|
 |
| |
|
|
| |
|
|
|
 |
|  |
|
 |
 |
 |
disciplining a hitter.
My son is just 17 months old, and HITS. If he wants to drag me down to his room, but I tell him "no, I'm cooking right now", he screams and hits my leg. If my husband is sleeping on the couch, he hits him on the face. He throws things (sometimes BIG things like, oh, his high chair tray) at the dog. If I'm holding him in a situation where he can't get down (it's not safe, or whatever), he hits my face, claws at my hair and pulls it, and screams no over and over. How to deal with this? Obviously I can't hit him back! I've been told to try time out, but have no idea how that's supposed to work on a kid this young. Telling him "no, be nice" does no good. If I sternly tell him no, or act like I'm going to cry, and say "that's ouchie to mommy!" to try to get him to understand, he just laughs at me. He hits with his head, too! Once, when I was laying next to him in his bed, trying to get him to go to sleep, he head butted my nose so hard I almost fainted from the pain. I immediately started crying, and he cried too--for about a minute. Then, he just laid there and looked at me. Ten minutes later, when I had my eyes closed and was almost asleep myself, he did it again. What in the world do I do?
| |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
External LinksNo external links found | Related Content [Add link]No related content found | Related keywords: 17-months-old, baby, hit, hitter, hitting |
Other answers to this question:
 |
|
 | |
|
|
Re: disciplining a hitter.
Hi there, my sister has showed me this Q&A asking me to answer because I had a lot of behavior issues with my son (who is now 2).
Time out can be used from any age really. I had my son sitting in the corner at 10 months. He got the gist pretty fast and I can say by a week he knew that when I said "if you do ______ again you will go in the corner" i meant it and the behavior was often stopped before he even had to go in the corner. Even now it works. There is a corner everywhere you go. The shops, bus, in the street i can find one and on more than one occasion I have used it. People may stop and stare but I am the one having to deal with it at home and you can't threaten punishment at a later date (when you get home you are going in the corner), especially at that age. 1 minute per age and if they cry and scream and kick start the time from when you have silence. If they get up and walk away start over again. The first couple of times they might be a little hysterical but they need to learn that time out is a place to reflect on the bad behavior. When his time is up get him to come to you and say sorry after you have explained to him again why he was there. "You had to sit in the corner because you hit mummy in the face and hitting is not nice. It hurt mummy a lot. Please say sorry" and make sure he does. He needs to realize that it makes you sad and it is not acceptable.
As for the smacking him back you are right not to do so. You can't smack a child for misbehaving and not expect them to hit you when they are angry with you. I know a lot of parents that smack their children, and it is their choice, but they are the ones who have the violent children. It really sends a mixed message of "if you can hit me I can hit you".
I do not agree with putting a child in their place of rest for punishment. A bed or cot is supposed to be a fun, happy and relaxed place and if you use it as a form of 'time out' then bed time is seen as a punishment. This also goes for prams/strollers/buggies. If you put your child in one to restrain for punishment then you will have all sorts of issues getting them to sit there when you want to go out.
Sleeping alone after having constant parental comfort is hard. I co slept with my son for 12 months then had to stay in his room with him till he was 15 months and I had just had enough. It is exhausting and while it is nice when they are babies, they tend to play on it when they are older by making the time to fall asleep so much longer. I let him cry it out. He was also in a bed at this stage and would get out of his bed and I would take him by the hand, walk him to his bed, lay him back down and leave without saying a word. The first night I think he got up and came out about 30 times but gradually over the week it became less frequent and by the end of the 6th day he was sleeping in his bed without getting up alone. It was very trying the first few days as I thought it would never work but I was persistant and after a while they realize that it wont work and they stop doing it. You going back in and laying down with him that last time until he falls asleep is just encouraging and reinforcing what he is doing therefor he will not sleep by himself because at the end of the night he gets what he wants.
I am by no means an expert and I know all children are different but I hope this helps you as it did me.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
| |  |
|
 | |
|
|
Re: disciplining a hitter.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
| |  |
|
 | |
|
|
Re: disciplining a hitter.
Thanks, Izzy. I tried this last night when he hit my face in bed. I found that if I reacted by grabbing his hand and saying "no hitting!" he giggled, waited for me to lay down again, and did it again. Once, I got up, told him "no hitting, that hurts mommy." and left the room, thinking maybe if I did that every time, he'd eventually get that when he hit me, I wouldn't lay with him. He started hysterically crying, which I let him do for ten minutes, then it took me an hour to calm him down enough to attempt to go to sleep again. (ugh)
When I acted like I was still asleep and didn't react at all, he settled in and went to sleep. Of course, those are the "hitting to get a reaction" hits, not the "hey, do what I say!" hits.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
| |  |
|
 | |
|
|
Re: disciplining a hitter.
oh, geez, I wasn't trying to give him a 10 minute time out! Gosh, it looked like that, didn't it. It's probably how he felt, too. :(
See, we've been working on getting him to lay down for bed by himself. Normally, he needs me to lay next to him until he falls asleep, and flat-out refuses to go to sleep on his own. I asked for some advice about this not too long ago, and my friend gave me what I think is a good idea.
For several days, now, I've been laying next to him when I first put him down, then leaving the room. He lays and cries a bit, then gets up to get me. I lay with him again till he looks sleepy, then get up and leave again. Sort of a ferberize-esque thing, getting him used to the idea of laying there by himself, with the knowledge that I will come back.
Gradually, the time's been getting longer before he gets up. We're up to about 10 minutes, at which point I just lay with him until he goes to sleep. He won't fall asleep by himself, but getting used to being in the room alone is, I think, the first step. It might not be the right way to do it, but it seems to be working. Because even though he's crying, he's still staying in bed for a bit before coming for me. I'm hoping he'll figure out it's okay to stay in bed by himself, because mommy will still come when he needs me to.
Ultimately, I let him cry for 10 minutes because of the sleep-thing, but you're right, I probably should've just gone in after a minute, because if the hitting-thing, which is probably why it took me so long to calm him down. I assumed he would get up and come get me, like he normally does. Probably not a great decision on my part.
I know the one-minute one-year rule. I'm not the best mommy in the world (really, who is?) but I'm not THAT bad of a mommy. I'm dealing with hitting and sleep issues at the same time, and apparently not coordinating them very well.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
| |  |
|
 | |
|
|
This Comment has been deleted
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
| |  |
|
 | |
|
|
This Comment has been deleted
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
|
 | |
|
|
Re: disciplining a hitter.
I really feel for you.. my son has been doing this since he was 13-14 months old (he is now 22 mths old). He tends to hit when he is tired, he will get really angry and hit me, the walls, sofa or my husband (thankfully not other kids) It has driven me crazy and I have gone through various stages including taking it personal etc. My son has also head-butted me and I have treated it the same way as the hitting.
Your son is old enough to understand what time out is and seriously, it works! I am not saying it is going to be easy, but if you persevere and be consistent you will see the improvements. When my son hits I will say that is not nice use gentle touches and ask him to show me the sign for gentle (we did some baby sign language) and he does. If he hits again he goes in time out for two minutes, I have even had to put him in time out for hitting me in stores and at playgroup.. and he knows what he has done and will say sorry (or when he was younger gave me a kiss and a hug to say sorry) The consistency has paid off, it is soooo much better, although I am not going to say it has gone away completely... he still tries to push his boundaries every now and again. He would hit me several times a day and it felt like he lived in time out but now he may hit out every couple of weeks, sometimes he will hit me without thinking, realise what he has done and before I can say anything he will say no, no and hug me!
I have waffled, but your son is old enough for time out and it has worked wonders for us.. it feels at times like it will never get better, but it will. Also make sure you use positive reinforcement when he uses 'gentle touches'. I am still working on my son's throwing, he has great accuracy and alarming strength for hisage, but will throw things at you (like a hard ball or toy) when you are not expecting it, again we use time out and he is getting better.
Good luck!
Lorna
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
 |
|