minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 
RSS

babysmartsdad
babysmartsdad | October 2006

What do you think of the Domans?

The Domans have some books - How to teach your child to read and how to teach your child math - that rely on strict flashcard routines.  They call it the gentle revolution and have some good theory behind their ideas.

But the flashcards seem a little outrageous and maybe a bit over the top.  What are people's opinons on the flashcards?  I've done a few searches here and haven't found much on the Domans or flashcards.

Write Answer Got an answer... share it now Report

Other answers to this question:


StacieSkehan
4.60 (Excellent) | October 2006 | StacieSkehan
What do you think of the Domans?

I haven't heard of the 'Domans' as such, but i've just finished my degree in teaching and just feel that sitting a child down and making them memorise flash cards is boring and meaningless for both involved! Reading is more than knowing what the word 'says' as such, they need to know the meaning and understanding of both the word and the sentence.

 Learning can be fun and occur in every part of the child's life, you dont need to set aside an amount of time to learn cards. Count stairs as you walk up them, create signs for your child's room or cubby houses and read stories and talk about them. Children really learn best when it is fun, meaningful and they can see a purpose to it - a reason to count or a reason to read.

Dont get me wrong if your child enjoys playing memory or another games with the cards then they are certainly doing no harm but is it fair to make a young child sit and memorise cards if they dont want to? They are only young for such a short time, let them explore the world with all their senses and learn in a way that's best for them - before too long they'll be put behinds desks and told what and how to learn.



Reply Reply Report
      babysmartsdad
5.00 (Excellent) | October 2006 | babysmartsdad
What do you think of the Domans?
Well, they aren't traditional flashcards.

They do many sets a day, for very small periods of time - they know a child's attention span will shrink as the child grows older and can move and explore. They do suggest starting while they are 6 months or younger, because the children do tend to sit there.

They suggest learning words first - and then letters. Because words actually mean something and are used in all the interactions they see. Learning letters is too abstract at first. They suggest learning the words first, then after they understand how words work and what they are good for, they can learn how to build words. And how to say new words. And understand new words.

I agree with how learning should be captured throughout all aspects of a child's day - which is why I wonder - why not add flashcards to the mix?  The doman way in no way prohibits other ways of learning - they encourage it - but they also have a twist on things which makes me curious about them. Though they are rather dated too.

Still, their story interests me, as they started work with disabled children, using exercises (including flashcards) to help these brain damaged children to perform at the same level as "average" kids.  Their work was successful. And then they went on to ask -

Why are non-brain damaged kids, performing at only an "average" level? 

Zing.  So, I like that story and am just looking for people with more experience with the Doman style.  The fact that it isn't part of a teaching degree program might be telling too though!


Reply Reply Report
           StacieSkehan
October 2006 | StacieSkehan
What do you think of the Domans?

Can you tell me more, they have me quite interested, is it just a picture with a word that you are showing? and then the child remembers it? The fact that they say learn the word first then the letter has caught my interest....

And just because they aren't in the teaching degree doesnt signal much! You'd be surprised how much the actual degree misses out, i think the past few months in a classroom has taught me a lot more than the 4 years at uni! :)

 



Reply Reply Report
                iahpinfo
April 2008 | iahpinfo
Re: What do you think of the Domans?

I recommend you read How To Teach Your Baby to Read, by Glenn Doman and Janet Doman. There are over 5 million copies in print, and you can purchase it at amazon.com. Glenn Doman founded an organization named the Institutes for the Achievement of Human Potential, an organization that works with both well and brain-injured children. The organization teaches that child brain growth and development can be speeded. It is based on neuroplasticity, the concept that the brain has the ability to grow and expand itself through stimulation. It is a revolutionary method, and tens of thousands of parents swear by it. Also, if you go to youtube and search "Doman", you will find videos of parents teaching their children to read. Pretty amazing!

 



Reply Reply Report

Related Content

Add

No related content has been added

Related Tags

Add

None

Bookmarks

No bookmarks found