minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.96 (Highly recommend) from 34 votes (187 Visits)

So....Why DO We Stay ???

nell18-3 by nell18-3 Young Parent(April 2008) (rank 1st)

Of all the things I am asked since leaving my marriage

The question that I am asked the most is

"Why Did You Stay ?"

Unless you have been in the very same situation

You cannot understand why

anyone would stay in an abusive relationship

But what is it that makes us so loyal to people that have no respect, love or care for us and our feelings

I can only speak for myself when I try to make even myself understand,

Why did I stay???

Bottom line for me is that I was with a man, who as far as I could see, was loved by everyone, he had friends everywhere, even my friends loved him, everyone laughed at his jokes, even if they were at my expense, I would get understanding shrugs as if to say “Sorry I’m laughing but you got to admit thats funny, and he means no harm, we know he loves you !!!” People would be telling me all the time how lucky I was to have such a wonderful husband and father. He would be the life and soul of every gathering and clearly was Mr Popular in the community. It was only when everyone else was gone, the children and I were home with an uncommunicative, hard to please, unloving, bad tempered and downright scary man.

What else was I to think? If no one else had a problem with him, then it had to be ME !

I was the one that provoked his bad moods, made him unhappy, he wasn’t a bad father at all he just had bad children that seeing I was the main carer, they were only bad because I was a bad parent !!!

When you live your life to try and please someone, only to come up short everytime, never to quite  be as acceptable in presenting yourself, your home, your family then if he was to do it himself. Its you that becomes the failure in your own mind.

What are your options?

You have two options, you either bring further misery and failure to your family by leaving the relationship, making life unstable for you all, what happens to the family home? what happens to the family set up? Who lives with whom? The pain you will bring into your family............ Doesn’t seem to look like such a great option at the time
 

Or option two, you try harder and harder to get it right, to not disappoint him, to not anger him, to stand between the children and him to keep them safe. In your mind, the only one being hurt is you and you deserve it anyway, because you believe it is all your fault.

THE GOOD NEWS

I woke up to myself !!!!!!
It was not my fault !!!!
It was not my childrens fault !!!

IT WAS HIS !!!!

I realised I would never be good enough or do things good enough, because as long as he could put me down, then he was King of his own Castle. No one questioned his authority in his own home ???? How dare they !!!

This is not living in a relationship,  this is being someones puppet, not only are you their puppet, you are the toy that they only want to play with as a stress reliever, putting you down makes them feel good about themselves.

I remember once crawling through the lounge on my knees to beg his forgiveness because once again I had gotten upset over something “trivial” and he slipped up!!!!  because he told me I had nothing to apologise for, he told me he liked seeing me like this because he knew I would be more ameniable after I came to my senses !!!!

ALARM BELLS RANG ALL OVER THE PLACE !!!!!!!!!

The reason we stay is because we believe we don’t deserve anything better, we are the damaged goods, its the partner who has all the stress and its us that make things harder for them.

The reason we have to leave is because it is actually us that is so much better than them, its them that don’t deserve us !!!

Take it from someone who has walked this road. I have gone from a big house and no money worries at all, to council rental, benefits and even begging from a charity for help with food for the week. Yet I am happier, free and so are my younger children.

It is not too much to ask to be respected , loved and treated as an equal in a relationship

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.
ADVICE RATING
 (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) (Highly recommend) 4.96 (Highly recommend) from 34 votes
Report
ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

pauline27
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | pauline27
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

As your Mum I would never have recognised this if I hadnt visually seen it and lived through this with you he was Jekyll and Hyde to not only you but to all of us as well. I still have nightmares thinking back to the times when the children would send for me and dad with des there being as nice and kind as can be with you sobbing and then the children saying . Nan when we rang you dad was not being nice like that. But once we caught him out on lots of occasions we knew it was serious and not even we thought he would be capable of such cruelty. Because of the lies he has told us and we have caught him out on so many times.



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thanks Mum

You know I believe I wouldn't be here today without the support of you, Dad and the rest of the family

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
Pumpkinbum
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | Pumpkinbum
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

This was like reading a story written about me. My ex was the life of the party, could make friends with anyone and i felt it had to be just me.

Since leaving i have realised it wasn't me and his family and a lot of his friends asked why i stayed when he treated me so bad. Funny how things come out once you have left. Good Luck

We will survive and be stronger for it. Thanks



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Well done

Its great to meet another survivor !

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
Lumina
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | Lumina
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Hi, I'm pretty new to Minti and this just happened to be the first article I've read.  I couldn't believe how similar our stories are!  Three days after our wedding, Mr.Charming moved my son and myself to Alberta, where things were Jekyll and Hydeish after a month.  I stuck it out for nine months before packing up my son, throwing some clothes in the car and getting the heck out of there.  And when I arrived back in my hometown I was criticised by so many people because they all believed that he was some super guy!  After some healing time my son and I are much better and I have resumed my relationship with my highschool sweetheart.  Thanks for sharing your story, I don't feel so alone.  Glad you're safe and happy now...



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thankyou

I'm glad you are safe and happy too, so pleased for you that you realised fairly quickly what was going on.

I kept telling everyone that he was Jekyll and Hyde myself, still waiting for lots of them to believe me, but I'm beginning to realise that is their loss not mine.

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
llmunchkin
4.75 (Excellent) | April 2008 | llmunchkin
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Tops advice Helen, I love how you just tell it how it is, without insisting that some should do A, B, or C... I think for many people, just the fact that someone understands, and that others have been in the same situation is enough to give them strength and hope for their own future.




Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thanks Lui

You're right about the understanding, when i first realised that it had been abuse I read so many books and the stories are so similar its creepy yet comforting, probably cos you feel so alone when you are going through it and then you read others stories and realise you aren't alone after all

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
tamg
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | tamg
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

what you say is so true.

it is eaasy for other ppl to tell u t leave but some times its not that easy, i have been there before. it is hard.



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

It is definitely the hardest thing I have ever done, but when you think of the alternative....................

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
lightbee
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | lightbee
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Helen you are so right!!!  I remember my counsellor once saying that unless you've been through a divorce, you can't really understand what it's like.  I would add to that, unless you have lived in an abusive relationship, you can't understand why you would stay. 

It just is so different actually being in such a situation than it is hearing about it.  In hindsight it might be obvious that you should have left ages before.  But at the time it is not obvious.  In fact, the option of leaving might not even be in your head!  You don't feel like you have any other options but to try harder to modify your behaviour so that your partner is less abusive. 

When I finally told my grandma why I had left my ex, she said to me "You must have been living on your nerves the entire time".  She was absolutely right.  And when you're under that sort of constant stress, it is hard to think of options.  It's easier to do what you've always done and what you're being told to do. 

I think it either takes someone else to step in or something extreme to happen to make you realise that this situation must change.

Great article. 



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

I ditto everything you just said Leith

My Mum once said to me "You must feel you have been walking on eggshells" I replied no mum its far worse than that

Thanks Hunni for your added perspective

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
           DarkenedAngel
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | DarkenedAngel
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Yeah, its more like being forced to run on sharp thin shards of expensive fine crystal.

Well done Helen, good to see you confirming within yourself the reality of the situation. You're growing stronger every day. Proud of you.



Reply Reply Report
                nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Ouch !!  yea you are right there !!!!

Thankyou DA I really appreciate that

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
elonblock
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | elonblock
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

You had said " It is not too much to ask to be respected , loved and treated as an equal in a relationship

From my perspective tbeing treated as an equal, with respect and love is the core of any relationship.

I acknowledge you for your awareness regarding your situation. And IMHO, the most important thing is you took action!

It's one thing to talk about something, because everything looks good on paper. It's a toally different story to act on your thoughts.

Congratulations,and thank you for the reminder and a confirmation for taking action!



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thankyou for your comment

I'm glad you agree with me

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
superpo
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | superpo
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

This was very insightful and I think it's good for people who aren't in abusive relationships to be able to read something like this and maybe get a glimpse of understanding of the WHY. Thanx for sharing. I admire anyone who has the courage to start anew without the abuser because as bad as it is with them I imagine the prospect of leaving to be pretty scary at first! That's great you found the courage!



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

thankyou

I'm glad I did get out too

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
Ravenheart
4.56 (Excellent) | April 2008 | Ravenheart
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

as always nell excellent advice

xoxo



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thankyou Hun

xxx



Reply Reply Report
monyq83
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | monyq83
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Nell If I could have given you 10 stars for that article, I would have done. I would so loved to have been able to show that to so many people when I was with the father of my eldest two. You summed up everything in my head and put it down on paper. Or monitor.

Well done on another great article.



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thankyou Mony

I really appreciate that

xxx



Reply Reply Report
mariamum
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | mariamum
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

You are an inspiration to me!!!!  Not sure if I could be that strong in the same situation.  The only reason I managed to escape my x was because he ended up in prison and I then met Jon in that time  I had the break I needed to rethink my options and get the courage I needed, and with my parents help I did it and I was so lucky to have not married him.   I am a great believer in second chances and I believe we all have the option to take them but it is down to us to make that decision and make it the right one.



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thanks Maria

Whatever the way you did escape I'm just so glad that you did. Good for You. It would have still taken a great deal of courage and you DID it !!!!

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
electrifying02
4.75 (Excellent) | April 2008 | electrifying02
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

thanks for sharing i have been in a simaler but we broke up two days before our wedding day

bel xxxx



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Sorry to hear that Bel but glad you didn't go through with the wedding !!!!

xxx



Reply Reply Report
FremantleDocker
4.75 (Excellent) | April 2008 | FremantleDocker
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

I can't start to imagine how you felt through this as i haven't been through it myself to this extent. Hoping you are alot better off now, and that your children are more happier now.



Reply Reply Report
      loopylisa
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | loopylisa
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Kids are far better off. He took me to court for access and parental responsibility and got neither.Their stepdad is a fab dad to them both and have lost nothing,I believe in not having contact with the biological dad.



Reply Reply Report
           nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

I agree with you, but it is slightly different when the children are old enough to make the choice for themselves, I believe it should then be down to them whether they see him or not

xxx



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thanks Kerri

I'm so much happier now and so are the children, except for when the thorn in my side pops its head up

xxx



Reply Reply Report
loopylisa
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | loopylisa
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

I think we were with the same man!!. Your story is so similar to mine.My boys dad was much the same. I totally idolised him and would have walked over hot coals for him. Nobody knows what it's like to be in an abusive relationship until it happens to them. He was physically abusive until the twins were born and then it changed to verbal. He would make me feel so bad about myself as a mother and as a person. I left him when the twinnies were 18 months old-once an ass-always an ass. I don't regret a thing but it infuriates me so much now when women stay in these relationships.But,unfortunately everyone has to learn for themselves.



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thanks for your comment

I'm sorry for what you must have been through and can totally understand your feelings and frustrations

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
lonely28
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | lonely28
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

All I can say is thank you for writing such a great article and putting a voice to what many women/men can't say............

Well done you,

fi xoxoxo



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thankyou Fi

Love ya

xxx



Reply Reply Report
mumof2b
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | mumof2b
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

I hate that he put you all through that............no-one should have to beg for forgiveness!!!

You have become so much stronger for everything you've been through.......You should be so proud of where you are today because I know I am.

Love ya....Amanda xxxx



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thankyou Amanda

Its weird when everything around you feels abnormal yet you believe the cause of it all is you yourself !!!! Everything makes so much more sense now

Love ya

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
anniebabe
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | anniebabe
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

its well written because its come from your heart . very emotional

the fear and anxiety you no longer have to put up with. as you say you wake up happy . that is the way it should be .

cheers annie



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thankyou Annie

There is no feeling like waking up free !!!!

xxx



Reply Reply Report
Kellzacar
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | Kellzacar
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Hi honey,

Why is it that most men like this seem to be thought by others as GREAT men!!! Its really very frustrating when our friends etc can;t see the real side of who he really is .  ..

Thank for for wonderful but very TRUE insight . . .

Cheers Kellz



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thanks Kellz

Its like I have said before its very hard when you are fighting against a monster hiding in a superhero suit !!!!!!

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
AZMom
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | AZMom
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Great advice! Hindsight is such a wonderful thing.. I am sure it is a easy for those on the 'outside' to wonder why, but when you are stuck living with Jeckel and Hyde it must be easy to justify it (if that makes sense ) I hope this helps others in similar situations!

Lorna



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thankyou

It is a Jekyll and Hyde character isn't it, and they are very clever who sees both sides to their character

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
cazza
4.56 (Excellent) | April 2008 | cazza
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Great advice and you have come so far, and im so proud of you.

xx cazza

 



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thanks Cazza

the only reason I have been able to gain confidence is having friends like you on here believing in me

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
emmie
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | emmie
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Hey Helen.

Another fantastic advice. You are such a strong woman you are so much better than that scum bag .

Thanks for sharing this .

Luv Emz xxx



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thanks Emz

I still chuckle when I hear him called scum bag !!!!! Love it

xxx



Reply Reply Report
2BeautifulGirls
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | 2BeautifulGirls
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Nell, thank you for sharing this.  You are an amazing woman and should be proud that you took the stand.  There are so many women and men who don't. 

My aunty was in an abusive relationship with a really horrible man and she didn't leave (she has since passed from cancer) and it left scars on her children that I don't think will ever heal.

I hope that by sharing this you may just help someone.



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

I'm so sorry to hear about your Aunt, thats such a tragedy for everyone concerned

Thankyou for your comment of support

xxx



Reply Reply Report
HeadNotMyOwn
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | HeadNotMyOwn
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

nell u have my upmost respect, and if there were medels for women in situations like urself then u would all deserve a lorry load.

my mum was in a mirror image relationship the same as ur own with my father and we all paid the price,but she found the strenght 2 leave and is now a much happier person

all the best in your new found freedom

take care karen xx



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thankyou Karen

For your lovely comment

Good on your Mum I am so pleased for her that she was able reclaim her life and once again be happy

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
           HeadNotMyOwn
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | HeadNotMyOwn
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

ur very welcome nell

and if ever u need 2 get a load of im hear 2 listen and try and help the best i can

wat u need 2 do now is try and concentrate on U and ur kids but moastly U as even though they have paid the price wit u u bore the brunt

keep in touch

karen xx



Reply Reply Report
MrsSanders
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | MrsSanders
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Nell thank you so much for this advice, it must be very hard to share these experiences, and I do appreciate the insight into the hardships and abuse you suffered. For people who have never suffered an attack on their self esteem, it can seem like a mystery or conundrum. There for the grace of god or fate, it could be anyone of us at anytime. I for one have learned a lot from your advice and continue to do so. 

Luv,Winnie.xxxx



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Thankyou Winnie

Its sometimes strange writing as it feels like a bad dream !!!! But at the same time it also seems to bring healing with it, I guess if its out in the open it cant go septic inside, if you know what I mean

Thanks for everything

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report
cathbusymum
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | cathbusymum
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Oh Helen,  you know I understand completely. What I ask myself now is, Why did I think so lowly of myself to begin with? Why did I never think I was as good as everyone else?  Self esteem is THE major issue.



Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2008 | nell18-3
Re: So....Why DO We Stay ???

Yes Cath

I know you understand and I know why you understand, you are so right it is definitely all about our own self esteem and feelings of self worth. If someone takes those emotions from you it is really hard to get them back

xxx

 



Reply Reply Report

Related Tags

Addabusive, misery, unhappy

Bookmarks

No bookmarks found

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend