minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 
RSS

KathrynR1402
KathrynR1402 | March 2007

Boys & girls playing separately

Hi! Just a question for those of you with school-aged (or older) kids:

My 4 1/2 year old daughter mostly plays with boys - all her "best friends" are boys, but I've noticed that by 6 the girls almost exclusively with girls & boys with boys. I'm trying to encourage her to play with more girls and saying "when you're older the boys may not want to play with you coz you're a girl" but HOW OLD DOES THIS SEPARATION HAPPEN? I fear this is imminent and I might need to do more encouraging urgently!



Write Answer Know a little? Give an answer Write Advice Know a lot? Write some advice Report


External Links

No external links found

Related Content   [Add link]

No related content found

 

Want to help? Know a little? Give an answer or Know a lot? Write some Advice

Other answers to this question:


Dawn
March 2007 | Dawn
Boys & girls playing separately
Why does the sex of a child come into play at all? As long as they are friends and treating each other as they should then there should never be a problem with girls and boys hanging out! Point of fact just 2 nights ago 2 of my 11 yr old sons friends dropped by to ask for his help in finding a lost cat! They are both girls after searching for about an hour, they chose to have a snoeball fight in our backyard instead. One of the girls is 11 and the other is 12. they have been friends since first grade, and why should that change just because of their age? my daughters who are 20, 21 & 24 still hang out with their guy friends that they have had since public school, they are pals and always will be so what do you forsee as the problem? Why seperate friends just because of gender? Do you have any male friends or are all of them female? Let them have the friends that make them happy, they are kids for such a short time why put pessure on them when its not necessary!


Reply Reply Report
llmunchkin
March 2007 | llmunchkin
Boys & girls playing separately
Your daughter was born as a clean slate... Let her paint her own life picture without you projecting her worries on to her.  Just nurture her, guide her & be there for her IF this so-called separation occurs - I can't say it EVER happened to me.  Everyone needs all different sorts of friends, the fact is - she has friends - this is the most important thing.

Boys have better toys, are a lot more fun & they aren't half as nasty as a lot of young ladies can be.  They say what they mean, that makes them seem mean, but they are a lot easier to understand because of this.  She sounds like a very sensible young lady to me.


Reply Reply Report
lucky321
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | lucky321
Boys & girls playing separately

Well when i was growing up thought the years i play with boys more so then girls  ,My bothers mates use to come over and we all knock around togther , and some of us are still in touch today.

I just let it be  , also i fine one of sons knock around with more girls then boys and the other compelte oppoised to that  .



Reply Reply Report
Wendigo
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | Wendigo
Boys and girls are children - what's the big deal?

I personally find encouraging children to segregate by such superficial sexist social casting to be offensive.  Would you tell your child she is should not be playing with children of a different skin colour?  Or to not play with children that aren't of exactly the same religion?  Children will naturally segregate into groups, but it's not by gender, it's by interest.  Boys usually prefer boyish things, and girls prefer girlish things, so they separate for that reason.  You will still find the occassional girl hanging out with the boys or boy with the girls, because they have similar interests. There is nothing wrong with that. The kids that break the standard gender interests will only stop doing so when external pressure from other kids teasing them makes them stop - and the other kids usually only tease because parents teach and encourage the idea that 'boys don't do that, girls don't do this' nonsense in the first place.

I was never one for having girly friends, I always prefered to play with the boys just because their games were more interesting to me.  I didn't want to play dolls or tea sets, and the other girls didn't want to play cars and ride bikes, play footy, etc; so I stuck with having the friends that were doing the things I was most interested in.  Consequently I was the girl that played it rough with the boys from Kindy right through to... well... still do!

I'm inclined to say, let your daughter choose her own friends with similar interests to her.  You wouldn't want someone coming along and dictating to you who you should be talking to or what you should be interested in reading on Minti now would you? Sure, if your daughter starts hanging out with a group of kids that are totally undesirable and into doing all the wrong things, then certainly that should be discouraged, but other than that, it's really up to her who she hangs out with.

My 7 year old son's best friend is a girl in his class, has been since their first day at school.  They both play with cars and dolls together equally and have a lot of similar interests.  It's really good.  He gets on better with the girls in the class, and his little best friend gets along better with the boys.  I wish more kids could interact like that and show the rest of society how to forget about the whole sexist social casting nonsence that goes on.

Just my thoughts.



Reply Reply Report
      KathrynR1402
March 2007 | KathrynR1402
Boys and girls are children - what's the big deal?
Thanks for your thoughts! Don't worry, I'm not trying to dictate to her, I was trying to explain to her why the 6 year old boys she's always played with were being mean to her and wouldn't play with her any more. Fortunately most of the 3 & 4 year olds do still play with her, and she'll be in the same class as them.


Reply Reply Report
cookclan
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | cookclan
Boys & girls playing separately
Hiya all the way through school my mates were guys....My best mate of 21 years is a guy....I never played with the girls for a few reasons for one they wanted to play girly games and I wanted to be rough and tumble you know....Then as I got older girls were just so nasty and I was not interested in their rubbish....I had a couple of female friends when I got older but only ones who were interested in normal stuff not girly stuff....I dont think its a big problem most of the boys when I was younger still played with me after they worked out girl germs too because they saw me as one of the boys....Just my thoughts on it
Cheers
Angie


Reply Reply Report
      KathrynR1402
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | KathrynR1402
Boys & girls playing separately
Thanks! You sound like my daughter - her best friends are all boys coz she loves rough & tumble and the girls (and their mums) get scared off! But some of the boys do too!


Reply Reply Report
nell18-3
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | nell18-3
Boys & girls playing separately
My daughter always had mostly boy friends too and even now she has a few close girl friends that she has know for years and also lots boy friends. She says you can have a laugh with the boys and there are no catty remarks!! Your child will make her own friends male or female to suit her needs
xx


Reply Reply Report
mandymum3
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | mandymum3
Boys & girls playing separately
Kids will be kids. you cant choose there friends for them. Rather guied them softly in the right direction. You'll find at this age though, 1 day they will be friends and the next day they wont. Dont stress about it too much, She'll have lots of girl friends soon!!


Reply Reply Report
      KathrynR1402
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | KathrynR1402
Boys & girls playing separately

True! Yesterday she fell out with and made up with one of her best mates all in the space of half an hour. But she was so heartbroken, and I was too watching her!

Thanks!



Reply Reply Report
narni
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | narni
Boys & girls playing separately
personally i dont think its something that needs to b interfered with, not at this point anyway they work it out themselves usually. i would b worried that saying these types of things to her will create a real sense of difference in herself an inferiority complex if u will. i know heaps of little tomboys who play with their 'boy' friends and cruise along quite fine with it.


Reply Reply Report
youngmumof2
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | youngmumof2
Boys & girls playing separately
I don't think this is anything to huge. I was the same when i was l younger and still am. I have always had more guy friends than girl friends. I have just been more comfortable around guys, they don't bitch as much. haha. She will sort things out for herself so i doubt you have to do anything. Some girls just want to hang out with the guys. When i got to the "boy" stage of my childhood i wasn't that into it like most girls. I think that was mainly due to the fact that i had hung around them all my life. So it could be a blessing when she hits those boy crazy years. I think just let her go and if it does start to be a problem then step in but for now just let her be. Hope this helps.


Reply Reply Report
      KathrynR1402
5.00 (Excellent) | March 2007 | KathrynR1402
Boys & girls playing separately

Thanks! Good advice!

I think I'm just trying to help her avoid rejection, as if I could ever do that! My own insecurities coming out - aren't kids great at doing that!



Reply Reply Report
           youngmumof2
March 2007 | youngmumof2
Boys & girls playing separately
 No worries. Glad to help out another minti member who needs it. That's understandable. We all want to protect our kids from being hurt or left out. Natural reaction really.


Reply Reply Report