minti, powered by parents Powered by Parents
First Visit?     Register     Login
 
RSS

meggles
meggles | January 2008

Inappropriate comments

My son has Aspergers, unforutnatly that means he often says things that he should not. He sees someone smack a child he will say to them "why are you mean to your son" etc. How can I help him see that this is not only inappropriate but potentially dangerous? I have tried talking to him but am getting nowhere.



Write Answer Know a little? Give an answer Write Advice Know a lot? Write some advice Report


External Links

No external links found

Related Content   [Add link]

No related content found

 

Want to help? Know a little? Give an answer or Know a lot? Write some Advice

Other answers to this question:


Pip
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | Pip
Re: Inappropriate comments
unfortunatly its who they are, my nephiew is being tested for it but has been diagnosed with autisum as well, he will often tell of strangers for doing things he finds wrong, not only telling them off but yelling at them and smaking them. both aspergers and autisum are problems with how people comunicate and how they understand. just keep going it might take a while but eventualy it might get threw. good luck  with it :-)


Reply Reply Report
      meggles
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | meggles
Re: Inappropriate comments
sadly people react to the comment before t hinking. Shane last year when he was 6 asked a little aboriginal boy why his face was brown and got punched in the face. The childs mother watched and said and did nothing. I grabbed shane and took him home. Shane could not understand why that was inappropriate and said. Mum if he asked me why my face was white I would not have hit him. I fear for shanes safety in these times


Reply Reply Report
           Pip
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | Pip
Re: Inappropriate comments
I would be more inclind to think there was more wrong with the other little boy as the question Shane asked i have heard asked by  kids his adge without this illness, i was even asked by a 6 year old why i had mouth jewlery when i was 18 when i had my braces on, my nephiew asked me what the spot was on my face very loudly when i was 16 and i get told of a story about when my sister was young telling mum very loudly in a shopping center how larg a womons but was, another kid i was babysitting for a friend desided to tell everyone in the line for the movies that he had worms, i think its natural for kids to have these outburst anyway and the other little boy has been shown the wrong way to deal with them, kids are crewel as they say. It's just a shame that with asburges and autisum these kids dont understand that boundery after the 1st outburst, i am more worried that this other little boy feels violance is the only way to cope with anything thats said that he dose not like.


Reply Reply Report
           cheleinkal
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | cheleinkal
Re: Inappropriate comments

I feel awful for your Shane... where did this happen?  Was it a public place or a school/Kindy/day care?  I would if public, write a letter to the editor of your local news paper, explaining how the situation happened and the in affectual behavior of the other mother in regards to HER childs inappropriate behavior.  I think his question was very healthy and his reasoning incredibly wise and mature especially considering his age.  Tell him that I think he is a very very clever youn man who wont become someone important in the world because he already IS.

Go Shane... your my hero.



Reply Reply Report
                Pip
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | Pip
Re: Inappropriate comments

Its scary to think that these kids are being raised to think punching others and destroying public places is ok, if Shane is anything like my nephiew Asher he will have his close friends that accept him for who he is, ive noticed Asher gives his friends alot of attention and stands up for them when he thinks its in need, his best friend is my daughter Isabel and i have been told a couple of times not to say no to her or not to be angery at her when she has done something wrong, even shouting at people to get off the toilet when Isabel has needed to use it.  There are still problems with sharing his games but he is fine as long as they play how he wants them to play with the toys or if they just watch him play. They are grate kids and make things intresting. When my sister 1st found out about Asher i turned to her and said how it dosnt change him, he is still our Asher and we wouldnt have him any other way.



Reply Reply Report
                meggles
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | meggles
Re: Inappropriate comments
it was at a park the same family where allowing their kids to smash glass and leave it all over the basketball courts. So defintely some issues there. I guess I worry cause with Shane he does not learn like another kid might. Like I certainly would not say the same thing again but Shane probably will. But yes he is my hero too. He never gives up even when I feel like it sometimes. I am so proud of him and tell him how much I love him as much as I can


Reply Reply Report
llmunchkin
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | llmunchkin
Re: Inappropriate comments
That's funny, I don't have Aspergers, and I would be prone to asking the same question... Seriously though, at this age he should be ok, and I think that it is a common thing to most children so don't fret too much.

Try to give him more 'socially acceptable' or 'positive' methods of saying things, and practice them together and reward him for getting them right/

For example, our little midget learned to say 'no' to everything, and it was so annoying, I kept insisting that he say 'no thank you'... It is so much kinder on the ear, and everyone thinks he has great manners - whereas he is basically just saying NO. 

As your little man is bigger, you can work with him on 'nicer' ways to say things, that may not offend people so much.  (Give him a hug from me, he sounds charming and adorable).


Reply Reply Report
mom2jedd
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | mom2jedd
Re: Inappropriate comments

Thi9s is one of the most ocmmon chracteristic of Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD). It can take years to "teach" a child with ASD to understand what is appropriate in social settings. School can help him to "learn" what is apprpriate. Chidlren with autism don't have the "tackfullness" of others, thye say exactly what is on their minds no matter whose feelings it may hurt.

If you out in public I would just quickly tell them sorry it's a trait fo the autistic disorder he has. After saying that the other shoudl be more understanding. As he gets older he should be able to "learn" socail function better, whith children with ASD it takes time....

 



Reply Reply Report
tdv
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | tdv
Re: Inappropriate comments

hi, I agrree with the other response, kids say things without knowing the consequences and other people know this as well.  All you can really do is be a good role model and constatnly repeat that what was said was not appropriate.  As they get older and have a better understanding of right from wrong you can explain it to them.  I once taught an asperges child who was 11 and he used to say things to me all the time.  I liked the fact that he was upfront and spoke his mind. However, if it was inappropriate or he had said something to another kid I would quietly take him aside and have a one of one chat to him.  He understood and would always a apologise.  At our school we always ask the child what they are sorry about this way they can explain it to you and you know that they have understood that what they said or did was not appropriate. It also makes it clearer in their head.

Best of luck!



Reply Reply Report
cheleinkal
5.00 (Excellent) | January 2008 | cheleinkal
Re: Inappropriate comments
Personally, I don't think it's anything to worry about at his age, it's expected that young children will say innapropriate things or state the obvious, thats where the saying "Out of the mouths of babes"comes from, god, my brother 15 months my junior has never learnt the meaning of tact and has ALWAYS said the wrong thing, and he has survived to repeat this error in judgement again and again LOL.  Until he hits High School, don't stress about it, just smile sheepishly like we ALL do and apologise and if it's really bad, explain then and there that that was not a nice thing to say and have hm applogise.  but unless he says something that is really bad, like commenting on an old ladies saggy boobs or something that someone will obviously take un forgiving offence to, don't over react to it.  he'll be able to be explained to sooner or later, probably you'll have bettr luck around aged 8 or 9, but till then, perfect the sheepish smile and he'll get good at saying he's sorry LOL.


Reply Reply Report