minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 
RSS

cazza
cazza | April 2007

no homework- whats your views..

i read today in thats life that tasmanian department/or government is trying to stop homework.. My opioion is that some children learn from home as well as school and homework is ok in moderation, but children do learn enough at school as well.. so just want some advise, no critisism please

Write Answer Know a little? Give an answer Write Advice Know a lot? Write some advice Report


External Links

No external links found

Related Content   [Add link]

No related content found

 

Want to help? Know a little? Give an answer or Know a lot? Write some Advice

Other answers to this question:


Jessgore
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | Jessgore
no homework- whats your views..
HMMMM Interesting topic this one.

I think home work is good.   It gives the parents a real chance at seeing how their child works out problems, and maybe able to come up with a few solutions to maybe that child not doing so well at school.

Then my sister in-law who was a teacher said she never gave her kids home work because they did a lot of it in the class.  I think it would depend on the age.   Here at the moment my step daughter when she comes here on a weekend she always has homework, but it is not that much, and it is given at the beginning of the week and they hand it in on the following Monday. Meaning they have a whole week to do what ever it is. And usually it is a very small amount of work. 

She has a lot of issues at school getting most of the time 25% to 50% out of 100% so in her case I would say the extra help is really needed.   We can see where she gets frustrated, where her strengths are and where her weakness lies.  

I don't agree on homework every  night, but given time to spread it out is great. That way they still have time to play on the weekends. And still be kids..
One last word...

Parents who are able to help their kids do their home work are able to give individual coaching where as teachers are not always able to do so, and Parents can also try to help get things a little exciting. Hard to explain that but when I watch my step daughter and hubby do homework together I see them bonding and having fun with it.  It gets done.


Reply Reply Report
4BOYZ
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | 4BOYZ
no homework- whats your views..
Kids are in school for 6 hours a day. If the teacher can't teach our kids enough in those hours then I don't believe they are very good teachers. I mean to say, we go to work and once your shift has finished you stop what your doing and go home. You don't take work home and continue doing it, so why should kids. Thats just my opinion.


Reply Reply Report
      MummaBear
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | MummaBear
no homework- whats your views..
depends on your job if you take work home with you, I take on average 15 hours worth of work home with me each week, sometimes more. In the lead up to Mothers' Day I will bring home more just to finish it off.  But I agree, my brother's school is 8:30 to 3:30 so when you take out 1 hour worth of breaks, he is in the classroom for 6 hours of that time and doesn't do his homework. Like Madchanny said, it's also what brings his grades and comments down in school even though he does well in exams and with assignments.  He does too much after school to worry about homework and I'd rather he earnt money than did homework.


Reply Reply Report
           madchanny
April 2007 | madchanny
no homework- whats your views..
oh yeah! forgot all about me working when in high school, how could they have expected me to do homework when i went to work at hungry jacks (burger king) straight after school? man i was just a kid and after work i was drained, and i needed to earn that extra cash at the time :(
xx channy


Reply Reply Report
      madchanny
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | madchanny
no homework- whats your views..
i totally agree with you here, kids are learning at school for 6 - 6.5 hours a day, and i do believe they need a break, i was at school up until i fell pregnant with Koen so that was just over 2 years ago, and like i said to the teachers when i was in school, '' at school you are doing your school work, and once you are home... you are home so why should i do school work at home?''    i never had the time or patience to do any homework, i had chores, dinner and sleep... i barely even had the time to watch tv at all,

i do think children should still bring home a reader (book that the child has to read to parents) so that the parent can have one on one time to help the child out with their reading, but my niece is 10 and has to do homework every night (which is irrelivent to the school work she does during the day) which I dont even understand... so how could a ten year old figure it out?

sorry its a bit of a touchy subject for me as homework was the only thing that lowered my grades, and other than that, i was a top student at the schools i have been to :)

cheers, channy xx


Reply Reply Report
           cazza
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | cazza
no homework- whats your views..
well i agree with you channy and yes i love the home reader part as it is also helping chloe get ready for school next year.. but what i cant understand is iof the teachers want our children to do homework, why cant they explain it better to the parents so then our children dont get stressed and we can be there to help them......


Reply Reply Report
princesskc88
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | princesskc88
no homework- whats your views..
yeh mummabear i could do it now way easier but when i was @ school it felt so hard thats wat i men t:P, i have done the same apprentiiceship i loved lol dat ws school and work sooo chill ok mummabear .........dude


Reply Reply Report
wolonfab
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | wolonfab
no homework- whats your views..
I know in yr 11 and 12 i was doing 5 hours a night trying to keep up with assignments...I had no life at all.....

My son is in year 1 and he was doing 3 pages last year.... He really struggles with homework cause he doesn't get why he has to do it at home when he spends all day doing it at school...This year he is just refusing to do it at all...He is hiding it and wont even bring it home sometimes....so i spend my time trying to explain to the teacher i dont get it ...

I think homework is good in moderation but i feel it is often pushed too hard and too much is given sometimes(esp from classes at high school)......

hugs


Reply Reply Report
      cazza
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | cazza
no homework- whats your views..
thats my thoughts as well, its all good that we as parents can assist our children with their education, but the education depmartment need to structure it and maintain it in moderation while the children are little... When they get to high school and college thats when they mostly struggle and need help with their schooling from parents and teachers..


Reply Reply Report
iancherine
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | iancherine
no homework- whats your views..

the amount of home work that secondary schools (and increasingly, primary schools)expect of  their students is phenomenal and unrealistic, as it is only school, generally that requires that much home work,, i mean if you have a job how much of it do you do at home?(not including stay at home parents whom have never known the pleasure of clocking off!!) I think up to one hour per night is plenty, until you get to exams etc in yr 11 and 12, then i suppose it depends on the student and by then they might have learned the value of study! I have a twenty year old son, who completed year twelve in 2004, and He studied up to five hours per night and on Saturdays, (he took Sundays off)during most of that year.  it nearly burned him out, He passed with good scores thankfully but even he doesnt think it was worth all that home work!  When i went to school we had a two hour bus ride each way to and from school, so i did all my home work on the bus and my parents didn't see any of it, but we didn't need the Internet back then, it'd be hard to do home work on the bus these days!  Ian.



Reply Reply Report
      cazza
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | cazza
no homework- whats your views..
5 hours that is a lot to do, wow when did he get time to do what he wanted... and it is hard these days as most of the homework does require internet...


Reply Reply Report
Deborahsc2203
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | Deborahsc2203
no homework- whats your views..
my boys go to a catholic school oh gezzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz the homework and the assignments are way too much they dont get their sleep because they both need to be able to use the internet for the information and being twins it has to be differnt information also ,,so i had to go out and get another computer just for school work ,,  they also get assigments on holidays ontop of their homework and struggle to have a social life out of school hours because of this ,they are in year 10 now,, its been this way since year 7 .. home works fine but not the amount they have been getting from this school and most assigments are 700 words pluss it makes it hard also when your children are not up to the same standard of the class they are in , theres no excuse in this school for not having a computer or no ink or even computer problems it all has to be done and done on time , it is the same for every year at this school also ,some of my boys have friends that go to others schools and they dont get as much as what my boys do ,,


Reply Reply Report
mumof2b
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | mumof2b
no homework- whats your views..
I think homework is extremely important for all ages because you don't necessarily take it all in and process it at school because there can be so many distractions. By taking work home you can process it easier in your own time and the parents are there to help as some teachers aren't always very approachable. As long as there is a commitment from both the parents and child (of any age).......without the pressure.......that's what's given homework the bad name, especially in high school.


Reply Reply Report
      MummaBear
April 2007 | MummaBear
no homework- whats your views..
I agree that homework has its place. I think to begin with through primary school it should be mostly revision work and then replaced by assignments with study/revision in secondary school. The amount my brother gets is insane and he refuses to do it, therefore he is getting really bad comments on his report card.  I forgot to mention earlier that he is lead singer and guitarist in a band that practices 3 nights a week and plays at the local pub on a friday night.  I'd rather he was doing something that will get him somewhere in life than sitting back doing phenomenal amounts of homework that isn't going to help him out in the long-run anyway. He won't be going to Uni, he is doing a TAFE course that he does through the school holidays.


Reply Reply Report
           cazza
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | cazza
no homework- whats your views..
it certanily doesnt work for all children, so the teachers are going to want the children to do homework they need to support the parents as well, and vice versa.. I know brodie came home not very long ago with homework and we didnt even know some of the answers, thank god for the internet and google...But what about the parents that dont have that sort of access, it would be hard for the children...Hope your brother dreams come true as well...


Reply Reply Report
Ngairi
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | Ngairi
no homework- whats your views..
to give a bit more of an idea, my kids high school, the homework and study recommendations are Year 10 = 14 x 45 min sessions per week; Year 11 = 15 x 1 hour seesions adn Year 12 = 21 x 1 hours sessions.


Reply Reply Report
      MummaBear
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | MummaBear
no homework- whats your views..
That's way too much when you think of other commitments that a lot of these kids have in the way of working/family/sports commitments.  When are they able to sleep? Their performance would drop and they would start going downhill in every aspect after a while. My performance levels would drop and i am 26!  21 hours of homework for a year 12 student? That's ludicrous.  Let's see now, 7 hours of school each day (my school went from 8:30 to 3:30), which is 35 hours of school each week, 21 hours of homework each week, my brother does around 30 hours of work (paid) each week, spends around 15 - 20 hours in the water or at the pool for some carnival or special event each week, that's 106 hours out of the week.  There's only 168 hours in a week, which leaves 62 hours to relax and catch up with friends and family, doing chores around the house, and maybe take care of pets/some even have children at that age, and sleep!  If they were able to get the recommended amount of sleep, they would take a further 56 out of the 62 hours in sleep.  No wonder my brother doesn't finish his homework!


Reply Reply Report
MummaBear
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | MummaBear
no homework- whats your views..

I think that children need to have basic homework sent home with them in lower primary school which includes some spelling, addition, and a book to read to the parent/guardian.  Mostly revision work though. Then Grade 5-7 some more detailed homework like reading a novel with more pages and writing about it, or having more difficult maths homework then just revision so that in year 8 they are prepared for assignments. I think kids get enough assignments in high school that they probably don't need homework on top of it.

I also think that no more than 10/15 minutes for lower primary, no more than 1/2 an hour for upper primary and increase that gradually to no more than 1 to 1 1/2 hours a day for year 11 and 12 kids.

We have to keep in mind that many kids in high school are not only at school, they are involved in some kind of recreational/sports activity and many have jobs after school and weekends.  Heck, some even have babies to care for in year 11 or 12!

My brother is in year 12 and although he is doing well in exams and with assignments he is not completing his homework due to other commitments after school. He has a business he runs with our mother from home, he works at the pool weekends and he is Club Captain of the swimming club which means he has a lot of work to do with that. So I think there is far too much homework being sent home.

I think parents/guardians need to be more hands-on with homework in primary school and also help out as much as they can in secondary school. That's my essay for you :)



Reply Reply Report
      cazza
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | cazza
no homework- whats your views..
thanx mummabear and you get a big pass for that lol.... and yes i love the reading part of homework for my children, but the teachers say its more of a enjoyment then homework, hmmm.


Reply Reply Report
           MummaBear
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | MummaBear
no homework- whats your views..
Children learn to read by being read to.  Enjoyment or homework, they are still learning to read. I teach my daughter to read by reading to her and going over the alphabet letters with her, it's all enjoyable to her and she loves it, but she is still learning. Kids learn better if it's fun.  My 3 and a half year old can write her own name, find the letters of her name and type it using a keyboard and knows other letters too like M for Mummy and G for Grandma.  The best way to teach a child is by doing something with them that you want them to do, make it enjoyable and make it a special one-on-one time, even if you have lots of kids.


Reply Reply Report
                cazza
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | cazza
no homework- whats your views..
absolutely-  and yes my 3 year old loves reading and can write well.... so thankyou for your input here as if there were more mums like you and me wouldnt it be easier for all children to have the education they deserve


Reply Reply Report
princesskc88
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | princesskc88
no homework- whats your views..
hey as a young person my self lol 18 yrs old hehe, umm i strongly issagree with home work like if you work from 9 till like say 5 i wouldnt want too bring your work home would you no way no!!!! plus i think a project once a term is kool but no more than that!!!!!!!


Reply Reply Report
      MummaBear
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | MummaBear
no homework- whats your views..
I work 8:30 - 5 and bring approximately 15 hours of work home with me each week. In the lead-up to Christmas it was more like 20 or 30 hours worth of work that was coming home with me, and I was working 7 - 5:30 at that time too.  As well as studying through TAFE completing a subject a month which has 5 assignments on average in each subject.  So yeah, we do have to bring work home with us, and we don't even get paid for it.


Reply Reply Report
Ngairi
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | Ngairi
no homework- whats your views..

There is a big push towards no homework for schools throughout Australia. I both agree and disagree with it.

Agree because it gives me an indication of how my children are doing and at what stage they are at, if they need extra help with something, and also keeping up with what methods are being used to teach these days. This goes with both primary and high school. Also, when they get to Uni, TAFE,etc they are going to be expected to do work at home. If they do not learn at the outset, how are they ever to do this then?

Disagree because it can cut into family time, especially with the amount of parents working, sport committments, etc. and can cause great pressure on the child.A lot of parents out there (and I don't mean those on here, because as you are here I am assuming that you care about you child and how they are doing) who just don't want to have or don't care to have the time to sit down and help or supervise their children with homework.

While I fully support homework, once the kids get to high school, the amount of assignments as well as homework can be a drag. In high school, there are a lot more independent students as well these days who have to work to support themselves and this then cuts into their homework time. A child who is spending 5 hours on homework is not going to be in any state to learn the next day.

Sorry for the long answer, but as you can probably tell, homework is something I have strong views about. Cheers

Leisa



Reply Reply Report
      cazza
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | cazza
no homework- whats your views..
thanx for your views and i agree with some of your views as well... and yes i do care about my childrens education, i spend a lot of time at their school and we sit down after bathtime and look at their work they have to be done...


Reply Reply Report
LISA722
5.00 (Excellent) | April 2007 | LISA722
no homework- whats your views..
your right children do learn just aswell at home then at school but although i did read and hear about the same thing but not in tassie but in ACT schools also i believe that this would most likely not happen as all teachers seem to love is sending homework for kids and even though mine are yet to start primary school my eldest is in preschool and sometimes get sent home with homework so i doubt it will even happen but is interesting to think about though i must admit but why now that's my question???


Reply Reply Report
      cazza
April 2007 | cazza
no homework- whats your views..
yes  agree.. thanx for your views


Reply Reply Report