minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 
RSS

DoctorC
DoctorC | February 2007

Out of control

My wife and I have a 19 month old son who, from the moment he came home from the hospital, has been extremely tempermental and high maintenence.  He had colic for three months, and literally would cry almost every waking second.  He cried before, during, and after feedings, whether he was wet or dry, so much in fact that it was impossible to tell whether he was uncomfortable or not.  I can still remember the days of taking turns, two hours at a time, trying every technique imaginable with cotton sticking out of my ears using the 5 S's (Harvey Karp technique, the only thing that seemed to work at times).  The interesing thing is, our son gets nothing but accolades from the daycare providers who say he is very well behaved all day.  We've also noticed that whenever we have our parents in town, he makes a liar out of us, but the moment they leave, it's like a rebound effect.  Needless to say, we are stressed out and frustrated.  We've tried ignoring the tantrums, putting him in the corner with a pacifier until he calms down, cuddling him during tantrums, and distraction by jokes or goofy faces, but it feels like we are just postponing the inevitable.  My questions are, 1) have other people had children whose mood seems to change with about as much predictability as the weather, regardless of the interventions used by the parents?  2) Do children ever grow out of this, or are we looking at having stages of grief throughout his childhood (lately, it feels like it)?  3) Have other people had problems where their children behave well in daycare or with parents, but are unruly at home?  I am truly humbled by this experience.  Please help.



Write Answer Know a little? Give an answer Write Advice Know a lot? Write some advice Report


External Links

No external links found

Related Content   [Add link]

No related content found

 

Want to help? Know a little? Give an answer or Know a lot? Write some Advice

Other answers to this question:


RebeccaDorant
March 2007 | RebeccaDorant
don't panic
although i was harsh in my comments on your articles this seems like a genuine call for help... and as such here is my 2c... firstly dont panic, easier said than done hey... babies and todlers still do all their comunicating without language and that includes what you are saying to them with your body posture and facial expressions if he can sence you are wound up it will rub off on him and it will only get worse... i found that a good way to overcome the 4 hour middle of the night screaming sessions that i used to have with my son was to sing to him. i think it helped me more than him but at least i could stay calm and not completely lose my cool. my partner on the otherhand has a slightly shorter fuse lol if either you or your wife is like that then it will work better if that person is out of sight of your son when he gets upset... all it is, is frustration with his environment and lack of finer motor skills to manipulate it... also try keeping life fairly simple and without too much distraction for him just for a while... it might just be that he's overwhelmed by it all at the moment, (just like mum and daddy :)...) finally, it gets easier... even with a high maintanince child. once they can communicate using language they tend to be the intelegent and motivated ones. :)'s for you, hang in there


Reply Reply Report
Marguerite
February 2007 | Marguerite
Out of control
Hi - I've already posted a comment on your homepage.  Firstly, about tantrums.  Yes, he will grow out of them.  I found that nothing worked other than just me walking away and ignoring it.  Secondly, yes, children will behave in front of others but not at home. They are comfortable with you and they can predict your reactions whereas they're not so sure about others.  It's so frustrating when this happens because then when you try to share your experience people look at your blankly.  My mother is known for saying "oh, she doesn' t do that with me" ... and I just want to stab her in the eyeball with a fork when she says things like that. Thirdly, whilst he will grow out of the current challenges they will be replaced by new ones.  But I have discovered that the older they get the easier it gets to communicate with them and, consequently, the less frustrated they feel.  I hope this helps.   


Reply Reply Report
      DoctorC
February 2007 | DoctorC
Out of control
Thank you for the reply.  Sounds like our mothers are in cahoots.  Although I'm sure it is well intentioned....that is, to show that your child is not as bad as you think, but it sure has a way of contributing to feelings of inadequacy.  It is reassuring to hear from you that things may get better as communication improves.  Have a great day.


Reply Reply Report
breannababy
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | breannababy
Out of control
Hi there,I too have one of these high need children.Mind you B was mildly lactose intolerant so she had a reason in earlier life,she has grown out of that but is still highly sensitive to food additives like sugar,sodium and colourings.If she has the wrong foods boy do we pay for it LOL.I think perhaps your toddler thrives on different stimuli eg,day care and your parents etc the only method that seems to work with B is giving her a time out.I will go and get her as soon as she calms down though so she has a clear knowledge of what we will tolerate from her behaviour.I refuse to pander to her tantrums,when B goes into full throttle I dont fuss or coddle I just say calmly "OK B you can calm down now or I will put you to bed"Now she has no doubt I mean it and she knows I will not let her out until she has calmed down.Oh dear she has flung herself off the bed spun around on the floor kicked and screetched seemingly possessed.I let her go as long as she is not ill or hurt I know she is just wanting her own way or attention from me.I will add that having my method in place for quite a while now is brilliant the tantrums are fewer and usually food related only now,even then I will still use above method.I find the calmer I can remain the easier and more efficient I can deal with B and her tantrums.Hope this has helped a bit regards Merle


Reply Reply Report
MummaBear
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | MummaBear
Out of control
Although not a crier, my daughter has always a high needs child. She slept 3 times for 10 minutes through the day and that was it. I didn't mind though.  She did feed every hour at times so I would be putting washing in the dryer while feeding her or vaccuuming while feeding her.  People who dropped in unannounced thought it was the funniest thing.  I think children generally who are 'difficult' children are the more alert ones.  I have been told this behaviour is what makes the high-fliers of our society so successful and they were probably disgusting as babies, the ones you want to return to the hospital for a refund!  Hang in there, in another 20 years we'll see if these high demand children really are as great as I've been told they will be.


Reply Reply Report
      zacsmum
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | zacsmum
Out of control
I hope your right, that will mean I'll be well taken care of in old age!! LOL


Reply Reply Report
Deborahsc2203
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | Deborahsc2203
Out of control

My twin where high matinence for years ,, its like they can pick up on our stress and frustraitions they hardy slept while i was with them , ,, , when people came over i looked like a lier also ( I think they where just destracted thats why they where ok ) .

can i suggest taking your son to the park to run arround with a ball for while to get all that energy out



Reply Reply Report
lucky321
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | lucky321
Out of control

Yes sometimes i find kids behaving this  waty,but  not vey often though . Its like somrthing come over them and just go for it.

i deal with by the  the next time they want a treat  ,At that age i would pack up there flouvar toys  or wouldn't aloud them to watch a show that they like . my kids soon learnt iy wasn't worth carrying on .Even today when they  carrying on like two old the same thing happens no movies or hiring games no sleep overs .I found this work for me .



Reply Reply Report
Izzy
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | Izzy
Out of control

I have a 23 month old son and is also high-spirited/high-need from the day he was born. He was very very alert infant so when we were out, he hardly cries - though this meant he didn't nap very well either. He absorbed anything and everything around him. He never cried 24 hrs a day, but when he did cry, he cried loudly and insistently. Now as a toddler, he is pretty much the same way. He knows instantly if something changed in the room. He is harder to put down to nap when we have visitors. But all in all, of course he is much easier now than when he was an infant.

If you think your child is high-need, I suggest visiting Dr. Sears' website http://www.askdrsears.com/search.asp. There's also a link for survival tips for parents of high-need children.

 



Reply Reply Report
upinchina
5.00 (Excellent) | February 2007 | upinchina
Out of control

My children are the same way with other people. It seems they save it for me. One day my 4 yr old was very tired from the weekend and gave the teacher a little taste of the medicine she usually saves for me. Boy, was the teacher surprised. I think the kids know what they can get away with other people and can probably get away with more things with the parents. When my 4 yr old was out of control like that at 19 months, I'd put her in her room for quiet time. Once I even threw myself on the floor, and pretended to cry and scream like her, and said that  was not allowed. She seemed to get it from there.  I think it was at 2 or 2 1/2 that I started making her earn toys with her behavior which included no tantrums on the floor, no crying to eat, no crying to bathe, etc. That also seemed to help curb the tantrums because she knew that she was not earning stars for the item she wanted.  Good luck, it gets better.



Reply Reply Report
upinchina
February 2007 | upinchina
Out of control

My children are the same way with other people. It seems they save it for me. One day my 4 yr old was very tired from the weekend and gave the teacher a little taste of the medicine she usually saves for me. Boy, was the teacher surprised. I think the kids know what they can get away with other people and can probably get away with more things with the parents. When my 4 yr old was out of control like that at 19 months, I'd put her in her room for quiet time. Once I even threw myself on the floor, and pretended to cry and scream like her, and said that  was not allowed. She seemed to get it from there.  I think it was at 2 or 2 1/2 that I started making her earn toys with her behavior which included no tantrums on the floor, no crying to eat, no crying to bathe, etc. That also seemed to help curb the tantrums because she knew that she was not earning stars for the item she wanted.  Good luck, it gets better.



Reply Reply Report