minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 

This site gets better with user participation. Please participate... Some of the main things you can do is rate this advice, add comments to this advice, add links to and from this advice, and/or write your own advice.

  email  print
  report   
Like this topic?
Write Advice
Add to Favorites
Advice that links to this one
ADVICE RATING
 (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) 4.16 (Worth a try) from 28 votes (4108 Visits)

Breast or Bottle?

Anonymous Author (March 2006)

Since baby formula first came on the scene in the 1860s, it offered an alternative to breast milk. The popularity of baby formula surged at the end of World War 2.

 

There are many arguments in favour of baby formula. Some are convincing:

 

Eg:

“Breast milk is not the purest form of food source for babies as humans reside at the top of the food chain. Hence, our bodies are the most contaminated – from the ingestion of mercurial seafood to pesticide infested veggies and meat. Inevitably the poisons will pass into our breast milk and are fed to our babies. Formula on the other hand, is manufactured in a controlled environment where toxins are eliminated and nutritional benefits are optimised”.

Others are not so convincing:

 

Eg:

“I don’t want to get saggy breasts through breast feeding.”

 

“It’s not acceptable in our culture to breast feed and the bottle less likely to offend”.

 

“Mastitis hurts, and I don’t want to go through that.”

 

I am a mother of 2. Both babies have been breast fed. My son was breast fed until he was 9 months old and I would have continued to do so had he not decide to wean himself from the breast. He was on solids and he preferred the taste of ‘real food’.  My daughter was breast fed until she was 19 months old. She loved the breast milk, it took some doing for me to wean her off the breast in time for pre-kindy! Besides, she was already drinking cow’s milk.

 

A paediatrician once asked me whether I breast fed my daughter and when I replied yes, he whole heartedly approved. He told me that breast milk is comprised of “living tissues” from the mother and nothing is more perfect for the baby than the food the mother produces specifically for the baby.  This validated my resolve to breast feed as long as I could.  

 

In the 21st century, mothers are encouraged to breast feed. This begins a resurgence in breast feeding.

 

If you are considering the breast feeding, consider these benefits:

 

(1) It is more convenient that bottle feeding. There is no need to sterilize bottles, boil and cool water, pack formula and related paraphernalia as the milk comes out in the right consistency and at the right temperature all the time.

(2) Experts say that breast fed babies don’t get sick as often. I tend to agree. My daughter (the one who was breast fed until 19 months) was only sick once, when she had her first major inoculation. She recovered quickly and is still not a sickly child, even when she is quite petite.

A girlfriend of mine had a baby who was prone to ‘wind’. She was mixing bottle feeds with breast feeds and then she decided to drop the bottle altogether in favour of the breast. The occurrence of tummy pains due to winds reduced significantly.

Scientifically speaking, breast milk includes a mother's immunoglobulins that help the baby fight infections. The baby’s immune system is still largely undeveloped and these anitibodies help the baby’s system to recognise and combat the illness that the mother has been exposed to. 

(4) There is nothing like the bond you feel when you hold a baby in your arms and when you’re breast feeding. It is special, tender and warm and I looked forward to those tender moments (especially amidst a hectic working life) when it was just me and the baby. The world was shut out and it was our special time together.

 

(5) There is also the theory that breast fed babies are smarter. In my experience, I think that this could be true!

 

Scientifically, it is a proven fact that a mother's breast milk changes in response to the feeding habits of her baby and over time, the make-up of the breast milk adjusts to the baby’s individual growth and development.

 

I am biased towards breast feeding as I have personally experienced all of the benefits.

 

However, there are also real disadvantages.  Mastitis is one of them. Mastitis is caused by the inflammation of milk ducts and is quite painful. There are steps to take to minimize incidences (future article) of mastitis. Another disadvantage which I felt was that it excluded my partner from the “feeding experience”.  It is important for the father to feel involved in the early stages. As the baby sleeps and feeds almost 24 hours in the first few months, it may be an idea to ‘express’ breast milk into a bottle so that dad can participate in the feeding.  

 

Some women may be averse to the thought of breast feeding in public. In Australia, there are special rooms in shopping centres for breastfeeding. I was pleasantly surprised when I found similar set-ups in Singapore whilst traveling there. Generally, I think that people are more accepting of the idea of breast feeding in public places. 

 

As for saggy breasts, that can’t be prevented if you intend on breastfeeding. There are good bras on the market. There are push-ups and other exercises that you can do to build pectoral muscles. Pregnancy, weight gain and weight loss, age and time will all contribute to the loss of shape. The way that I see it, you can’t defy gravity forever anyway. As long as our children are happy and healthy, don’t sweat this little detail. 

 

Breast is still best.

 

Any contributed content above is the subjective opinion of that member or external author, and not of Minti.com Pty Ltd. If you are searching for health related advice we strongly suggest you seek professional medical support. View our Terms of Service for more details.

Related Content:

Bookmarks:

ADVICE RATING
 (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) (Worth a try) 4.16 (Worth a try) from 28 votes
Report

Thankyou for your vote (you can change your vote at any time). Please leave some helpful comments about this advice using the box below.

ExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellentExcellent
GoodGoodGoodGoodGood
AverageAverageAverageAverageAverage
PoorPoorPoorPoorPoor
Very PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery PoorVery Poor

Voting help


 
Add a comment on this article.

 

archiesmum
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | archiesmum
Bottle Feeding
Due to latching problems, I swapped to formula at 6 weeks. I couldn't believe the guilt that some people put on me when I told them what I'd done. The health nurse even frowned upon me. I felt terrible, and thought I was failing as a mother when people voiced their opinions about me not breast feeding anymore. I don't care what anyone says anymore, I can see that it was best for both of us - my son isn't screaming all the time and I'm much more relaxed. I think being a first time mother is hard enough without being made to feel bad about the decisions that you make


Reply Reply Report
      nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2007 | nell18-3
Bottle Feeding
Totally agree with you, Feeding baby is better when you are doing whatever is best for you and the baby. I breastfed all 4 of mine, however my daughter didn't benefit at all so after a few weeks I switched to the bottle, I was frowned on and made to feel a bad mother, but my daughter thrived and I stopped resenting her for not feeding properly with the breast as it had been feeling like she was rejecting me. She would not breast feed but would drink breast milk after I pumped it into a bottle! It worked out fine for us.


Reply Reply Report
franni
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2006 | franni
good advice
i didnt get to brest feed i couldnt cuz she went straight into special care and i didnt really no about exspressing at that time. iam going to breast feed this time with bubs number 2.


Reply Reply Report
Girraween
5.00 (Excellent) | October 2006 | Girraween
Finding your way
I breatfed all my children .. at least until teh teeht came through and they thought it a great game to bite down.  My advice to anyone though, specially the first time around, is find the way it works for you and the baby.  Listen to the advice but honestly as long as the baby is getting the milk and you are both comfortable there is no right or wrong way in my opinion.  Everyone is different and therefore what workds for one may differ for what works for the next.


Reply Reply Report
dolphins30
5.00 (Excellent) | October 2006 | dolphins30
I agree
What you are saying i agree with. You have some good points and good advice.


Reply Reply Report
gr8est
2.67 (Average) | August 2006 | gr8est
whats best
for the mother and baby eg my partner had watery milk and lots of it she leaked, had a fst flow, and would sometimes squirt bub in the eye trying to put it in his mouth.. Bub was not getting nutrients, vitamins and what he needed so formular was best for both esp bub it really depends on the circumstances


Reply Reply Report
KatieW
3.83 (Good) | April 2006 | KatieW
breast fed babies smarter?
Both of my babies were breast fed, and then formula/toddler milk fed at a later date. Emma (4) was breastfed for 10 months and Harry (2) was breastfed for 14 months. My sister and I were formula fed from a very early age. Although I *know* my babies are intelligent regardless of breast or bottle fed, I can tell you that as a formula fed baby, I suffered no lack of intelligence as a result of formula feeding. :) I think there are a whole lot more factors that come into intelligence besides breast vs formula.


Reply Reply Report
rachelcook
3.18 (Average) | April 2006 | rachelcook
Blend it a little
maybe for one feed, express some into a bottle so that dad can bond every now and then. mastitis was terrible but I worked out if i massage the blocked ducts really hard at any slight niggle this got them working and after two bouts of them one in each breast, i was breast feeding fantastically. but my little one then weaned himself off it, as the mini pill was the last straw...at 4 months he went to formula and then solids at 19 weeks. next baby i know now what to do to strike a balance and increase chances of no mastitis, breast feeding successfully for as long as i can, no mini pill and express for family members. phew!! next baby here we come!!!


Reply Reply Report
Anonymous Member
3.42 (Average) | April 2006 | anonymous  
Whatever is best for the individual child
It is continually argued that 'breast is best' and I do agree to SOME degree..........but:
I disagree with the statements 'breastfed children are less likely to become sick' and
breastfed children are smarter', I think the latter is particularly unfair. I believe genetic, dietary and environmental factors are more important in shaping the health and intellect of a growing baby.

When my son was born, I spent several weeks on antibiotics and did not want to pass these to my son who had already received a high dose of antibiotics separatly which had the potential to affect his hearing.

After 4 weeks of bottle feeding, my son did not want to be breast fed and after several weeks it got to the point where my son would scream if he even saw my breasts (they're not that bad!).

I then tried to express my breast milk and continue bottle feeding but he was continually upset and hungry. After a few experiments between formula and breast milk we established that he preferred the taste of; and was more settled and happy on formula. Knowing that my son was happy and healthy helped me from feeling guilty about not breast feeding (lots of people try to make you feel like a bad mum).

My son is almost three now and is happy, healthy and very cheeky. They say 'breast is best' but I think it is an individual choice about what is best for you, your baby and your situation.


Reply Reply Report
      rachelcook
3.85 (Good) | April 2006 | rachelcook
Wow what great conversations!!!!
Wow, what a contentious issue, well done on taking the plunge in writing such a great article and getting such detailed comments from both sides!!! I have experienced trying to breast feed, but I'm more for adapting to the situation. However, I agree with breast feeding advocates when the mother doesn't considering breast feeding at all!! I think that is trying to defy nature?? I think if we could all breast feed till 6 months it's a gold medal...and a platinum medal if it's any further than that. I think parents these days are more for striking a balance. I breast feed and also topped up with formula but I also made sure the formula contain breast milk nutrients. Well done on deciding to breast feed longer. I don't know if I could handle the occasional bite, but I might try up until 10 months, we'll see with bub two!!! However, my bub was thriving. If they aren't thriving formula is a life line. I think go with what you can deal with, but try breast feeding. In the end we all want what gives baby a good start in life.


Reply Reply Report
      ClayCook
3.65 (Good) | April 2006 | ClayCook
Re: Whatever is best for the individual child
Loved your comments. I too find it a little hard to believe that breastfed babies are necessarily smarter... however if it is healthier for them... then maybe it helps them be more alert and less sick... which in turn means they learn faster?

It seems a stretch doesn't it?... I am sure it all adds up though in the end.

Having said that... Our boy went fairly quickly onto formula and he is smart in my opinion ;)


Reply Reply Report
Anonymous Member
4.06 (Good) | April 2006 | anonymous  
My thoughts
I am not one to post comments regularly unless I feel very passionate about something.

My experience has given me a firm belief that if you do what is best for you it will in turn be best for the baby.

Unfortuantely/Fortunately we no longer live in a society where multiple generations share the same housing and therefore receive handed down skills such as breastfeeding.

There is nothing easy about learning to breastfeed, it does not come naturally, it is a skill to be learnt by both mother and child. This learning process is made more difficult by the various opinions expressed by friends, family, doctors and mid wives.

I have a 2 year old daughter and spent the first 4 weeks of her life battling with the breast feeding process. As each unsuccessful session finished (her crying, me sweating and tearful and husband wringing his hands wishing he could help) I felt more and more helpless. I was determined to excel at this thing called breastfeeding as it was supposed to be best for her.

What no one told me is that a breast fed baby will not thrive with a mother who is stressed to all limits everytime a feeding session looms. And a mother who forgets to enjoy her new born child as the stress takes over.

Thankfully I came to the conclusion that my daughter was better off having a loving relaxed mother than a few drops of breast milk offered inbetween screams of hunger.

She is now 2yrs 3mnths and is beautiful. We often receive comments about her abilities not only physically but her speech and ability to interact with others. Her illnesses have also been minimal in comparison to others.

My advice is do what is best for you and that will be what is best for your child.


Reply Reply Report
      ClayCook
3.74 (Good) | April 2006 | ClayCook
Re: My thoughts
great comment - thanks for sharing your experience.

I know you said that yuou dont comment often... but please do! :)


Reply Reply Report
Anonymous Member
1.91 (Poor) | March 2006 | anonymous  
why oh why....
Why do people have to go on about babies that are breast fed are healthire and smarter.. cos it is so not true!
I bottle fed and am very happy that I bottle fed. My daughter is healthier and alot smarter than her breastfed friends. (2 fed till 12 months and the other to 18 months)
Her friends are always ill, have colds and ear infections all the time. if there is something going around they all get it... they have had the sickness bug and chickenpox... my daughter fine.
She rolled, crawled, walked months and months before they did. She has just turned two and her speech compared to her 3 friends is amazing.. people always think she is alot older than she is.
And the most important difference.. she has the most wonderful realtionship with her dad.. the other three ladies are so jealous of my realtionship. Their husbands have never ever changed a dirty nappy and because they were never involved with the child they don't do anything with them at all! My husband spends every minute he can with his daughter... theirs either down the pub or on the PS2!
Breast isn't best for everyone.
Thanks


Reply Reply Report
      ClayCook
4.15 (Good) | April 2006 | ClayCook
Re: why oh why....
Glad to hear you baby is so healthy (and smart!) ;Also glad to hear that your husband is so involved. Being a husband myself... it hurts me when I hear a father say he has never changed a nappy (diaper)... how close can he be to his child! :(


Reply Reply Report
      Anonymous Member
3.94 (Good) | April 2006 | anonymous  
Re: why oh why....
my boy is 7 months old and is breastfed and his dad has an excellent relationship with him. I dont think the father /child relationship really has anything to do with how they are fed. If a dad wants to be involved he will be. As far as children being smarter than others, we all just strive to give them the best start in life - and this will be different for everyone.


Reply Reply Report
Daedalus
4.00 (Good) | March 2006 | Daedalus
a dad in agreement
It's easier from my perspective to whole heartedly agree with you as it's my partner that wakes up in the middle of the night to feed our daughter, and it's my partner who is constantly living at the whim of our daughter's hunger. However, the health benefits of breast feeding are difficult to deny and the corporate propaganda behind the formula industry is difficult to take seriously (Nestle has representatives in African villages giving "educational seminars" wherein they try to teach tribal women that their breast milk could actually be harmful to the babies whereas formula ensures their children a beneficial nutritional source).

If you're worried about passing mercury from eating seafood, there seem to be some quick fixes for this problem that I've either read about or was told of:

* Don't eat tuna yourself (tuna live a long time and take in a lot of mercury).

* If you need fish, try to only eat smaller fish with extremely short life spans.

* If you just love larger fish, ones with lifespans below 3 years seem to have low enough mercury levels.

* Supplement your diet with either Hempseed Oil or Flaxseed oil (both in some sort of rotation is even better).

Nice post.


Reply Reply Report
      ClayCook
3.68 (Good) | April 2006 | ClayCook
Re: a dad in agreement
Great comment - good advice.


Reply Reply Report
      mrsesquilo
5.00 (Excellent) | August 2006 | mrsesquilo
a dad in agreement
Wonderful post! I am somewhat baffled by all the comments here wherein people attack the very validity of the concept of "breast is best." (Breast milk is an infinitely superior food for babies. It's the PERFECT food for babies. That's not an opinion, folks. That's just a fact.) It's a relief to see someone with your level of awareness. Another safer fish choice, by the way, is Sockeye Salmon. Sockeye is very low in mercury and is chock full of healthy oils. Yum!


Reply Reply Report

Know someone who would like this site? Refer a friend