Graphic details? I missed those! LOL.
Every birth is different. Just because you had a bad experience with your first, doesn't mean it will be the same with the others. Actually, it should be easier because your daughter has paved the way so to speak.
Talk with your medical staff about your experiences and what you want. Especially about your fear of tearing like you did last time, as it can lead to prenatal depression.
I'm not an advocate of a C-section without a valid medical reason. Recovery time is much longer, you aren't able to move around for the first few hours after delivery and post natal depression is more common amongst women who have c-sections.
In addition to that, women have a harder time trying to breastfeed because they are so sore and you can't lift anything heavier than your baby for several weeks, which makes doing anything hard. Housework has to fall by the way because you just can't bend and stretch as normal, so keep that in mind.
Often, women can feel a sense of failure, even if a c-section is planned, and this can cause bonding issues with their baby, and onto the pnd.
On the upside, you know when your baby will be born, you don't have to be hours in labour and it is relatively pain free.
Ultimately, the choice is yours, but i prefer vaginal births because I can go home the same day and get my new normal going asap, which is important with so many kids (5! lol). If you have friends who would be prepared to be with you when you give birth, who have had more kids than you and can keep calm and help you keep focused, then have them there. I'd do it, but no transport! LOL.
Most of all, keep talking to your medical team, even raising your voice if they are brushing you off, so that you are treated like a person, not just another baby producing machine.
And no, you don't have to suck it up. No one should ever tell you you should because they aren't you and don't know what you experienced. Just read as much as you can and ask specific questions, we are more than happy to help after all.