minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
RIMG0552.jpg
Three weeks old in the SCN
Bunny Jan 10 Teeth.jpg
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) 4.22 (Worth a try) from 50 votes (2640 Visits)

Getting a Nanny for a newborn - Right or Wrong?

StephinSydney by StephinSydney Talking(August 2006) (rank 264th)
Today, I was interviewed by the Australian Newspaper for an article that will appear in Monday's edition. I was requested to be interviewed by the owner of a business whose services I have used in the past - www.nightnannies.com.au. I am the very proud mother of a 22 week old boy,
C.A.R.D. (Short version of Constantine-Antonio) Jane, the journalist, asked how I found out about the services of this company. I told her that I saw a print ad in a local monthly free publication, and the idea of getting a decent night's sleep was paramount at that time, so I rolled the dice and rang them. The proprietor was very helpful and emailed me about the company promptly, and I poured through their website and read every word. Jane then asked, "Are you prepared for the backlash that you might receive from other new parents about using a service like this one?" That question is what prompted this blog.
<p/>     Let me tell you about my son, because every child and situation is different. CARD was born 6 weeks premature (34 weeks), and spent the first week in a CPAP humi-crib unable to be held, and a further 5 weeks in the Special Care Nursrey (SCN) at Prince of Wales Private Hospital (God bless those wonderful nurses!) Although a premmie, he is blessed to be robust and healthy (7.25kgs at the moment) with no physical impairments. He is a very happy camper, and spends a heck of a lot more time laughing and smiling than crying. Attending to the needs of a premmie is very challenging. It is like being in parenting purgatory because you are not fully in charge and you don't get to retreat into your den with your cub like other parents get to do when they get to go home from the hospital. It is also terribly TIRING! We spent 6 hours a day doing nothing but feeding -firstly through the nose, then attempting to breastfeed, and then a bottle because the breastmilk supply was insufficient due to prematurity. Australian midwives are nazi-like about breastfeeding, but even Hitler could not get my breasts to perform. Add to the six hours important things like the daily bath, dressing, nappy changing, cuddles and entertaining all the visitors who wants to cast an eye on our first born, and I can tell you that it was a three hours on, one hour off, three hours on, one hour off, process. The only positive thing I can think of or come away with out of the premmie experience was at the end of every night, after the 10PM feed and he was tucked safely into his bassinet in the SCN, was going home and going to bed and getting a good night's sleep and knowing that I had the best babysitters my private health insurance would afford me.
<p/>    Recovering from an emergency Cesearean, post-natal issues about feeling cheated out of the 'birthing process', and the daily stress of life at the hospital got the best of me. I selfishly relished my Egyptian Cotten sheets and fluffy pillows and 8 hours of rest. The happiest day was bringing him home, hands down. But again, as first time parents it is a vast new universe and there is little training on offer. Four hourly feeds and night-time nappies we lovingly and gratefully attended to with a smile, althought sometimes with bleary eyes.
<p/>    Now, I know what you are thinking...Where was the help? Grandma, Auntie, Sisters...?
<p/>    My partner and I do not have any family in NSW where we live, and infact, all my family live no less than a 45 hour plane ride away. (Not close and certainly not cheap). So there we were in the land of the great unknown with no instruction manual, although we do own a plethora of books for new parents (including a very popular blue one, and the Baby Love book that we have read cover to cover) If only our son could read and then know how he was supposed to behave so that everything could run on a perfect Stepford schedule. FAT CHANCE!
<p/>    My partner and I, after our first forty-five days as full time parents, had a benchmark evening. We awoke to cries as junior stirred around 4 am, after he had been up at 1am and had a complete feed. I had tears in my eyes and I said to Paul, "That is it. He has defeated us. I surrender! I give away my need for sleep and my previously memory of a solid 8 hours undisturbed." He got up, I nodded back off, and the next day, over breakfast, he suggested that we get some help. Now I will kneel and bow to all mothers who hit this low and did not crack, but we cracked. We were irritable, exhausted, our sex life was non-existent, we could not exercise, our social life suffered, and we became short tempered. Basically, we were crappy parents because we were not taking care of ourselves. We decided that we were going to take the plunge and 'phone a friend'.
<p/>    We planned a dinner at our favourite restaurant and booked a night nanny using the aforementioned service. Elenor, our savior, arrived at 7pm. She was a trained speech pathologist by day and moonlighted on weekends to earn spare cash. She was personable, knew her way around a nursrey, and imbued our trust immediatley. She seemed happy with our guest room accommodations for the evening, and we left with the knowledge that we would come home from dinner, drop off to sleep, and until 9am, not have to wake up. We were giddy like two teenagers, and terrified like two axe murders on death row. Was our child safe? Would she be responsive to his every cry? would she whisper to him and comfort him or throw him around like a case of rockmelons? Through dinner I called once and sent a few text messages, I admit. I, however, did not ask for hourly photo affirmations to be sent to me via SMS to ensure that all was calm and bright. Trusting my gut had to be good for something, even with my most precious possession.
<p/>    The fact that the agency did thorough background and criminal checks also put us at ease. Leaving a newborn, even with our experience of kissing him goodbye for the first month at the hospital every night, was very stressful. It was harrowing, but necessary. On personal experience and from my mother's group, the sooner the better. We learned from that first evening onward that in order for us to give him our best, we had to be at our best. Wringing the life out of ourselves would not do him any favours, but probably do more damage. It is easy to become resentful, to both your child and to your spouse for all the tests and trials you encounter as new parents. (It technically is not my partner's fault that I am tired because after a few too many cosmos I fell into bed with him and willing conceived.)
<p/>    Elenor's presence in the house brought not only much needed sleep but also a source of knowledge. We had "Yoda" and could ask as many questions about what our baby was doing or not doing to a knowledgeable source in the privacy of our own living room. We got feedback! With that came confidence. Elenor got pretty busy on the nannying circuit and the agency sent along Susan. Susan has over ten years experience and is the mother of two children, 9 and 10. While she works, they stay at home with their dad. She came for a weekend and then ad hoc as we needed her. She is an expert on sleep training and weaning. The nannies agree, we are very lucky as CARD is a very placid, happy baby. He is easy to settle to sleep and even during the night, wakes, feeds and drops back to sleep. We have had nearly no unexplainable crying bouts.
<p/>    Today having the issue raised about whether or not it was the right thing, to invite a stranger into my house to care for my child, made me look back at my actions and what fueled them. First, the nannies were not stangers, but trained, qualified and competent women. If parenting was only permitted by CV, then I would have been one that John West rejects because before my child I have very little interaction with newborns. Quite honestly, unless you come from a very large family and get lots of hands on time as an Auntie or Uncle, who does?
<p/>    Caring for a child is one part love, one part common sense and two parts intuition. All the love in the world will not change a nappy or give a bottle correctly, or know when your baby is ready for solids. My second reason for hiring a nanny was EXHAUSTION! I did not want to (This portion has been edited on 26/3/07) become so numbed from lack of sleep that I was unable to feel or cope with all the exeprience and handle all the emotions that were part of becoming a new parent, giving birth to a premature baby, and learning how to care for him. I knew that if I didn't get physical help I would suffer in much greater ways, my nerves would deteriorate and ultimately I would require medical intervention.
<p/>    Truth is, I was so busy just trying to accommodate my son and his condition that I shut out all the PND issues, skillfully surpressing them until he was about 4 months old, and then it all hit the fan. My 'perfect mom' 'I am coping' bubble blew up. The meltdown was at my first mothers group and we still laugh about it to this day. What did I do? I read a few great books on the subject, changed my views and began meditation and I am happy to report that my paradigm has shifted. Now back to the nanny issue... Getting a nanny meant getting a good night's sleep. From my experience, the world and its problems looks totally different when you are not looking through bleary, sleep-deprived goggles. CARD is well adjusted and has no seperation anxiety issues. He can be comforted by a kind stranger, and is a better baby for that skill. He is a total "self soother" according to his paediatrician. <p/>    After a good night's sleep we relish the 7am morning rolecalls at the crib-side of our son as Paul and I race to see who will get the first smile of the morning. (CARD is now sleeping from 11pm til 7am.) Getting a nanny may be frowned on by other mothers but it changed our life. Paul and I have returning to a life of normalcy. We accept that we are not super-human, although we aspire to be super parents. Nannies are like anything you would expose your child to: do your homework, read the label (or website), check references, and trust your gut instinct.

For tips for first time parents on weaning, nannies, nutrition and other important stuff, get my free newsletter at www.stagescookbook.com or email me with your hot topic and I will blog about it.
Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) 4.22 (Worth a try) from 50 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

Anonymous Member
 
This Comment has been deleted
kardelen133
May 2008 | kardelen133
Re: Getting a Nanny for a newborn - Right or Wrong?

Hi

Good importants.

http://www.ankara-evnakliyat.org

thanks.



Reply Reply Report
familyof5
February 2008 | familyof5
Re: Getting a Nanny for a newborn - Right or Wrong?

You did the right thing. You do whats best for you and your family.



Reply Reply Report
lindterbean
November 2007 | lindterbean
Re: Getting a Nanny for a newborn - Right or Wrong?
OMG we were in a similar situation with a preemie and no close friends or relatives available to help us out and I was telling just about everyone I ran across how someone ought to open up a night care instead of a daycare for new parents. I would certainly have paid a premium for a good night's rest even 1 night a week. What with all the other issues came the breastfeeding/pumping/reflux problems, so for the first 2 months I was getting between 1/2 hour and 2 hrs sleep a night. I honestly don't know how I made it through. If we had access to a sevice like that I may have been able to breastfeed properly and maybe those first couple of months would be filled with a couple of nice memories instead of being just a blur. In fact it wasn't until I returned to work and put our sweetie in daycare that he established a routine and I got my sensibilities back. I definitely think that as long as you aren't abandoning your baby to a caregiver, a little extra help can leave you room to enjoy your child while you still have the consiousness to do so.


Reply Reply Report
LeahW
September 2007 | LeahW
Re: Getting a Nanny for a newborn - Right or Wrong?

Thanks for sharing your story with us.

I thik with everything you have been through with your darling lil man you have done the right thing.Asking for help isn't always an easy thing to do but you have and how much better do you feel in yourself  for doing so.

Take care



Reply Reply Report
bertiethebee
September 2007 | bertiethebee
Re: Getting a Nanny for a newborn - Right or Wrong?

My second daughter was born unwell.  She spent some time in Neonatal unit at the Royal Childrens Hospital in Melbourne.  It was really hard when she did come home.  Her record was crying for 25 hours straight (with maybe 5 minute breathers every now and then).  In one way I would have loved to have nanny (couldn't afford it though) but I'm not sure I would have been able to hand control over.  As we nearly lost her very early into her life I must admit that I'm quite protective (probably over protective!!). 

So .... in saying all that, well done to you!  I hope CARD continues to stay strong and well and healthy!  A job well done!



Reply Reply Report
Mystique
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | Mystique
Re: Getting a Nanny for a newborn - Right or Wrong?
What a fantastic article. Well done do you for taking those first steps of seperation to help yourself before it became too late. You should be very proud of yourself for following your intuition and not letting anyone else butt in. Good luck to you.


Reply Reply Report
winja
4.50 (Excellent) | May 2007 | winja
nannies
oh im so jelous! lol. sorry but i have to admit that! i have my eldest daughter by myself now and i breastfed for 14 months loved it and she was never babysat. im now pregnant and alone and the dad wont be having anythin to do with it so i will raise this bub entirely on my own from the beggining that means i will still haev to care for my daughter and a new bubby by myself and i know il manage but its a scary thought, i prob wont be able to stay in hospital after the birth unless its my weekend off from chloe, but really i think its still gunna be great this baby is a blessing even with the dramas and i wouldnt have it any other way.


Reply Reply Report
llmunchkin
4.33 (Good) | April 2007 | llmunchkin
I must look up these Nannies...
They sound great - like you, we have no family here either, & sometimes it makes having a life outside the house together pretty impossible.  We get out & about & do stuff now that Jaydee is older & sleeps well throughout the night, just not together.  I am sorry to hear that you had to edit out some of what you thought were more humorous aspects in an effort not to offend any other members or would be members of minti.  However, it does show that you are compassionate & caring, which is a very good trait for any person to have, especially a mum.

Sometimes I worry that people read advice and articles on minti & assume that someone is having a go at them personally... Remember gang, it is a public forum, everyone is asked to participate freely so that we can share opinions, and learn new things.  Not everyone has the same opinion, or the same life experiences, or the same way of expressing themselves - that is what makes it worthwhile. 


Reply Reply Report
exquisite-flower
4.83 (Excellent) | March 2007 | exquisite-flower
Good on you
There were times when I wished I could have had the luxury of a full nights sleep, so good on you for being able to indulge!  Looks like you got the best of both worlds.  Good article
Peace
EF.x 


Reply Reply Report
lightbee
4.52 (Excellent) | March 2007 | lightbee
Good on you!
When my eldest child was born, my mother came and helped us and the most wonderful thing for me was when she stayed till late and gave my daughter last feed for the night (she was bottle-fed) so I could have a stretch of uninterrupted sleep.  I remember thinking I don't know how I could have coped without the help of 2 or 3 other people at that time.  I applaud you for taking steps and seeking out the help you needed.  And what a wonderful solution that there are people out there, trained and willing to give up their night and look after a newborn baby.  Like all child care solutions, you need to feel confident that the carer is competent and you feel comfortable with them, but once you feel happy with that, why not pay for help rather than using family and friends (especially when they're not available!).


Reply Reply Report
kseers
4.76 (Excellent) | March 2007 | kseers
Tough call
Yes. i think you will get  a lot of criticism but I think good on you for doing what you thought would get you through.  I am sure most of us are in some way envious.  A good night's sleep - what's that??  A night out with hubby - what's that?? sex life (I'm sure I had one sometime...)????

Anyway, it is not what I would have chosen - but who am I to judge your situation?  We each of us do whatever gets us by and makes us the best parents we can.  I think so long as you have carers who respond to your child as lovingly as you would then he will be fine.  Good luck with it all!


Reply Reply Report
RebeccaDorant
4.60 (Excellent) | March 2007 | RebeccaDorant
did the best you could

man that's a long article...lol... um ok well my first impression i have to say was that you winge alot most parents go through sleep deprivation and all the funky things that a bub can throw at a parent. it's just part of the job and yer it's hard but it's hard for everyone at times. basically get over it.

ok that said i believe that you did the best you could and i don't think that having a nanny was a bad idea for you... point being we all do what we need to to get by as parents and if you needed a nanny for your bub then that's cool because you are the only one who can decide that, personally i went the other way and did not allow anyone at all to sit logan until he was 1 1/2 years old but i guess that's a bit left of centre for the majority too so yer kudos to you for writing this lotta courage in ya :)'s... i must admit childcare is a touchy subject for some.

ps:was the mental health issue everyone is on about editied out? :)'s from becca.



Reply Reply Report
      Wendigo
4.05 (Good) | March 2007 | Wendigo
did the best you could
Yep, the mental health bit has been edited out - as of this morning I take it. I suspect a few of the votes on it might improve now because of it. It only takes one little comment that wasn't thought through thoroughly (Eeks! try saying that fast, it was hard enough to type!) to put people off what they are reading. It hink this advice has improved a lot for that small edit.


Reply Reply Report
           RebeccaDorant
4.67 (Excellent) | March 2007 | RebeccaDorant
did the best you could
yer i just got the mail about it.  wendigo, if i report my comment will your's still be here because it's off mine?


Reply Reply Report
                MadMel
4.33 (Good) | March 2007 | MadMel
did the best you could
why would you want to report your comment?


Reply Reply Report
                     RebeccaDorant
4.60 (Excellent) | March 2007 | RebeccaDorant
did the best you could
i think i was a little too quick to judge, and let my own feelings about childcare speak rather than taking an objective perspective. which i feel would have been more constructive.


Reply Reply Report
Wendigo
4.76 (Excellent) | March 2007 | Wendigo
I'm with Mony on this one.

I never suffered PND myself, but I have had my share of mental illness and depression was part of that (it just wasn't post-natal). I was reading your advice and thinking, good on you, well done, well written.... then omg another one without a clue about mental health.

Do yourself a favour. Read a few of these stories I'm linking here below. 1 in 5 people will suffer a mental illness at some point in their life, and you or your partner, or one of your children, could end up being one of them.

I understand that you're intentions were not to offend anyone, but matey, the first article I'm linking will explain the reasons why I recommend having a read of the others.

How are you?

PND

PND

PND

PND

Mental illness

Mental illness

Mental illness



Reply Reply Report
monyq83
4.78 (Excellent) | March 2007 | monyq83
Night Nanny
You know, I really enjoyed reading that. I was totally captured by the way you write, and was really enjoying it. That was up until the bit about the Zoloft popping mother bit. Id just like to point out that most mothers that take Zoloft (myself included) take it because they have a chemical brain imbalance and are unable to function normally without the chemicals in the meds. I take my medication not because Im looking for an 'easy way out' but because everything else has failed me and my family and I want to be a better parent than my brain will allow without the medication. Sometimes mothers who have to take it have a legitimate reason and take it for the better of their family as a whole. Because as we all know, an unhappy mother means an unhappy family.
Just a thought.


Reply Reply Report
      StephinSydney
4.79 (Excellent) | March 2007 | StephinSydney
Night Nanny and Zoloft
Firstly Mony, my thoughts were not meant to offend you or anyone who takes anti-depression drugs. I believe that they are useful and necesary and I understand the implications of post natal depression. I had a whopping case of it around my premmie birth issues that I coped alot later than the second 6 weeks after delivery because I refused to acknowledge that the matters were there. My thoughts on getting help, not just mental but physical, were about me, and trying to terms with accepting that I was not superwoman as I think I repeated again and again, and that I just couldn't find balance anywhere on my own. Getting help in the house so that I could cope with my depression, perceived failures (they were all in head and my kid is great) was just where I put my processes, they were not to judge anyone one else for theirs. I hope that makes greater sense or clarifies point of view. Many mothers that I know with kids older than mine take Cipramil and find it has a great effect on their life. I have regard for all those willing to take actions and get the help they need, whatever type of help that is. Maybe writing my nanny article was a little cathartic and selfish of me, pushing my experiences and inner thoughts on the Minti world for all to see and exposing my weaker self. I guess I deserve all that you and everyone has to say about it.


Reply Reply Report
Jessgore
4.58 (Excellent) | November 2006 | Jessgore
I don't know where I'd be with out my mother in-law

I think what you did was great...  And not only that the fact that you had no family there what other option did you have..   When my son was born, from the age of two months my mother in-law asked if she could take him one day a week from 7.30am until 9pm. Giving myself and the hubby time to have dinner together before I went to pick him up, and I'd have a day to tidy up or just plain rest... I often rested :)... Being a first time mother it never went like the book said it would, not for me anyway...  

I almost said to my mother in-law no thank you we'll be fine. But I have to say that even just for the day was enough for me to get myself back on track to go for another week.   Sure I missed him while he was at grandma's but I was able to look after myself and the hubby when he got home from work...   And I am sooo sure that I would have been a wreck had she not have put the offer in..



Reply Reply Report
      Jessgore
4.79 (Excellent) | November 2006 | Jessgore
I don't know where I'd be with out my mother in-law
By the way. LOVE THE NAME... And such cute photos...


Reply Reply Report
bleshu
4.79 (Excellent) | October 2006 | bleshu
???
I honestly dont know how to comment on this???  My first instinct was to think you took the easy way out, however, my 2nd instinct was to think, "good on you"  I would never have thought to hire someone to come in and let me sleep.  My baby is pretty good at night, slept for 8hrs straight from 1-2months then went haywire for a month but is now back to his 8 hrs.  I wish I had the self confidence that you have that would allow me to hire someone to help.  I cant help feeling guilty if Im not the one attending to him.  We too live away from family and my husband works nights and sleeps all day so I am the main caregiver to our 2 children, it is hard for me to give up full control when I get offered help.  I do totally support your "happy mum happy bub" mantra, I have been spouting this one myself for yrs.  So good on you for having enough confidence in your abilities to allow another mother figure into your home.  good luck for the future.


Reply Reply Report
      StephinSydney
4.83 (Excellent) | March 2007 | StephinSydney
???
Thanks for your feedback. That posting was six months ago and I now have a happy, healthy toddler who does sleep through the night (6:30pm-6:30am), and walked one week before his first birthday, albeit that he was premature 6 weeks. (his due date was April 11 so he technically wouldn't even be 1!) Bunny (as he is called for his enormous Bugs Bunny like feet) is well adjusted and takes easy to new faces. I work from home part-time, and he is left in the hands of the live-in nanny so that I can get a few things done. The emotional price-tag has been a big one as you might have guessed. He doesn't have a moment of neglect or positive interaction, but I often feel that it is my job to nurture him and wish that I had nothing more to do than hang out and read books and exchange smiles. The nannies that we have had had not been Mrs. Doubtfires baking cookies but they are kind and he is well cared for. I have worked to achieve the balance so that I can spend quality time with him. He knows who Mom and Dad are and his interactactions with the nannies is more like Aunties or cousins. It does require extra work, and that work is in training the nannies and aligning them with our values and processes. I don't necessarily believe I had more confidence than other new moms, I just know that I do rule the roost in my house -whether or not there is help on hand. It has also been a big step to admit to myself that I am not superwoman, and perhaps cannot do it all. Rather than do an average job across the board at mothering, cleaning, cooking, working, writing (which is my profession), partnering, and taking care of me when time permits, that I needed to swallow my pride, get over myself and make the most of what I could for all parties. We have only been parents for a year, but I don't think I could have coped, with no support structure in the country, any other way. That is my honesty and I really appreciated yours! Cheers!


Reply Reply Report
           Wendigo
2.33 (Poor) | March 2007 | Wendigo
???
There's a lot of stuff to read on Minti, it takes a while to get around to everything. Better late than never, right? lol


Reply Reply Report