minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (May work) (May work) (May work) (May work) (May work) 3.21 (May work) from 15 votes (906 Visits)

AEDs: More Effective and Easier to Learn Than CPR

biglarry by biglarry Walking(March 2006) (rank 500+)

For decades, when someone’s heart stops beating, CPR has been the standard and most effective form of first aid. CPR is taught in classroom and community centers throughout the world, led in great part by the American Red Cross, who urges all Americans to become certified in the correct

methods and techniques of giving CPR. However, new and increasingly affordable technology is now viewed by many as easier and more effective than CPR. An Automated External Defibrillator, often called an AED, may be a far more powerful tool for saving lives. Impressively, defibrillation via an AED is far easier to perform than CPR, even for someone without any training.

AEDs are lightweight, portable devices that can jumpstart a victim’s heart by using an electrical pulse called a biphasic shock. Guiding the rescuer with a combination of simple and clear voice, text and graphical instructions, AEDs do nearly all of the work, enabling practically anyone save a life!

As opposed to CPR, which can easily be done incorrectly, too slowly, or too shallow of compressions so that the heart is left unaffected by the efforts and will not restart on its own, an AED is easy to use and can actually restart the heart with just the push of a button. Using the same technology found in emergency rooms, operating rooms, and doctor’s offices all over the world, an AED can not only help an individual suffering from cardiac arrest until professional medical help arrives, it can literally save their life. Phillips, Zoll, Heartsine and other companies manufacture very portable defibrillators that are surprisingly affordable, and refurbished models are often available for under $1,000, according to AED resource Web site Start A Heart.

Generally speaking, performing CPR is a great deal more complex than one may believe. Training and refresher classes are incredibly important to ensure that you not only perform the motions of CPR in the correct method and speed, but also know the appropriate times to perform CPR. Many AEDs however, use sophisticated software and simple voice commands to analyze a patient and instruct the operator on how to restart a heart. These AED devices are found in airports, schools, public spaces, and private homes all across the country, providing an advanced option in case an emergency requires resuscitation.

Many individuals do not have the strength or stamina to properly perform CPR, since the activity takes a great deal of energy to correctly perform in order to receive the best results. Furthermore, you may need to perform CPR for an extended amount of time depending on where the victim is currently located and how easily accessible they are by emergency medical staff. In contrast, individuals of all strengths can use the AED device, since it requires the individual merely to push a button in order to jolt the heart back to life using a shocking stimulation. Generally speaking, it only takes one or possibly two shocks to the heart in order for the victim’s heart to properly respond, allowing the individual working the defibrillator to perform other medical tasks that my be necessary.

As they become increasingly common, you will find an AED in nearly every public place. However, you should still ensure you know the proper methods associated with CPR in case you need to assist someone and are unable to access an AED.

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (May work) (May work) (May work) (May work) (May work) 3.21 (May work) from 15 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

Jessgore
April 2007 | Jessgore
AED will only be more effective if the heart has actually stopped.

I did my first aid course on Saturday and this is what I learnt….

 CPR is very important. It is not used to restart a heart (I always thought it was). I learnt that because a heart runs on electricity the only real way to restart someone’s heart is to use a defibrillator.

 CPR’s main function is to continue giving oxygen to the brain.   When someone has stopped breathing and the heart has stopped, there is no oxygen getting to the brain running the risk of brain damage.  It only takes about 15 minutes of no oxygen before the damage sets in….   

 So if the ambulance is going to take 20 minutes to get there the person in trouble s/he stands a better chance of avoiding brain damage if given CPR.  You won’t be able to restart the heart, but at least you give them a fighting chance at avoiding brain damage…

 My instructor is also an ambulance driver, and he said that CPR is very important and not enough people know how to use it. And even after 20 minutes the person may be resuscitated but be brain dead because no one knew how to do CPR and continue giving the oxygen to the brain…

 The AED is good, if in fact the heart has stopped. But it won’t give Oxygen. And if the heart is still pumping and the person is just not breathing, you don’t want to be giving them an electric shock…

 So in saying all of this, AED will be only more effective then CPR if the heart is in fact actually stopped…  It can’t breath oxygen.. SO PLEASE EVERY ONE LEARN CPR…

You could just save a life….  



Reply Reply Report
      Jessgore
April 2007 | Jessgore
AED will only be more effective if the heart has actually stopped.
PS:  CPR really does not take that long to learn... And if stamina is a problem there are others that you can show how to help you while you are doing it.. Take turns...


Reply Reply Report
           Jessgore
April 2007 | Jessgore
AED will only be more effective if the heart has actually stopped.
By the way sorry.. Yes the AED is a great to have, and should be more available....  But it won't as said below replace CPR...


Reply Reply Report
exquisite-flower
January 2007 | exquisite-flower
Supplementary
I agree with Helen that AED is supplementary to manual CPR.  In my opinion it is important for everyone to be aware and to have training in firstaid.  this then means that should anything happen where you are you are equpiied to do more than panic and at the very least will have the presence of mind to make the necessary phone call. 
Peace
EF.x 


Reply Reply Report
hrs2004
3.88 (Good) | March 2006 | hrs2004
Interesting, but one-sided
I have, in the past, trained and subsequently trained others in the use of both CPR and AEDs. I have to agree with the general comments in that AEDs are the best piece of kit I have come across for ages, but they do not replace CPR - they supplement it. CPR still needs to be taught and still has it's uses. Hospitals still use CPR even though they have high-tech equipment. AEDs should, in my opinion, be all through the community and are life savers, but I believe that they are not recommended for use in children under 8. Buy one, use one, but don't forget the basics.


Reply Reply Report
senoragilbert
2.76 (Average) | March 2006 | senoragilbert
SCAM!
Isn't it AMAZING that these comments come directly from the linked site, and also that the site has a direct link to purchase an AED for an "amazingly low price"?


Reply Reply Report
Anonymous Member
3.50 (Good) | March 2006 | anonymous  
Comment
It would be great if you could link some external sites of the external link. Do you have an personal experiences or friends that had to use an AED on a child/teenager?


Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend