minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 
RSS

HOTMAMA
HOTMAMA | November 2007

Advice and Voting

Ok, this is not so much a parenting question, but a question about the site.  Sorry in Advance.  I was just looking over the advice, where I always find great advice, but due to the back lash of a few months ago, where people were saying mean things to one another about voting people down, and I am sure it was happening, I am afraid to vote!  If I dont like it I just move on, but then that isnt really fair to the people who have written great advice.  I am just confused I guess, and there seems to be quite a few articles that are not really parenting advie just advice.  Just like this isnt really a parenting question, just a question.....how do you vote???

Write Answer Know a little? Give an answer Write Advice Know a lot? Write some advice Report


External Links

No external links found

Related Content   [Add link]

No related content found

 

Want to help? Know a little? Give an answer or Know a lot? Write some Advice

Other answers to this question:


HOTMAMA
November 2007 | HOTMAMA
Re: Advice and Voting
Thanks everyone for your input, although it was extremely helpfull I feel as if even making it known my opinion has caused an adverse reaction. I will continue to vote as to what I see fit.  I am here for the advice, and support, not to be #1, 2, 3 etc...  Thanks Again!!!


Reply Reply Report
ClayCook
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | ClayCook
Re: Advice and Voting
Please vote exactly what you think the article/advice deserves. If you believe it is poor advice then vote it a 1 or 2 stars. If you think it is ok, give it a 3, if you think it is good give it a 4, if you think it is AMAZING then give it a 5.

If someone emails you about your voting habits and you feel even slightly intimidated then let admin know immediately.

Personally I think far too many 5 stars are given out to articles that are a long way from being AMAZING. It is in Minti's best interest to help the creme rise to the top and the dirt (can't think of anything better) sink to the bottom.


Reply Reply Report
avanliamsmum
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | avanliamsmum
Re: Advice and Voting

If I personally don't like an article, or think it needs improvement, I either skip it and don't vote or I would vote and say why I did it.



Reply Reply Report
ajv00
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | ajv00
Re: Advice and Voting
When all the stuff was going around about voting Rachelcook wrote a Q about voting well it was one she had received from a member.  Click  here to read all about it, you also might like to go here to see a question she answered about articles.


Reply Reply Report
matthew
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | matthew
Re: Advice and Voting

If you want to vote or comment then you should feel frree to do so.  We take a very negative view of people who try to track down the votes placed based on the timing of comments etc.  Votes are anonymous for a reason, we had problems in the past with personal attacks against people who had voted honestly but not enthusiastically for advice.

We are working on a number of improvements to our system so that votes are more difficult to track back to their original source and so that extreme voting or attempts to game our algorythm system are not easily done.

If any writes to another member about thier voting, accusing or asking for explanations or trying to change someones opinion I consider this a breach of our first code of honor guildine:  "Above all else, respect others"

If members write to you, on or off the site and try to influence your votes or attack you for your comments (so long as they were reasonable and not attacks themselves) then you can message Minti admin (the big shield people) and get warnings sent out.

Voting makes this site better for all, coersive or threatening behaviour will not be tolerated.

all the best

Matt



Reply Reply Report
cazza
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | cazza
Re: Advice and Voting
I wouldnt be scared of Voting, and please check out rachel,and clays advise on this....

THIS SITE IS FOR PARENTS, NOT FOR Children and for some that think i have the Power to run this site, well thanx for the Compliment, but i just enjoy being ME..

and i voe with all the best intentions...
xxxxx cazza


Reply Reply Report
Ngairi
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | Ngairi
Re: Advice and Voting

Regardless of what has been going on, I just live in my little bubble and vote how I feel I want to vote. I try and leave a comment as well, but not always. Something everything has already been said, or I just don't know what to say. But I still vote.



Reply Reply Report
merlin0903
5.00 (Excellent) | November 2007 | merlin0903
Re: Advice and Voting

 

hi hotmama

the way i have always looked at it is, be honest to how you feel about the advice, if think its great then vote a 5 and if you don't think its great then vote honest to how you feel don't feel you have to not vote and move on, if you feel that there are things that either needed to be changed or you want to add something then either leave a little message for the person that wrote it or send them a minti mail then that way they have some feedback from you as to how you feel about their advice,

you are right there has been a lot of BS over the whole voting thing, i was voted down along with others like Lui  Kellz  Cazza who all write really great and helpful advice, we don't know why this happens but it does its just how life around minti is, my hubby loves to say that there are just to many hormones flying around, and i kinda agree with him, we are not all going to get along but when it comes to reading someones advice that they have put a lot of work into leave how you feel about them at the door and just focus on what they have written, and if you still don't like it then fine but its also nice to let them know as to why you didn't,

but please don't ever feel afraid to vote just continue the way you have always done it and you can't go wrong, and if you feel that it isn't parenting advice contact the person that has written it and let them know,

i hope that this has helped a little sorry its so long lol,



Reply Reply Report