privacy.  It is inappropriate for little children to witness or be present when you are making love.  I could be more clear here, but don't want to tip off the Minti censor-machine!  :)  But you know what I mean, and I hope this is an obvious point that goes without saying.
That's my take on it.  What do you think?  Let's let the ridiculous fuss about Britney focus our attention on something positive for a change!
Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.70 (Highly recommend) from 26 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

llmunchkin
October 2007 | llmunchkin
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
What a lovely article - I don't remember feeling modest around my parents, and since I had Jayden - poor Stephen's parents have helped out and copped the lot too!  I certainly think people should feel comfortable around their own family and friends - especially in their own home.  Kids do need to feel confident about their bodies - especially when so many change and shower rooms are shared when they go to school.  They also need to have a healthy understanding about when they should try to keep their private areas private too.

Everyone has different comfort levels, and it is a very personal thing - isn't it ridiculous that anyone should debate about poor old Britney.  Imagine having to cover up in front of your children - they will tell you to soon enough?!  (I wish you would though mum... JustJokes!).


Reply Reply Report
boredmum
5.00 (Excellent) | October 2007 | boredmum
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide

Great article! I couldn't stop my 8yr old coming in if I tried!! Our toilet is in the bathroom so if I'm in the shower or bath & he has to go he just comes in. I'm not allowed to see him naked but he thinks it's ok to see me naked!!

Thanks.



Reply Reply Report
KathrynR1402
5.00 (Excellent) | October 2007 | KathrynR1402
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide

I grew up in an overly modest house but have a DH who is perfectly at home in his skin, and so this has improved my own body image no end. As a result I can see how important it is to be comfortable being naked in front of your young kids.

Last night my 5 year old insisted on keeping her knickers on until the moment she got into the bath with her baby sister, so she is learning modesty, albeit a bit selective as I was there while she was in the bath and we dont use bubble bath due to eczema! We still bath together and shower together, but have explained to her that as she gets older her body will get increasingly private - now it's ok for us to see her nudy but she might not want her grandparents to see her nudy much longer and it's not ok to be nudy at school or with people not in the family any more (like in the fountains at the park!!!). We've also started talking about inappropriate touch when the moments occur.

Thanks for a great article! A good balance to the nonsence about this aspect of Britney's life!



Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
October 2007 | jenlemen
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
i think it is really great when we can recognize and follow our children's cues!!  good work, mama!


Reply Reply Report
Flicka
5.00 (Excellent) | October 2007 | Flicka
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
DD always watched me shower, often had a bath/shower with me and sometimes still does.  She watched me go to the loo when she was younger and that's how toilet training began.  She learnt all the appropriate ways of doing things, and eventually by her 3rd birthday would not go in the loo with others, and would not use a loo that didn't have a door on it because part of what she learnt was that going to toilet was a "private" matter and we remain unseen.  She uses the Schoolies toilet at daycare, which is like a staff toilet but there's one in her Kindy room, as this is room accessible to children in the afternoons, and there's one in the Preschool room, as this is the room the Schoolies use also.  I think as far as being in the home, learning about how to look after bodies and learning about our anatomy is part of growing into a healthy adult.  I'm also a breastfeeder, so she's seen those a few times.  Considering where she came out of, she's used a couple of my "private" parts herself and really should not feel ashamed of anything she has, she should know to protect herself and that's part of teaching them about healthy touching and bad touching.  They need to know about their bodies, feel comfortable with their bodies, and feel safe in their bodies.


Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
October 2007 | jenlemen
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
i agree that feeling comfortable in your body is the only way to learn how to feel safe as well.  good point.


Reply Reply Report
goodie
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | goodie
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
hey all i think this is an awesome article. my family have always been very comfortable with nudity although my step dad is a bit of a prude but the rest of us are open n unashamed of our bodies. my step dad would always tell me that i needed to cover up but thats just him. my mum walked round the house in the nudy a lot and so did my bro, sis and i. i still have no worries bout it which is lucky coz i'm a breast feeder and i am not worried bout gettin them out to feed my son. i still even have showers or spas with my mum and i'm 22. i think every1 should be comfortable with their bodies!


Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
October 2007 | jenlemen
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
it's so great you grew up in such a positive environment!  thanks for adding your experience.


Reply Reply Report
cheekymonkey
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | cheekymonkey
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide

I think the whole nude thing gets blown waaay outta proportion by those in the media. Unfortunately due to the fact that there are nasty sorts out there who have a completely different mind set on what is healthy and right, we feel that we should adhere to what someone else thinks is best for our children.

But, personally I feel that while they are young it is fine, they become accustomed to the differences in male/female bodies and  ascertain a certain amount of respect that another deserves in relation to thier body. I have had showers/baths with Grub since day1. He sees me getting changed all the time, and OMG going to the toilet. But that is how they learn.

Geez what's next from these so called "experts"...........not allowing the baby to touch your breast when breastfeeding. I reckon these experts have never had kids of thier own and have no idea the bonding and development experiences aquired from human touch and visualisation.

Good article Jenlemen!!



Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
October 2007 | jenlemen
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
thanks cheeky monkey!!!  i'm glad i finally came back and saw your encouraging comment here!


Reply Reply Report
           cheekymonkey
November 2007 | cheekymonkey
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide

NO problem, it's something I never understood until I had Grub. But I mean when I was young I had showers with my parents, and no harm done here. I was the kid at school who new about sex first and was last last to lose my virginity. I was taught about it when I was about 7/8yo and given the best books like "where did I come from?"etc...it also had to be done as I have abrother 9y older than me and his body was going through many changes and I needed to be aware of them.

My 2yo knows he has a penis and that's what it's called, and that girls are different. He hasn't asked what mummy has yet, except breasts. He asked if I had a penis one day and I told him that girls don't have penises only boys do...and that was all he asked. When he asks I'll tell, him I have no qualms about that.



Reply Reply Report
blackwidowkate
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | blackwidowkate
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
Hi
We have never had a issue of covering up as the kids have always had a bath with me.
Even now as teenagers 15 and 14 I will still walk into the bathroom without them worrying and they will do the same to me and Darren.  Megan will hold the curtain or a towel in front of her when Darren walks in to grab Jalan if they are bathing together though
She calls him and he comes get Jalan so she can finish showering in peace or vice versa if Darren and Jalan are in there and I can't grab her. 
Neither of them have any qualms about me jumping into the shower with them if we are in a hurry
Some days my teenage daughter requests it as she still likes me washing her hair in there.  It is also a good time for her to talk to me without anyone interrupting. Sort of our one on one bonding time with no one else
When Darren and I first got together he always covered up around the kids but as they got older they would often catch him in the middle of the night in summer getting a drink from the fridge....needless to say he was naked thinking they were asleep.
I have taught them good touches bad touches but also that it is only skin and nothing to be ashamed of.
Also helps identifying anything changing unusually on their body. 
Nowadays both Darren and i are often naked and the kids walk in and it does not bother them as they dont see the nudity. 
We would not let them see anything sexual unless it was by accident like my son walking in at a inoportune moment but the sheet is always there as well.
Jalan is a nudist to the extreme lately she hates clothes...but this is normal they tell me for her age group.
It all depends on the focus you place on nudity and the human body as they are growing up.
In my younger years i spent some time on a community and a lot of people chose not to wear clothes and at first you would have a good look and/or be embarrased but as time went on you didn't see the nudity as it was just there
They always said you can tell the difference between a true nudist and a pervert  All will look at first it is human nature but a true nudist will not stare.
We learned to appreciate the human form as just that....a human form.....all the same bits just different sizes.  It is a shame when it is seen as something more by perverts and people who can't control their own thoughts and feelings.  I see a naked body i see a beautiful creation not a sexual object....but admitedly like my son say .... most people that like to be nudists...really shouldn't lol
I would become a nudist permanently but i burn really easy and don't like ironing (hehehehehe)
I love fat (skinny) dipping it is awesome
Luv Deb


Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
October 2007 | jenlemen
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
so many people on this thread with really great stories about feeling comfortable in your own skin.  this is great deb, thanks for adding your experience.


Reply Reply Report
Libby24
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | Libby24
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
at 15 i got into a shower as my mum was leaving it, and with my 2 kiddies 5 and 3 they get into the shower with my hubby and i and i even get into the bath with my daughter. I dont with my son as there isnt enough room. I personally dont care what people say about it either. At 18 my dad would come into the bathroom if i was in the shower or whatever if i had a phone call.

I can see it being a problem if the parents are dodgy but for the ones who would never even contemplate the harm of their child i cant see it being a problem.


Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | jenlemen
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
i think your level of personal comfort as a child and your level of sensitivity and intuition as a parent to read the situation and act accordingly makes all the difference in the world!  thanks for commenting.


Reply Reply Report
mummy2girls
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | mummy2girls
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide

i have 2 girls and they both bathe with me quite often.

recently caitlin has come up with some 'interesting' questions about the human form!!!

but i just answered them as honestly as i could, hopefully without causing any stress!

well she seemed satisfied that her questions had been answered anyway!!

i think that as you have pointed out it is important not to be too modest about showing your body, but to set strict boundries about touch, especially in the times that we live in!!

great article hun...

lol lisa xxxx. 



Reply Reply Report
      Libby24
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | Libby24
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
My son asked about babies the other day and thanks to the net i was able to answer hiss question without going into to much info and used some pics.

I love that my daughter will point to my boobs and says mummy i will have them one day and that she knows mums and dads look different.


Reply Reply Report
           jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | jenlemen
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
libby that really is wonderful!!  :)


Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | jenlemen
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
i don't bathe with my kids now (hence the touching comment in the article above!!  :)  but i did so for many years and it is one of their fondest memories now that they are older.  thanks for commenting!


Reply Reply Report
5kids
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | 5kids
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
i agree with you. kids need to have a healthy attitude towards their body and they only get that from us. with all the controversy also on obesity in kids they need to be comfortable with themselves naked and clothed.


Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | jenlemen
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
it's true--body image is just as important.  i think it helps all of us make healthy choices regarding eating and exercise!


Reply Reply Report
Ngairi
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | Ngairi
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
I have never had an issue with the kids seeing us 'in all our glory'. Going from the bathroom to the bedroom, getting up and going to the toilet in the morning etc. At no time have we intentionally had any intimate side of our relationship in public view of the kids - except of course if they have accidentally walked in in the middle of the night LOL. I think it gets rid of the inhibitions faced by some kids. We all have the stuff, just different shapes colours and sizes.
Leisa


Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | jenlemen
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
thanks for adding this!  i think it does help our kids feel comfortable when there is a very everyday attitude about living in the house together.  it might be more negative for kids when we are very, very modest and they never ever see us in the normal course of life.  what's to hide? 


Reply Reply Report
nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | nell18-3
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
My boys are older now so they relish their privacy as do I like mine
But certainly when they were younger I used to not make any issues about the body so they grew up without it being a taboo subject
Agree with you that they shouldn't be exposed to the wrong things though


Reply Reply Report
      jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | September 2007 | jenlemen
Re: To Cover Up or Bare it All? You Decide
yes-- i totally agree!  i really hope this article doesn't leave anyone thinking that exposing our kids to adult content or graphic sexuality of any kind is appropriate.  just because we are comfortable with our bodies and our children are too doesn't give us license to expose them to things best reserved for adults.  thanks so much for making the point!!!  it's important!


Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend