minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (May work) (May work) (May work) (May work) (May work) 3.95 (May work) from 24 votes (2134 Visits)

Preschoolers who cry about everything ...

karenalonge by karenalonge Talking Back(November 2007) (rank 76th)

Today's post is in response to a question from Lisa, who asked  www.advice-for-parents.com , "What can I do about my preschooler who cries about everything?" 

Some preschoolers are a bit more tender than others. They have a harder time with transitions, take social

interactions very personally, and seem to need a lot more attention. They are easily overwhelmed by changes in routine, and once they are overwhelmed, they have a very hard time calming themselves down. Often they will continue spiraling emotionally out of control until they receive the help of a calm and caring adult.

This is where it gets tricky! We adults often find ourselves becoming impatient and exasperated when the crying and whining goes on and on. The more upset our child is, the more strain we feel on our own nervous systems. The more we want them to stop crying, the harder it is to provide the calm and caring presence that could help bring it to an end.

So here's what to do. When your child is crying, and you feel the tension building in yourself, take a deep, slow breath. Calm yourself down first.

Then, get down to your child's level, look at her, and ask her if she wants you to hold her. If she nods, go ahead and bring her into your lap and comfort her.

If she doesn't want to be held, just sit yourself nearby and be with her. While you are holding her or not, speak some guesses as to what might be going on for her. "Oh, you weren't quite ready to leave yet." "You wanted more." "You wanted that toy." This is not an endorsement, it's simply an acknowledgement of her feelings. Kids start to calm down very quickly after they feel understood.

You might be thinking, "Yeah, right, that's sounds nice and everything, but I have things to do!!" Which of course is true, but let's think about that for a second. Which takes longer and costs more of our energy - trying to move on ahead with our schedules while dragging around a crying child, or investing a moment now to have a cooperative and willing helper for the rest of the errand?

Until she has calmed down, her emotional state will prohibit any kind of reasonable conversation. A crying child needs to be comforted before any learning will take place. Current brain research tells us that learning is simply not occuring while a child is in a state of emotional distress. Period.

So job one is to comfort the child. When she feels understood, you'll see her start to relax a bit, and the storm will start to subside. Sometimes, just this release of energy will be enough to allow you to continue with your activity - stimulation just builds up in the nervous system and needs to vent through crying in order to return to manageable levels.

Other times, after your child calms down, you can talk a little bit about what might have triggered the blow up, and troubleshoot ways to avoid it. For example, you may decide your child needs more warning before a transition, or that it works better to run errands after naptime, or that an earlier lunch might head off a blood sugar crash.

In any case, you'll be able to think much more clearly about all this after the crying has stopped, so don't put pressure on yourself to figure it out on the spot. Simply take a deep breath, soothe your child by holding her (or sitting nearby) and see if you can understand where she's coming from. Later, when things are calm, you can make some changes to her routine if necessary.

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.
ADVICE RATING
 (May work) (May work) (May work) (May work) (May work) 3.95 (May work) from 24 votes
Report
ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

WinnierooPooh
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2007 | WinnierooPooh
Re: Preschoolers who cry about everything ...

Funny how different approaches work for different people. My first born responds well to this form of empathy however she has learning difficulties and she does not really know how to manipulate or take advantage. Our second child worked out really quickly that initially if she had a crying fit she would get full empathy. She began to take advantage. Nipped that in the bud pretty quickly. I have a very close friend who uses this style of approach, sadly to the detrement of the child. The child in question 7yrs still cries habitually when her friends wont bend to her feelings. This irritates other children who then back off and complain that she shouts and cry's all the time. As soon as Mummy gets down and shows empathy and an ear then she will settle, but Mummy cant be there all the time, and teachers dont have the time to dicuss individual upsets all day during class. I think one has to carefully try to undestand the personality of each individual child and introduce a support system to suit the childs nature. Some need strong ridgid boundries to help them cope with upset, others need tollerance and understanding and others need a combination. We are teaching our children, in the hope they can cope and succeed well in the wider world, where others will not take their feelings into consideration. Time out if used sensibly encourages, in my oppinion, children to learn to step back and think things through before launching. All non human social species use time out to teach younger members of the herd to conform to certain norms for the benefit of the whole. If a young horse, wolf, dolphin, gorilla or chimp is not confoming to reasonable behaviour, then the rest of the herd will isolate the animal, to help it learn it needs to conform to a certain degree for survival of themselves and the whole. We also need to do this for our children to help them understand the basic social norms and that it is best to consider your actions before reacting.

Luv Winnie.x



Reply Reply Report
Domestic-warrior
5.00 (Excellent) | December 2007 | Domestic-warrior
Re: Preschoolers who cry about everything ...
There are so many differing opinions regarding this which is great feedback.  I have tried this theory with my kids and found that generally it works for them.  Getting down to their level and acknowledging their feelings or emotions (not necessarlly agreeing with them) can sometimes diffuse a situation.  I can see were there are circumstances that it wont work in but generally i like this approach and try to use it.


Reply Reply Report
Aaliyah
4.00 (Good) | November 2007 | Aaliyah
Re: Preschoolers who cry about everything ...
I think this advice would work depending on the situation.

More times than not, we can easily identify why a child is crying.  Most of the times they are crying as a result of being told no.  Sometimes they cry because they got hurt.  Sometimes they cry because they are tired or hungry.  Our children learn from day one to cry for necessities so it shouldn't be a surprise that they still try to use this skill in other aspects of their life as they get older and become more aware.  Children are pretty smart.

Asking a series of questions to a child that is crying, in an attempt to figure out the cause of the crying, can actually cause the child to cry more because the wrong questions were asked.  So out of desperation, when I had this dilemma,  I phoned my mom and she had a solution. (Of course, this might not work for everyone but it did work for me.  I think it also depends on the age of your child but for this post I assume the child is at least 2 or 3 years old since it is regarding a preschooler.)  

Simply put, "Mommy can not understand you when you are crying.  Please come talk to me when you are finished."  And then go about whatever it is you were doing before the show. 

By making this statement to the child, you are helping to teach him or her about how we communicate with one another.   Hopefully they will calm down, and be able to tell you what it is that is bothering them so much that they had to cry. 

I also refuse to give an audience to my children when they wish to display their ability to turn red or hit that high note that hits you on that last nerve.  Most parents call these, "Oscar Moments".  I just walk away and continue about my business provided they are in no immediate danger of injuring themselves.  

Once they realized that no one was watching them, they stopped crying.  (This type of crying was usually after they had been told NO for something.)

Again, I think your advice would work depending on the situation.

Sincerely,

Aaliyah   

 

 


Reply Reply Report
emmysmum
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | emmysmum
Re: Preschoolers who cry about everything ...
i am with you 100% on this.
Great advice.
Thanks for sharing.


Reply Reply Report
yummymummyof3
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | yummymummyof3
Re: Preschoolers who cry about everything ...
Love this advice, little people don't really know how to express themselves in any other way, treating their emotions and feelings with respect and as you say making them feel understood is the best approach x


Reply Reply Report
ClayCook
4.64 (Excellent) | November 2007 | ClayCook
Re: Preschoolers who cry about everything ...
what happens if the child just crys to get your attention?
I think that what you describe is good in some instances where you feel as though their is real frustration or fear, however other times they just need some time out (ie: time out corner).


Reply Reply Report
      karenalonge
3.65 (Good) | November 2007 | karenalonge
Re: Preschoolers who cry about everything ...

In my experience, rarely does a child cry solely for attention.  Whining, yeah, if it's paid off for them in the past.  But crying is not fun, and there are a lot of other ways to beg for attention before getting that extreme. 

I wouldn't be likely to recommend that a parent use time out to stop a kid from crying.  Actually, I'm not a super big fan of time out anyway.  Kids, just like adults, do what they do for a reason that makes sense to them.  I've found it to be far more effective to figure out what purpose a child is attempting to serve with his behavior, and then teach/model a more appropriate way to reach that end. (ie, if you want me to pick you up, just ask me like this, "Mommy, will you please carry me?)

I also like to make sure kid are getting plenty of attention when they are acting in ways I like, so that hopefully, they don't feel the need to beg for more in ways I don't like. 

However, if by 'time out ' you mean that sometimes kids might prefer to be alone to release pent up energy, that makes good sense to me.  If you've investigated the situation and it's clear there's nothing you can contribute, then giving the child some space to finish up in private is not a bad idea! 

I would be more likely to move myself elsewhere than to send the child away (it's so much easier to control my own whereabouts than to argue with a crying child, and I am a control freak after all!)

 



Reply Reply Report
           ClayCook
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | ClayCook
Re: Preschoolers who cry about everything ...
I think our whining and crying definitions may be getting blurred. I find that sometimes a child (ie: mine) will whine and use crying as part of the tactic. Time-out is a good solution for whining.

Full crying is a different story, yes the child needs your (my) attention.


Reply Reply Report
                kathryn-solaris
4.14 (Good) | November 2007 | kathryn-solaris
Re: Preschoolers who cry about everything ...
This is an interesting idea but i don't entirely agree with it... think i am with you on this Clay, my kids both cry for attention. it is plainly obvious because they know it is something that parents are, for lack of a better word, "programed" to respond to from the time the little tricksters are babies. as they get older reasoning can help teach morals and alike but sometimes parenting needs to be a bit tougher especially for the ones who only understand infliction in a voice and body language. can not imagine reasoning with a two year old, or more to the point rewarding them with a cuddle for a tantrum in the shops, more like scream to your hearts content strapped in the pram so i can keep walking. cuddled for hurt/tired/hungry crying and other basic needs like that fair enough. but if they want anything else and we are in the middle of errands they listen to me mum is the boss, deal with it! especially when ya know they are gonna be bigger than you one day...LOL ::P


Reply Reply Report
ellamia
4.24 (Good) | November 2007 | ellamia
Re: Preschoolers who cry about everything ...
i dont know alot about this topic, but thank you for sharing this view.


Reply Reply Report
MrMintyMan
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | MrMintyMan
Re: Preschoolers who cry about everything ...
i have found getting down to the childs level and a gentle rub on thier back and asking whats wrong gently works well for me.

we have not had probs getting our little ones to go to school or kindy as we begin working towards this way before they actually start.


Reply Reply Report
jenlemen
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | jenlemen
Re: Preschoolers who cry about everything ...
i am wholeheartedly for empathy as a parenting tool.  well done.


Reply Reply Report
emmie
4.11 (Good) | November 2007 | emmie
definatly not ...

This may be good advice to some BUT unfortunatly for me it isnt as we have already  tried this and it has made things 10 times worse than before and also i would delete your email offer before it gets reported as you arnt actuallly allowed to advertise here in mintis advice section

cheers

emz



Reply Reply Report
      karenalonge
3.61 (Good) | November 2007 | karenalonge
Re: definatly not ...

thank you emmie.  I'd copied it over from my blog and missed that!

I think it's awesome that you are so clear about which advice you want to try and which you don't.  That's one of my favorite things about Minti -- there are so many options! 



Reply Reply Report

Related Content

Add

No related content has been added

Bookmarks

No bookmarks found

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend