minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 
RSS

emmie
emmie | June 2007

When kids are talking to theirselfs

i was wondering if antyone could tell me if a child means what they say wen they are playing and talking to theirselfs ??????



Write Answer Know a little? Give an answer Write Advice Know a lot? Write some advice Report


External Links

No external links found

Related Content   [Add link]

No related content found

 

Want to help? Know a little? Give an answer or Know a lot? Write some Advice

Other answers to this question:


mrs-connell
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | mrs-connell
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs

Hi I agree with jessgore my daughter talks to some by the name of Johnny & we don't know anyone by that name.

Yesterday we were in the back yard with my parents & she started pointing at the kitchen window & my mother asked what she was pointing at & she said Johnny.

Mum asked is Johnny in the kitchen & she said yes he's going to come & play with me & then she sat down at her table & chairs & started having a conversation with this Johnny.

Now either she has an excellent imagination or this Johnny really exists.

I asked my mum is this normal behaviour & she said it is perfectly normal so I have no problems.



Reply Reply Report
Deborahsc2203
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | Deborahsc2203
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs
my son plays with his cars and has little chats to himself about it ,, all a part of growing up and interacting .. its a good thing


Reply Reply Report
Jessgore
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | Jessgore
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs
It could mean many things!  But two things come to my mind the most...

One he is talking to someone on the other side... I say this because there was a time when he used to look like he was trying to get some one to pick him up. He was talking and trying to stand up and fell down then laughed all the time looking up as if he was looking up at the person he wanted to pick him up....   it was a little freaky to watch... It was so intense yet he was having so much fun....

And second.... He has a great imagination.  Able to play by himself.... My sons imagination seems to be stuck running cars around the house at the moment.. But he talks, vroom vrooms, and all sorts of things... I think it is also a sign that he is just a happy little fellow.. :)


Reply Reply Report
sluxton
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | sluxton
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs

Chatting to themselves is a good thing.  You find out a lot of things about htem - what they are hearing, how they perceive things, they act out scenarios, role-play, use their imagination, grow their imagination.  If their is a lot of aggression in their role-play, perhaps that is what they are witnessing - either in life or in tv.  You'll know what feels right and what you need to change around them by listening.  Usually, it is just role-play though and growth of imagination which is encouraged at preschool and kindy and childcare.  Dont worry about it - listen to it from time to time though for your own amusement or curiosity - but dont let them know you are listening.

Sometimes, my son plays aggressively.  He often has been watching a lot of Powerrangers at the time, or maybe he is just copying my yelling and stress levels at time, which is a timely reminder to pull my head in and check my own attitude.  Then show him how to play nicely if it doesn't sound very "social".

Use it to your advantage, but respect it.



Reply Reply Report
sluxton
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | sluxton
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs

Chatting to themselves is a good thing.  You find out a lot of things about htem - what they are hearing, how they perceive things, they act out scenarios, role-play, use their imagination, grow their imagination.  If their is a lot of aggression in their role-play, perhaps that is what they are witnessing - either in life or in tv.  You'll know what feels right and what you need to change around them by listening.  Usually, it is just role-play though and growth of imagination which is encouraged at preschool and kindy and childcare.  Dont worry about it - listen to it from time to time though for your own amusement or curiosity - but dont let them know you are listening.

Sometimes, my son plays aggressively.  He often has been watching a lot of Powerrangers at the time, or maybe he is just copying my yelling and stress levels at time, which is a timely reminder to pull my head in and check my own attitude.  Then show him how to play nicely if it doesn't sound very "social".

Use it to your advantage, but respect it.



Reply Reply Report
emmie
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | emmie
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs

ok thanks for all those answers what if they are saYING THEY NEVER WANNA SEE SOMEONE AGAIN UNLESS MUMMY SAYS THEY HAVE TO !

THANKS



Reply Reply Report
      lightbee
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | lightbee
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs

I think we might need a little more information.  How old is the child in question?  What is their current relationship with the person they don't want to see?  What were the circumstances when this comment came out?

It could be something completely innocent and be just a child's way of relating - they hate someone one day and best friends the next - but it could also be an alarm bell depending on the context.  You're sounding pretty concerned which is making me wonder what else has been done or said that you're thinking about.



Reply Reply Report
           emmie
June 2007 | emmie
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs

ok, she is 4 yrsold , she was talking to her friend from school on telephone(pretend) and it only caught my attention when she said she never wanted to see her mother anymore.......unless mummy says i have to .which has really shocked me and am quite worried , i know she is angry with her and i dont know just how myuch but i know she has had a hate thing for her mother for a couple of weeks not that i can blame her she were supposed to see he 2 months ago we have not seen or even spoke to her since

Hope this helps a little more

thanks



Reply Reply Report
      MummaBear
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | MummaBear
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs
That's pretty normal if it's a person they are not close to or if it's someone who hasn't treated them right.  My brother said that about our father right up until our father left the state.  Our mum would try to make him go over for visits because she was sick of being told that he sees none of his kids because she stopped us from visiting.  So not true, we didn't like his company LOL.  So that's what my brother always said "Do I have to mum?" and if he had to he would, otherwise no.  Even if he did go, he sat with his phone in his hand texting his friends and wishing he was elsewhere.


Reply Reply Report
lightbee
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | lightbee
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs

Confession - I still talk to myself!  I have a pretty vivid imagination and when a scenario comes into my head I sometimes talk it out.  Pretty embarassing if someone catches me out.  If your child is anything like me, they may have the same vivid imagination but not yet have learnt what is socially acceptable and what is not.  I would think the comment that they are playing and talking to themselves is just to reassure you that they know there is noone else there even if it might sound like there is.

Unless there's something else going on that's concerning you, I wouldn't let this worry you. 



Reply Reply Report
      cheleinkal
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | cheleinkal
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs

Hahaha, no wonder we agree on most things, because so do I LOL.

I think most kids have sensational imaginations and are very apt at role playing games....they of course may be inspired by things they get from Mum & dad, hear over the fence, at School (or day Care) or T.V. etc.  My 17 month old daughter cannot yet walk on her own, but has begun to feed her dolls imaginary food, talks to them and makes slurpy eating sounds.............unless what you over hear is incredibly inapropriate, I would encourage it.  If it is inapropriate you need to find out where they heard about it from, so get down and play with them and gently nudge out the information.  if they get a whif that you are concerned, they may clam up and you'll never find out. Cheers



Reply Reply Report
llmunchkin
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | llmunchkin
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs
Like the other's say, I guess it depends what they are saying?  I think often when they are playing and talking to themselves they just repeat things that they have seen and heard.  It doesn't necessarily mean that they believe it, or mean it - they are just acting out.

You sound worried, is everything ok?


Reply Reply Report
MummaBear
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | MummaBear
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs
Hannah often chats to her thomas trains when she's playing or to her puppy toys while she's playing.  She talks to the dog too.  I don't think anything of it unless she talks about shooting people that aren't her friend, then I step in and have a talk to her about it but mostly it's just harmless things.


Reply Reply Report
Gypsie
4.60 (Excellent) | June 2007 | Gypsie
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs

Well....I guess it depends on what they are saying and in what context.

Does it sound like a 2 person conversation???

If so.....keep in mind...children under 8yr are tapped into other energies around them

( if ya know what I mean ) so that too may be an explanation.



Reply Reply Report
Jodie04
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | Jodie04
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs
Kids talk and make noises when they play there isn't too much too it unless they are souding aggressive, as the other mums said just listen in and see what story is being told. Usually it means they are contented in play.


Reply Reply Report
Ngairi
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | Ngairi
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs

Connor chats constantly to himself when he is playing. There is nothing in it, but I do listen in to check it out. Connor can make up a whole story book about whatever he is doing and it can last for hours.

Sometimes it can be that he has had a bad time with his brothers or someone at school and is quietly cursing them and acting out games with his toys and things like this car is running over dave etc. He certainly never means that he wants to run him over or see him dead or hurt, he is just voicing his frustration.

Just depends on what is going on with them and what they are saying. I would be concerned if someones name is coming up frequently in a bad way.



Reply Reply Report
luckyone
5.00 (Excellent) | June 2007 | luckyone
Re: When kids are talking to theirselfs

 a child means what they say when talking to themself  if they are upset  with something that happened that day , others they playing out in what they hear  around them and means nothing .

so i just listen to what they are saying and you know which one it is  i be talking to her or him if you know something upsetting them

julie



Reply Reply Report