minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 
RSS

griz
griz | August 6th

Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

I am getting 2 cows done for meat. Anyway it was never a secret. We have had home kill before. Anyway my 6 year old daughter has voiced that she is upset about one cow in particular being eaten. It is a bit over a year old and she hasn't really had much to do with it but has decided that its her cow. Even though all the kids have always known that cows are for meat and milk and some we eat and some we don.t.
So my idea - Is this wrong to tell her? That 'her' cow has gone to live on another farm and we swapped that farm for a meat cow which we are eating. What do you think or should I just tell her the hard truth that we are eating that cow?

Write Answer Got an answer... share it now Report

Other answers to this question:


griz
August 16th | griz
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

Well the cows  went last Friday and all of a sudden she is fine with it LOL. I didnt lie to her at all. She knows which ones we are eating. I also sent 2 to the saleyards so 4 cows are gone now.

I have considered all of the below answers (wow what a lot of emotions from childhood memories) but I did decide that I wouldnt lie to her about it. The cow was never her actual 'pet' as such but she just had a sort of ownership over it. She is looking forward to tasting the meat. So am I!

 



Reply Reply Report
      Arna
August 16th | Arna
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

LOL.  That's great!

If she understands that they are meant to be eaten, then it is easier.  Treat it like veggies, she helps to grow them, so she can eat them!!! LOL



Reply Reply Report
anniebabe
August 8th | anniebabe
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

this is tough. i had a lamb as a pet. we would bottle feed her. then she grew into a sheep. My family had her butchered and she was our meal. Of course i didnt eat any . i couldnt bring myself to.

when i went overseas for the first time in 1979 , my uncle lived in the country. he had a sheep slaughtered for dinner. I happened to walk past in the kitchen and saw it there with his head still atached. Even though he wasnt my pet, needless to say i wouldnt eat any meat that night . Only pasta.  My uncle was so upset. He tried to get me to eat meat but i couldnt bring myself to eat it. Mind you i have seen whole meats hanging in the butchers but somehow seeing the head still attached made me more emotional .   I was 20 at the time!!! 

i dont know whats the best thing to do but i know if you tell her the truth she will be upset. It wont be a short term upset either. It will stay with her.  She probably wont eat any either.  

anniexxx



Reply Reply Report
      griz
August 16th | griz
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

That is hard Annie! Poor little lamb. It's one reason I wouldnt let my kids bottle feed an animal destined for the table. Also we don't name animals we are planning to eat but we do call them a food name. Like Salami for the pig, the steer was called black. And it's best not to handle animals that y our planning on eating either, or no more than you need to.

My sisters and I actually had a pet lamb in our yard at Nambucca when we were little kids. We brought it home from my grandfather's farm at Inverell. Then one day we came home from school and the lamb was gone. It had strangled itself on it's tether. (at least thats what I have always believed all these years but hmmm after reading below who knows.....



Reply Reply Report
Arna
August 8th | Arna
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

In farming communities, or where livestock are kept as pets, its important that children learn early on that an animal is intended for the plate.

Sure, you are going to have tears, but telling them the truth isn't going to haunt you as badly as not telling.



Reply Reply Report
      griz
August 16th | griz
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

I do agree Arna. Especially when I read comments below and parents have actually let the kids eat the 'pet' then told them later. I guess the intention was good but it really seems to have a lasting effect.

At least my parents told me BEFORE  they killed and BURNT the ducks, even though I thought we were bringing them home as pets. I even helped pluck them LOL



Reply Reply Report
sandy41
August 8th | sandy41
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie
I would lie sorry but we all tell little white lies eg tooth fairy, santa, easter bunny but we just have to remember our little white lies. lol


Reply Reply Report
mystikal
August 7th | mystikal
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

I wish I could help you with your question I'm a big softy - I would let Rai keep his cow LOL

Just wanted to wish you luck!



Reply Reply Report
      griz
August 16th | griz
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

Thanks for the good wishes. All has turned out well. There will be more calves in the future.



Reply Reply Report
      janicepovey
August 7th | janicepovey
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

 I'm with Mel, I'm a softie also....but if your going to say anything to her my only advice don't lie.



Reply Reply Report
Jessgore
August 6th | Jessgore
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

My mother also raises cows...  Depending on your type of cow you could say you sold her as a milking cow and leave it at that.. Maybe she won't realize that you have twice the amount of meat you would not normally have from one cow.

Good luck with that...

Would you believe my mother has named all her cows, brushes their hair, and scratches their face lightly and they love it.. It is going to be very hard for her to part with her cows when they are old enough to go....



Reply Reply Report
      Arna
August 8th | Arna
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

In the meantime, those cows are producing the finest quality beef because they are less stressed.

I always treated the cattle at the ag college I attended like they were more than just meat on legs.  Was able to get them to cooperate more too.  But, I always remembered that they were destined for someones dinner plate and never seemed to have an issue with it, which is odd, considering how I am about animals.



Reply Reply Report
danielblake
August 6th | danielblake
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

i would tell her the "white lie", i remember when i was a kid i had a pet chook ( well it wasnt really my pet but ya know lol) and one day we had roast chick for tea..then later my mum told me that it was my chook..i burst into hysterics and ran to my room..after that i decided to become a vegitarian...i lasted like a month or so lol, anyway..i wouldnt tell her that you sent off the cow to be killed, saying it went o a better farm with lots of other cows would be better, then when she is older i would tell her :)



Reply Reply Report
      griz
August 16th | griz
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

I actually didnt have to tell her the 'white lie'. She watched the cows loaded on the truck and told me she cant wait to taste the meat! So that kinda made that one a little easier.

Thats pretty sad about your chook. I'm wondering if you still eat chicken LOL. It is pretty mean to actually tell you after you'd eaten it. they could have said something before. That's what my parents id when they ate my ducks. Actually we didnt even get to eat them because Mum burnt them!



Reply Reply Report
Rukia
August 6th | Rukia
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

dont lie to her. my grandad did when my rabbits went missing and we had yummy rabbit stew. it broke my heart when Dad finaly told me a few years later.

just remind her thats what life is about. if you are religious remind her that god gave us grain and animals to eat.

But dont lie to her



Reply Reply Report
      griz
August 16th | griz
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

How awful of them cooking your pets. Same thing happened to me when I was a kid except it was ducks. And to top it all off my mum burnt them! Still havn't quite gotten over that one.

This cow isnt actually her pet though. It's just out in the paddock and she has never handled it. So she knows the truth. And thinking of what you said and from my own memories of the ducks I just decided not to lie to her. So thanks for the input



Reply Reply Report
soozntone
August 6th | soozntone
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

I think this one very much depends on your daughter's personality..  Is she likely to get over it within a reasonable period of time?  If yes go with the harsh truth..  And then just make her favourite meal not hiding the fact that it's meat.  Then she can either sit by and eat vegies whilst the rest of the family eat dinner..  Or she can get over it and eat it..

I have not experienced it.  But I believe it is reasonably common for children to go through a stage of not liking the fact that they are eating animals.

Good luck



Reply Reply Report
      griz
August 16th | griz
Re: Should I tell my daughter a White Lie

LOL She would probably eat the meat anyway before she touched the veges. I get excited if she eats a leaf of lettuce or chews the celery tops.



Reply Reply Report

Related Content

Add

No related content has been added

Related Tags

Add

None

Bookmarks

No bookmarks found